I used to be good at this. For years I was one of those people that people called when a nephew came home from his first semester of college asking hard questions, or when a coworker found out I knew enough Greek or Latin to argue about the resurrection over lunch. I had the verses. I had the curated footnotes to counter the historical-critical footnotes. I could take a conversation that started with “I just don’t see how a loving God could...” and end it with the other person acknowledging that I took their doubt seriously instead of just handing them a tract or telling them they’re likely going to hell.
I don’t do that anymore. Not because I think every argument for the gospel falls apart under scrutiny, and not because I’ve stopped caring whether any of this is true. I stopped because the thing I’d be defending, in 2026, isn’t the faith I spent decades studying. It’s more of a brand these days. Defending a brand with tools built for defending a faith is a peculiar kind of dishonesty, and I’m done engaging in it.
The faith I grew up defending claimed a few basics, things like the historical reliability of the central events, the coherence of its moral vision, the plausibility of the whole account against its rival accounts. What’s being defended now is an entirely different animal. Biblical inerrancy, treated today like it has always been built into the text itself, is a nineteenth and twentieth century invention, formalized at Princeton1 and codified in 1978 at a hotel conference center in Chicago.2 Augustine didn’t need it. Origen would have laughed at it. The church existed for well over a thousand years without demanding that every verse operate as a flat, uniform, scientifically precise transcript of history that harmonizes like an auto-tuned boy band. Modern apologetics defends that invention as if it were somehow the whole deposit of the faith, and loses ground every time it does, because the Bible was never constructed to pass that particular test.
The reinvention didn’t stop with the Bible either. The faith itself got conscripted. What used to be a tradition oriented toward humility, repentance, and the slow work of becoming a better (read: more Christlike) person in community now functions, for plenty of people, as a political identity with a worship band in tow. Ask an apologist to defend Christian nationalism, complementarian hierarchy taken to its logical end, or the idea that doubt itself is a type of sin, and watch how fast defending the faith turns into defending a culture and a voting bloc.
And the project itself has morphed too. Apologetics used to mean preparing an answer and being ready, with gentleness, for someone actually wrestling with doubt. Now it means content, clips, debate highlights, dunks, owning Libs, and a guy with a ring light and a whiteboard promising to destroy an atheist’s worldview in under three minutes. The incentive rewards confidence and speed over care, because that’s what sells and gets clicks online. Two of the apologists getting the most traction right now make this point in opposite ways.
Take Wes Huff for example. He’s the Canadian apologist, a PhD student in New Testament studies and a director with Apologetics Canada, who became a minor celebrity overnight after a three-hour conversation with Joe Rogan in January 2025, watched by millions.3 Credit where it’s due up front, Huff is actually sharper than most people doing this work. He knows manuscripts and Greek better than the average megachurch resident apologist. When Bart Ehrman devoted an episode of his Misquoting Jesus podcast to fact-checking specific claims Huff made on Rogan’s show, he didn’t just nitpick. On the Great Isaiah Scroll, Ehrman agreed with Huff’s headline point but noted it leaned on the single best-case example while skating past other Dead Sea Scrolls that diverge from the Masoretic text far more than that one does. On how early and unanimous agreement on the biblical canon really was, Ehrman pushed back harder, pointing to manuscript evidence that complicates the clean story Huff told Rogan.4 Huff himself posted a follow-up video afterward, titled “I Debunk...Myself,” walking several of his own claims back.5
What bothers me most about apologists like this is a specific kind of zeal. The drive to defend and prove the faith as they understand it clouds judgment and crowds out objectivity, so they end up promoting claims and evidence that don’t hold up, because the claims serve the narrative they already believe. Call it an ends-justify-the-means approach to the Gospel, where a half-truth that helps the defense gets to live another day because the cause outweighs the accuracy of any single claim.
That’s, again, more integrity than most of his peers show, I’ll admit. It also proves my point. Huff knew more than almost anyone else in that chair, in a controlled setting with no editor and no fact-checker, and still found it necessary to issue corrections after the fact. The genre rewards whoever talks fastest and sounds most confident, full stop. Being the smartest kid in a classroom that rewards speed over rigor doesn’t change what the classroom rewards. The same formula worked for Charlie Kirk too, a guy who never called himself an apologist and ran his operation on the same fuel anyway, talking fast, talking loud, and sounding supremely certain. That approach read as convincing to an untrained, sympathetic ear whether or not the argument underneath earned it. It seldom did.
Then there’s Josh Howerton, pastor of Lakepointe Church in Rockwall, Texas. He’s a pastor by title, a defender of a specific evangelical vision of marriage and gender by practice, delivered with enough charisma to fill an arena. In February 2024, Howerton told his congregation that on their wedding night, women should “stand where he tells you to stand, wear what he tells you to wear, and do what he tells you to do.”6 The line drew cheers from the room, national coverage, and eventually a required apology that Howerton first dismissed as people missing a joke. That apology turned out to be lifted almost word for word from a different pastor’s apology, given two years earlier for an unrelated scandal, down to the same verse from Proverbs. Howerton couldn’t even fail with real honesty. He had to outsource that too.7
Here’s what both cases share, even though they’re really nothing alike as thinkers. Huff is doing real scholarship and still gets swallowed by a format built for speed. Howerton isn’t doing scholarship at all, really, he’s doing crowd work and gets handed a bigger platform every time the crowd cheers along with something that would get him walked out of most rooms outside a church. Both men are stand-ins for an industry that has confused confidence for credibility. When that industry calls itself apologetics, when it invokes Peter’s command to always be ready to give an answer for the hope within you, it’s cashing a check written by people who meant something very different by “answer” than a clip built for the algorithm.
