Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Jon Westlake's avatar

As I’ve said before, you can be a Christian without the book. Behaviour and practice are what matter. Any branch of Christianity is defined by its nitpicking pomposity, structure and abuses of power. Mostly (with some exceptions) hollowed out structures far away from Christ’s central discourse with us. We’re both in the same place, thinking about our humanity and how best to make a connection that’s not filtered through endless discussion and rule making. In the end, try your best to be the man he was. Nothing else matters

Duke Taylor's avatar

You name dubious characteristics of a popular view of Christianity: personal savior, white American Jesus, sexual abuse & coverup, threat of fire & brimstone hell, & the church as the only path to a comfortable afterlife. The addition of these peculiar theological features come years, decades, even centuries after the beginning of the common era & with questionable author, translator, editorial pedigree. You can also add Jesus’ divinity, trinitarianism, Filioque, & a host of other deemed heretical by one Christian faith expression or another.

Jesus was a Jew at a time & place where announcing even to your most intimate circle of followers would likely get you stoned by others if they heard tell. Even in the story where Jesus asks the disciples for their opinions on who he might be he tells them to keep the SoG idea to themselves. Is it because “his time hasn’t come,” he knows he risks death by an angry mob, or it isn’t true is left to the reader. Just because you pick an option doesn’t make the others less plausible.

My opinion is that it probably matters most whether you do justice, love mercy, & help your neighbor especially the foreigner. That seems core Jewish & Muslim teachings, given that they’re the children of Abraham. It’s the core of Jesus’ message & found in other religious expressions.

That’s basic Christianity, the rest is adiaphora, to use a bit of Greek.

21 more comments...

Ready for more?