A woman named Sarah Gardner walked up to James Talarico at a CNN town hall last week, said she wanted to talk “Christian to Christian,” and then spent four minutes giving him a faith exam. She asked three questions. Does he hold the Bible as the absolute source of truth and God’s final authoritative word. What does Jesus’s death and resurrection mean to him. Is Jesus the only savior for people here on earth. She was fairly gracious about it all. She granted up front that she and Talarico obviously read the Bible differently, and she remained positive the whole time.
None of that is the problem.
The problem lies under the questions themselves, in a set of assumptions she never had to defend because the room and most of the people watching likely already shared them.
So I want to leave Gardner mostly alone. She asked what she wanted to ask. What interests me are the presuppositions behind the questions; the quiet confidence and certainty that one iteration of modern Christianity gets to define the whole thing and grade everyone else against its standard.
Take her first question. She asked whether the Bible is “the absolute source of truth and God’s final authoritative word, even when our culture says otherwise.” Listen to that last clause in particular. It has already settled the fight in her mind. Any reading that lands somewhere other than hers gets categorized under culture, as though her interpretation showed up unmediated straight from God’s mouth while everyone else’s is some sort of distortion.
Let’s be clear; there is no reading of the Bible that isn’t an interpretation of the Bible. Gardner admitted as much in her opening breath, then built a question that treats her interpretation as the plain truth and the rest of us who might believe otherwise as people who caved to “the world.”
There’s a deeper trouble still. “God’s final authoritative word” borrows language the Bible attributes to someone else. Someone, not something. When the New Testament reaches for the title “Word,” it means Jesus. John opens with it and Revelation closes with it. Nobody in the first century called a bound canon of texts, one that wouldn’t actually exist for centuries, the final word of God, because the real final word of God had a face and a name.
Karl Barth spent a good chunk of the twentieth century reminding Protestants that Scripture points to the Word and is not itself the thing it points to. Talarico immediately said yes to her question, and I think he was being gracious. He knows the honest answer carries more qualifications than a town hall format allows. He reached for one; that the early church was really early churches, and they were full of arguments. He’s right, of course, and the argument never stopped.
Her second question is where the undercurrent shows. She told Talarico he talks plenty about Jesus’s love, inclusion and social reform, but rarely about “his core mission on earth,” which she defined as calling out human sin, driving people to repentance, and then the cross and resurrection, “the heart of the gospel message.”
Core mission? Heart of the gospel? Spoken as absolute fact already agreed upon. What she described is actually one particular theory of the cross, and it happens to be the most recent one of them all. For the first thousand years, Christians mostly read the crucifixion as God’s victory over death and the powers that hold us, what Gustaf Aulén later called Christus Victor. Anselm gave us the satisfaction model of atonement in the eleventh century. The courtroom scene Gardner assumes, where Christ absorbs a penalty the Father would otherwise aim directly at us, is Reformation vintage, a full five hundred plus years later.
Irenaeus had Christ gathering up all of human history and healing it from the inside. The Eastern tradition of the church never understood any of this through a ledger or transaction at all. It spoke of us being drawn up into God’s own life instead.
Paul, who did more than anyone to say what the cross accomplished, favored a word Gardner didn’t use. That word is reconciliation. God was in Christ reconciling the world to himself. Colossians stretches it to all things; the whole creation pulled back toward its source. That is the older and wider claim, and it’s the one I’d put at the very center. Jesus came to redeem humanity to God, to mend the breach between creation and its maker. The courtroom transaction idea is one attempt to explain how, but certainly not the core mission itself.
And the gospel Jesus announced with his own mouth was the kingdom of God. “The kingdom has come near.” That was his headline, his campaign slogan if you want to call it that. I’m not claiming he ignored sin or that repentance is a later invention. He opened his ministry telling people to repent, yes. But the word there, metanoia, means a turning of the whole self toward that kingdom, a reorientation of life, not a receipt printed at a cosmic point-of-sale. Gardner took a wide, strange, world-remaking mission and shrank it down to a single transaction, then judged him for emphasizing the wrong part.
