Stevie Wonder released “Superstition” in 1972 (my birth year), built around a line that gets easily lost under the epic riff: when you believe in things you don’t understand, you suffer. He was writing about horseshoes and broken mirrors and walking under ladders, not church, but the structure of the claim is identical to half of what gets taught from a pulpit on any given Sunday. Do this specific thing, avoid that specific thing, and a force you cannot verify will respond accordingly. Wonder knew it was nonsense. Much of evangelicalism has never really considered the possibility theirs is too.
In my early teens, I moved from my Catholic heritage to a non-denominational church, mostly to attend the youth group. That move made me aware there was a whole swath of Christianity I knew little about, and I found it both fascinating and weird. Fascinating because everything seemed so spontaneous, casual, and loud, nothing like my formal liturgical upbringing. Weird because I was watching practices I’d never seen or even heard of before. They raised their hands in worship, clapped, occasionally shouted “amen” or “hallelujah.” Those were new to me, but it was the more overt practices that took a while to process as something people actually did: the occasional trip down to the altar for anyone feeling particularly contrite, the laying on of hands, anointing with oil, claiming of things, proclamations of healing and deliverance pronounced in Jesus’s name. None of it really existed in the tradition I came from, which had its own set of superstitions, just quieter ones.
A Working Definition
Superstition is not a synonym for “religious belief I find embarrassing.” That’s how the word often gets used, however. The definition that actually works comes from how anthropologists of religion have long separated magic from religion from science. Magic claims a direct causal link between a specific action or formula and a specific outcome, with no explanation offered beyond the claim itself. Religion, in the narrower technical sense, petitions a free agent who may or may not respond. Science proposes an explanation and submits it to testing. James Frazer drew this line in The Golden Bough, first published in 1890 and expanded across the following decades, arguing that human thought and practice runs from magic to religion to science.1 The line still cuts cleanly through most of what gets labelled faith today.
When the formula doesn’t deliver, the explanation always comes from the same short list. Not enough faith. Hidden sin. Bad timing, or God’s timing instead of yours. Every option on that list does the same job; it protects the claim by relocating the failure in the person praying rather than in the formula itself.
This definition has to hold up under its own weight, or this essay simply devolves into petty score-settling. It draws a hard line I need to heed myself. I don’t claim absolute certainty about the bodily resurrection, for example. I hold it loosely, as something I find compelling without being able to objectively verify, and I’m honest about that uncertainty rather than papering over it with a formula or an override of my rational faculties. A belief held under real, honest uncertainty is an entirely different animal than a mechanism asserted with total confidence that nobody has ever had to defend. Those are the “you must believe this because it is what we believe” situations. I’d contend this is not always consistent with authentic faith. Sometimes it has more to do with upholding the system and defending our own predilections.
None of this asks faith to retreat from every place reason can’t fully settle. Trust that outlasts proof, hope held without guarantee, the sense that existence carries weight beyond what a lab can measure, none of that is the target here. That kind of faith doesn’t promise a specific outcome in exchange for a specific action. It admits the limit and lives inside it honestly. What’s at issue here is a narrower, more testable claim: do this, and this specific result follows, guaranteed, whether or not anyone ever checks.
The test running through everything that follows is whether the claim offers a specific, formulaic, causal mechanism, and whether that connection survives contact with actual evidence. Five pieces of foundational evangelical teaching can serve as examples of how to fail that test, not at the fringe and not among faith healers on late-night cable, but at the center of what gets called the gospel.
Inerrancy
The doctrine of inerrancy makes a claim that sounds textual but functions like something closer to talismanic. The book itself, in its original autographs, carries a kind of supernatural protection that exempts it from the ordinary hazards every other ancient document faces, like scribal error, political editing, competing manuscript traditions, centuries of copying by hand before anyone had a printing press to stabilize the thing. The claim is causal. God preserved this specific text so it would remain intact, and the fact we have a canon, well, one of several, is offered as proof of the preservation. No working explanation gets offered beyond the assertion itself.
