Greatly appreciated your essay. Absolutely glad to see Talarico standing up to hypocrisy when it rears its ugly head. Knowledge is not the same as wisdom. The latter only comes from God. Humility is the proper attitude for us all.
Thanks for this! It is very well written and I appreciate it. I have a question-when you say her tradition is two hundred years old-what tradition are you referring to? Thanks!
Ms Gardener seems to have violated the US Constitution by attempting to apply a religious test to public office. One which I know I cannot pass because even though I identify as Christian on surveys, according to her litmus test, I fail.
Whenever anyone starts a discussion as Christian 2 Christian by defining Christianity solely in their terms, I’m sure in my case it’ll turn out to be Christian 2 Heretic.
I’d have failed her test of faith because I don’t agree that “the Bible [is] the absolute source of truth & God’s final authoritative word” as it’s been edited through the years to support various theological positions. In fact, the books included in the New Testament were those that didn’t support various competing theologies & were of dubiously ascribed authorship. Is it inerrant? Maybe but that doesn’t mean all interpretations are.
What “Jesus’s death and resurrection means” to me is personal because I’m in the Thomas camp. If one takes the accounts literally, it seems strange that the thieves didn’t die & had to have their legs broken but Jesus expired quicker than most. The story is that the Sabbath was eminent & that expedited the deaths of the convicted. Jesus was hastily taken down, wrapped up & placed in a new grave. Granted, he’d had his side pierced but that’s not necessarily conclusive. I’ll agree that Jesus was crucified & suffered. I don’t know if he then died which doesn’t mean he didn’t appear to Mary Magdalene & others later. I’ve had these thoughts before they became a blockbuster novel & Tom Hanks movie.
When it comes to “Jesus [being] the only savior for people here on earth” again it’s a hard pass because it raises questions about those who do what Jesus taught without them being “saved.” After Jesus’ death was the afterlife exclusively for those professing Jesus as Lord & Savior? What was the fate of all those in the world who didn’t have access to the itinerant preachers making their way slowly through the Roman Empire? Ms Gardner might grant a waiver to those in the Western Hemisphere who were caretakers of the new promised land for Christians awaiting the generosity of the saving grace known as the Doctrine of Discovery.
What then of the other children of Abraham, Jews & Muslims? Buddhists? Hindus? Are they denied an afterlife even though they clothed the naked, fed the hungry, ministered to the ill & infirm, welcomed the stranger, etc? Jesus was after all a Jew who came to fulfill the law which was also Jewish.
I’d be judged by Ms Gardener as falling short in her estimation as to whether our conversation was indeed Christian 2 Christian as one of us obviously isn’t.
It would have been great to ask the questioner about an issue I brought up with you in a different context.
That is:
Given the peoples who lived in what is currently described as the Middle East at the time, do you believe that Jesus of Nazareth, had blue eyes and yellow hair, as has been so often depicted?
I get why you want to give Talarico a pass when he said "yes" to the question of whether he believes that the Bible is “the absolute source of truth and God’s final authoritative word, even when our culture says otherwise.” He was reading the room, and it would have been hard to qualify that with any depth without disrupting his Christian creds.
But as someone who values religious pluralism and is very skeptical of politicians who put their individual religion above our collective constitution, I have to say it makes me deeply uncomfortable to have any politician, even one I like, affirm things like "absolute course of truth" and "final authoritative word even when our culture says otherwise." Even though I know it is a gotcha question and that the asker will likely vote for crooks and pedophiles in the ballot box.
I know we are in the era of the religious purity test, but I really would have preferred a more expansive answer or at least one that differentiated between his personal beliefs and the implication that his governing philosophy would be "God's final authoritative word" first, and the Constitution second.
Same goes for the other two questions. I am fine with politicians who are Christians. I want to run for the hills when I hear people describe themselves as Christian politicians, which is probably their intention.
Great stuff… I appreciate your analysis and your gentleness… as an evangelical for more than 50 years, I see so many ways in which the movement needs to be rescued from its own certainties…. More power to you
Nice writeup. But there’s a completely secular critique of Ms Gardner’s questions that should also be pointed out. Her questions were UNCONSTITUTIONAL IN EVERY WAY. Article VI says that “…no religious test shall ever be required as a qualification to any office or public trust under the United States.” It doesn’t say Congress shall not require a religious test, or that the States shall not require a religious test, but it says that there shall be NO religious test. Presumably everyone there said the Pledge of Allegiance to the flag, and to the Republic for which it stands, at the beginning of that Town Hall, and that republic is governed by our constitution, of which Article VI is a key provision. It is binding ON ALL OF US, in all cases at all times. That woman was fundamentally unamerican in her questioning of James Talarico. Just once I’d like to see someone stand up and say “No! We don’t have religious tests in this country!”
When I see/hear those who question the faith/theology of others, I'm reminded of a quotation from seminary: The opposite of faith isn't doubt; the opposite of faith is certainty (Tillich?).
Greatly appreciated your essay. Absolutely glad to see Talarico standing up to hypocrisy when it rears its ugly head. Knowledge is not the same as wisdom. The latter only comes from God. Humility is the proper attitude for us all.
Thanks for this! It is very well written and I appreciate it. I have a question-when you say her tradition is two hundred years old-what tradition are you referring to? Thanks!
