The Line Nobody Checked
“I like your Christ, I do not like your Christians. Your Christians are so unlike your Christ.” That line gets attributed to Mahatma Gandhi in memes, sermons, and the comment section of virtually every religion debate ever held online. Snopes went looking for a real source and found no authoritative one linking it to him.1 The nearest ancestor anyone has located is a remark by an Indian philosopher called Bara Dada, reported in the mid-1920s, to the effect that Jesus is wonderful and his Christians are nothing like him.2 A Harvard Crimson item from January 1927 has a version crediting Gandhi with liking Christ but not Christianity, though Snopes found even that attribution quite muddled.3
I quote the line here anyway because it’s a good one and it survives its own bad citation, which is a reasonable summary of how religious belief travels. One of the most quoted sentences about Jesus and his followers has no verified author, and it spread because it said what a lot of people already felt and nobody wanted to spoil it by checking its authenticity. Turns out a great deal of what Christians believe about Jesus works in much the same way.
This essay has two jobs, in my mind. The first is to inventory five places where the evangelical Protestant institution I grew up in has failed the man it’s named for, in ways that look purposeful, which is worse than looking accidental. The second job is harder still. The man at issue reaches me through that same institution’s book and hands, and I still can’t put him aside.
The Best Objection
Anyone writing something like this owes the reader the strongest reply, so here it is. Jesus doesn’t come to us in the raw. The Gospels were written by communities decades after the actual events, copied by scribes, sorted and argued over by councils, and handed down by the very institution I’m about to openly criticize. If the church is really that unstable, the obvious question is why trust its Jesus? I’m keeping the painting here and condemning the museum, I suppose, and it’s on me to explain why the painting isn’t likewise compromised.
A fair reader (or writer) will add that churches organize food pantries, show up with casseroles after funerals, offer all sorts of tangible benevolence, and keep a lot of lonely, hurting people less lonely and hurting. All very true. I have been on the leadership side of it, and I’ve been on the receiving side of the institutional church’s mercies, so I know this to be the case more often than it’s not. I admit the whole list, and the conclusion stands anyway, because the failures enumerated below aren’t just a few bad apples in an otherwise good bunch. Each grows out of how the system handles Jesus himself, which is part of the reason why patching the shortcomings one at a time keeps failing over and over.
Five Places It Breaks
1. “Personal Lord and Savior”
The phrase is so familiar it sounds like Scripture (as in the stock question, “Have you accepted Jesus Christ as your personal Lord and Savior?”), but it appears nowhere in the New Testament. Leave it to Americans to add that. Writers who trace the idea tend to find it in nineteenth-century American revivalism, where conversion was a private decision made at an altar.4 The faulty vocabulary is really the smaller problem. Once Jesus is primarily personal, salvation becomes a matter of transaction between two parties, and everyone else becomes either an observer or a recruiting target, by default.
Most of Paul’s letters were written to congregations, and the “you” in them is plural, a Greek y’all attached to instructions for people who have to eat dinner together. Warner Sallman’s Christ at Heart’s Door is one of the signature images of this private Jesus, and it rests on Revelation 3:20, where Jesus says, “I am standing at the door, knocking.”5 That verse is addressed to the church (y’all) at Laodicea, a congregation that had shut him out, and the promise attached to it is a shared meal. Evangelical preaching turned that narrative into an altar call for individual souls.
The way the verse gets preached, Jesus is stuck on the porch, knocking, with no doorbell camera to confirm who he is or why he came to call, waiting for a stranger to decide whether he gets in. He is treated like a salesman offering replacement windows or lawn mowing. The people at Laodicea knew exactly who he was. They had what’s called an established relationship, which is why the letter is addressed to a church of believers in the first place. Y’all know full well he has a key. Actually, you know he doesn’t need one. The knock was an appeal to a congregation that already belonged to him, and an altar call asks a different question of a different audience. This reading lives mostly in transactional, Arminian-leaning evangelicalism. Reformed folk rarely lean on the verse, because they generally know better and have some appreciation for context.
A faith built this way can be practiced alone, defended alone, and lost alone, and plenty of people have lost it exactly that way.
2. The White Jesus and the Flag
The print of Jesus on the Sunday school wall has an origin story, and it’s recent. Warner Sallman, a Chicago illustrator in the Swedish Evangelical Covenant church, drew a Christ in charcoal for a denominational magazine in the 1920s, painted the oil version called Head of Christ in 1940, and watched it become one of the most reproduced images in American history, with more than 500 million copies by the 1990s.6 You know the one. The face is often traced to a French painting by Léon Lhermitte, and some scholars have noticed a resemblance to the shampoo ads of that era. Can we just state the obvious? A first-century Galilean Jew did not look anything like that and certainly didn’t have those long, flowing locks full of bounce and body.
