Thanks Shawn for your honest and probing post. As an evangelical I admit that much needs to be reformed. I am certainly not always proud of my tradition.
I do think that many of the doctrines you consider evangelical superstitions though are biblical and have historical support. You mention that the original ending of Mark doesn't have any mention of resurrection appearances. While the longer ending is a later addition, vv. 5-7 do have the angels proclaiming, "He has risen! He is not here. See the place where they laid him. But go, tell his disciples and Peter, 'He is going ahead of you into Galilee. There you will see him, just as he told you.'" Thus, they will see him appear.
It is also notable that Paul in 1 Cor. 15:3-8 says that what he received from the original apostles as of "first importance" emphasized the resurrection appearances to the apostles and one to a group of 500! This is the earliest tradition we have of what the apostles preached as the good news which dates to around two years after Paul's conversion and is referenced by him in Galatians 1:18-19. This could have been as early as year 35. Paul also mentions Christ's appearance to James and himself. This is significant because these men were opposed to Jesus and the claims of the apostles. What they saw turned around two enemies of the gospel and turned them into believers who went to the point of martyrdom for the faith.
Concerning penal substitutionary atonement (PSA), I think that it is defensible as the plain teaching of the Bible and the early church fathers.
Lev. 17:11 provides the rationale, "For the life of the flesh is in the blood, and I have given it for you on the altar to make atonement (kippur) for your souls, for it is the blood that makes atonement (kippur) by the life." It is life for a life.
Your point about ritual cleansing is well taken but the sacrifice was also to ransom from sin. Jay Sklar who is a specialist on Leviticus notes, "Scholars from a wide array of backgrounds understand kipper in Leviticus 17:11 to refer to ransom (see Levine, 115; Milgrom, 707–8; Moffitt, 263–64). This is because the exact phrase “to [kipper] for your lives” found in 17:11 occurs in only two other places, both of which use kipper to refer to “ransom” (Ex. 30:15; Num. 31:50).
Sklar continues: "Kipper in 17:11 is therefore well understood as relating to ransom. Instead of the offerer’s lifeblood, the animal’s lifeblood is given in death as the ransom payment. And this means all the elements of PSA are in place: The animal experiences the death the offerer deserves (the penalty) in the offerer’s place (as a substitute), to reconcile the offerer to God (for atonement)" (https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/reviews/lamb-free-atonement-biblical/).
In Romans 5:7-8 Paul teaches that just as one might die in the place of a good man, God demonstrates a greater love for us in that while we were still sinners Christ died for us. 2 Cor. 5:21, "For he made him who knew no sin to be sin (P) for us (S), that we might become the righteousness of God in him (A)."
Jeffrey, Ovey, and Sax in Pierced for Our Transgressions document PSA in the the church fathers starting with Justin Martyr (100-165) who wrote, "Whoever is crucified is said in the law to be accursed...If, then, the Father ... wished his Christ for the whole human family to take upon him the curses of all knowing that after He had been crucified ... He would raise him up ... who submitted to suffer these things as if he were accursed (165)." Quotes about Christ bearing the curse of our sin in our place continue through early centuries to Gregory of Nazianzus ("He makes my disobedience his own") and on to Augustine.
PSA is present outside of Israel too as Aeschylus wrote in Prometheus Bound:
Look for no ending to this agony
Until a god will freely suffer for you,
Will take on him your pain
And in your stead,
Descend to where the sun is turned
To darkness, the black depths of death.
I covet your thoughts on this Shawn and value your point of view as I seek to pour over our theology in the pursuit of God's truth. Yours
One clarification first. Nothing in my essay called the resurrection into question. The claim was about Mark’s longer ending specifically, 16:9-20, which is absent from Vaticanus and Sinaiticus and viewed as a later addition by nearly every textual critic, evangelical ones included. My claim is about manuscript transmission and what it does to inerrancy, not a about whether Jesus appeared to anyone. The angelic proclamation and the Galilee promise in 16:5-7 are part of the earlier, undisputed text. Your 1 Corinthians 15 point is a genuine argument for an early resurrection tradition, but it answers a question I didn’t ask.
