Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Donna T. Deal's avatar

When I see/hear those who question the faith/theology of others, I'm reminded of a quotation from seminary: The opposite of faith isn't doubt; the opposite of faith is certainty (Tillich?).

Kristine Madera's avatar

I get why you want to give Talarico a pass when he said "yes" to the question of whether he believes that the Bible is “the absolute source of truth and God’s final authoritative word, even when our culture says otherwise.” He was reading the room, and it would have been hard to qualify that with any depth without disrupting his Christian creds.

But as someone who values religious pluralism and is very skeptical of politicians who put their individual religion above our collective constitution, I have to say it makes me deeply uncomfortable to have any politician, even one I like, affirm things like "absolute course of truth" and "final authoritative word even when our culture says otherwise." Even though I know it is a gotcha question and that the asker will likely vote for crooks and pedophiles in the ballot box.

I know we are in the era of the religious purity test, but I really would have preferred a more expansive answer or at least one that differentiated between his personal beliefs and the implication that his governing philosophy would be "God's final authoritative word" first, and the Constitution second.

Same goes for the other two questions. I am fine with politicians who are Christians. I want to run for the hills when I hear people describe themselves as Christian politicians, which is probably their intention.

10 more comments...

Ready for more?