Essay Three – Total Depravity
My last essay ended on a promise. The doctrine of unconditional election looks like mercy only because of something Dort assumes before it even starts, which is that the whole race already stands fully and justly condemned and God wrongs no one by offering mercy to some and justice to others. That assumption points us to total depravity, and it is really the quiet foundation the rest of the entire construct is built on.
It is also the doctrine most often attacked in a form no one who holds it actually believes.
Dort takes up human corruption in the third and fourth heads of doctrine, which the synod combined because it considered the diagnosis and the cure to be inseparable. The opening articles say that humanity was created in God’s image with a sound knowledge of the Creator, righteousness in the will, and purity in the emotions, and that in rebelling we stripped ourselves of all of it, exchanging those gifts for darkened minds, hardened wills, and disordered affections. Corrupt parents produced corrupt children all the way down the line. All of Adam’s descendants inherit the condition by propagation.
Dort says the corruption reached us by propagation and explicitly denies that it reached us by imitation, which was the Pelagian position the synod wanted knocked down. What Dort describes is a corrupt nature handed down through the generations. The federal scheme most Reformed people learned, in which Adam acts as covenant representative and his guilt gets legally imputed to everyone he represents, is actually a later development. It receives its clearest confessional statement at Westminster nearly thirty years afterward and gets worked out in detail by theologians writing after the synod.1
This distinction appears to be a small thing, but it isn’t. Propagation gives you an inherited condition, a nature bent that way from birth. Imputation gives you inherited guilt for an act committed by somebody else millennia before you existed. The second claim is much harder to defend, and it rests on a reading of Romans 5:12 that has its own stand-alone essay coming, and Dort did not make it.
The sentence that carries the whole doctrine is essentially this. All people are conceived in sin, incapable of any saving good, prone to evil, dead in sin, and slaves to it, and apart from the regenerating grace of the Holy Spirit they are neither able nor willing to return to God, to reform their nature, or even to prepare themselves for reform.2
Read that really closely, because the crucial word here is able. The word depravity describes a condition, while the word inability describes a locked door; no access. The condition alone would leave room for a person to somehow reach for help. The locked door, on the other hand, is what makes unconditional election necessary and irresistible grace inevitable, and everything else in the system depends on that door staying securely locked.
Two clarifications before I continue, because the common caricature of this doctrine is a distortion and is almost always misaimed.
Total, in this instance, does not mean maximal or, in the crudest of terms, “the worst possible.” The claim is that the corruption of sin extends to every human faculty, mind and will and affections alike, leaving no clean compartment from which a person might launch a rescue. The claim is not that everyone is born as vile as they could possibly be. Anyone attacking the doctrine by pointing out that people frequently display decency, then, is attacking a scarecrow rather than the actual doctrine.
And Dort itself grants more than its heirs seem to remember. Article 4 of the same head allows that some light of nature survives the fall, so that human beings retain a certain knowledge of God, of the natural world, and of the difference between good and evil, along with some regard for virtue and for orderly public behavior.3 That article rarely gets taught for obvious reasons. It should, though, because it means the harsh version that gets preached from a great many pulpits is stricter than the confession those pulpits claim as their heritage.
A well-read Reformed reader will answer that Article 4 is doing nothing more than Paul does in Romans 1, where what can be known about God is plain from the things that were made, leaving people without excuse. That is exactly right, and the tradition has a ready reply for why this concession costs it nothing. The light of nature yields knowledge that God exists along with some sense of good and evil. What it never yields is any inclination toward God. A person can know and still have no desire whatsoever to approach, and on the Reformed account that missing desire is the entire problem.
Grant the whole thing, thus far, and then notice where the problem moves. It is no longer in the mind. The unregenerate person on this account is not blind, not ignorant, not lacking data. He sees, understands, and declines. Romans 1 works the same way, since the culpability there rests precisely on what they knew and refused to honor. Total depravity, stated at its most careful, turns out to be a claim about wanting rather than about perceiving. And wanting is exactly what the prophets spend their entire careers addressing.
Something surprised me when I went back to the sources while researching this piece. The Remonstrants largely agreed!
Their third article of 1610 says that fallen humanity has no saving grace of itself and no power in its own free will, and that a person in the state of sin can neither think, nor will, nor do anything truly good, and must be born again of God in Christ through the Spirit before he can even understand what the good is.4 The Society of Evangelical Arminians, which is not an organization with an interest in conceding ground on this point, publishes that text under the heading of total depravity and calls it an unqualified expression of the doctrine.
So the great Dutch fight, meaning the Remonstrant controversy that produced the synod in the first place, was never about whether humans are corrupt. Both sides affirmed it without equivocation. The argument was about what follows from the agreed upon diagnosis, and specifically about whether God’s grace, once extended, can be refused. Which means the T at the front of the acronym is the one point where the two sides came closest to actually shaking hands.
