I am not American, nor an Evangelical. This Substack is helping me to understand the inside of the American Evangelical social and religious system, which gets so much publicity across the world atm.
It's probably as complicated as any other strong culture or church, certainly like those I've known. But I find it beneficial to have this openness. Thanks again, Shawn.
Good to hear this. It's good to remember too, that the way we hear things, even the gospel, is deeply affected by our own social world. There are Christians and people of faith everywhere with quite different social environments, e.g., my refugee father-in-law. They hear the gospel differently.
If Westerners could talk less and not speak so loudly and fast, they will be less like "Pharisees" and become like the one commended by Jesus, the humble "publican" at the back of the temple.
Evangelicals smooth over textual problems in modern translations of the Bible as well as add words or take away words to follow Evangelical theology. They own the market on biblical books and theology studies. They read Evangelicals who read other Evangelicals In their critique of others who are not Evangelicals.I know this because I was an Evangelical for 35 years.
There is no trying to convinced the already convinced and certain. Yes, they can quote or refer to many Evangelical biblical scholars and theologians and the vast majority, outside real hard ball scholars, are on their side. Look how they have been Americanized into western individualism, co-opted by the conservative political ideas and the Republican Party, skeptic of anything, even the paranormal supernatural that does not fit into their worldview and echo chamber.
I’ve quit trying to talk to them because how we think, engage scripture, see the world is very different. So I appreciate your words and trying but I simply don’t have time for what Karl Barth back in the day called “Christianity yesterday.”
The Holy Spirit is moving in people churches have marginalized and discarded. God is working in the younger unchurched generation teaching them like Paul directed by the Spirit with visions and prophesy. God is working outside of religion and around it when God can’t get through it. People can keep trusting their paper pope but God’s Spirit can neither be tamed or domesticated which is why so many in institutional religion folks can’t stand or don’t want to understand the new thing God is doing.
And if you’re at all curious what the Religious Right kids are up to these days, it’s defending civilization itself, classical liberalism, the dignity and worth of the individual, freedom of conscience.
You might actually really enjoy the recent film Truth Rising, a documentary somewhat structured around the life and adventures of thinker, author Os Guinness, whose formative time at Francis Schaeffer’s L’abri study community set his whole life on a certain trajectory.
Featuring Ayaan Hirsi Ali, her beau Sir Niall Ferguson, Konstantin Kisin, David Berlinski and others, it is in my view a beautiful meditation on our current civilizational moment in the West.
Despite the sums invested in the project, the principals wanted as many people as possible to be able to view it, so the film is on YouTube for free:
Hey, I’m certainly sympathetic to the frustration you feel, from the experiences you’ve had. But I think you may have possibly overreacted:
To say that the Protestant understanding of inerrancy was formalized and defined in recent centuries or decades is not the same as saying that ancient commentators, much less the Hebrew Bible’s prophets, or Jesus and His Apostles thought the Word given by the Almighty had mistakes in it.
And the culture war is not one that we started.
Call us reactionaries if you like, but it’s been waged by conservative Christians as a defensive war, to protect the unborn, to preserve families, institutions and freedom of conscience itself from constant attacks on every side.
My favorite apologist is a friend of mine, the Thomist philosopher Dr. Richard Howe, Provost at Southern Evangelical Seminary:
There is a place for apologetics, but I soured on it when I arrived at Seminary. Young men arguing viciously about things they hadn't even deeply studied yet. Too often, they were unwilling to listen to the wisdom of the professors. And some of what we believe is supernatural, and sadly apologetics can flatten what is mysterious and supernatural about the Christian faith.
My grandfather, an OT professor, didn't really do apologetics. He would share what he believed, but wasn't intent on producing students who believed exactly as he did. Instead, he insisted they drink deeply of the Scriptures, and trust God to lead them to truth. I'm thankful for the work of apologists. We do need them! However, most of us will never be able to study the original manuscripts. Most of us do not have a strong grasp of Greek or Hebrew or Aramaic (or even English lol). We need to balance the importance of some doing the important work of apologetics with the supremely more important work of the Holy Spirit's transformation of hearts, opening eyes to see God's realities.
I'm thankful for how you served when you were seeking to do apologetics faithfully. But I'm very thankful for your humility to see the limitations of debate, and the ways debate and speed do produce something that falls short of what apologetics is meant to accomplish.
I’m convinced that truths such as 1 Corinthians 12:3 and John 6:44 combined with a realistic view of human irrationality make apologetics a discipline for eh already believing, not an evangelistic tool. Faith does not come by reason. “I believe, in order to understand; and I understand, the better to believe,” (Augustine).
