Alas, HYPOCRISY is seen not only in those who’ve been forgiven 10,000 talents (i.e., who’ve been forgiven for betraying and crucifying the Creator and Lord of all things [cf. Acts 3:15]) but refuse to forgive 100 denarii owed them (i.e., refuse to forgive parishioners who’ve committed mere trifles against them)—see Matt. 18:21-35 (cf. my post earlier today)—but is seen also in those who rail against an INDIVIDUALISTIC view of salvation (Jesus solely as one’s PERSONAL Lord and INDIVIDUAL Savior) but then JUSTIFY DESERTING the empirical, visible, INSTITUTIONAL church.
But ACTING INDIVIDUALISTICALLY has another problem. Yes, it’s HYPOCRITICAL to do this if one CONDEMNS INDIVIDUALISM (Jesus as merely one’s personal Lord and Savior) but it also smacks of GNOSTICISM. The “HYPER-PROTESTANT” or GNOSTIC notion that one can have a relationship with the Lord apart from the sacraments, the means of grace, etc., reeks of rejection of the INCARNATION. Look, I’m “Protestant” enough to recognize that the institutional, empirical, historical, visible church is not merely imperfect but deeply flawed. However, I also recognize that the Lord has ORDAINED to relate to us through His COVENANT, which is MEDIATED through several OBJECTIVE “MEANS OF GRACE”: Scripture (the apostles’ teaching), fellowship with fellow IMPERFECT believers, the Lord’s Supper (the breaking of bread), and set or liturgical prayers (see Acts 2:42).
Alas, the world seems filled with HYPOCRITES—i.e., those who claim to LOVE JESUS CHRIST but NOT the CHURCH, His BRIDE.
I do acknowledge that one can legitimately question His taste in women—e.g., He seems to prefer disreputable sinners (tax collectors and prostitutes) over respectable sinners (sanctimonious, heretical hypocrites). Nonetheless, it’s ironic that the very people who DESERT the CHURCH because it’s filled with sinners are themselves acting SINFULLY and HYPOCRITICALLY by NOT FORGIVING even though THEY’VE BEEN FORGIVEN.
I’m not trying to attack my Lutheran friends—who note that Jesus taught that faith in Him was sufficient for eternal life (Jn. 3:16, 18, 36; 5:24; 6:28-29; etc.) and who cite Gal. 2:16 and many other passages by Paul the apostle that teach that faith is sufficient for justification—but I don’t think we should simply ignore the “coda” to the Lord’s Prayer in Matt. 6:12, 14-15):
"12 ‘“And forgive us our debts, as we also have forgiven our debtors. . . . 14 For if you forgive men for their transgressions, your heavenly Father will also forgive you. 15 But if you do not forgive men, then your Father will not forgive your transgressions'" (1977 NASB).
So, sure, the INSTITUTIONAL CHURCH is filled with SINNERS (even pedophiles and those who cover up the sins committed by pedophiles), but SO WHAT? Jesus came to save SINNERS, NOT the RIGHTEOUS! Jesus makes this clear in Mk. 2:16-17 (cf. Matt. 9:11-13; Lk. 5:30-32; 19:10; etc.):
“16And when the scribes of the Pharisees saw that He was eating with the sinners and tax-gatherers, they began saying to His disciples, ‘Why is He eating and drinking with tax-gatherers and sinners?’ 17And hearing this, Jesus said to them, ‘it is not those who are healthy who need a physician, but those who are sick; I did not come to call the righteous, but sinners’” (1977 NASB).
Thus, Christ and His bride are a “package deal”—if one LOVES CHRIST, one must LOVE the CHURCH—hence it’s folly to FORSAKE or DESERT the INSTITUTIONAL CHURCH (e.g., Heb. 10:25 specifically cautions against giving up “synagogue-ing” together).
