The winter Amy Stearns lived in a tent, Youngstown got cold the way it always does. She was a kid on the city’s north side whose family had nowhere else to go. She and her younger brother moved eighteen times in twelve years, and some mornings the neighbors fed them breakfast on the front porch, she says, “just because we were hungry.”1
On the night of November 3, 2026, that girl, now Dr. Amy Acton, stood on a stage in Columbus as governor-elect of Ohio and made the crowd a promise. “No one will ever be unseen by me.”2
I want to be forthright about what this essay is, because the subject invites a kind of writing I don’t really trust. Acton is a politician now. She has a record, she is about to build a much longer one, and Ohioans should judge it as skeptically as they would judge any governor’s. Granting sainthood is above my pay grade. What pulls me to her story is older and deeper than a political platform. It is what she did with what was done to her. And it is what another campaign chose to do with it one more time, fifty years later, with four million dollars behind it, just two weeks before an election.
The cruelty was not incidental to the campaign against her. It was the campaign against her. And it lost.
The Girl in the Tent
She was born Amy Leigh Stearns on February 16, 1966, on the north side of Youngstown. After her parents divorced she lived with her mother, and the years that followed held neglect, abuse, and stretches of homelessness, including that winter in the tent. When she was twelve, her stepfather, Cledith Arthur, was arrested and charged with raping her after her biological father reported the abuse. A grand jury indicted him that September; he pleaded not guilty, vacated his last known address, and fled Ohio with her mother, and the warrants the court issued were never answered. These are court records, pulled and verified by newsrooms across the spectrum in October 2026, while the campaign against her was insisting none of it happened.3 Her mother lost custody. In seventh grade Amy moved in with her father and found, for the first time, a stable home.
From there the story’s trajectory runs uphill the whole way. She worked her way through Youngstown State, earned her medical degree in 1990, and trained in pediatrics and preventive medicine, the two specialties you choose when your interest is children and the conditions that harm them. None of this was hidden. She has told the story publicly for years now. She told it to Mike DeWine, Ohio’s Republican governor, in 2019, in the job interview that made her the state’s health director, long before she wanted anyone’s vote.3 Her brother, Philip Stearns, has also corroborated the tent and the abuse on the record.4
By both women’s accounts, mother and daughter have not seen or spoken since the hearing at which a twelve-year-old Amy testified against her stepfather, a man Donna Arthur stayed married to until his death in 2004.4 Asked after the election about seeing her mother on screen for the first time in forty-eight years, Acton answered with more grief than anger. “Obviously, she’s not doing well. I don’t recognize her fully.”5 Life rarely cooperates with a campaign ad, and it did not cooperate with this one.
The Doctor and the Mob
Survival would have been achievement enough, but she did more. Acton became an award-winning professor of maternal and child health at Ohio State and directed Project L.O.V.E., a children’s health initiative, and on February 26, 2019, a Republican governor appointed her director of the Ohio Department of Health, the first woman ever to hold the job.6
Then came 2020 and we all know what that brought. For a stretch of that spring she was the most visible public official in Ohio, the doctor at the podium explaining exponential curves to a frightened state. The reward for her service arrived at her house. Protesters, some carrying semiautomatic rifles, gathered outside her home in Bexley, and the signs there turned antisemitic. At the Statehouse protests against her orders, a demonstrator carried a sign depicting a rat with a Star of David on its side and the words “The Real Plague”; reporters identified him as a neo-Nazi named Matthew Slatzer, and he pleaded guilty to a federal weapons charge that September.7 She was assigned a security detail. On June 11, 2020, she resigned. By her account, the breaking point came when Republican House Speaker Larry Householder pressed her to sign an order allowing fifteen thousand unmasked people into an indoor county-fair event.8 Householder has since begun a twenty-year federal sentence for racketeering, which is its own commentary on whose judgment seems to have held up.8
Her COVID record is fair game for critique. The early projections overshot. The closures carried costs; to businesses, to kids, to trust in public health itself, that Ohio is still tallying, and a voter who held those costs against her was doing what voters are for. But keep the record honest about what kind of criticism that is. Getting a projection wrong is a failure of forecasting and maybe erring on the side of caution. The ad that ended the gubernatorial race accused her of lying about her own childhood. Those are different species of claim, and the opposing campaign needed Ohioans to confuse them as much as possible.