The textual history of “the Bible” tells a different story, and it’s not exactly a secret. The oldest ending of Mark stops at the empty tomb, with no resurrection appearance. The two oldest complete manuscripts of the New Testament, Vaticanus and Sinaiticus, lack verses 9 through 20 entirely, and most textual critics judge them a later addition, though it isn’t a unanimous verdict.2 The story of the woman caught in adultery, one of the most quoted passages in American preaching, doesn’t appear in any manuscript earlier than Codex Bezae, centuries after John was likely written.3 First John’s trinitarian proof text, the Comma Johanneum, starts life as a Latin addition, enters the Vulgate tradition later still, and only makes it into a Greek New Testament because Erasmus, under pressure from critics for leaving it out, said he’d add it if anyone could produce a single Greek manuscript containing it. One turned up, quite conveniently, right on schedule.4 The clause rode Erasmus’s text into the Textus Receptus and then the King James Version, then got quietly dropped from modern translations once the manuscript evidence became impossible to keep ignoring.
Bart Ehrman has built a career cataloguing exactly this kind of transmission history, and none of it is controversial among serious textual critics.5 It’s controversial only to people who’ve already committed to a doctrine that can’t survive without the erroneous or augmented reading remaining intact.
Watch closely what happens when inerrantists encounter these facts, because the pattern repeats exactly through every doctrine on this list. The claim never gets revised. It gets a footnote, maybe. Inerrancy now applies only to the original autographs, which nobody possesses and nobody has ever possessed, a conveniently unfalsifiable location for the perfection to live. A textual variant that would almost certainly sink a claim about any other ancient source gets absorbed into the system and explained as God’s providence working even through copying errors, which turns the evidence against the doctrine into evidence for it instead. That tactic, where failure becomes confirmation instead of disconfirmation, is perhaps the clearest marker of superstitious thinking in this entire essay. It’s the same logic as the knee that didn’t heal. The prayer worked. You just weren’t looking at it right, or you lack the faith to see it.
Penal Substitution
Drink Wisely has looked at this doctrine at length previously, in the piece on Anselm and Calvin’s heirs, so the case here stays brief. Penal substitution claims that the death of one specific person, under one specific set of conditions, discharges a legal debt owed by everyone else, provided the transaction is accepted on the correct terms. That’s a causal mechanism as precise as anything found in the prosperity gospel, adorned with weightier vocabulary, wrath accumulating until blood satisfies it and the ledger balances. Ask how blood satisfies wrath, in literal cause-and-effect terms rather than symbolically or narratively, and the answer runs out immediately. Anselm offered one account in the eleventh century, built on feudal honor rather than criminal law. Calvin’s heirs built another formulation in the sixteenth century, closer to a courtroom scene. Neither one explains how the exchange actually works so much as claims it with increasing confidence across the centuries.
The Hebrew sacrificial system this doctrine claims to now fulfill never worked this way in the first place. The dominant modern reading of Leviticus’s blood rites, following Jacob Milgrom’s influential analysis, treats the blood as a ritual detergent that purifies the sanctuary itself, not a payment made to an angry deity who needed appeasing before he could stand to look at anyone in their sin.6 Not every specialist agrees with Milgrom on every detail, of course, but even his critics still locate the ritual’s function in purification and covenant maintenance. Nobody exercising serious rigor reads it as a courtroom transaction.
The leap from ancient ritual to a legal transaction satisfying abstract divine wrath is a theological construction centuries in the making, not a plain reading of the text. Christus Victor and recapitulation theories of the atonement existed much earlier and operate on entirely different logic, victory over death and corruption instead of payment of a legal debt. Penal substitution was never the obvious biblical answer. It is one competing model that eventually won the argument in the West, at least, largely through Calvin and the Reformers who followed him.
What makes it superstitious instead of simply wrong, although it can indeed be both, is what happens when someone asks for the mechanism directly. The honest answer is that nobody has one. What gets offered instead is restatement with greater intensity, the wages of sin is death, as though repeating the claim in its own language counts as explaining it. A kid raised in this system learns early that pressing on the mechanism marks you as someone with a faith deficiency rather than someone asking a reasonable question a legal system would require of any other transaction. That’s the rub. A real mechanism survives scrutiny. A superstitious one treats the scrutiny itself as the real problem.