I enjoyed this essay very, very much. I especially appreciate your candor about your own journey. I have been a devotee of Jesus outside of the church for most of my life, since my dad was kicked out by the Presbyterians when I was ten. I still feel like a misfit--I describe myself as a "Greek Orthodox Quaker," fully aware of the incompatibility of those descriptions. I'm a Quaker in my total rejection of all human spiritual hierarchy--but Orthodox as a pupil of Gregory of Nyssa, believing that the Logos heals and restores all of us by making us sharers in his resurrection embodiment.
One thing I wanted to say in favor of our mutual friend, Kierkegaard. His thought often gets flattened out in terms of the "leap." And I confess that I haven't yet grappled with the Postscript, although I can say of a number of his other major works that they have changed my life. But I am familiar with the Philosophical Fragments (to which the Postscript is a postscript), and I think a more representative description of his project would be the question that he sets as the goal of his investigation: can an eternal concern have a historical point of departure? Far more than a blind "leap of faith," Kierkegaard is interested in the degree to which we can become "contemporaneous with Christ"--meet him as a real person, in the same way that his first disciples got to meet him. And I think this speaks to your own (and my) central longing--to retain a personal devotion to the real person Jesus, in the midst of our emphatic rejection of so much of our Protestant tradition, in its current septic condition. (I would argue that this septic condition is a result of its refusal to reform itself in the 19th century, when it become excessively obvious that the human moral consciousness had evolved further than the Christian attachments to retributive justice and textual infallibility.)
While Kierkegaard will speak of the "absolute paradox," and the collision between our need to know and God's unknowability, the way he resolves this (it seems to me) is to return us directly to Jesus as God the Teacher. We must receive him not only as one who imparts the knowledge of himself, but as the one who imparts the condition of being able to know. In this way, we owe everything to him, unlike anything that we could ever owe to a human teacher, who, at best, can only be the occasion for our discovery of the truth.
This is not really different (as Kierkegaard points out) from the situation of the first disciples. They had to come to grips with their Teacher as a profoundly perplexing person--and yet as one who drew them irresistibly with the "words of Life." Thus Kierkegaard could ultimately reject (in his later years) all the forms of institutional Christianity with which he was familiar, and yet remain passionately devoted to the Jesus of the gospels. True, Kierkegaard's prescription can seem excessively individualistic. But, as I slowly and cautiously reenter the world of communal expression of faith through my increasing identification as a Quaker, I find that there is room for coexistence between a radical insistence on individual immediate access to the Teacher, and fellowship with one another.
One who is leaving behind the household of sinful humanity with whatever inheritance you have
And into the arms of the Father who runs to meet you.
The Church is household of faith. Just as all of our households raised children in different eras and cultures and languages, so also does the congregations of Christs body have eras and cultures and languages.
All are fruitful for a season. All that are fruitful are abiding in the vine, which is Christ alone. How each decides which language to use to talk about this is specific, historical, and a paradox of Word and human.
All of us are looking in a mirror dimly.
You bring up key points here. I am learning from your essays how language choices shape what is heard and believed about ourselves and our relationship with YHWH. Thank you for this. I’m keeping this one to ponder more.
Many of us identify with your comments and questions. God doesn't seem to mind, it seems to me. I started these questions at about 17. Fifty years later they do continue.
One thing I've found useful is to be open to cross-fertilisation and as I'm older and like you, a well-educated (but hopefully humble) thinker, I have no trouble viewing my relationship with God through an array of other churches' lenses.
Have you tried Ignatius Loyola? I spent 30 weeks with a spiritual advisor going through the Exercises that Loyola laid out for his original Jesuits. Was it too Catholic? Not at all!! It led me to a much deeper relationship with my God and Jesus. It was all about me and God. I found it profound as I applied myself to the bible readings in this way.
Reading the writings of CSLewis, Henri Nouwen, NT Wright and Richard Rohr have also given me perspectives that fertilise my faith. Also poets: Mary Oliver and others.
Look outside your tradition, I say, and see your faith and others' faith through different windows, and see how it all fits together. I think that's the way God wants us to go.