Agreed. And here's how a real Biblical scholar handled things. Dr. Michael S. Heiser (R.I.P.):
"I don’t believe in debates. Debates are for the lazy. What I mean by that is that, if someone really wants to learn something, they’ll study and do research. They won’t be content to be entertained. Debates are a substitute for study. They are academic bloodsport — entertainment for both sides that allows both sides to avoid the hard work of studying. I’m not an entertainer. If you want to know what I think and why I think it, read what I write. If you still want entertainment, get used to disappointment. Don’t be lazy.
In regard to people who have never read my work and are suspicious of what I teach, see the last line line above. Have the patience and honesty to read the material. Many thousands have, of all traditions, and enjoyed the experience: Calvinists, Arminians, amiller, premillers, [fill in some other thing Christians fight about].
Really, folks, I’m serious about viewing my life as a race against time. I will not spend my time shooting at other Christians. I care only if the clarity of the gospel is present, and what the biblical text can exegetically sustain on all other matters. I don’t care about anyone’s views of creation, end times, election, tongues, etc. I want people to stop parroting the views of their traditions and get their noses back into the biblical text — and read that text in its own context, not some post-biblical context or tradition.
If it irritates you that I don’t have the gift of indignation and want to have a “ministry” that fights other believers, go somewhere else. Again, I’m not here to entertain. I’m here to help you become a better reader and student of Scripture. I’m here to help people see when their views are possible, and perhaps plausible, or not. I’m not here to tell people what to believe or gain followers. I’ll let other “ministries” do that (sarcastic, but sadly true).
I am not American, nor an Evangelical. This Substack is helping me to understand the inside of the American Evangelical social and religious system, which gets so much publicity across the world atm.
It's probably as complicated as any other strong culture or church, certainly like those I've known. But I find it beneficial to have this openness. Thanks again, Shawn.
You’re quite welcome. Thank you for reading and commenting!
PS Thank you Shawn, for this!
Good to hear this. It's good to remember too, that the way we hear things, even the gospel, is deeply affected by our own social world. There are Christians and people of faith everywhere with quite different social environments, e.g., my refugee father-in-law. They hear the gospel differently.
If Westerners could talk less and not speak so loudly and fast, they will be less like "Pharisees" and become like the one commended by Jesus, the humble "publican" at the back of the temple.
Very well said!
Good response Shawn.
Evangelicals smooth over textual problems in modern translations of the Bible as well as add words or take away words to follow Evangelical theology. They own the market on biblical books and theology studies. They read Evangelicals who read other Evangelicals In their critique of others who are not Evangelicals.I know this because I was an Evangelical for 35 years.
There is no trying to convinced the already convinced and certain. Yes, they can quote or refer to many Evangelical biblical scholars and theologians and the vast majority, outside real hard ball scholars, are on their side. Look how they have been Americanized into western individualism, co-opted by the conservative political ideas and the Republican Party, skeptic of anything, even the paranormal supernatural that does not fit into their worldview and echo chamber.
I’ve quit trying to talk to them because how we think, engage scripture, see the world is very different. So I appreciate your words and trying but I simply don’t have time for what Karl Barth back in the day called “Christianity yesterday.”
The Holy Spirit is moving in people churches have marginalized and discarded. God is working in the younger unchurched generation teaching them like Paul directed by the Spirit with visions and prophesy. God is working outside of religion and around it when God can’t get through it. People can keep trusting their paper pope but God’s Spirit can neither be tamed or domesticated which is why so many in institutional religion folks can’t stand or don’t want to understand the new thing God is doing.
Shalom.
And if you’re at all curious what the Religious Right kids are up to these days, it’s defending civilization itself, classical liberalism, the dignity and worth of the individual, freedom of conscience.
You might actually really enjoy the recent film Truth Rising, a documentary somewhat structured around the life and adventures of thinker, author Os Guinness, whose formative time at Francis Schaeffer’s L’abri study community set his whole life on a certain trajectory.
Featuring Ayaan Hirsi Ali, her beau Sir Niall Ferguson, Konstantin Kisin, David Berlinski and others, it is in my view a beautiful meditation on our current civilizational moment in the West.
Despite the sums invested in the project, the principals wanted as many people as possible to be able to view it, so the film is on YouTube for free:
Truth Rising
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=XXc5IhgSZkg&t=2526s&pp=ygUMdHJ1dGggcmlzaW5n
(84 minutes)
S i r ~
Hey, I’m certainly sympathetic to the frustration you feel, from the experiences you’ve had. But I think you may have possibly overreacted:
To say that the Protestant understanding of inerrancy was formalized and defined in recent centuries or decades is not the same as saying that ancient commentators, much less the Hebrew Bible’s prophets, or Jesus and His Apostles thought the Word given by the Almighty had mistakes in it.