The Sinner’s Prayer
No verse in scripture presents a scripted, singular prayer as the on-switch for salvation. The sinner’s prayer as practiced in American evangelicalism, admit, believe, confess, repeat after me, is a thoroughly twentieth-century innovation. Bill Bright worked out the four-point outline in 1959 while consulting with a salesman named Bob Ringer on how to make the pitch land faster. A Toledo businessman, Gus Yeager, then took those talking points and built them into the printed tract people actually held in their hands, Have You Heard of the Four Spiritual Laws?, in 1965.7 Nine years between the idea and the artifact, refined like a sales pitch because that’s substantially what it was built to be. That history alone should cause some concern for a tradition that insists on calling itself clearly and plainly biblical. The deeper problem is what the prayer is claimed to do. Say these specific words, meaning them sincerely, and a permanent legal and spiritual status changes instantly and irreversibly. What connects the words to the outcome never gets explained beyond the words themselves.
Anyone who spent time in evangelical youth group watched the superstitious structure play out in real time. I was baptized twice myself, at least, unsure the first one had really “taken.” Kids said the prayer once, then again a year later at camp because they weren’t sure the first one counted, then a third time because some new anxiety about sincerity crept back in. Nobody in leadership read that pattern as evidence the formula itself wasn’t doing what it claimed. It was seen as spiritual seriousness, when the simpler explanation was that a formula whose success condition depends entirely on an unverifiable internal state will always generate this exact anxiety. You cannot check whether you really meant it. The uncertainty is baked into the claim, and the system interprets the resulting compulsive repetition as piety instead of a symptom of an unfalsifiable formula.
This is where the comparison to Wonder’s song gets less cute and more accurate. He’s describing exactly this structure, a belief that performing an action correctly controls an outcome you have no way to verify, and that getting it wrong, saying the words without quite enough sincerity, carries consequences you’ll never be able to measure until it’s too late to fix. The sinner’s prayer runs on that same architecture, just in theological language instead of folk wisdom about broken mirrors, and evangelicalism built an entire conversion industry on it.
Hell (Eternal Conscious Torment)
Of everything on this list, eternal conscious torment carries the highest stakes against the weakest textual support, the exact combination a tradition built on evidence would treat as a flashing warning sign rather than a settled doctrine.
The word carrying the weight of the doctrine is aionios, usually translated “eternal,” though its root sits closer to aion, an age, a bounded span of time, than to the strict infinity English readers assume. Even BDAG, the standard lexicon scholars use, gives the adjective a range running from something like “long ago” through “enduring” to “eternal” depending on context, a range real enough that translators have never agreed on a single rendering.8 Matthew 25 uses the same word for the punishment of the wicked and the life of the righteous in a single verse, which is a real problem for anyone insisting it means strict endlessness in one clause and something looser in the other. Translators since the King James have mostly resolved that tension by rendering it “everlasting” across the board, which settles nothing substantive about the Greek and settles everything about what continues to get preached.
Gehenna, the word Jesus actually uses for the fire of judgment, geenna in the Greek text the Gospels preserve, itself a transliteration of the Aramaic form of the Hebrew place name Jesus would have spoken aloud in his own Galilean tongue, starts as a place name: the Valley of Hinnom outside Jerusalem, associated in the Hebrew scriptures with child sacrifice to Molech and condemned by the prophets.9 The popular claim that it was a continuously burning garbage dump in Jesus’s day shows up in study Bible footnotes and sermon illustrations by the thousands, yet it has no ancient source behind it at all. Scholars have traced the claim to the medieval rabbi David Kimchi, writing around the year 1200, roughly twelve centuries after Jesus, with nothing earlier, Jewish or Christian, supporting it.10 A detail invented in the Middle Ages, repeated with total confidence for eight hundred years, and treated as settled background for a first-century teaching, is its own small case study in exactly the pattern this essay keeps finding: a claim survives not because anyone checked it and it held, but because everyone assumed somebody already had.
Second Temple Judaism held no single position on what happens after death. N.T. Wright has mapped this terrain in detail: Sadducees denying any future existence at all, Pharisees affirming embodied resurrection on the far side of an intermediate state, and other strands, including the Essenes as Josephus describes them, closer to a Greek-style immortality of the soul with no body attached.11 Apocalyptic texts like 1 Enoch add their own visions on top of all of it. Jesus spoke into that live argument. He didn’t settle it by fiat, and reading later systematic certainty back into first-century teaching turns a live debate into a doctrine it was never meant to be.