Thanks for this. I think we are occasionally 'in the same pew', or 'singing from the same hymnal'. We probably listened to the same music on the radio, too. I've been fortunate to have found people and places, from time to time, who also were not fearful or loathing of other windows into the intimate infinite.
Thanks Tim. My husband and I have talked recently to each other about looking at the many aspects of life through new windows or lenses. Health and age are creating new perspectives and new ways to think and live.
I had a peek at your writing. Nice perspectives there, especially you friend who delivers drinks to hikers.
Good evening, Marita. (assuming you're six time zones to the east..).Gosh, you're welcome, and health and age do offer up new lenses with which to be present. I also read Fr. Rohr every morning, and have more than just dipped a toe into Lewis, Nouwen and Wright, too. I recall standing in the bookstore poetry aisle stifling sobs upon having picked up Mary Oliver and randomly opening it. Having been in 'church leadership' in the sagging Iowa Diocese of the Episcopal Church of the US, I've seen the reality of the causes of that sagging: demographics, sinking productivity of the land, the Iris Dement-ing* of what were once quietly flourishing small towns (I was a small-town city administrator in this part of the country for thirty years), and all the warnings and heartbreak that Wendell Berry could so heartfully convey (I cannot recommend highly enough one of his novels of the Port William Membership: "Hannah Coulter", 2004, the life story of a twice-widowed farm wife of Northern Kentucky, literally where Berry still farmed with mules until very recently. Having grown up in a farming market community of Northern Illinois, I could recognize the environs from my own past.) Nonetheless:
Karen and I are, and there are folks within that diocesan 'leadership group' that are becoming "collapse aware"; that those post-war assumptions my parents came out of the Great Depression and That Big War with are not presently realistic for most of us; and,
That a nearer look at the message and the manner of delivery brought by that sandal-clad troublemaker from Nazareth does provide an alternative to the Enclosure Acts of Empire, and steps toward living it. But, I do go on. I so appreciate these opportunities of conversation, and trust you are finding measures of contentment in whatever the day brings. Me; I'm finally getting the roof nailed down on my two-cord woodshed in the sideyard, and the two cords of deadfall hardwood split and stacked for winter.
I also read closely Paul Kingsnorth ("The Machine: On the Unmaking of Humanity", 2025); and, Iain McGilchrist ("The Master and His Emissary: The Divided Brain and the Making of the Western World", 2019), mention of either will likely land you at the sink doing dishes with the other iconoclast at a party. Again, thanks for your note.
15+ years since I've been involved with a church. 30 since I've been heavily involved. I happen to tick the boxes for a white Evangelical church on the outside, but my theology is way too radical. (I often think of what sitting at Jesus's table must have looked like!) So much of the last 30 years has been the process of deconstruction, reconstruction, and finding the cornerstone: God is; Jesus is; the Spirit is; and Love binds all through Grace.
While I still struggle with how it all fits together, I am comfortable with accepting mystery and the understanding that I may never have it all figured out.
And I think I've finally found a new place to call "home." They are welcoming to all regardless of background, gender identification, social status, etc. (Not easy to find in the far west U.S. Bible Belt!) The communion table is open to anyone who wishes — without examination, judgement or proof. The pastors are good at pointing out context for scriptures, textual differences and historical questions. And questions from Joe and Jane are respected and treated with dignity.
I doubt the seeking journey ever ends. Whether this church is an end point or simple stop on the way, I don't know. But after 30 years and 1500+ miles, I'm beginning to feel like I belong again.
I'm astounded how every point you made aligns with my experience. You just articulated it in a way I never could. That *certainty* about what is true is the main thing in evangelical Christianity. Once a few doubts start chipping away, the whole thing inevitably collapses.
I'm 15 years away from it now, but the disentangling was long and complex. What's left is uncertainty mixed with a certain kind of freedom. It isn't comfortable the way being an active member of a church was. But once you see certain things, you can't unsee them.