The historians Edward Blum and Paul Harvey argue in The Color of Christ that Americans have repeatedly used images of Jesus’ body to fight over race, politics, and who counts as one of us.6 The point is really easy to see once the picture is in your head. A Jesus who looks like the dominant racial or ethnic group is available for enlistment, and he can be posted at the border, the ballot box, and the battlefield with equal ease. This happens today as much or maybe more than it ever did in the past.
Drink Wisely has examined elsewhere how the Christian-nation story was built, and one passage from that piece shows the oldest version of the distortion.
Then Constantine happened. The Edict of Milan legalized Christianity in 313 CE, and imperial patronage followed. A faith built on humility was draped in imperial regalia. A kingdom defined by peace began blessing armies. The sword that once threatened the church now belonged to it. John Howard Yoder argued that this Constantinian shift was a theological transition as much as a political one. The church moved from embodying the Sermon on the Mount to explaining it away.7
From “The Myth of a Christian Founding” (Drink Wisely, Oct. 8, 2025)
Nowhere is this more blatant than in the Christian Nationalist movement, where the white Jesus for white men reigns supreme. No wimpy suffering servants here; no meekness, our Jesus rides a big ’ol draft horse and is armed with something automatic, or at least semi-automatic, fully ready to kick some infidel ass.
This version of Jesus works as a mirror with a halo, and the people holding it are routinely surprised to find that he agrees with (and looks like) them every single time.
3. Abuse, Scandal, and the Cover
In February 2019, the Houston Chronicle and San Antonio Express-News reported that roughly 380 Southern Baptist church leaders and volunteers had faced allegations of sexual misconduct since 1998, leaving behind more than 700 victims.8 In May 2022, an independent firm (so no axe to grind) hired by the denomination’s Executive Committee, after delegates demanded an outside probe, concluded that top SBC leaders had stonewalled and denigrated survivors for almost two decades while protecting their own reputations.9 The report also said a staffer maintained a list of accused ministers, with no indication that anyone acted to remove them from their positions of power in the denomination.9
The Southern Baptists have plenty of company across traditions, but their paper trail is particularly public and recent, so I’ll use theirs as illustration. The structural problem is simple enough to explain. An institution that measures its success by the reputation of a name has a built-in reason to protect the name before it protects the child. Not a good reason, but a reason nonetheless. A decade before the 2019 reporting came out, SBC leaders had declined to create a database of accused clergy, and executives cited the autonomy of local churches.8 Local autonomy, in itself, is a respectable principle with a respectable history. It also means nobody is in charge when a pastor moves to the next town to do it all over again.
I’ve seen it. We’ve probably all seen it if we’re being honest. The lack of accountability is not a fault, it’s a feature for those who want to run the full show and answer to no one besides their own ego and ambitions.
All of this took place in the name of a man who, in Mark’s Gospel, says a millstone around the neck would be a better fate than causing one of the little ones to stumble.10
4. Hell and the Performance Treadmill
Drink Wisely has previously delved into how the hell most evangelicals believe in was actually cobbled together from several sources over centuries, and I won’t rebuild that case here.
The most useful passage from that work for this essay comes from the section on how the doctrine of eternal conscious torment, or ECT, works as a tool. Maybe the most effective tool in the evangelical arsenal.
From early on, the threat of hell became a powerful mechanism for incentivizing obedience, solidifying group identity, turning evangelism into a time-trial rescue operation, making faith resemble fire insurance, and converting theological disagreement into something closer to existential threat. It tempted leaders to rule by fear when compassion and persuasion felt slower or less effective.
There is also a psychological dimension to this that rarely is acknowledged. ECT reinforces an “us versus them” mentality. We are safe, they are in danger. We are inside, they are outside. We are vindicated, they will be proven wrong and pay an eternal cost. That emotional logic is extremely powerful, and it is part of why ECT persists even when the biblical data are more complex and actually show something quite different.
A doctrine that functions this well as social control will not go away simply because someone produces better exegesis. We’ve had that the whole time. It has to be confronted as a spiritual and psychological structure, not only as a set of suspect proof-texts. Evangelicals are deeply invested in their belief in hell and in its utility for their purposes.11
Adapted from “The Hell We Think We Know (Expanded)” (Drink Wisely, Feb. 26, 2026)
What I can add to this is how the doctrine functions day to day. If the penalty for a wrong answer or failure in completing a transaction is infinite, every question about belief and behavior becomes serious risk management, and risk management produces performance. Quiet times get logged, testimonies get polished, doubts get hidden or suppressed, and assurance of salvation gets checked like the charge on a phone. A frightened member is a dependable member, after all, and institutions that use it know it.