On penal substitution, I want to give Sklar his due. His ransom reading of kipper in Leviticus 17:11 is a real position, and it can complicate the purification-only reading I focused on. But ransom and substitution in the Levitical sacrifices is a narrower claim than the doctrine of PSA. Leviticus gets you an animal’s life standing in for a person’s, I’ll grant. It doesn’t get you wrath specifically propitiated, guilt specifically imputed, a debt specifically paid to satisfy retributive justice. Those are specific (and later) theological additions to the sacrificial logic, not contained in it. These, in my mind, have to be retrofitted back into the text.
The patristic case is where I’d differ the most. Gregory of Nazianzus is the clearest example. You cite him as carrying the doctrine forward toward Augustine. In Oration 45.22, he takes up the exact question PSA depends on; who received Christ’s blood and why, and rejects the premise outright. He considers whether the ransom went to the devil and dismisses it. He considers whether it went to the Father and rejects that too, pointing out the Father didn’t even demand Isaac’s death and substituted a ram rather than take it. Gregory’s conclusion seems to have been that the Father accepts the sacrifice but never required it. That’s a direct denial of the mechanism penal substitution needs, not a precursor to it.
I’d argue that Justin Martyr is less supportive than it looks too. His language about Christ bearing the law’s curse draws on Deuteronomy’s curse on one hanged on a tree and Galatians 3:13, which is about Christ absorbing a public, legal category attached to crucifixion itself, fulfilling a messianic pattern. It isn’t the same claim as a courtroom transfer of personal guilt for individual sin, and Derek Flood’s 2010 piece in Evangelical Quarterly goes through this and several other citations from Pierced for Our Transgressions and reaches the same conclusion. The fathers are working inside a restorative, Christus Victor logic, not the retributive one the modern doctrine of PSA requires. I couldn’t find the citation for “He makes my disobedience his own” in the Nazianzen material I scanned.
Last point, I think. I looked into the Aeschylus. My read is Prometheus isn’t punished for a wrong requiring atonement. He’s tortured for helping humanity, which the play treats as heroic. The line about a god suffering “in your stead” is Hermes threatening him with the end of an unjust persecution, not describing wrath being satisfied. That, it seems, one would have to read into the text. The Chiron myth doesn’t even agree with itself across sources. One version has Chiron dying in Prometheus’s place, another has Prometheus trading his immortality to end Chiron’s suffering instead. Neither aligns with or supports a notion of penal substitution. If anything, I’d posit that it supports my point … a god who suffers for someone else shows up across unrelated cultures long before anyone turned that instinct into a specific legal transaction with terms attached.
I love this pushback! Keep sending me the hard stuff, Matt.
You're right that your post did not question the resurrection. I misread where you were taking that point about the ending of Mark.
BTW, do you hold to the resurrection? I know you're a fan of NT Wright who of course argues persuasively for it in The Resurrection of the Son of God. It seems that it is historically the best explanation of the facts that Jesus was crucified by the Romans, his disciples were so convinced that he had risen that they were willing to lose all their worldly goods to proclaim it and be persecuted unto death, and why the hostile James and enemy Paul converted to Christianity and were willing to be martyred. They must have truly been convinced that he "appeared" to them alive.
I agree that the ending of Mark is a later addition. I don't think that this threatens the inerrancy though. I am comfortable saying its probably not apostolic and therefore not the word of God thus the brackets in all modern translations. I do believe that inerrancy applies to the autographs based on the rationale that Christ promised the apostles that the Spirit "would guide them into all truth" and would take from what is his and make it known to them (John 16:13-14). I would argue that Peter treats Paul's writings as on par with OT Scripture when he writes that some twist Paul's words "as they do the other Scriptures" (2 Peter 3:16-17). I know apostolicity is a broad concept but I would say that the early church treated anything "written, sourced, or endorsed" by the apostles or the apostolic community as inspired Scripture and thus authoritative and by extension incapable of error. This is important even though we no longer possess the autographs because whenever we are confident that we have established the original reading we are bound to submit to it as the word of God.
Gavin Ortlund in What it Means to Be Protestant documents that Augustine held to sola Scriptura and at least infallibility as the blessed bishop wrote that “the sacred canon of Scripture … stands … absolutely in a superior position to all letters of the bishops that about it we can hold no matter of doubt or disputation whether what is confessedly contained in it is right and true” (On Baptism 2.3.4, Cited in Ortlund 96). Ortlund points out how Augustine recognized a “unique infallibility” of Scripture superior to even ecumenical councils.
