Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jim Stephens's avatar

Thank you so much for this! Grace to you! Jim Stephens

Rob Bright's avatar

Love 99% of the article. Thought provoking and interesting. I shared it on my Facebook wall.

Your discussion of Dolly's failure to "call out sin" reminds me of my own article, Should Christians Focus on "Telling People the Truth About Sin?" Did Jesus?" which can be found here (I don't accept money from anyone for my Substack):

"In my experience, the approach of many evangelical/fundamentalists would be closer to that of the Pharisees than to that of Jesus."

https://robwbright.substack.com/p/should-christians-focus-on-telling

I agree completely.

I think you also might enjoy Jewish-Christian Biblical scholar Dr. Eitan Bar's take on Matthew 25:

https://eitan.bar/articles/is-the-parable-of-the-sheep-and-the-goats-about-hell-matthew-2531-46/

But brother... it seems like you sometimes feel a need to grind a political axe in weird places that aren't even relevant to the point you're making. You said:

"An unconditional cash transfer to disaster victims, regardless of income, which is a policy most conservative evangelicals would label socialism if an opposition party politician proposed it."

Come on. I mean it's a true statement as far as it goes, but why would you throw that in the article? You were talking about a private organization giving money away and somehow thought it appropriate to bring government and politics into the situation.

Why? You were talking about one thing and implied an association to a completely different thing.

I can't think of ANY conservative evangelicals who would consider it socialism when a private organization does that. They may or may not approve of that, but they wouldn't call it socialism.

And I'm neither conservative nor Evangelical (although I spent 30+ years as both).

The issue conservatives object to (and as a libertarian, I also object) is government taking taxpayer money by force from some people and giving it to other people. That is done with minimal regard for whether or not the taxpayers approve of who their money is given to.

Our government sometimes gives that taxpayer money to BOTH sides of an issue. See: the Iran/Iraq war in the 1980s and countless other examples.

And government aid is ALWAYS terribly inefficient with tons of waste.

Those are LEGITIMATE reasons to think that government charity isn't all it's cracked up to be.

Regardless, the statement I quoted is irrelevant to the situation and a strange addition to an article that's otherwise excellent.

Please consider not politicizing your articles. It distracts from the main point, which is excellent.

5 more comments...

Ready for more?