I’m not familiar with TULIP & find this discourse interesting. The nuanced discussion of Total Depravity (TD) is much deeper than the more cursory one about Original Sin (OS) that I encountered during my denomination’s confirmation process. I found the arguments for OS peculiar & not very compelling but learned to keep some questions to myself in order to be confirmed in the faith tradition.
I find the distinction between propagation & imputation fascinating to ponder, I must begin with what bothers me about TD/OS. While Hebrew scripture is quoted, TD/OS isn’t a Jewish theological doctrine. My understanding is that it was proposed by Augustine & elaborated by others as a later interpretation of epistolic scripture.
The distinction is important because Jesus was a practicing Jew, implying that he would either not have embraced TD/SO or would have introduced the concept in his teachings as a new tenet for his fellow Jews & gentile followers. Indeed, TD/OS doesn’t appear in the Apostles’ or Nicene Creeds as a core precept of Christianity.
The other notion bothering me was for what purpose did god create such a flawed creature that would be tempted to eat of the Tree of Knowledge of Good & Evil, why would such a tree grow in the Garden of Eden & what evil was there in the Garden lurking lurking beyond the awareness of Adam & Eve (A&E)? It’s like children don’t know they’re naked until others make a fuss about their state of undress.
Was god punking them by leaving them naked, admonishing them not to eat something that would cause them to consider their genitalia as pundenda? This state of affairs is peculiar if one considers that Genesis 1 states god created A&E in god’s image directing them & the rest of the life forms to be fruitful & multiply. That suggests A&E were already informed about sexual reproduction & didn’t need to give it any thought.
I’m putting this forward because it has bearing on the rest of TULIP. My arguments were put forward under OS without the TD elaboration. I’m looking forward to reading about the other TULIP concepts & pondering their implications.
This is a nuanced analysis, thank you! Off-topic but adjacent-have you written about the Federal Vision? I am concerned that it gives rise to racist, misogynistic and nationalistic ideas. I still consider myself a Christian and I had a Reformed framework for years, but I always thought the Federal Vision went too far. (The racism, etc. could be seen as evidence for corruption of the will.)
I appreciate this series. Thank you.
I’m not familiar with TULIP & find this discourse interesting. The nuanced discussion of Total Depravity (TD) is much deeper than the more cursory one about Original Sin (OS) that I encountered during my denomination’s confirmation process. I found the arguments for OS peculiar & not very compelling but learned to keep some questions to myself in order to be confirmed in the faith tradition.
I find the distinction between propagation & imputation fascinating to ponder, I must begin with what bothers me about TD/OS. While Hebrew scripture is quoted, TD/OS isn’t a Jewish theological doctrine. My understanding is that it was proposed by Augustine & elaborated by others as a later interpretation of epistolic scripture.
The distinction is important because Jesus was a practicing Jew, implying that he would either not have embraced TD/SO or would have introduced the concept in his teachings as a new tenet for his fellow Jews & gentile followers. Indeed, TD/OS doesn’t appear in the Apostles’ or Nicene Creeds as a core precept of Christianity.
The other notion bothering me was for what purpose did god create such a flawed creature that would be tempted to eat of the Tree of Knowledge of Good & Evil, why would such a tree grow in the Garden of Eden & what evil was there in the Garden lurking lurking beyond the awareness of Adam & Eve (A&E)? It’s like children don’t know they’re naked until others make a fuss about their state of undress.
Was god punking them by leaving them naked, admonishing them not to eat something that would cause them to consider their genitalia as pundenda? This state of affairs is peculiar if one considers that Genesis 1 states god created A&E in god’s image directing them & the rest of the life forms to be fruitful & multiply. That suggests A&E were already informed about sexual reproduction & didn’t need to give it any thought.
I’m putting this forward because it has bearing on the rest of TULIP. My arguments were put forward under OS without the TD elaboration. I’m looking forward to reading about the other TULIP concepts & pondering their implications.
This is a nuanced analysis, thank you! Off-topic but adjacent-have you written about the Federal Vision? I am concerned that it gives rise to racist, misogynistic and nationalistic ideas. I still consider myself a Christian and I had a Reformed framework for years, but I always thought the Federal Vision went too far. (The racism, etc. could be seen as evidence for corruption of the will.)
I’m appreciating this!