Is your main issue with PSA the "legal" transaction and retribution for sin? I think that whether you characterize it as legal or not we seem to agree that it's substitutionary in the sense of one life standing in for another, right? If so, is this substitution not to absorb the penalty due the sin incurred by the one who needs the substitute?
As for the retribution do you agree that God is wrathful toward our sin? If so, what does it mean that "Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures?" How do you understand Is. 53 where the prophet says that the suffering servant will be crushed and wounded for our transgressions so that "the punishment that brings us peace was upon him?" How do you interpret the propitiation passages like Romans 5:9: "Since, therefore, we have now been justified by his blood, much more shall we be saved by him from the wrath of God."? In the end I think PSA a beautiful truth wonderfully put by John Stott and paraphrased by me :) : The essence of sin is our substituting ourselves for God. The essence of salvation is God substituting himself for us." Also Luther, "All his sin was mine and all my righteousness was his."
Your points about Gregory deserve further study on my part. The Nazianzus reference you asked about is The Fourth Theological Oration in Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, ser. 2, vol. 7 p. 311. Here's the full quote:
"For my sake he was called a curse, Who destroyed my curse; and sin who taketh away the sin of the world; and became a new Adam to take away the curse of the old, just so he makes my disobedience his own as head of the whole body. As long as I am disobedient and rebellious, both by denial of God and by my passions, so long Christ also is called disobedient on my account" (cited in Pierced 174).
I would also point out that Christus Victor and PSA are not necessarily at odds but work together to paint a fuller picture of a glorious redemption. Regarding the Prometheus passage do you at least agree that it is substitutionary?
I am glad to renew our friendship over a discussion of these issues Shawn. You are truly a careful scholar and theologian. Regarding the new perspective I do like Wright on the resurrection of course but think he is revisionist to a fault in other areas. I have not studied him and his school though as extensively as you and look forward to any response you have. Yours
I can't tell you how much I appreciate your engagement here. This is precisely the kind of thing I'd hoped for with my Substack. I get it here and there from readers but few with the acumen you bring. I love this stuff.
You've asked me three essential questions: resurrection, inerrancy, and penal substitution, and I think it is probably wise to take them in turn instead of cramming an adequate answer into a single comment. That said, let me start with inerrancy, because I think it's maybe the most foundational one to this conversation. I'll then take up the substitutionary atonement and the resurrection questions on their own.
Regarding inerrancy, here's where I land. The doctrine as it's usually stated makes its claim about a Bible we don't possess. I mean the Chicago Statement's version, the original-autograph position, which I take to be the most solid form of it. Given it applies only to the original autographs, which nobody possesses and nobody has ever possessed, it seems a conveniently unfalsifiable location for the perfection claim to live.
In 1881, Hodge and Warfield centered inerrancy specifically in the "original autographs," again, manuscripts that no longer exist and that nobody then living had ever seen. Before that article, American Protestants had plenty of high views of Scripture, yes, but none in this particular formulation we now champion, fully airtight and located in documents no one could produce or verify.
What survives is thousands of handwritten manuscripts and those manuscripts do disagree with each other. Ehrman counts more variations among our manuscripts than there are words in the New Testament. Mark 16:9-20 is the exhibit we already agree on in the previous exchange: in every KJV, bracketed in every modern translation, absent from the two oldest complete manuscripts we have. The doctrine survives that fact, in my opinion, only by hiding behind documents nobody can access or verify.
On John 16, I don't think the promise there does the work you're asking it to do, respectfully. "The Spirit will guide you into all truth" is a promise about the Paraclete's guidance of the disciples, and in John truth is a person before it's a proposition and certainly before it's a book. Nothing in the passage in John promises error-free autographs, and nothing in it addresses scribal transmission at all.
On 2 Peter 3:16, I have two things. First, the verse is about readers distorting hard passages, not about error-free originals. That Paul's letters were counted among the writings speaks to their status, not their inerrancy. Second, 2 Peter is very much a disputed letter. The case that it wasn't written by Peter himself is strong, and if that's correct it can't carry the weight of Peter's own testimony about Paul's writings.