One honest complication, however. Dort was not answering the 1610 articles. By the time the synod convened, the Remonstrants had submitted a later and more developed document, and Dort’s rejection of errors attributes to them the position that the unregenerate is not really dead in sin and can still hunger and thirst after righteousness. Whether that is a fair reading of what they meant by 1618 is a fight I am certainly not equipped to settle here. Still, the 1610 text says what it says.
Moving on to the case for the doctrine itself, which is stronger in my opinion than anything else offered in the five points.
Total depravity describes something. People do not reliably choose the good, including people who know exactly what the good is and want to want it. Moral effort fails in patterned, predictable, humiliating ways. Self-deception operates at a depth that makes self-diagnosis unreliable, which is precisely the problem the doctrine is flagging. Anyone who has spent thirty years losing the same argument with himself understands the intuition behind Article 3 without needing a syllogism. The doctrine did not invent the human condition it describes out of thin air.
The texts themselves are formidable too. Ephesians opens its second chapter by telling readers they were dead in trespasses and sins, following the course of the world, and by nature children of wrath. Romans 3 assembles a devastating chain of quotations. Nobody is righteous, nobody understands, nobody seeks God, all have turned aside, and no fear of God stands before their eyes. Genesis says every inclination of the human heart was only evil continually. Jeremiah calls the heart devious above all else and beyond cure. The psalmist says he was born guilty, a sinner when his mother conceived him. Romans 8 says the mind set on the flesh is hostile to God, cannot submit to God’s law, and cannot please God.
That last one is the hardest verse in the discussion, and it uses the word cannot twice. So where can the argument really go?
We’ll start with Ephesians, since it supplies the metaphor everyone points to. The dead in that passage are described as walking, following, living, and carrying out desires. A corpse can do none of those things. Death there is a way of naming which domain a person belongs to and which power he is aligned with, and the whole letter is preoccupied with the transfer of people from one sphere into another. The Reformed reading takes the metaphor and runs it through a mortuary, insisting that dead means unable to respond to any stimulus whatsoever. The Reformed articulation is dead means dead. Paul’s own sentence, however, has the dead being quite busy.
To be clear about what I am claiming, since this is where the conversation usually goes somewhat sideways, everybody agrees the word is metaphorical. No Reformed theologian has ever thought Paul meant his readers were literal cadavers sitting in the pews at Ephesus, and it would be cheap to pretend otherwise. The disagreement is entirely about what the metaphor carries. The Reformed reading extends it to unresponsiveness, since the one thing corpses reliably do is fail to react. My reading takes its cue from how Paul finishes the sentence. He defines the death he means by describing a way of living, an allegiance, a direction of travel. Elsewhere he uses the same vocabulary for people under the verdict and power of death rather than people incapable of motion. Metaphors have edges, and the author usually shows you where they are.
Then there’s Romans 3, which rewards a close look at its sources. The passage is a catena, a string of quotations from the Psalms and Isaiah, and Paul is stacking them for cumulative effect. Go back to the psalms he is quoting and they turn out to be poems that draw sharp lines between the wicked and the righteous inside the same composition. Psalm 14 says there is none who does good and then, four verses later, refers to the company of the righteous. Whatever the psalmist was doing, he was not issuing a clinical verdict on the species. He was denouncing a particular kind of person, in the way prophets and poets are wont to do.
And Paul’s own conclusion is stated a few lines further on. His point is that Jew and Gentile alike stand under sin, so nobody enters on privileged terms. That is the same essential corporate argument running through the last essay. He is equating two groups, not filing a report on individual human neurology. Paul, in context and read through the lens of the covenantal nature of God’s promises, isn’t talking about individual ability or inability; he’s talking about the fact that Jews and Gentiles are both on a level playing field.
The Hebrew Bible is where the pressure really gets uncomfortable.
God tells Cain that sin is crouching at the door, that its desire is for him, and that he must master it. That is a command issued to a man who has not yet committed the murder, and it assumes at that point in the narrative that he could refuse. Deuteronomy insists that the commandment is not too hard and not far away, that it is not up in heaven or across the sea, but near, in the mouth and in the heart, so that it can be done. Ezekiel tells Israel to make themselves a new heart and a new spirit and asks why they would choose to die, since God takes no pleasure in the death of anyone. Turn, then, and live.
Multiply that by the entire prophetic corpus. The call to repent, issued relentlessly to people who apparently could have responded, is one of the most consistent features of Israel’s scriptures. If total inability is the true anthropology, then an enormous portion of the Bible consists of commands addressed to people constitutionally incapable of actually obeying them, delivered by a God who knew they couldn’t.
The standard Reformed response to that is that the commands establish obligation and expose incapacity without implying ability. That answer is coherent on its face. It is also a strange thing to do for centuries, and stranger still coming from a God who says through Ezekiel that he takes no pleasure in the death of the one who dies.