One thing I have come to believe is true is that human nature is consistent. Any group that forms, whether religious or political, will follow a similar pattern. Ideology becomes hardened. Factions fight for control. Dogma is enforced. Dissent is suppressed. Group cohesiveness is strengthened by the groups enemies, who are dehumanized. Authority will be established and legalization will dictate morality. It's a pattern as old (or older) than civilization.
As I’ve said before, you can be a Christian without the book. Behaviour and practice are what matter. Any branch of Christianity is defined by its nitpicking pomposity, structure and abuses of power. Mostly (with some exceptions) hollowed out structures far away from Christ’s central discourse with us. We’re both in the same place, thinking about our humanity and how best to make a connection that’s not filtered through endless discussion and rule making. In the end, try your best to be the man he was. Nothing else matters
You name dubious characteristics of a popular view of Christianity: personal savior, white American Jesus, sexual abuse & coverup, threat of fire & brimstone hell, & the church as the only path to a comfortable afterlife. The addition of these peculiar theological features come years, decades, even centuries after the beginning of the common era & with questionable author, translator, editorial pedigree. You can also add Jesus’ divinity, trinitarianism, Filioque, & a host of other deemed heretical by one Christian faith expression or another.
Jesus was a Jew at a time & place where announcing even to your most intimate circle of followers would likely get you stoned by others if they heard tell. Even in the story where Jesus asks the disciples for their opinions on who he might be he tells them to keep the SoG idea to themselves. Is it because “his time hasn’t come,” he knows he risks death by an angry mob, or it isn’t true is left to the reader. Just because you pick an option doesn’t make the others less plausible.
My opinion is that it probably matters most whether you do justice, love mercy, & help your neighbor especially the foreigner. That seems core Jewish & Muslim teachings, given that they’re the children of Abraham. It’s the core of Jesus’ message & found in other religious expressions.
That’s basic Christianity, the rest is adiaphora, to use a bit of Greek.
Hi Shawn, I always enjoy reading these pieces of yours. I know that the origins of Christianity are murky, but I can’t get past Jesus-yes, even the claims of divinity. That God would come and be one of us in every aspect of humanity, and then die to spring the trap we had made for ourselves, and rise again because the trap was well and truly sprung-the solidarity with us!
Very like my experience, except I don’t have the academic study of history behind it. At one point, I simply told Him I was done with Him. Funny thing, He wasn’t done with me and I couldn’t escape that. So here we are.
Ehm, gosh. This. This was like a freshly percolated second cup of coffee for this weary old churchman. Thank you. I'm printing this out and bringing it with me for re-reading during our annual Diocesan convention this weekend. Again, me with analogies from that 1912 ship-sinking: there's already seawater in Second Class, and there's no bailing brigade's buckets gonna put this off. If we can't get 'out there' with the Word, it ain't gonna get carried. And it's a word that counters the self-destructing Enclosures of Empire.
You're very kind to say, brother Connelly, I greatly appreciate the depth and the searching I find in your reflection and writing, among other pilgrims of similar bent, and intent, and grow from the exchanges, the sharing. I'm striving to put all this epiphany together, in writing and conversations, for the benefit of my two fine sons, that they might better understand where their Old Man is coming from, and perhaps find more sound footing for their own trek. And,
I actually did have some notion plant itself in early hours, that of setting off again on a pilgrimage on two wheels into the smaller corners of the country, on the back roads to the already beaten down regions, like that which changed my life a dozen years ago.
You, Shawn, are a map-maker into the Odyssey of this place and time for me. I look forward to your seekings here.
Alas, HYPOCRISY is seen not only in those who’ve been forgiven 10,000 talents (i.e., who’ve been forgiven for betraying and crucifying the Creator and Lord of all things [cf. Acts 3:15]) but refuse to forgive 100 denarii owed them (i.e., refuse to forgive parishioners who’ve committed mere trifles against them)—see Matt. 18:21-35 (cf. my post earlier today)—but is seen also in those who rail against an INDIVIDUALISTIC view of salvation (Jesus solely as one’s PERSONAL Lord and INDIVIDUAL Savior) but then JUSTIFY DESERTING the empirical, visible, INSTITUTIONAL church.