The threat never fully receded, either. On September 6, 2026, at the Canfield Fair, a man forced his way through the crowd toward her while she spoke at the Mahoning County Democrats’ tent, knocking people aside and injuring two of them before troopers took him down. He was carrying multiple weapons. He never got close enough to use them.9
Four Million Dollars
The now-infamous ad surfaced overnight on October 19; a one-minute video spreading through conservative accounts like wildfire by morning.10 On screen was Donna Arthur, Acton’s mother, a woman her daughter had been estranged from for roughly fifty years. “Amy has a serious problem,” Arthur tells the camera. “She is a liar.” The ad disputes the tent, disputes the homelessness, and insinuates that the Democratic nominee for governor is mentally ill.10
For a day its provenance remained vague. Then Vivek Ramaswamy owned it. It was his campaign’s production, he confirmed on October 21, adding that he had never actually met Arthur and that she had not been paid, and defending the spot on the grounds that voters should hear her out. Axios reported the campaign was putting four million dollars behind it statewide.10
Here is what that four million dollars was spent against. Court records showing Arthur’s husband charged with raping her twelve-year-old daughter, records public enough that Tapper had them on air within days.3 The custody ruling that took the children away from the household now making the accusation. A brother who released a video backing his sister in every particular.4 A sitting Republican governor who had heard the whole story from Acton herself, seven years earlier, in a job interview, and hired her. And within twenty-four hours, PolitiFact had assembled what the ad left out, including a detail that needs no commentary from me: Donna Arthur and Cledith Arthur were both convicted of felony theft by deception in Pennsylvania in 1996.11
The defense offered for the ad was that a mother had spoken and voters could weigh her words. But a source’s say-so has never made a claim true, and this source had lost her children precisely because of what the ad asked Ohio to disbelieve. Ramaswamy admitted he had never met his own star witness. He aired her anyway, at full saturation, with just thirteen days left to campaign.
The Men Who Chose It
Start with the Republican who knew her best. Mike DeWine interviewed Acton in 2019 and heard the story of her childhood from her own mouth before he gave her charge over the health department. In 2026 he endorsed Ramaswamy, his party’s nominee, as you’d expect. When the ad ran, DeWine called it “deeply, deeply troubling” and said publicly that it was wrong to run it.12 Jon Husted, campaigning for Senate on the same Republican ballot, told the AP, “I would not have run that ad.”12 Keep those two in mind, because they establish the available choice here. A Republican could work for Acton’s defeat every waking hour and still refuse this particular weapon. Everyone who picked it up did so freely and with intention.
A Republican could work for Acton’s defeat every waking hour and still refuse this particular weapon.
Donald Trump picked it up with both hands. On Truth Social, he called the spot “a very powerful ad,” and said the press was attacking it “because it’s so good,” pronounced the strategy “hitting pay dirt,” and described Acton as a “defective, dishonest, and incapable Candidate.”13 He had already told reporters that Acton, childhood and all, was “fair game.”13 At an October 28 rally in Chillicothe he was still telling the tale. “The mother said that Amy Acton, the daughter, is a liar,” he told the crowd, before asking of Ramaswamy, “How the hell is that his problem?”14
JD Vance went even further. Visiting Ohio the day after Ramaswamy claimed the ad, the vice president said he was “a little bit disgusted,” seemingly to his credit, though his disgust ran toward fellow Republicans, the ones “whining more about that advertisement” than about Democrats. He praised the ad’s candor, saying Ramaswamy “calls it out like it is, and calls Amy Acton a liar.” He told reporters Acton “lies about every single one of her positions.” He compressed his whole ethic into four words, “Politics is a tough business,” and sent his party a closing instruction: “stop whining about an advertisement and go win the race in 13 days.”15
The ad was one front, and Vance worked the others personally. At an early-October rally he described Acton as “the woman who wanted to mask all of our 2-year-olds and keep them from going to school,” then joked that he had “promised Amy that I would meet her at a bar later. I understand that she’s into that sort of thing.”16 The bar line was a wink at a smear running in Ramaswamy-allied ads, which paint Acton as an alcoholic on the strength of a 2019 domestic-dispute 911 call; she denies any alcohol or drug problem and has called the ads “horrible to make lies about alcohol and drug abuse.”16 At the Cincinnati stop where he scolded the whiners, he returned to the insinuation, saying of her 2020 resignation, “She kind of disappeared for a little while,” and then pointing into the crowd. “I think that somebody said alcohol. You can say it, sir. I can’t.”16 The vice president of the United States, playing don’t-make-me-say-it with a rally crowd, about a woman whose actual biography was sitting in a county courthouse the whole time.16
Drink Wisely has looked at why faith-tests almost always measure the wrong things, and I don’t intend to administer one here. I claim no window into these men’s souls. Their conduct, though, sits in public, and so does the standard they campaign under. The tradition Trump brandishes at rallies and Vance professes with evident seriousness includes a commandment against false witness and a Messiah who reserved his most violent image, the millstone, for anyone who puts a stumbling block in front of a child.17 A campaign took the rape of a twelve-year-old girl, routed it through her estranged mother’s mouth, and sold it back to Ohio as proof that the victim was the liar. The men at the summit of that tradition’s loudest political movement called the result powerful, called the objections whining, and called the woman defective.