On Augustine, I want to grant you the high view. Ortlund is right that Augustine held Scripture above bishops and councils. But Augustine's own rule for handling a difficulty seems to cut the other way too. Writing to Jerome in Letter 82, he said that if he found anything in Scripture that seemed opposed to truth, he would suppose "either the manuscript is faulty, or the translator has not caught the meaning of what was said, or I myself have failed to understand it." Manuscript fault is his leading explanation there. That concedes exactly what the transmission argument needs, I believe. The text as we have it can be faulty, and Augustine agreed.
Here's the distinction I keep coming back to on this and I've wrestled with it a lot (in no way suggesting you haven't!). Most Christians defending inerrancy are doing it out of devotion to a book they take to be God's own speech, and that's not a small thing to risk. I get those stakes. But devotion to the text and defense of a particular reading strategy for it are two separate commitments, and the second one keeps disappointing the first one. The certainty I gave up, by intention, is not directly from God. It's not even directly from the Bible. It's a construct that is younger in origin than I think we want to admit.
Since you didn't, shrewdly, rebut me with 2 Timothy 3:16, I won't address that claim for inerrancy here unless you'd like me to. This is not a dodge, but I've also written pretty extensively on this subject (as I worked through it over time) and would be happy to point you to that work if you want to read further into my position and rationale for rejecting the modern articulation of inerrancy and verbal plenary inspiration (by implication). For the time being, I'll leave you with one link - https://drinkwisely.substack.com/p/half-for-the-fire-half-for-the-altar with the promise of more only if you want to read it!
Again, thanks for pressing me on all of this, my friend. I mean that. I'll follow up as time allows with my thoughts on your PSA and resurrection questions. Iron sharpens iron, right?
You give such deep reasoning in your posts that I’m surprised more readers have not responded to them. I have no theological background other than growing up Presbyterian, having relatives that are Catholic and Orthodox, and now being a member of an Episcopal church. The more I read articles like this from you and from others including the older writers (currently making my way through MacDonald’s Unspoken Sermons), the more I feel that to criticize others that have different outlooks is to try to convince them of “my way” without being able to truly back “my way” up with facts. It IS faith, and like people though history, it seems to me that the best a person can do is to aim their lives in the direction that helps others as much as possible, and hope that I am helping to spread God’s kingdom to the greater good instead of criticizing, discounting, and throwing barriers in front of others that ends up diminishing the welfare of those around me. Thanks for your thoughts and for sharing them with others.
For me, extraordinary experiences and abilities are not the ultimate goal of the spiritual path. If they arise, I see them as tools; what matters to me is how a teaching translates into real change in our own lives. Helping others has value in its own right, even while we still have work to do in understanding ourselves.
When I have an inner insight, I may not immediately know whether I’m interpreting it correctly. That’s why honest inner work matters to me: what have I actually experienced, and what am I adding from my own desires, fears or expectations? Other people’s perspectives and further experience can help me refine my understanding.
I therefore also see the cross as a symbol of inner transformation. For me, redemption is inseparable from a journey we each have to make for ourselves. We can receive guidance and support, but we need to experience our own insights and put the resulting changes into practice. Not to earn God’s love—which, from my perspective, is already ours—but to make that relationship a lived part of our everyday lives.
From this perspective, prayer is a gateway to a relationship with God. Asking can also involve letting go: I don’t seek to dictate what form the answer should take or when it should come. Simply expressing my desire doesn’t mean I necessarily understand everything its fulfilment would involve, and I may not see how it fits into my own path.
Questioning formulas, then, doesn’t necessarily mean moving away from God. It may be the beginning of a desire not merely to accept statements about God, but to come to know and nurture that relationship—while remaining open to the possibility that we may later understand things differently or more deeply than we do today. For me, developing this living, direct relationship is an important step and a source of support on the spiritual path.
Nicely put. God says, "I am. My Word. My Grace. My Love. Trust me." And over and over again, we people say, "No, my way. My control. It's gotta be what I think is fair!" The old saying of, "Let go and let God," is much deeper and profound than generally given assumed.
A second reading is merited here, Shawn. And, I'm physically carrying hard copies of this and your previous conversation along on my pilgrimage to a gathering next week up in Madison, Wisconsin for conversation with writer Paul Kingsnorth, and thd following week to the leadership retreat of the Iowa diocese of the Episcopal church. Thanks.
Thanks Shawn for your honest and probing post. As an evangelical I admit that much needs to be reformed. I am certainly not always proud of my tradition.