But ACTING INDIVIDUALISTICALLY has another problem. Yes, it’s HYPOCRITICAL to do this if one CONDEMNS INDIVIDUALISM (Jesus as merely one’s personal Lord and Savior) but it also smacks of GNOSTICISM. The “HYPER-PROTESTANT” or GNOSTIC notion that one can have a relationship with the Lord apart from the sacraments, the means of grace, etc., reeks of rejection of the INCARNATION. Look, I’m “Protestant” enough to recognize that the institutional, empirical, historical, visible church is not merely imperfect but deeply flawed. However, I also recognize that the Lord has ORDAINED to relate to us through His COVENANT, which is MEDIATED through several OBJECTIVE “MEANS OF GRACE”: Scripture (the apostles’ teaching), fellowship with fellow IMPERFECT believers, the Lord’s Supper (the breaking of bread), and set or liturgical prayers (see Acts 2:42).
Alas, the world seems filled with HYPOCRITES—i.e., those who claim to LOVE JESUS CHRIST but NOT the CHURCH, His BRIDE.
I do acknowledge that one can legitimately question His taste in women—e.g., He seems to prefer disreputable sinners (tax collectors and prostitutes) over respectable sinners (sanctimonious, heretical hypocrites). Nonetheless, it’s ironic that the very people who DESERT the CHURCH because it’s filled with sinners are themselves acting SINFULLY and HYPOCRITICALLY by NOT FORGIVING even though THEY’VE BEEN FORGIVEN.
I’m not trying to attack my Lutheran friends—who note that Jesus taught that faith in Him was sufficient for eternal life (Jn. 3:16, 18, 36; 5:24; 6:28-29; etc.) and who cite Gal. 2:16 and many other passages by Paul the apostle that teach that faith is sufficient for justification—but I don’t think we should simply ignore the “coda” to the Lord’s Prayer in Matt. 6:12, 14-15):
"12 ‘“And forgive us our debts, as we also have forgiven our debtors. . . . 14 For if you forgive men for their transgressions, your heavenly Father will also forgive you. 15 But if you do not forgive men, then your Father will not forgive your transgressions'" (1977 NASB).
So, sure, the INSTITUTIONAL CHURCH is filled with SINNERS (even pedophiles and those who cover up the sins committed by pedophiles), but SO WHAT? Jesus came to save SINNERS, NOT the RIGHTEOUS! Jesus makes this clear in Mk. 2:16-17 (cf. Matt. 9:11-13; Lk. 5:30-32; 19:10; etc.):
“16And when the scribes of the Pharisees saw that He was eating with the sinners and tax-gatherers, they began saying to His disciples, ‘Why is He eating and drinking with tax-gatherers and sinners?’ 17And hearing this, Jesus said to them, ‘it is not those who are healthy who need a physician, but those who are sick; I did not come to call the righteous, but sinners’” (1977 NASB).
Thus, Christ and His bride are a “package deal”—if one LOVES CHRIST, one must LOVE the CHURCH—hence it’s folly to FORSAKE or DESERT the INSTITUTIONAL CHURCH (e.g., Heb. 10:25 specifically cautions against giving up “synagogue-ing” together).
I enjoyed this essay very, very much. I especially appreciate your candor about your own journey. I have been a devotee of Jesus outside of the church for most of my life, since my dad was kicked out by the Presbyterians when I was ten. I still feel like a misfit--I describe myself as a "Greek Orthodox Quaker," fully aware of the incompatibility of those descriptions. I'm a Quaker in my total rejection of all human spiritual hierarchy--but Orthodox as a pupil of Gregory of Nyssa, believing that the Logos heals and restores all of us by making us sharers in his resurrection embodiment.