Their own scriptures call that false witness.
Repairing the World
Acton will be Ohio’s first Jewish governor, and her Judaism is a faith she chose twice, once by birth and once as an adult, when she began studying Torah alongside her children and later joined the board of Congregation Beth Tikvah. “Judaism is a huge part of my life,” she told the Cleveland Jewish News.18 Her husband, Eric, is Episcopalian, a household arrangement she treats as an asset, and she told RNS her personal beliefs embrace a multitude of faiths.19
The religion of her childhood household was a different animal. She has described her stepfather’s relationship with religion as cult-like. The spirituality she found for herself as a girl was small and self-administered, reading Charlotte’s Web under a single lightbulb in a dark basement, and it later picked up a vocabulary from Joseph Campbell’s The Power of Myth.19 As an adult she talks about her work in openly religious terms, and the term she reaches for is tikkun olam, the repair of the world. “I’ve spent my whole life talking about spirituality as another component in people’s holistic well-being and health,” she told Religion News Service in October, in the middle of the ugliest stretch of the campaign. Then she said the thing that gives this essay its rationale. “There are people who keep seeing kindness as weakness, and I keep saying kindness is a fierce commitment to justice. It’s in every religious tradition. It’s about recognizing the humanity in one another, and quite frankly, the God in one another.”19
The Hebrew Bible has a scene for her. Genesis 16. An enslaved Egyptian woman, pregnant and mistreated by the household that holds her, runs into the wilderness, which in that world is close to choosing death. God finds her by a spring in the desert. And Hagar, a foreigner, a slave, a woman, a person three rungs below anyone’s notice, does what no patriarch, prophet, or king in the Hebrew Bible does. She gives God a name. El-roi, which the translators’ note renders “God of seeing,” or “God who sees.”20 The entire sweep of scripture, and the one person who presumes to name God is the one nobody saw.
The entire sweep of scripture, and the one person who presumes to name God is the one nobody saw.
I have no idea whether Acton has ever read Hagar’s story closely, or at all, but it makes no real difference. A girl spent a winter unseen in a tent and grew up to make seeing people her medical specialty, her public health practice, and now the stated premise of her governorship. Her faith tradition calls that tikkun olam. Her own words in October went further than most sermons I ever heard. The God in one another. That’s the claim her life keeps making. That’s God.
Voicemail
On election night, with the race called, Ramaswamy phoned Amy Acton to concede. She let it ring to voicemail.
Six days later she sat across from Jake Tapper on CNN and explained the unanswered call without a hint of apology. “I am not going to normalize this behavior,” she said. She called the conduct of the campaign against her “beyond the pale” and said she has no intention of speaking with the man who ran it. “Leaders’ words matter and we need to hold folks accountable.”5
The obvious rejoinder writes itself here; that a sixty-year-old governor-elect screening her calls is beneath the moment, and that the gracious person swallows hard and takes the handshake. But ask what the handshake signifies. The concession call is the ritual by which both sides certify that everything that happened was politics, regrettable maybe, but within bounds, water under the bridge by inauguration day. It is the machinery of normalization, and normalization is precisely how cruelty stops costing anything. Acton declined to countersign this. The refusal was not pettiness, in my mind, it was her whole candidacy in a moment.
And the story has already outgrown her. She told Tapper that since the ad aired, men and women have been coming up to her at rallies and rope lines to tell her their own stories of abuse, strangers handing a governor-elect the things they had never said out loud. “The universe has sort of called me to taking this on,” she said, and promised to keep speaking about it from office.5 A four-million-dollar weapon built to shame one survivor into silence is instead producing testimony, in fairground crowds, on rope lines, in public. Her abusers’ loudest amplification became other survivors’ permission.
Readers of Genesis will recognize the shape of this. Joseph, standing on the far side of everything his brothers did to him, tells them, “Even though you intended to do harm to me, God intended it for good.”21 I handle providence language carefully, because it has excused a great deal it should have indicted, and nothing about that ad or the childhood behind it gets redeemed by a good outcome. Still, look at what the harm is becoming in her hands: testimony, permission, a governor who plans to keep talking. Joseph’s old line starts to read like reporting.