I do think that many of the doctrines you consider evangelical superstitions though are biblical and have historical support. You mention that the original ending of Mark doesn't have any mention of resurrection appearances. While the longer ending is a later addition, vv. 5-7 do have the angels proclaiming, "He has risen! He is not here. See the place where they laid him. But go, tell his disciples and Peter, 'He is going ahead of you into Galilee. There you will see him, just as he told you.'" Thus, they will see him appear.
It is also notable that Paul in 1 Cor. 15:3-8 says that what he received from the original apostles as of "first importance" emphasized the resurrection appearances to the apostles and one to a group of 500! This is the earliest tradition we have of what the apostles preached as the good news which dates to around two years after Paul's conversion and is referenced by him in Galatians 1:18-19. This could have been as early as year 35. Paul also mentions Christ's appearance to James and himself. This is significant because these men were opposed to Jesus and the claims of the apostles. What they saw turned around two enemies of the gospel and turned them into believers who went to the point of martyrdom for the faith.
Concerning penal substitutionary atonement (PSA), I think that it is defensible as the plain teaching of the Bible and the early church fathers.
Lev. 17:11 provides the rationale, "For the life of the flesh is in the blood, and I have given it for you on the altar to make atonement (kippur) for your souls, for it is the blood that makes atonement (kippur) by the life." It is life for a life.
Your point about ritual cleansing is well taken but the sacrifice was also to ransom from sin. Jay Sklar who is a specialist on Leviticus notes, "Scholars from a wide array of backgrounds understand kipper in Leviticus 17:11 to refer to ransom (see Levine, 115; Milgrom, 707–8; Moffitt, 263–64). This is because the exact phrase “to [kipper] for your lives” found in 17:11 occurs in only two other places, both of which use kipper to refer to “ransom” (Ex. 30:15; Num. 31:50).
Sklar continues: "Kipper in 17:11 is therefore well understood as relating to ransom. Instead of the offerer’s lifeblood, the animal’s lifeblood is given in death as the ransom payment. And this means all the elements of PSA are in place: The animal experiences the death the offerer deserves (the penalty) in the offerer’s place (as a substitute), to reconcile the offerer to God (for atonement)" (https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/reviews/lamb-free-atonement-biblical/).
In Romans 5:7-8 Paul teaches that just as one might die in the place of a good man, God demonstrates a greater love for us in that while we were still sinners Christ died for us. 2 Cor. 5:21, "For he made him who knew no sin to be sin (P) for us (S), that we might become the righteousness of God in him (A)."
Jeffrey, Ovey, and Sax in Pierced for Our Transgressions document PSA in the the church fathers starting with Justin Martyr (100-165) who wrote, "Whoever is crucified is said in the law to be accursed...If, then, the Father ... wished his Christ for the whole human family to take upon him the curses of all knowing that after He had been crucified ... He would raise him up ... who submitted to suffer these things as if he were accursed (165)." Quotes about Christ bearing the curse of our sin in our place continue through early centuries to Gregory of Nazianzus ("He makes my disobedience his own") and on to Augustine.
PSA is present outside of Israel too as Aeschylus wrote in Prometheus Bound:
Look for no ending to this agony
Until a god will freely suffer for you,
Will take on him your pain
And in your stead,
Descend to where the sun is turned
To darkness, the black depths of death.
I covet your thoughts on this Shawn and value your point of view as I seek to pour over our theology in the pursuit of God's truth. Yours
Matt,
Thanks for reading this so closely.
One clarification first. Nothing in my essay called the resurrection into question. The claim was about Mark’s longer ending specifically, 16:9-20, which is absent from Vaticanus and Sinaiticus and viewed as a later addition by nearly every textual critic, evangelical ones included. My claim is about manuscript transmission and what it does to inerrancy, not a about whether Jesus appeared to anyone. The angelic proclamation and the Galilee promise in 16:5-7 are part of the earlier, undisputed text. Your 1 Corinthians 15 point is a genuine argument for an early resurrection tradition, but it answers a question I didn’t ask.
On penal substitution, I want to give Sklar his due. His ransom reading of kipper in Leviticus 17:11 is a real position, and it can complicate the purification-only reading I focused on. But ransom and substitution in the Levitical sacrifices is a narrower claim than the doctrine of PSA. Leviticus gets you an animal’s life standing in for a person’s, I’ll grant. It doesn’t get you wrath specifically propitiated, guilt specifically imputed, a debt specifically paid to satisfy retributive justice. Those are specific (and later) theological additions to the sacrificial logic, not contained in it. These, in my mind, have to be retrofitted back into the text.
