6 Comments
User's avatar
bluebird's avatar

Great column. It highlighted a political situation that is easy to have overlooked if you are in another state and focusing on other matters. Two of the politicians named in this article --surnames you can guess at--are so nakedly desperate -- and not even charming about it. Appreciated the focus on Acton's story. "No one will ever be unseen" --awesome line! Many of us can relate ---and welcome her personal victories in more areas than just one.

Jon Westlake's avatar

Yes! This is the voice and attitude that we need to bring the USA back from the edge

Rob Bright's avatar

I'll open with this: I live in Ohio, didn't care for either of the major party candidates for governor that much, and before the election I posted the article below on Facebook. The article is quite critical of Vivek and his ad. His approach in the ad was beyond the pale and was a desperate attempt to turn around an election he clearly wasn't going to win.

https://greenwald.substack.com/p/vivek-ramaswamy-flavio-bolsonaro

Now with that out of the way...

You said:

"[Acton] was the most visible public official in Ohio, the doctor at the podium explaining exponential curves to a frightened state.... Her COVID record is fair game for critique. The early projections overshot. The closures carried costs; to businesses, to kids, to trust in public health itself, that Ohio is still tallying, and a voter who held those costs against her was doing what voters are for. But keep the record honest about what kind of criticism that is. Getting a projection wrong is a failure of forecasting and maybe erring on the side of caution."

----

Your description DOESN'T BEGIN to touch how bad she was on the COVID response. I posted about it repeatedly on Facebook. It was far more than just screwing up a projection.

She was quite literally incompetent and ignorant on the issues she was supposed to be an expert on. I posted some of the receipts below.

She didn't even understand basic virology and was running the state response to a viral pandemic.

Among other incorrect things, she claimed in a video in spring 2020 that viruses will multiply on surfaces in your house when you don't clean enough. See here:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Oac-otuF1js

That's a VERY basic mistake (see links below). One would think the person who is controlling policy decisions based on a virus would understand basic virology.

"Viruses cannot eat food or grow on their own, but they can make more of themselves if they live inside the cells of other organisms, called "hosts"."

https://www.cdc.gov/rabiesandkids/virus.html

"Viruses aren’t actually alive – they don’t grow or move themselves, or eat or use energy, and they can’t reproduce on their own. This is why they must invade our cells – so that they can take advantage of the complex machinery, nutrients and energy in our cells, and force the cell to make millions of copies of the virus using the genetic blueprint carried in the virus."

https://www2.mrc-lmb.cam.ac.uk/viruswars/viruses.php

Again, that's a MAJOR, BASIC mistake. That resulted in her giving terrible advice and increasing the chance that people would be frightened/panic.

-----

In this video (May 2020), Dr. Acton showed that she was not familiar with the research re: the infectiousness of the virus in children and the minimal effect it had on children. Or, the less generous option, she was aware of the research, but chose not to talk about it. That research is also documented in the short video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dMwCdnnaT9Q

Again... her ignorance (or choice not to discuss the research) resulted in terrible advice and increasing the chance that people would be frightened/panic.

In this one (May 2020), Acton showed that she didn't know the difference between logarithmic and exponential growth. Yet she presented herself as understanding them and made decisions based on her ignorance.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Rd8B64hEQ_0

I have ZERO use for someone who presents themselves as an expert, making decisions that affect the lives of millions of people... when they don't even understand the basics of the thing they present themselves as an expert in.

That could be called "fraud" without stretching the term very much.

Her complete incompetence in that position should have disqualified her for any additional position in government, IMO. I expect the next four years of her governance in Ohio to result in Ohio shifting back to the right.

Finally, I can't speak for the big cities, but we in the rural areas were not particularly "frightened" during the pandemic. People largely went about their business (as much as was possible under the limits set by Acton's "leadership").

bluebird's avatar

I appreciated your extra insights! Thanks

Cameron S Denney's avatar

Thank you for this tribute to goodness over meanness. It feels to me like it has been a long time since we have seen love be stronger than hate in the political sphere in such a clear instance. I appreciate your pointing it out.

Satchel's avatar

“It is the machinery of normalization, and normalization is precisely how cruelty stops costing anything.”

Exactly. If we take any lesson from the last ten years, it should be this one. Nicely done.