Drink Wisely has detailed elsewhere how Augustine’s Latin hardened contested Greek and Hebrew ideas into what became settled Western dogma, the inherited guilt case specifically, and the same pattern runs through ECT. A live, textually ambiguous tradition passes through translation, gets picked up by a brilliant and enormously influential bishop working from texts he couldn’t check against the originals, he didn’t have them and couldn’t have likely read them if he had, and comes out the other side as certainty nobody questions for the next fifteen centuries.
What makes ECT superstition instead of theology is what the doctrine does for the system built on it. It’s the go-to enforcement mechanism. Disbelief is seen as hardness of heart and suffering in this life gets retooled as a warning about what’s coming. The claim itself never gets tested, because the only people positioned to report back on whether it’s true are, by definition, unavailable for comment. A causal claim that cannot be checked, defended by explaining away every objection as evidence of the very problem it diagnoses, is the cleanest case of superstition in this entire essay, precisely because the stakes are too high for most people raised inside it to ever examine the premise.
The Rapture and Dispensationalism
Ask most evangelicals where the rapture comes from and they’ll point to scripture, confident the doctrine is as old as the New Testament itself. It isn’t. The pretribulational rapture, the secret removal of believers before a seven-year tribulation, has a clearly traceable origin in the 1830s, developed by John Nelson Darby within the Plymouth Brethren movement, and stayed very much a minority position until Cyrus Scofield printed his dispensational theology directly into the notes of his 1909 Reference Bible.12 The printing itself did real formative work, embedding an innovative nineteenth-century interpretive system into the same physical page as the verses, so readers absorbed it as though it carried the same authority as the text itself.
None of the major early creeds mention it. Nicaea doesn’t know it. Chalcedon doesn’t address it. Augustine, Aquinas, Luther, and Calvin all wrote extensively about eschatology without landing anywhere close to it. A doctrine absent from roughly eighteen centuries of Christian reflection, then suddenly central to American evangelical identity within one, needs a more precise term than “biblical truth.” It needs recognition as the nineteenth-century theological contrivance it is.
The superstitious structure shows up most clearly in how the system handles prophecy and current events. Specific geopolitical developments, Israel’s founding, the nation-state, not the biblical Israel, though that’s a separate superstition for another time, shifting European alliances, particular American political figures, get interpreted as signs pointing toward an imminent and highly specific timeline. When the timeline fails to arrive, and it always fails to arrive, the system doesn’t treat the failure as disconfirming evidence at all. It recalculates.
Hal Lindsey’s bestselling The Late Great Planet Earth, published in 1970, argued that a biblical generation runs forty years, which pointed straight at 1988 as the fortieth anniversary of Israel’s founding. Readers took the math and ran with it as the deadline.13 Harold Camping went further and set an actual date, twice, in the same year: May 21, 2011, and then, when that one passed without incident, October 21, 2011.14 Each failure gets absorbed, a date adjusted, a prophecy reinterpreted, this generation stretched to cover whatever span keeps the system alive, and the believer walks away with the system intact and occasionally more entrenched than before. A causal claim, specific enough to generate real expectation, yet flexible enough to survive every single time it fails. Impressive, if nothing else.
Coda
Strip the formula out of each of these five doctrinal examples and what remains underneath is much smaller than advertised, and probably more honest. An ancient library of texts worth serious study on its own historical terms doesn’t need magical immunity from the hazards every other ancient document survived. A death on a Roman execution device carries real weight as tragedy and hope without requiring a legal mechanism nobody can actually explain. Following Jesus doesn’t need a verbal password with a witness present to confirm it took, and whatever judgment waits past death doesn’t need Dante’s fictional vision applied to it to still mean something. Whatever comes after history ends can stay unknown without a chart predicting the exact sequence.
None of this requires abandoning faith, only abandoning the versions of it that function like charms and magic. Wonder’s song never really resolves, it just rides the riff out, which might be the more honest instrument for this subject than anything I inherited in those youth group years. I don’t know what happens after death, and I’ve stopped needing a formula to promise me. It might be the first version of faith I’ve held that doesn’t ask me to lie about how much I actually know.
The Cappadocians had language for this before I did. Gregory of Nazianzus, writing in the fourth century on the limits of theological speech, said it was “impossible to express Him, and yet more impossible to conceive Him.”15 He wasn’t hedging. He was describing the actual size of the subject, honestly, in a way the tradition that raised me rarely allowed itself to do. A faith that can admit the size of what it’s talking about doesn’t need formulas standing in for the parts it can’t reach. It can just acknowledge it and keep going anyway.