The patristic case is where I’d differ the most. Gregory of Nazianzus is the clearest example. You cite him as carrying the doctrine forward toward Augustine. In Oration 45.22, he takes up the exact question PSA depends on; who received Christ’s blood and why, and rejects the premise outright. He considers whether the ransom went to the devil and dismisses it. He considers whether it went to the Father and rejects that too, pointing out the Father didn’t even demand Isaac’s death and substituted a ram rather than take it. Gregory’s conclusion seems to have been that the Father accepts the sacrifice but never required it. That’s a direct denial of the mechanism penal substitution needs, not a precursor to it.
I’d argue that Justin Martyr is less supportive than it looks too. His language about Christ bearing the law’s curse draws on Deuteronomy’s curse on one hanged on a tree and Galatians 3:13, which is about Christ absorbing a public, legal category attached to crucifixion itself, fulfilling a messianic pattern. It isn’t the same claim as a courtroom transfer of personal guilt for individual sin, and Derek Flood’s 2010 piece in Evangelical Quarterly goes through this and several other citations from Pierced for Our Transgressions and reaches the same conclusion. The fathers are working inside a restorative, Christus Victor logic, not the retributive one the modern doctrine of PSA requires. I couldn’t find the citation for “He makes my disobedience his own” in the Nazianzen material I scanned.
Last point, I think. I looked into the Aeschylus. My read is Prometheus isn’t punished for a wrong requiring atonement. He’s tortured for helping humanity, which the play treats as heroic. The line about a god suffering “in your stead” is Hermes threatening him with the end of an unjust persecution, not describing wrath being satisfied. That, it seems, one would have to read into the text. The Chiron myth doesn’t even agree with itself across sources. One version has Chiron dying in Prometheus’s place, another has Prometheus trading his immortality to end Chiron’s suffering instead. Neither aligns with or supports a notion of penal substitution. If anything, I’d posit that it supports my point … a god who suffers for someone else shows up across unrelated cultures long before anyone turned that instinct into a specific legal transaction with terms attached.
I love this pushback! Keep sending me the hard stuff, Matt.
Thanks for your careful and eloquent reply Shawn.
You're right that your post did not question the resurrection. I misread where you were taking that point about the ending of Mark.
BTW, do you hold to the resurrection? I know you're a fan of NT Wright who of course argues persuasively for it in The Resurrection of the Son of God. It seems that it is historically the best explanation of the facts that Jesus was crucified by the Romans, his disciples were so convinced that he had risen that they were willing to lose all their worldly goods to proclaim it and be persecuted unto death, and why the hostile James and enemy Paul converted to Christianity and were willing to be martyred. They must have truly been convinced that he "appeared" to them alive.
I agree that the ending of Mark is a later addition. I don't think that this threatens the inerrancy though. I am comfortable saying its probably not apostolic and therefore not the word of God thus the brackets in all modern translations. I do believe that inerrancy applies to the autographs based on the rationale that Christ promised the apostles that the Spirit "would guide them into all truth" and would take from what is his and make it known to them (John 16:13-14). I would argue that Peter treats Paul's writings as on par with OT Scripture when he writes that some twist Paul's words "as they do the other Scriptures" (2 Peter 3:16-17). I know apostolicity is a broad concept but I would say that the early church treated anything "written, sourced, or endorsed" by the apostles or the apostolic community as inspired Scripture and thus authoritative and by extension incapable of error. This is important even though we no longer possess the autographs because whenever we are confident that we have established the original reading we are bound to submit to it as the word of God.
Gavin Ortlund in What it Means to Be Protestant documents that Augustine held to sola Scriptura and at least infallibility as the blessed bishop wrote that “the sacred canon of Scripture … stands … absolutely in a superior position to all letters of the bishops that about it we can hold no matter of doubt or disputation whether what is confessedly contained in it is right and true” (On Baptism 2.3.4, Cited in Ortlund 96). Ortlund points out how Augustine recognized a “unique infallibility” of Scripture superior to even ecumenical councils.