Rogan, to his credit, didn’t stop with Huff. In October 2026 he had Dan McClellan on, the biblical scholar behind the Data Over Dogma podcast. McClellan ignored the first invitation, consulted people on both sides before accepting the second, and has said openly that he considers the show a vector for the kind of misinformation he spends his career correcting. Once he showed up, he didn’t try to win anyone to anything. He laid out what the historical and textual evidence says, left the supernatural and devotional questions off the table, and let the material do the work. Huff showed up to defend a conclusion he’d already reached. McClellan showed up to describe what the evidence actually shows, then stopped talking.8 Big difference.
So here’s my apology, if it counts for anything. I spent years telling people the case for Christianity was solid enough to bet a life on, and I believed it, and I still think the historical core holds up fine under honest scrutiny. Where I went wrong was agreeing to defend everything attached to that core along the way, the inerrancy project, the culture-war add-ons, the whole industry of confident men with microphones selling certainty like doubt were a moral failure instead of the ordinary—even healthy—condition of anyone paying attention. I’ve set that job down. I’m relieved and I’m content with that.
There’s a line that gets passed around as Spurgeon, though as far as I can tell nobody has ever actually pinned him down saying it in exactly these words.9 It’s close enough to things he preached more than once to count as his in spirit though. The gospel doesn’t need lawyers. It’s a lion. Stop guarding the cage, open the door, and let it out. It’ll take care of itself.
I think that’s true of anything real, not just the Gospel. Authentic faith doesn’t need me to twist arguments into the shapes that defend it. Truth doesn’t need a defense attorney. It just needs room to be what it already is.
Notes
1. On Princeton’s role in formalizing the modern doctrine of inerrancy, see A. A. Hodge and B. B. Warfield, “Inspiration,” Presbyterian Review 2 (1881); and Stephen Nichols, “How We Got Here,” Ligonier Ministries, learn.ligonier.org/articles/how-we-got-here.
2. The Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy was drafted October 26–28, 1978, at the Hyatt Regency O’Hare in Chicago by roughly 300 evangelical leaders convened by the International Council on Biblical Inerrancy. See Liz Charlotte Grant, “The Certainty Summit,” Christian Century, April 2025, christiancentury.org/features/certainty-summit.
3. Joe Rogan Experience #2252, “Wesley Huff,” January 13, 2025. See also Kentucky Today, “No Topic Off-Limits: Joe Rogan Hosts Christian Apologist Wesley Huff, Millions Hear Defense of Gospel,” January 14, 2025, republished at thebaptistpaper.org.
4. Bart Ehrman, “Bart Fact Checks Apologist Wes Huff,” Misquoting Jesus podcast, episode 197, bartehrman.com.
5. “‘I Debunk...Myself’—Christian Apologist Responds to Several Errors He Made When Talking to Joe Rogan,” ChurchLeaders, churchleaders.com/news/504021.
6. Josh Howerton, sermon at Lakepointe Church, Rockwall, TX, February 24, 2024. Reported in “Megachurch Pastor Defends Controversial Remarks About the Wedding Night as a ‘Joke,’” ChurchLeaders, churchleaders.com/news/475034.
7. On the plagiarism allegation, see “Megachurch Pastor Responds to Accusation He Plagiarized His Apology for ‘Joke’ About Wedding Nights,” KENS5, April 2024; and “Megachurch Pastor Accused of Plagiarizing an Apology,” Plagiarism Today, April 18, 2024.
8. Joe Rogan Experience #2562, “Dan McClellan,” released October 7, 2026. See also “LDS Scholar Dan McClellan Appears on Joe Rogan’s Podcast,” Salt Lake Tribune, October 10, 2026.
9. This wording is a popular paraphrase, not a verified direct quotation. See “6 Things Spurgeon Didn’t Say,” Spurgeon.org, spurgeon.org/blog/6-things-spurgeon-didnt-say. The closest authentic parallels appear in Spurgeon’s sermons “A Happy Christian” and “Christ and His Co-Workers” (1886).




Thanks for this.
There is a place for apologetics, but I soured on it when I arrived at Seminary. Young men arguing viciously about things they hadn't even deeply studied yet. Too often, they were unwilling to listen to the wisdom of the professors. And some of what we believe is supernatural, and sadly apologetics can flatten what is mysterious and supernatural about the Christian faith.
My grandfather, an OT professor, didn't really do apologetics. He would share what he believed, but wasn't intent on producing students who believed exactly as he did. Instead, he insisted they drink deeply of the Scriptures, and trust God to lead them to truth. I'm thankful for the work of apologists. We do need them! However, most of us will never be able to study the original manuscripts. Most of us do not have a strong grasp of Greek or Hebrew or Aramaic (or even English lol). We need to balance the importance of some doing the important work of apologetics with the supremely more important work of the Holy Spirit's transformation of hearts, opening eyes to see God's realities.
I'm thankful for how you served when you were seeking to do apologetics faithfully. But I'm very thankful for your humility to see the limitations of debate, and the ways debate and speed do produce something that falls short of what apologetics is meant to accomplish.
I’ve never seen a more misleading headline. You’re one of the best Christian apologists I’ve ever read. So there. (And keep it up!)