One thing I wanted to say in favor of our mutual friend, Kierkegaard. His thought often gets flattened out in terms of the "leap." And I confess that I haven't yet grappled with the Postscript, although I can say of a number of his other major works that they have changed my life. But I am familiar with the Philosophical Fragments (to which the Postscript is a postscript), and I think a more representative description of his project would be the question that he sets as the goal of his investigation: can an eternal concern have a historical point of departure? Far more than a blind "leap of faith," Kierkegaard is interested in the degree to which we can become "contemporaneous with Christ"--meet him as a real person, in the same way that his first disciples got to meet him. And I think this speaks to your own (and my) central longing--to retain a personal devotion to the real person Jesus, in the midst of our emphatic rejection of so much of our Protestant tradition, in its current septic condition. (I would argue that this septic condition is a result of its refusal to reform itself in the 19th century, when it become excessively obvious that the human moral consciousness had evolved further than the Christian attachments to retributive justice and textual infallibility.)
While Kierkegaard will speak of the "absolute paradox," and the collision between our need to know and God's unknowability, the way he resolves this (it seems to me) is to return us directly to Jesus as God the Teacher. We must receive him not only as one who imparts the knowledge of himself, but as the one who imparts the condition of being able to know. In this way, we owe everything to him, unlike anything that we could ever owe to a human teacher, who, at best, can only be the occasion for our discovery of the truth.
This is not really different (as Kierkegaard points out) from the situation of the first disciples. They had to come to grips with their Teacher as a profoundly perplexing person--and yet as one who drew them irresistibly with the "words of Life." Thus Kierkegaard could ultimately reject (in his later years) all the forms of institutional Christianity with which he was familiar, and yet remain passionately devoted to the Jesus of the gospels. True, Kierkegaard's prescription can seem excessively individualistic. But, as I slowly and cautiously reenter the world of communal expression of faith through my increasing identification as a Quaker, I find that there is room for coexistence between a radical insistence on individual immediate access to the Teacher, and fellowship with one another.
Maybe you’re a different kind of prodigal child?
One who is leaving behind the household of sinful humanity with whatever inheritance you have
And into the arms of the Father who runs to meet you.
The Church is household of faith. Just as all of our households raised children in different eras and cultures and languages, so also does the congregations of Christs body have eras and cultures and languages.
All are fruitful for a season. All that are fruitful are abiding in the vine, which is Christ alone. How each decides which language to use to talk about this is specific, historical, and a paradox of Word and human.
All of us are looking in a mirror dimly.
You bring up key points here. I am learning from your essays how language choices shape what is heard and believed about ourselves and our relationship with YHWH. Thank you for this. I’m keeping this one to ponder more.
Many of us identify with your comments and questions. God doesn't seem to mind, it seems to me. I started these questions at about 17. Fifty years later they do continue.
One thing I've found useful is to be open to cross-fertilisation and as I'm older and like you, a well-educated (but hopefully humble) thinker, I have no trouble viewing my relationship with God through an array of other churches' lenses.
Have you tried Ignatius Loyola? I spent 30 weeks with a spiritual advisor going through the Exercises that Loyola laid out for his original Jesuits. Was it too Catholic? Not at all!! It led me to a much deeper relationship with my God and Jesus. It was all about me and God. I found it profound as I applied myself to the bible readings in this way.
Reading the writings of CSLewis, Henri Nouwen, NT Wright and Richard Rohr have also given me perspectives that fertilise my faith. Also poets: Mary Oliver and others.
Look outside your tradition, I say, and see your faith and others' faith through different windows, and see how it all fits together. I think that's the way God wants us to go.
Thanks for this. I think we are occasionally 'in the same pew', or 'singing from the same hymnal'. We probably listened to the same music on the radio, too. I've been fortunate to have found people and places, from time to time, who also were not fearful or loathing of other windows into the intimate infinite.
Tim Long, Just Up the Hill from Lock 15
Thanks Tim. My husband and I have talked recently to each other about looking at the many aspects of life through new windows or lenses. Health and age are creating new perspectives and new ways to think and live.