Is your main issue with PSA the "legal" transaction and retribution for sin? I think that whether you characterize it as legal or not we seem to agree that it's substitutionary in the sense of one life standing in for another, right? If so, is this substitution not to absorb the penalty due the sin incurred by the one who needs the substitute?
As for the retribution do you agree that God is wrathful toward our sin? If so, what does it mean that "Christ died for our sins according to the Scriptures?" How do you understand Is. 53 where the prophet says that the suffering servant will be crushed and wounded for our transgressions so that "the punishment that brings us peace was upon him?" How do you interpret the propitiation passages like Romans 5:9: "Since, therefore, we have now been justified by his blood, much more shall we be saved by him from the wrath of God."? In the end I think PSA a beautiful truth wonderfully put by John Stott and paraphrased by me :) : The essence of sin is our substituting ourselves for God. The essence of salvation is God substituting himself for us." Also Luther, "All his sin was mine and all my righteousness was his."
Your points about Gregory deserve further study on my part. The Nazianzus reference you asked about is The Fourth Theological Oration in Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, ser. 2, vol. 7 p. 311. Here's the full quote:
"For my sake he was called a curse, Who destroyed my curse; and sin who taketh away the sin of the world; and became a new Adam to take away the curse of the old, just so he makes my disobedience his own as head of the whole body. As long as I am disobedient and rebellious, both by denial of God and by my passions, so long Christ also is called disobedient on my account" (cited in Pierced 174).
I would also point out that Christus Victor and PSA are not necessarily at odds but work together to paint a fuller picture of a glorious redemption. Regarding the Prometheus passage do you at least agree that it is substitutionary?
I am glad to renew our friendship over a discussion of these issues Shawn. You are truly a careful scholar and theologian. Regarding the new perspective I do like Wright on the resurrection of course but think he is revisionist to a fault in other areas. I have not studied him and his school though as extensively as you and look forward to any response you have. Yours
Matt,
I can't tell you how much I appreciate your engagement here. This is precisely the kind of thing I'd hoped for with my Substack. I get it here and there from readers but few with the acumen you bring. I love this stuff.
You've asked me three essential questions: resurrection, inerrancy, and penal substitution, and I think it is probably wise to take them in turn instead of cramming an adequate answer into a single comment. That said, let me start with inerrancy, because I think it's maybe the most foundational one to this conversation. I'll then take up the substitutionary atonement and the resurrection questions on their own.
Regarding inerrancy, here's where I land. The doctrine as it's usually stated makes its claim about a Bible we don't possess. I mean the Chicago Statement's version, the original-autograph position, which I take to be the most solid form of it. Given it applies only to the original autographs, which nobody possesses and nobody has ever possessed, it seems a conveniently unfalsifiable location for the perfection claim to live.
In 1881, Hodge and Warfield centered inerrancy specifically in the "original autographs," again, manuscripts that no longer exist and that nobody then living had ever seen. Before that article, American Protestants had plenty of high views of Scripture, yes, but none in this particular formulation we now champion, fully airtight and located in documents no one could produce or verify.
What survives is thousands of handwritten manuscripts and those manuscripts do disagree with each other. Ehrman counts more variations among our manuscripts than there are words in the New Testament. Mark 16:9-20 is the exhibit we already agree on in the previous exchange: in every KJV, bracketed in every modern translation, absent from the two oldest complete manuscripts we have. The doctrine survives that fact, in my opinion, only by hiding behind documents nobody can access or verify.
On John 16, I don't think the promise there does the work you're asking it to do, respectfully. "The Spirit will guide you into all truth" is a promise about the Paraclete's guidance of the disciples, and in John truth is a person before it's a proposition and certainly before it's a book. Nothing in the passage in John promises error-free autographs, and nothing in it addresses scribal transmission at all.
On 2 Peter 3:16, I have two things. First, the verse is about readers distorting hard passages, not about error-free originals. That Paul's letters were counted among the writings speaks to their status, not their inerrancy. Second, 2 Peter is very much a disputed letter. The case that it wasn't written by Peter himself is strong, and if that's correct it can't carry the weight of Peter's own testimony about Paul's writings.