Eight Points
The Associated Press called Ohio at 10:49 p.m. on November 3.22 When the counting ceased, Acton had 52.31 percent to Ramaswamy’s 44.38, a margin just under eight points in a state Donald Trump carried three times, against a campaign that, with its allies, spent north of a hundred million dollars to stop her.22 She is the first woman elected governor of Ohio, its first Jewish governor, and the first Democrat to win the office in twenty years. Midway through her victory speech, someone in the crowd fainted, and she stopped the biggest speech of her life until they were looked after, which surprised nobody who had been paying attention.2
Then she finished it. “Because of your hard work, Ohio has chosen unity and decency over division and hate,” she said. “The healing begins today.” And the lines aimed at every kid currently on her eighth address in six years: “This win is for all of us, for all the scrappy kids who have been underestimated, overlooked, or counted out. This is my promise to Ohio. No one will ever be unseen by me.”2
The Columbus Dispatch, surveying the wreckage of the Ramaswamy strategy, put it plainly: “Swimming to the bottom of the sewer should not be the price of victory.”23
One election is a small sample, of course, and I’ll keep my claim narrow. Cruelty has won American elections before and will likely again, probably soon. What Ohio showed is narrower, but it’s enough. The cruelty was unnecessary, as DeWine’s refusal proved, and it went unrewarded, as the election returns proved. A party was offered a choice between contesting her record and marketing her rape. They chose the second and lost a governorship it had held for twenty years.
Acton takes the oath on January 11, 2027. Ramaswamy’s four million dollars bought him a concession speech and a voicemail greeting. Trump called the ad pay dirt. Vance called the objections to it whining. And a state that voted for Trump three straight times looked at a woman who was raped at twelve, lied about at sixty, and unbroken at both ends of the story, and made her its new governor.
The cruelty lost, by eight points.
Endnotes
1. “Amy Acton’s Prescription for Ohio,” The Bulwark, October 2026. The breakfast recollection and the “no one in this state is ever unseen” stump line appear there.
2. Acton victory remarks, Hilton Columbus Downtown, November 3, 2026 (Associated Press via WLWT; CBS News; Ideastream; Scioto Post transcript). Verified wording: “This win is for all of us, for all the scrappy kids who have been underestimated, overlooked, or counted out. This is my promise to Ohio. No one will ever be unseen by me,” and “Because of your hard work, Ohio has chosen unity and decency over division and hate. The healing begins today.” [The “We must never give up on one another” line didn’t surface in coverage; restore from video if you have it.]
3. Mahoning County court records, as obtained and reported by the Associated Press, NBC4/WCMH, and CNN’s Jake Tapper, October 2026: Cledith Arthur arrested and charged in July 1978 after Acton’s biological father reported the abuse; grand jury indictment September 1978 (rape; sexual conduct with a minor under thirteen, December 1976–April 1978); not-guilty plea; found by the court to have “willfully vacated his last known address.” NPR (October 21, 2026) verified the campaign-produced records, including the tent. [Warrant dates differ by outlet: NBC4’s reading of the records gives October 1978 and December 1981; earlier coverage said December 1978 and 1982. The body text now avoids specific warrant dates; if you want them back, pick one sourcing.]
4. Statement and response video from Philip Stearns, released via the Acton campaign, October 20–21, 2026 (Associated Press; People): “our birth mother stayed married to Amy’s rapist until he died.” Arthur died in 2004. A Yahoo News profile (October 2026) reports both women say they have not seen or spoken to each other since the hearing at which Acton testified.
5. Acton’s post-election interviews: CBS Mornings, November 6, 2026 (“terrible and despicable,” “no intention of speaking to him,” “leaders’ words matter,” and, on her mother, “Obviously, she’s not doing well. I don’t recognize her fully”); The Lead with Jake Tapper, CNN, November 9, 2026 (the rope-line disclosures, “The universe has sort of called me to taking this on”). [You watched the Tapper interview: confirm which Voicemail-section quotes are Tapper’s versus CBS’s and adjust attribution if needed. Coverage also has Tapper raising Vance’s allusion to a drinking-problem rumor, if you want that material. The outline’s note about a reunion with her mother is contradicted by the record, so I cut it from the draft; restore only if the interview says otherwise.]
6. Ohio Department of Health appointment, February 26, 2019; Acton was the first woman to direct the department. Biographical details (Youngstown State; M.D., 1990; residencies in pediatrics and preventive medicine; Ohio State professorship; Project L.O.V.E.) per the Acton campaign biography and contemporaneous profiles.