I had a peek at your writing. Nice perspectives there, especially you friend who delivers drinks to hikers.
Good evening, Marita. (assuming you're six time zones to the east..).Gosh, you're welcome, and health and age do offer up new lenses with which to be present. I also read Fr. Rohr every morning, and have more than just dipped a toe into Lewis, Nouwen and Wright, too. I recall standing in the bookstore poetry aisle stifling sobs upon having picked up Mary Oliver and randomly opening it. Having been in 'church leadership' in the sagging Iowa Diocese of the Episcopal Church of the US, I've seen the reality of the causes of that sagging: demographics, sinking productivity of the land, the Iris Dement-ing* of what were once quietly flourishing small towns (I was a small-town city administrator in this part of the country for thirty years), and all the warnings and heartbreak that Wendell Berry could so heartfully convey (I cannot recommend highly enough one of his novels of the Port William Membership: "Hannah Coulter", 2004, the life story of a twice-widowed farm wife of Northern Kentucky, literally where Berry still farmed with mules until very recently. Having grown up in a farming market community of Northern Illinois, I could recognize the environs from my own past.) Nonetheless:
Karen and I are, and there are folks within that diocesan 'leadership group' that are becoming "collapse aware"; that those post-war assumptions my parents came out of the Great Depression and That Big War with are not presently realistic for most of us; and,
That a nearer look at the message and the manner of delivery brought by that sandal-clad troublemaker from Nazareth does provide an alternative to the Enclosure Acts of Empire, and steps toward living it. But, I do go on. I so appreciate these opportunities of conversation, and trust you are finding measures of contentment in whatever the day brings. Me; I'm finally getting the roof nailed down on my two-cord woodshed in the sideyard, and the two cords of deadfall hardwood split and stacked for winter.
I also read closely Paul Kingsnorth ("The Machine: On the Unmaking of Humanity", 2025); and, Iain McGilchrist ("The Master and His Emissary: The Divided Brain and the Making of the Western World", 2019), mention of either will likely land you at the sink doing dishes with the other iconoclast at a party. Again, thanks for your note.
Tim
*Iris Dement : "Our Town" https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FikZwgj89HI&list=RDFikZwgj89HI&start_radio=1
I think she lives quietly in SE Iowa now, not far down the river from here...
Thank you Tim. I'm loving all this conversation.
I'd summarize your journey as one who has thrown out the bathwater and is keeping the baby. Nice. Me too.
15+ years since I've been involved with a church. 30 since I've been heavily involved. I happen to tick the boxes for a white Evangelical church on the outside, but my theology is way too radical. (I often think of what sitting at Jesus's table must have looked like!) So much of the last 30 years has been the process of deconstruction, reconstruction, and finding the cornerstone: God is; Jesus is; the Spirit is; and Love binds all through Grace.
While I still struggle with how it all fits together, I am comfortable with accepting mystery and the understanding that I may never have it all figured out.
And I think I've finally found a new place to call "home." They are welcoming to all regardless of background, gender identification, social status, etc. (Not easy to find in the far west U.S. Bible Belt!) The communion table is open to anyone who wishes — without examination, judgement or proof. The pastors are good at pointing out context for scriptures, textual differences and historical questions. And questions from Joe and Jane are respected and treated with dignity.
I doubt the seeking journey ever ends. Whether this church is an end point or simple stop on the way, I don't know. But after 30 years and 1500+ miles, I'm beginning to feel like I belong again.
I'm astounded how every point you made aligns with my experience. You just articulated it in a way I never could. That *certainty* about what is true is the main thing in evangelical Christianity. Once a few doubts start chipping away, the whole thing inevitably collapses.
I'm 15 years away from it now, but the disentangling was long and complex. What's left is uncertainty mixed with a certain kind of freedom. It isn't comfortable the way being an active member of a church was. But once you see certain things, you can't unsee them.