. . .
Endnotes
1. James George Frazer, The Golden Bough: A Study in Magic and Religion, 1st ed. (London: Macmillan, 1890), later expanded to a 12-volume 3rd ed. (1911–1915). The formulation that human thought moves from magic through religion to science runs throughout the work.
2. Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament (Stuttgart: United Bible Societies, 1971), 122–126. Codex Vaticanus and Codex Sinaiticus, the two oldest complete New Testament manuscripts, both end Mark at 16:8.
3. Daniel B. Wallace, “My Favorite Passage That’s Not in the Bible,” bible.org. The earliest manuscripts with substantial portions of John, P66 and P75, skip directly from 7:52 to 8:12; the earliest manuscript to include the passage is Codex Bezae (5th century).
4. On Erasmus and the Comma Johanneum, see Metzger, Textual Commentary, and the manuscript history summarized in standard critical apparatuses; the clause appears in only a handful of late Greek manuscripts out of the thousands extant.
5. Bart D. Ehrman, Misquoting Jesus: The Story Behind Who Changed the Bible and Why (San Francisco: HarperOne, 2005).
6. Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1–16, Anchor Bible, vol. 3 (New York: Doubleday, 1991), 254–261. For the critical response, see N. Kiuchi, The Purification Offering in the Priestly Literature: Its Meaning and Function (Sheffield: JSOT Press, 1987), and Roy Gane, Cult and Character (Winona Lake, IN: Eisenbrauns, 2005).
7. John G. Turner, Bill Bright and Campus Crusade for Christ: The Renewal of Evangelicalism in Postwar America (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2008), 69–74. Turner’s account resolves the conflicting dates found elsewhere (1952, 1956, 1957): 1959 is when Bright developed the four-point outline, and 1965 is when Gus Yeager compiled it into the printed booklet that circulated widely.
8. Walter Bauer, A Greek-English Lexicon of the New Testament and Other Early Christian Literature (BDAG), 3rd ed., rev. Frederick William Danker (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2000), s.v. “aiōnios.”
9. Encyclopedic Dictionary of the Bible, s.v. “Gehenna”; the New Testament geenna is a Greek-influenced form of Aramaic gêhinnām, corresponding to Hebrew gê’hinnōm, the Valley of (the son of) Hinnom.
10. Lloyd R. Bailey, “Gehenna: The Topography of Hell,” Biblical Archaeologist 49, no. 3 (1986): 187–191. The burning-dump tradition traces to the medieval commentator David Kimchi (d. ca. 1235); Bailey and subsequent scholars find no earlier Jewish or Christian source for it.
11. N.T. Wright, The Resurrection of the Son of God (Minneapolis: Fortress Press, 2003); see also Josephus, The Jewish War 2.163–165, on the differing Pharisee, Sadducee, and Essene positions.
12. On Darby, see Crawford Gribben, Writing the Rapture: Prophecy Fiction in Evangelical America (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2009), and standard biographical accounts of the 1830s Powerscourt conferences. On Scofield, see the Scofield Reference Bible (New York: Oxford University Press, 1909).
13. Hal Lindsey and C.C. Carlson, The Late Great Planet Earth (Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1970). Lindsey’s own later public statements disclaimed firm date-setting even as readers drew the 1988 conclusion from his math.
14. Contemporary coverage of Harold Camping’s 2011 predictions, e.g. ABC News and Christian Post reporting from May and October 2011.
15. Gregory of Nazianzus, Oration 28 (The Second Theological Oration), sec. IV, in Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers, Series II, vol. 7, trans. Charles Gordon Browne and James Edward Swallow (1894).




Thanks Shawn for your honest and probing post. As an evangelical I admit that much needs to be reformed. I am certainly not always proud of my tradition.
I do think that many of the doctrines you consider evangelical superstitions though are biblical and have historical support. You mention that the original ending of Mark doesn't have any mention of resurrection appearances. While the longer ending is a later addition, vv. 5-7 do have the angels proclaiming, "He has risen! He is not here. See the place where they laid him. But go, tell his disciples and Peter, 'He is going ahead of you into Galilee. There you will see him, just as he told you.'" Thus, they will see him appear.