There is also the matter of what Paul inherited. The Judaism Paul grew up in had its own accounts of why people go wrong, and incapacity was not the standard one. Ben Sira says God made humanity in the beginning and left them in the power of their own choice, with fire and water set before them so they may stretch out a hand toward whichever they prefer. Other streams ran even darker. Fourth Ezra broods over an evil heart carried since Adam, and the Qumran community described two spirits contending for every person. What holds across the variety is a picture of a divided self under pressure from competing inclinations rather than a stiff corpse passively awaiting resuscitation.5
I am working from translations I have access to and from scholars summarizing this literature rather than from years spent in it, so I am not going to build anything substantial on top of it. The claim I am making here is intentionally modest. Paul had several anthropologies available to him in his own setting, and the one Dort assumes he picked was not the obvious choice among them.
Then there is what the doctrine does to people, which is not a formal argument but should be said because the human element is often overlooked or ignored completely.
A child raised on total depravity learns to distrust his own good impulses, on the grounds that they were never really good to begin with. Kindness becomes suspect, since a corrupt nature cannot produce anything untainted. Wanting to be better can become evidence of pride. The doctrine offers no way to distinguish humility from self-contempt, and in my experience the people most damaged by it were the sincere ones, the students who took it seriously enough to apply it to themselves at three in the morning. There is a version of this teaching that produces gratitude. There is another that produces a person who cannot receive a compliment, and the second version is far more common than many will care to admit.
None of that alone makes the doctrine false. Plenty of true things are hard to live with. But when a teaching consistently produces the same wound in the people who believe it the hardest, that is data of a kind, and a tradition serious about the fruit of doctrine should be willing to take a good, hard look at it.
Where this leaves the argument, to this point, is roughly as follows. Human beings are in trouble, deeply and structurally, and any theology that skips past that has not been paying very close attention. The Bible says so on nearly every page. What the Bible does not say, at least not in the places Dort points to, is that human beings are wholly inert. It says they are enslaved, deceived, hostile, and hard, all of which describe a will pulling in the wrong direction rather than a will that has stopped pulling altogether.
The difference sounds technical, but it’s really not. Everything downstream depends on it. If the condition is total inability, the remedy has to be unilateral, and if the remedy is unilateral, the next question is who it was aimed at. Which is where the machine starts making that noise I mentioned way back in the introduction. Don your safety gear.
That said, limited atonement is next.
Endnotes
1 Canons of Dort, Third and Fourth Main Points, Article 2, which states that corruption spread from Adam by propagation of a corrupt nature and rejects the Pelagian account of transmission by imitation. The Westminster Confession, completed at the end of 1646, adds the language of imputed guilt at 6.3, holding that Adam and Eve being the root of all mankind, the guilt of this sin was imputed and the corrupted nature conveyed to their posterity. The Westminster Larger Catechism, question 22, states the covenantal mechanism more explicitly still, describing the covenant as made with Adam as a public person, not for himself only but for his posterity.
2 Canons of Dort, Third and Fourth Main Points of Doctrine, Articles 1 through 3. The phrase “neither able nor willing” follows the older English rendering of Article 3.
3 Canons of Dort, Third and Fourth Main Points, Article 4.
4 The Five Articles of Remonstrance (1610), Article 3, in Philip Schaff, The Creeds of Christendom, vol. 3, 545-549. The Society of Evangelical Arminians publishes the article under the heading “Total Depravity of Humanity.”
5 Sirach 15:14-17; 4 Ezra 3:20-22 and 7:48; the Treatise on the Two Spirits at Qumran, 1QS 3:13-4:26. Ben Sira sets out the position most directly, saying that God created humankind in the beginning and left them in the power of their own free choice, and that fire and water are set before a person to reach toward whichever he chooses. The developed rabbinic doctrine of the yetzer hara, the evil inclination, is attested in sources later than Paul; the claim here is the narrower one, that competing-inclination models were available and current in his lifetime.
6 Scripture references in this essay: Genesis 4:7; Genesis 6:5; Deuteronomy 30:11-14; Psalm 14:1-5; Psalm 51:5; Jeremiah 17:9; Ezekiel 18:31-32; Romans 1:19-21; Romans 3:9-20; Romans 8:7-8; Ephesians 2:1-3. Scripture is paraphrased throughout rather than quoted.




I appreciate this series. Thank you.
This is a nuanced analysis, thank you! Off-topic but adjacent-have you written about the Federal Vision? I am concerned that it gives rise to racist, misogynistic and nationalistic ideas. I still consider myself a Christian and I had a Reformed framework for years, but I always thought the Federal Vision went too far. (The racism, etc. could be seen as evidence for corruption of the will.)