One thing I have come to believe is true is that human nature is consistent. Any group that forms, whether religious or political, will follow a similar pattern. Ideology becomes hardened. Factions fight for control. Dogma is enforced. Dissent is suppressed. Group cohesiveness is strengthened by the groups enemies, who are dehumanized. Authority will be established and legalization will dictate morality. It's a pattern as old (or older) than civilization.
As I’ve said before, you can be a Christian without the book. Behaviour and practice are what matter. Any branch of Christianity is defined by its nitpicking pomposity, structure and abuses of power. Mostly (with some exceptions) hollowed out structures far away from Christ’s central discourse with us. We’re both in the same place, thinking about our humanity and how best to make a connection that’s not filtered through endless discussion and rule making. In the end, try your best to be the man he was. Nothing else matters
You name dubious characteristics of a popular view of Christianity: personal savior, white American Jesus, sexual abuse & coverup, threat of fire & brimstone hell, & the church as the only path to a comfortable afterlife. The addition of these peculiar theological features come years, decades, even centuries after the beginning of the common era & with questionable author, translator, editorial pedigree. You can also add Jesus’ divinity, trinitarianism, Filioque, & a host of other deemed heretical by one Christian faith expression or another.
Jesus was a Jew at a time & place where announcing even to your most intimate circle of followers would likely get you stoned by others if they heard tell. Even in the story where Jesus asks the disciples for their opinions on who he might be he tells them to keep the SoG idea to themselves. Is it because “his time hasn’t come,” he knows he risks death by an angry mob, or it isn’t true is left to the reader. Just because you pick an option doesn’t make the others less plausible.
My opinion is that it probably matters most whether you do justice, love mercy, & help your neighbor especially the foreigner. That seems core Jewish & Muslim teachings, given that they’re the children of Abraham. It’s the core of Jesus’ message & found in other religious expressions.
That’s basic Christianity, the rest is adiaphora, to use a bit of Greek.
Quite well said!
Hi Shawn, I always enjoy reading these pieces of yours. I know that the origins of Christianity are murky, but I can’t get past Jesus-yes, even the claims of divinity. That God would come and be one of us in every aspect of humanity, and then die to spring the trap we had made for ourselves, and rise again because the trap was well and truly sprung-the solidarity with us!
You said "I’ve gone from dogmatic certainty to unsure about a lot," That's the difference between Knowledge and Faith.
You also said "There is a feeling, a drawing toward, that I can’t describe or attribute." That's called Love.
Very like my experience, except I don’t have the academic study of history behind it. At one point, I simply told Him I was done with Him. Funny thing, He wasn’t done with me and I couldn’t escape that. So here we are.
Thank you, still sorting out my own journey, and this helps.
Ehm, gosh. This. This was like a freshly percolated second cup of coffee for this weary old churchman. Thank you. I'm printing this out and bringing it with me for re-reading during our annual Diocesan convention this weekend. Again, me with analogies from that 1912 ship-sinking: there's already seawater in Second Class, and there's no bailing brigade's buckets gonna put this off. If we can't get 'out there' with the Word, it ain't gonna get carried. And it's a word that counters the self-destructing Enclosures of Empire.
Tim Long, Just Up the Hill from Lock 15
Tim, you need to be doing your own writing, it seems!
You're very kind to say, brother Connelly, I greatly appreciate the depth and the searching I find in your reflection and writing, among other pilgrims of similar bent, and intent, and grow from the exchanges, the sharing. I'm striving to put all this epiphany together, in writing and conversations, for the benefit of my two fine sons, that they might better understand where their Old Man is coming from, and perhaps find more sound footing for their own trek. And,
I actually did have some notion plant itself in early hours, that of setting off again on a pilgrimage on two wheels into the smaller corners of the country, on the back roads to the already beaten down regions, like that which changed my life a dozen years ago.
You, Shawn, are a map-maker into the Odyssey of this place and time for me. I look forward to your seekings here.
Tim Long, Just Up the Hill from Lock 15
Thank You for putting this into perspective, I've felt this way, point for point, all of my life. Thanks for making me feel truely connected.