It is also notable that Paul in 1 Cor. 15:3-8 says that what he received from the original apostles as of "first importance" emphasized the resurrection appearances to the apostles and one to a group of 500! This is the earliest tradition we have of what the apostles preached as the good news which dates to around two years after Paul's conversion and is referenced by him in Galatians 1:18-19. This could have been as early as year 35. Paul also mentions Christ's appearance to James and himself. This is significant because these men were opposed to Jesus and the claims of the apostles. What they saw turned around two enemies of the gospel and turned them into believers who went to the point of martyrdom for the faith.
Concerning penal substitutionary atonement (PSA), I think that it is defensible as the plain teaching of the Bible and the early church fathers.
Lev. 17:11 provides the rationale, "For the life of the flesh is in the blood, and I have given it for you on the altar to make atonement (kippur) for your souls, for it is the blood that makes atonement (kippur) by the life." It is life for a life.
Your point about ritual cleansing is well taken but the sacrifice was also to ransom from sin. Jay Sklar who is a specialist on Leviticus notes, "Scholars from a wide array of backgrounds understand kipper in Leviticus 17:11 to refer to ransom (see Levine, 115; Milgrom, 707–8; Moffitt, 263–64). This is because the exact phrase “to [kipper] for your lives” found in 17:11 occurs in only two other places, both of which use kipper to refer to “ransom” (Ex. 30:15; Num. 31:50).
Sklar continues: "Kipper in 17:11 is therefore well understood as relating to ransom. Instead of the offerer’s lifeblood, the animal’s lifeblood is given in death as the ransom payment. And this means all the elements of PSA are in place: The animal experiences the death the offerer deserves (the penalty) in the offerer’s place (as a substitute), to reconcile the offerer to God (for atonement)" (https://www.thegospelcoalition.org/reviews/lamb-free-atonement-biblical/).
In Romans 5:7-8 Paul teaches that just as one might die in the place of a good man, God demonstrates a greater love for us in that while we were still sinners Christ died for us. 2 Cor. 5:21, "For he made him who knew no sin to be sin (P) for us (S), that we might become the righteousness of God in him (A)."
Jeffrey, Ovey, and Sax in Pierced for Our Transgressions document PSA in the the church fathers starting with Justin Martyr (100-165) who wrote, "Whoever is crucified is said in the law to be accursed...If, then, the Father ... wished his Christ for the whole human family to take upon him the curses of all knowing that after He had been crucified ... He would raise him up ... who submitted to suffer these things as if he were accursed (165)." Quotes about Christ bearing the curse of our sin in our place continue through early centuries to Gregory of Nazianzus ("He makes my disobedience his own") and on to Augustine.
PSA is present outside of Israel too as Aeschylus wrote in Prometheus Bound:
Look for no ending to this agony
Until a god will freely suffer for you,
Will take on him your pain
And in your stead,
Descend to where the sun is turned
To darkness, the black depths of death.
I covet your thoughts on this Shawn and value your point of view as I seek to pour over our theology in the pursuit of God's truth. Yours
For me, extraordinary experiences and abilities are not the ultimate goal of the spiritual path. If they arise, I see them as tools; what matters to me is how a teaching translates into real change in our own lives. Helping others has value in its own right, even while we still have work to do in understanding ourselves.
When I have an inner insight, I may not immediately know whether I’m interpreting it correctly. That’s why honest inner work matters to me: what have I actually experienced, and what am I adding from my own desires, fears or expectations? Other people’s perspectives and further experience can help me refine my understanding.
I therefore also see the cross as a symbol of inner transformation. For me, redemption is inseparable from a journey we each have to make for ourselves. We can receive guidance and support, but we need to experience our own insights and put the resulting changes into practice. Not to earn God’s love—which, from my perspective, is already ours—but to make that relationship a lived part of our everyday lives.
From this perspective, prayer is a gateway to a relationship with God. Asking can also involve letting go: I don’t seek to dictate what form the answer should take or when it should come. Simply expressing my desire doesn’t mean I necessarily understand everything its fulfilment would involve, and I may not see how it fits into my own path.
Questioning formulas, then, doesn’t necessarily mean moving away from God. It may be the beginning of a desire not merely to accept statements about God, but to come to know and nurture that relationship—while remaining open to the possibility that we may later understand things differently or more deeply than we do today. For me, developing this living, direct relationship is an important step and a source of support on the spiritual path.