On Augustine, I want to grant you the high view. Ortlund is right that Augustine held Scripture above bishops and councils. But Augustine's own rule for handling a difficulty seems to cut the other way too. Writing to Jerome in Letter 82, he said that if he found anything in Scripture that seemed opposed to truth, he would suppose "either the manuscript is faulty, or the translator has not caught the meaning of what was said, or I myself have failed to understand it." Manuscript fault is his leading explanation there. That concedes exactly what the transmission argument needs, I believe. The text as we have it can be faulty, and Augustine agreed.
Here's the distinction I keep coming back to on this and I've wrestled with it a lot (in no way suggesting you haven't!). Most Christians defending inerrancy are doing it out of devotion to a book they take to be God's own speech, and that's not a small thing to risk. I get those stakes. But devotion to the text and defense of a particular reading strategy for it are two separate commitments, and the second one keeps disappointing the first one. The certainty I gave up, by intention, is not directly from God. It's not even directly from the Bible. It's a construct that is younger in origin than I think we want to admit.
Since you didn't, shrewdly, rebut me with 2 Timothy 3:16, I won't address that claim for inerrancy here unless you'd like me to. This is not a dodge, but I've also written pretty extensively on this subject (as I worked through it over time) and would be happy to point you to that work if you want to read further into my position and rationale for rejecting the modern articulation of inerrancy and verbal plenary inspiration (by implication). For the time being, I'll leave you with one link - https://drinkwisely.substack.com/p/half-for-the-fire-half-for-the-altar with the promise of more only if you want to read it!
Again, thanks for pressing me on all of this, my friend. I mean that. I'll follow up as time allows with my thoughts on your PSA and resurrection questions. Iron sharpens iron, right?
You give such deep reasoning in your posts that I’m surprised more readers have not responded to them. I have no theological background other than growing up Presbyterian, having relatives that are Catholic and Orthodox, and now being a member of an Episcopal church. The more I read articles like this from you and from others including the older writers (currently making my way through MacDonald’s Unspoken Sermons), the more I feel that to criticize others that have different outlooks is to try to convince them of “my way” without being able to truly back “my way” up with facts. It IS faith, and like people though history, it seems to me that the best a person can do is to aim their lives in the direction that helps others as much as possible, and hope that I am helping to spread God’s kingdom to the greater good instead of criticizing, discounting, and throwing barriers in front of others that ends up diminishing the welfare of those around me. Thanks for your thoughts and for sharing them with others.
For me, extraordinary experiences and abilities are not the ultimate goal of the spiritual path. If they arise, I see them as tools; what matters to me is how a teaching translates into real change in our own lives. Helping others has value in its own right, even while we still have work to do in understanding ourselves.
When I have an inner insight, I may not immediately know whether I’m interpreting it correctly. That’s why honest inner work matters to me: what have I actually experienced, and what am I adding from my own desires, fears or expectations? Other people’s perspectives and further experience can help me refine my understanding.
I therefore also see the cross as a symbol of inner transformation. For me, redemption is inseparable from a journey we each have to make for ourselves. We can receive guidance and support, but we need to experience our own insights and put the resulting changes into practice. Not to earn God’s love—which, from my perspective, is already ours—but to make that relationship a lived part of our everyday lives.
From this perspective, prayer is a gateway to a relationship with God. Asking can also involve letting go: I don’t seek to dictate what form the answer should take or when it should come. Simply expressing my desire doesn’t mean I necessarily understand everything its fulfilment would involve, and I may not see how it fits into my own path.
Questioning formulas, then, doesn’t necessarily mean moving away from God. It may be the beginning of a desire not merely to accept statements about God, but to come to know and nurture that relationship—while remaining open to the possibility that we may later understand things differently or more deeply than we do today. For me, developing this living, direct relationship is an important step and a source of support on the spiritual path.
Nicely put. God says, "I am. My Word. My Grace. My Love. Trust me." And over and over again, we people say, "No, my way. My control. It's gotta be what I think is fair!" The old saying of, "Let go and let God," is much deeper and profound than generally given assumed.
A second reading is merited here, Shawn. And, I'm physically carrying hard copies of this and your previous conversation along on my pilgrimage to a gathering next week up in Madison, Wisconsin for conversation with writer Paul Kingsnorth, and thd following week to the leadership retreat of the Iowa diocese of the Episcopal church. Thanks.
Tim Long, Just Up the Hill from Lock 15
Excellent article, Shawn. We are embedded, immersed in a wonder-filled cosmic mystery. Fear not, the universe is unfolding as it will.