And the culture war is not one that we started.
Call us reactionaries if you like, but it’s been waged by conservative Christians as a defensive war, to protect the unborn, to preserve families, institutions and freedom of conscience itself from constant attacks on every side.
My favorite apologist is a friend of mine, the Thomist philosopher Dr. Richard Howe, Provost at Southern Evangelical Seminary:
http://richardghowe.com/
Here is what might be his signature talk,
How Theology Needs Philosophy
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=2z4PO7R-CIY&t=178s&pp=2AGyAZACAcoFFGhvd2Ugc2FsdCAxNCByaWNoYXJk
(42 minutes)
and some of his other ‘greatest hits’ you may find relevant as you sort out your own position:
God Fading Away
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=khDIWiMF9ts&t=2253s&pp=ygUcUmljaGFyZCBob3dlIEdvZCBmYWRpbmcgYXdheQ%3D%3D
(74 minutes)
Jesus Just Left Chicago
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Gzha2sqA4jc&t=35s&pp=ygUkUmljaGFyZCBob3dlIEplc3VzIGp1c3QgbGVmdCBjaGljYWdv0gcJCSsMAYcqIYzv
(56 minutes)
Is the Bible Inerrant? (DEBATE: Richard Howe vs. Mike Licona - 2019)
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=rLwnjx6-5dc&t=4s&pp=ygULaG93ZSBsaWNvbmE%3D
(114 minutes)
Blest wishes! ✝️🙏
Dan Segal
Thanks for this.
There is a place for apologetics, but I soured on it when I arrived at Seminary. Young men arguing viciously about things they hadn't even deeply studied yet. Too often, they were unwilling to listen to the wisdom of the professors. And some of what we believe is supernatural, and sadly apologetics can flatten what is mysterious and supernatural about the Christian faith.
My grandfather, an OT professor, didn't really do apologetics. He would share what he believed, but wasn't intent on producing students who believed exactly as he did. Instead, he insisted they drink deeply of the Scriptures, and trust God to lead them to truth. I'm thankful for the work of apologists. We do need them! However, most of us will never be able to study the original manuscripts. Most of us do not have a strong grasp of Greek or Hebrew or Aramaic (or even English lol). We need to balance the importance of some doing the important work of apologetics with the supremely more important work of the Holy Spirit's transformation of hearts, opening eyes to see God's realities.
I'm thankful for how you served when you were seeking to do apologetics faithfully. But I'm very thankful for your humility to see the limitations of debate, and the ways debate and speed do produce something that falls short of what apologetics is meant to accomplish.
I’m convinced that truths such as 1 Corinthians 12:3 and John 6:44 combined with a realistic view of human irrationality make apologetics a discipline for eh already believing, not an evangelistic tool. Faith does not come by reason. “I believe, in order to understand; and I understand, the better to believe,” (Augustine).
Agreed. And here's how a real Biblical scholar handled things. Dr. Michael S. Heiser (R.I.P.):
"I don’t believe in debates. Debates are for the lazy. What I mean by that is that, if someone really wants to learn something, they’ll study and do research. They won’t be content to be entertained. Debates are a substitute for study. They are academic bloodsport — entertainment for both sides that allows both sides to avoid the hard work of studying. I’m not an entertainer. If you want to know what I think and why I think it, read what I write. If you still want entertainment, get used to disappointment. Don’t be lazy.
In regard to people who have never read my work and are suspicious of what I teach, see the last line line above. Have the patience and honesty to read the material. Many thousands have, of all traditions, and enjoyed the experience: Calvinists, Arminians, amiller, premillers, [fill in some other thing Christians fight about].
Really, folks, I’m serious about viewing my life as a race against time. I will not spend my time shooting at other Christians. I care only if the clarity of the gospel is present, and what the biblical text can exegetically sustain on all other matters. I don’t care about anyone’s views of creation, end times, election, tongues, etc. I want people to stop parroting the views of their traditions and get their noses back into the biblical text — and read that text in its own context, not some post-biblical context or tradition.
If it irritates you that I don’t have the gift of indignation and want to have a “ministry” that fights other believers, go somewhere else. Again, I’m not here to entertain. I’m here to help you become a better reader and student of Scripture. I’m here to help people see when their views are possible, and perhaps plausible, or not. I’m not here to tell people what to believe or gain followers. I’ll let other “ministries” do that (sarcastic, but sadly true).
It’s that simple."
https://drmsh.com/mikes-talked-lot-lately-seems/
For what it's worth, I stand with you. For me the focus on all the aspects you describe exists to conceal the hollow at the centre
I’ve never seen a more misleading headline. You’re one of the best Christian apologists I’ve ever read. So there. (And keep it up!)
Great post…