7. On the Bexley protests: “Pandemic brings protests, and guns, to officials’ personal homes,” Ohio Capital Journal, January 27, 2021 (armed protesters and an antisemitic sign outside Acton’s home). On the Statehouse sign: first reported by Cleveland.com (April 18, 2020); The Daily Beast identified Matthew Slatzer; “Alleged Neo-Nazi who carried anti-Semitic sign at COVID-19 protest pleads guilty to gun charge,” Ohio Capital Journal, September 16, 2020.
8. Resignation June 11, 2020. The Householder account is Acton’s own, given in later interviews. Householder was sentenced to twenty years in federal prison for racketeering in June 2023 (Associated Press).
9. Associated Press, September 6, 2026; Ohio State Highway Patrol statement. The patrol identified Patrick Havas, 38, who forced his way through the crowd; he was found to be carrying multiple weapons and did not draw them; two attendees were injured.
10. CNN, October 20, 2026 (the video surfaces); Associated Press and PBS NewsHour, October 21–23, 2026 (Ramaswamy confirms his campaign produced the ad, says he never met Donna Arthur, and says she was not compensated); Axios, October 21, 2026 (the $4 million buy).
11. “Abuse and estrangement: What Ramaswamy’s Ohio governor’s race ad with Amy Acton’s mom didn’t mention,” PolitiFact, October 21, 2026. Pennsylvania court records show Donna Arthur and Cledith Arthur were each convicted of felony theft by deception in 1996; the estrangement ran roughly fifty years.
12. DeWine quoted in The New York Times, October 2026; Husted statement to the Associated Press, October 21, 2026.
13. Donald Trump, Truth Social, October 22, 2026, as reported by The New York Times. The “fair game” remark came earlier, to reporters in mid-October 2026 (via contemporaneous coverage, including The Daily Beast).
14. Trump rally, Shoemaker Center, Ohio University Chillicothe, October 28, 2026 (WBNS-10TV; Journal-News; iHeart). Fuller verified wording: “The mother said that Amy Acton, the daughter, is a liar, that she’s no good, that she lied about the opponent. How the hell is that his problem?”
15. JD Vance, remarks to reporters and rally appearance in Ohio, October 21, 2026 (Associated Press; Newsweek; AP via Anchorage Daily News for “lies about every single one of her positions”).
16. Vance remarks at an early-October Ohio rally (Newsweek: the masking line, the bar joke, and “crazy person”) and at the October 21 Cincinnati stop (Yahoo News and other contemporaneous coverage: “She kind of disappeared for a little while”; “I think that somebody said alcohol. You can say it, sir. I can’t.”). Acton’s denial and “horrible to make lies about alcohol and drug abuse” per the Ohio Capital Journal, as cited by Newsweek. The smear ads draw on a 2019 domestic-dispute 911 call first reported by the Columbus Dispatch.
17. Exodus 20:16; Matthew 18:6 (NRSVue).
18. Cleveland Jewish News, 2025.
19. “Ohio will elect its first Hindu or Jewish governor. Here’s how religion is shaping the nasty race,” Religion News Service, October 29, 2026. Confirmed there: the “cult-like” description, the basement reading of Charlotte’s Web, the neighbors’ breakfasts, and the Joseph Campbell influence, alongside the spirituality quote. Board service (Congregation Beth Tikvah, Columbus JCC, Columbus Jewish Day School) per Jewish Insider. [Kindness/“God in one another” quote verified against the RNS piece and RNS’s own excerpts. She used a second version at her October 28 Liberty High School stop (HuffPost): “Kindness is a fierce commitment to justice and seeing the humanity and the God in one another.” The “My opponent is Hindu” line couldn’t be verified and was cut from the body.]
20. Genesis 16:13 (NRSVue); the translators’ note on El-roi reads “God of seeing” or “God who sees.” The observation that Hagar is the only character in the Hebrew Bible to confer a name on God is a commonplace of modern scholarship. [If you want a citation on record, Phyllis Trible’s Texts of Terror is the standard one; use it only if it’s on your shelf.]
21. Genesis 50:20 (NRSVue).
22. Associated Press race call, 10:49 p.m., November 3, 2026. Margin per unofficial statewide returns (52.31–44.38), certification pending; opposition spending figure per AP.
23. The Columbus Dispatch, post-election editorial, November 2026.




“It is the machinery of normalization, and normalization is precisely how cruelty stops costing anything.”
Exactly. If we take any lesson from the last ten years, it should be this one. Nicely done.
Great column. It highlighted a political situation that is easy to have overlooked if you are in another state and focusing on other matters. Two of the politicians named in this article --surnames you can guess at--are so nakedly desperate -- and not even charming about it. Appreciated the focus on Acton's story. "No one will ever be unseen" --awesome line! Many of us can relate ---and welcome her personal victories in more areas than just one.