7 Comments
User's avatar
Rob Bright's avatar

Love 99% of the article. Thought provoking and interesting. I shared it on my Facebook wall.

Your discussion of Dolly's failure to "call out sin" reminds me of my own article, Should Christians Focus on "Telling People the Truth About Sin?" Did Jesus?" which can be found here (I don't accept money from anyone for my Substack):

"In my experience, the approach of many evangelical/fundamentalists would be closer to that of the Pharisees than to that of Jesus."

https://robwbright.substack.com/p/should-christians-focus-on-telling

I agree completely.

I think you also might enjoy Jewish-Christian Biblical scholar Dr. Eitan Bar's take on Matthew 25:

https://eitan.bar/articles/is-the-parable-of-the-sheep-and-the-goats-about-hell-matthew-2531-46/

But brother... it seems like you sometimes feel a need to grind a political axe in weird places that aren't even relevant to the point you're making. You said:

"An unconditional cash transfer to disaster victims, regardless of income, which is a policy most conservative evangelicals would label socialism if an opposition party politician proposed it."

Come on. I mean it's a true statement as far as it goes, but why would you throw that in the article? You were talking about a private organization giving money away and somehow thought it appropriate to bring government and politics into the situation.

Why? You were talking about one thing and implied an association to a completely different thing.

I can't think of ANY conservative evangelicals who would consider it socialism when a private organization does that. They may or may not approve of that, but they wouldn't call it socialism.

And I'm neither conservative nor Evangelical (although I spent 30+ years as both).

The issue conservatives object to (and as a libertarian, I also object) is government taking taxpayer money by force from some people and giving it to other people. That is done with minimal regard for whether or not the taxpayers approve of who their money is given to.

Our government sometimes gives that taxpayer money to BOTH sides of an issue. See: the Iran/Iraq war in the 1980s and countless other examples.

And government aid is ALWAYS terribly inefficient with tons of waste.

Those are LEGITIMATE reasons to think that government charity isn't all it's cracked up to be.

Regardless, the statement I quoted is irrelevant to the situation and a strange addition to an article that's otherwise excellent.

Please consider not politicizing your articles. It distracts from the main point, which is excellent.

Shawn Patrick Connelly's avatar

Thanks for the note, and for sharing the essay on Facebook. I'll read both pieces you suggest when possible. Bar on Matthew 25 is relevant to what I was arguing and I appreciate the reference.

On the socialism thing, I think the conditional I put in there got lost. What I wrote was that unconditional cash to disaster victims regardless of income is a policy most conservative evangelicals would label socialism if an opposition party politician proposed it. That clause is the differentiator and what makes the statement relevant to the thesis. I wasn't suggesting anyone would call the Dollywood Foundation socialist, and I agree with you that they wouldn't. The point I was trying (and not so well, apparently) to make is that the same policy shape gets a different label depending on the venue and the proposer.

That's also why I put it in the record section instead of just a random political aside. The essay is about criteria and how selectively they get applied. Matthew 25 has no means test. Nobody in the parable asks whether the hungry man deserved lunch, and the sheep don't screen anybody on the way in. Parton's fund worked the same way, I think, and I wanted that obvious on the page.

Your libertarian objections are legit arguments. Taxpayer coercion, inefficiency, funding both sides of a conflict. Those are arguments to have on their own terms, and none of them is what my sentence was about (or intended to be about). I did write recently on how the word socialism gets deployed in American politics, mostly to argue that the definitional confusion serves the people deploying it. https://drinkwisely.substack.com/p/comrade-chris

On politicizing, I'd gently disagree. Drink Wisely is about how faith and power shape each other, and the power half isn't optional. When a policy counts as charity in one venue and socialism in another, the theology and the politics are already tangled long before I show up. My job is to notice and call it out. I've done that (or tried to) from day one. Thanks again for reading!

Jon Westlake's avatar

How is it that the statement “not a real Christian” is levelled at people by those who are not, by any rational standard, Christian?

Steve Suter's avatar

I'm still working on getting a handle on this hand grenade that Jesus tossed at us in Luke 10.

On one occasion an expert in the law stood up to test Jesus. “Teacher,” he asked, “what must I do to inherit eternal life?” “What is written in the Law?” he replied. “How do you read it?” He answered, “‘Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your strength and with all your mind’; and, ‘Love your neighbor as yourself.’” “You have answered correctly,” Jesus replied. “Do this and you will live.”

I cannot read this in any other way than that Jesus is telling us that following these two rules will let us inherit eternal life. Although we all, even Dolly, surely need forgiveness for the times that we come up short. God's blessings on you today, Shawn.

Shlomoh Sherman's avatar

Dolly Parton did not say a TV church program of hers was dropped, but she did make controversial remarks in 1994 about abandoning a planned television project because she believed Hollywood executives—whom she noted were mostly Jewish—were afraid to promote Christianity.The 1994 Interview and ApologyThe Statement: In a 1994 interview with Vogue magazine, Parton discussed an idea she had for a television series about a country singer who transitions to gospel music after a near-death experience.The Quote: She stated that she decided not to pursue the project because "everybody's afraid to touch anything that's religious because most of the people out here [in Hollywood] are Jewish, and it's a frightening thing for them to promote Christianity."The Backlash: The Anti-Defamation League (ADL) criticized the comments, stating they relied on old antisemitic stereotypes regarding Jewish control in Hollywood and hostility toward Christianity.The Apology: Parton quickly issued a public apology, expressing regret that her words could be interpreted as implying Jewish control or causing hurt, and emphasized that she rejected prejudice.הספרייה הלאומית של ישראלDolly Parton apologizes for remarks about Jews [ARTICLE]Mar 11, 1994 — NEW YORK (JTA) Country singer and actress Dolly Parton has apologized for comments she made in an interview with Vogue magazine ab...The New York TimesCHRONICLE - The New York TimesFeb 24, 1994 — DOLLY PARTON has apologized to the Anti-Defamation League for remarks she made about Jews during an interview published in the Jan...

Shawn Patrick Connelly's avatar

Thanks for the comment. I checked it and it holds up. Vogue's January 1994 issue, Foxman writing to her for the ADL, and her apology by late February.

The detail of Dolly's apology is what stands out to me. She wrote to Foxman that she regretted her words could have conjured an impression of Jewish control of Hollywood. That sentence goes after the trope itself instead of the hurt feelings, which is a rarer thing, I think. Foxman accepted it and said the matter was behind them. I'll assume it is.

Now, next to the Federalist writer in my piece, who regretted using Parton as her example and left her standard exactly where it was. Parton did the reverse. She retracted the claim and left the people alone.

You did catchthe one line in the essay I'd want to qualify, since I wrote that she wouldn't sort anybody and in 1994 she plainly did. Good catch. What I'd say is that Matthew 25 never promised a clean record. The sheep are astonished, which tells you none of them were keeping their own file. The big question the parable asks is what you did for people, right?, and my question is why that standard seems to make so many folks nervous.

Jim Stephens's avatar

Thank you so much for this! Grace to you! Jim Stephens