Ms Gardener seems to have violated the US Constitution by attempting to apply a religious test to public office. One which I know I cannot pass because even though I identify as Christian on surveys, according to her litmus test, I fail.
Whenever anyone starts a discussion as Christian 2 Christian by defining Christianity solely in their terms, I’m sure in my case it’ll turn out to be Christian 2 Heretic.
I’d have failed her test of faith because I don’t agree that “the Bible [is] the absolute source of truth & God’s final authoritative word” as it’s been edited through the years to support various theological positions. In fact, the books included in the New Testament were those that didn’t support various competing theologies & were of dubiously ascribed authorship. Is it inerrant? Maybe but that doesn’t mean all interpretations are.
What “Jesus’s death and resurrection means” to me is personal because I’m in the Thomas camp. If one takes the accounts literally, it seems strange that the thieves didn’t die & had to have their legs broken but Jesus expired quicker than most. The story is that the Sabbath was eminent & that expedited the deaths of the convicted. Jesus was hastily taken down, wrapped up & placed in a new grave. Granted, he’d had his side pierced but that’s not necessarily conclusive. I’ll agree that Jesus was crucified & suffered. I don’t know if he then died which doesn’t mean he didn’t appear to Mary Magdalene & others later. I’ve had these thoughts before they became a blockbuster novel & Tom Hanks movie.
When it comes to “Jesus [being] the only savior for people here on earth” again it’s a hard pass because it raises questions about those who do what Jesus taught without them being “saved.” After Jesus’ death was the afterlife exclusively for those professing Jesus as Lord & Savior? What was the fate of all those in the world who didn’t have access to the itinerant preachers making their way slowly through the Roman Empire? Ms Gardner might grant a waiver to those in the Western Hemisphere who were caretakers of the new promised land for Christians awaiting the generosity of the saving grace known as the Doctrine of Discovery.
What then of the other children of Abraham, Jews & Muslims? Buddhists? Hindus? Are they denied an afterlife even though they clothed the naked, fed the hungry, ministered to the ill & infirm, welcomed the stranger, etc? Jesus was after all a Jew who came to fulfill the law which was also Jewish.
I’d be judged by Ms Gardener as falling short in her estimation as to whether our conversation was indeed Christian 2 Christian as one of us obviously isn’t.
Shaun,
As usual, I appreciate your essays.
It would have been great to ask the questioner about an issue I brought up with you in a different context.
That is:
Given the peoples who lived in what is currently described as the Middle East at the time, do you believe that Jesus of Nazareth, had blue eyes and yellow hair, as has been so often depicted?
Do you, Shawn?
That Jesus could have had blue eyes and yellow hair? Absolutely not.
I think she would say "you will know we are Christians" by our theology. I once sang a song that had a different ending.
“… who heard ‘the kingdom of God has come near’ and understood Jesus was describing something far larger than their personal soul salvation.”
Woof. There’s a thrown gauntlet if I ever saw one ✊
I get why you want to give Talarico a pass when he said "yes" to the question of whether he believes that the Bible is “the absolute source of truth and God’s final authoritative word, even when our culture says otherwise.” He was reading the room, and it would have been hard to qualify that with any depth without disrupting his Christian creds.
But as someone who values religious pluralism and is very skeptical of politicians who put their individual religion above our collective constitution, I have to say it makes me deeply uncomfortable to have any politician, even one I like, affirm things like "absolute course of truth" and "final authoritative word even when our culture says otherwise." Even though I know it is a gotcha question and that the asker will likely vote for crooks and pedophiles in the ballot box.
I know we are in the era of the religious purity test, but I really would have preferred a more expansive answer or at least one that differentiated between his personal beliefs and the implication that his governing philosophy would be "God's final authoritative word" first, and the Constitution second.
Same goes for the other two questions. I am fine with politicians who are Christians. I want to run for the hills when I hear people describe themselves as Christian politicians, which is probably their intention.
Great stuff… I appreciate your analysis and your gentleness… as an evangelical for more than 50 years, I see so many ways in which the movement needs to be rescued from its own certainties…. More power to you
Nice writeup. But there’s a completely secular critique of Ms Gardner’s questions that should also be pointed out. Her questions were UNCONSTITUTIONAL IN EVERY WAY. Article VI says that “…no religious test shall ever be required as a qualification to any office or public trust under the United States.” It doesn’t say Congress shall not require a religious test, or that the States shall not require a religious test, but it says that there shall be NO religious test. Presumably everyone there said the Pledge of Allegiance to the flag, and to the Republic for which it stands, at the beginning of that Town Hall, and that republic is governed by our constitution, of which Article VI is a key provision. It is binding ON ALL OF US, in all cases at all times. That woman was fundamentally unamerican in her questioning of James Talarico. Just once I’d like to see someone stand up and say “No! We don’t have religious tests in this country!”
When I see/hear those who question the faith/theology of others, I'm reminded of a quotation from seminary: The opposite of faith isn't doubt; the opposite of faith is certainty (Tillich?).
A great description of Christian arrogance that permeates many churches, and sounds like this: "We have all the answers ... you better get in line."
Thank you for writing on behalf of the rest of us ... Christians who still have a lot of questions, but are seeking to follow Jesus.