The third question was the real test, though, the one the first two were meant to clear ground for. Is Jesus “the only savior for people here on earth.” Yes or no, please. Talarico didn’t bite so quickly this time. He answered with a verse, that Jesus is the truth, the way, and the life, and intentionally left the word “only” sitting on the table where she put it. While some may see that as an indictment, I think the omission was a good instinct. Plenty of serious Christians have declined that qualifier. Karl Rahner wrote about people reached by grace outside the visible church. C.S. Lewis, no theological amateur, let the Calormene soldier Emeth into Aslan’s country at the end of the Narnia books. The Second Vatican Council affirmed that other traditions carry real rays of the truth. Talarico’s reluctance to narrow the door draws on a stream much older and deeper than the one quizzing him, and I share it.
Notice what her question assumes, not once but twice over. First, that the thing worth asking a Senate candidate about faith is the mechanics of individual salvation. Second, that the exclusive answer she was looking for is the differentiator, the line between a genuine Christian and a fraud or pretender. She cares about salvation, which is fine and good. The trouble is she makes one narrow account of it the only gate every soul has to walk through, and it happens to be hers.
Run these three questions together and a pattern emerges. Bible as inerrant authority, cross as penal substitutionary transaction, and salvation as personal and exclusive. The historian David Bebbington catalogued the marks of modern evangelicalism decades ago, and biblicism, crucicentrism, and conversionism are at the very top of his list. Gardner walked that list in order, checking boxes on a form she believes God had drafted. This is absolutely textbook evangelical theology. The problem is that it isn’t the only theology representing authentic Christianity.
The presuppositions are hardest to see from the inside. I know. Plenty of thoughtful, well-meaning Christians hold these beliefs, and holding them isn’t the real problem. The error being made is mistaking the emphases of one modern movement (Evangelical Protestantism) as the definition of the faith itself, then using them to assess whether the man across the table even qualifies as a believer. Dan McClellan has a line for this. “The Bible says so” almost always turns out to mean “my tradition says so.” The tradition doing the talking here is about two centuries old but acts like it’s two thousand years old.
She came to talk Christian to Christian. Great. But her definition of the second Christian in that sentence had already written off most of the ones who ever lived, the ones who read the cross as victory, who met God through churches she’d disqualify on sight, who heard “the kingdom of God has come near” and understood Jesus was describing something far larger than their personal soul salvation.
Someone is going to read that and fire back. But Jesus said narrow is the gate, and few find it. Doesn’t that sink the whole argument? It doesn’t. That line closes the Sermon on the Mount, inside an old picture of two roads, one to life and one to ruin, that runs from Deuteronomy through the Psalms down into the first church handbooks. The gate is narrow, you see, because the road is so hard – you know, the long haul of mercy and loving enemies the sermon just finished describing.
But read what comes next. The people Jesus bars from entering are the ones saying “Lord, Lord” who never did the will of the Father, the ones he tells “I never knew you.” They fail by what they didn’t do, not by flunking a doctrine quiz and, dare I say it, not by failing to accept Jesus Christ as their personal lord and savior before they died. His gate is narrower than Gardner’s, and it opens the other way. And the same Bible that says few find the narrow gate ends with a city whose gates never close and a crowd from every nation too large to count.
So, the gate is narrow. What waits on the other side is not.




When I see/hear those who question the faith/theology of others, I'm reminded of a quotation from seminary: The opposite of faith isn't doubt; the opposite of faith is certainty (Tillich?).
I get why you want to give Talarico a pass when he said "yes" to the question of whether he believes that the Bible is “the absolute source of truth and God’s final authoritative word, even when our culture says otherwise.” He was reading the room, and it would have been hard to qualify that with any depth without disrupting his Christian creds.
But as someone who values religious pluralism and is very skeptical of politicians who put their individual religion above our collective constitution, I have to say it makes me deeply uncomfortable to have any politician, even one I like, affirm things like "absolute course of truth" and "final authoritative word even when our culture says otherwise." Even though I know it is a gotcha question and that the asker will likely vote for crooks and pedophiles in the ballot box.
I know we are in the era of the religious purity test, but I really would have preferred a more expansive answer or at least one that differentiated between his personal beliefs and the implication that his governing philosophy would be "God's final authoritative word" first, and the Constitution second.
Same goes for the other two questions. I am fine with politicians who are Christians. I want to run for the hills when I hear people describe themselves as Christian politicians, which is probably their intention.