Any chink in the armor, any sign of doubt is read as a lack of faith, maturity, sanctification, or whatever other characteristic indicates a strong, robust faith to them. If you have doubts or questions, keep them close to the vest or only share them discreetly with trusted spiritual advisors or your pastor. Being too open and honest with doubt will get you prayed for, but the prayer will likely be for your salvation and true repentance.
I’ve been guilty of the performance too, even as a church leader. Sometimes especially as a church leader. There are doctrinal disagreements I have had with my own tradition for years, but I seldom brought attention to them. I didn’t bring them up at times I’ve had opportunity, not because I wasn’t confident in my misgivings or ability to articulate them, but because I knew it could and would rock the boat in a way I didn’t want or couldn’t afford, vocationally speaking. Try getting ordained when you cannot affirm all the distinctives of your tradition’s confession of faith.
5. The Apparatus
The claim that nobody is saved outside the church has a long pedigree. Origen floated something close to it a few years earlier, in his Homilies on Joshua, but the best-known version belongs to Cyprian, bishop of Carthage, in a letter written around 256 CE, in the middle of a fight over whether baptism performed by heretics and schismatics counted at all.12 Churches in North Africa had been splitting for years by then, first over Christians who lapsed under the Decian persecution and then over who could baptize and who counted as inside. His line was a ruling in that dispute, aimed at people who had broken a local church apart. This wasn’t last Tuesday at General Assembly, mind you. It was the 250s CE.
Modern evangelical churches have mostly dropped the sacramental apparatus that gave Cyprian’s line its rationale and just kept the pressure, which now applies equally to expectations to attend, join, serve on a committee or in a class, and don’t forget to give ten percent. The New Testament doesn’t set a ten percent rule for Christians, and the texts usually cited for it concern Israel’s law, specifically, though the topic is argued among scholars.13 I digress. Add a building, a staff, a full-time vocational pastor(s), a budget, and a denominational office, and the institution develops needs of its own. At that point “Are you growing in Christlikeness?” quietly becomes “Are you attending, serving, and giving?” because the second question is eminently more enforceable and trackable.
The weekly (sometimes more frequent) rhythm of “doing church,” whether as a leader or as a member, can become almost automatic. I don’t mean in a thoughtless or heartless way, so much as the same way a repetitive or routine job can be. It’s easy to get to a place where you are going through the motions and tasks that were once viewed primarily as opportunities are later viewed as obligations. When you attend, or lead, out of obligation, I think it’s safe to say it’s time to reevaluate motives and reasons. You know, that whole growing in Christlikeness thing again.
You may note that items one and five pull in opposite directions, and the system needs both of these to be sustainable. The private Jesus hooks you, while the public apparatus keeps you.
What Is Left of Him
Subtract all five and the question gets much harder. An awful lot of what I learned concerning Jesus was assembled by people, some of it centuries ago and some of it from some Sunday school supply catalog curriculum. I don’t hold the Bible to be infallible or inerrant, though I once did and did for most of my life, and I’m confident that some of what’s in the Gospels “grew” in the telling over the centuries. I’ve called the grown parts fan fiction, and I haven’t found a kinder phrase that’s equally accurate. We all know the writers weren’t actual eye-witnesses, right? And that much of the narrative was oral tradition for a long while before anyone put pen to parchment. See, there are those questions I probably needed to keep to myself.
That leaves a problem I can’t solve but haven’t stopped trying to. Everything I know about Jesus comes through texts I don’t consider fully reliable and perfect in every way, and yet the central figure in them kept his grip on me even after the system that taught me to revere him lost its own grip.
Kierkegaard saw the shape of this in 1846. In the Concluding Unscientific Postscript, his pseudonym Johannes Climacus argues that the greatest certainty history can offer is “only an approximation,” and that an approximation is too thin to carry an infinite personal stake.14 Kierkegaard’s answer was a leap, and he kept the paradox of the God-man at the very center of it. I can’t make that same leap on his terms right now, though I’m no atheist or agnostic. What Christ is beyond a great teacher and exemplar, I’m uncertain. Is he co-equal with God? Is he God in the sense the Trinity describes? Which Trinitarian description? I’ve studied those questions a great deal and have plenty of thoughts about them, opinions even, but I no longer have the definitive answers I once championed. So I take Kierkegaard’s diagnosis and hold his prescription at arm’s length. He also spent the last stretch of his life attacking the established Danish church in print, which makes him a very fitting companion of mine for both halves of this essay.
What I can say with the confidence the evidence allows is that a Jewish teacher from Galilee was crucified under Pontius Pilate and that people who had known him couldn’t stop talking about him afterward. They still can’t. Whatever more there is, and I do think there’s more, I won’t pretend to define. I was dogmatic once, and I’m done with that. As I grow older, I see more and more wisdom in the model of apophatic theology for this precise reason.
The pull comes from several places at once, and I can only sort them into loose piles. The first is the life itself, or at least the life as the Gospels narrate it, which remains compelling to me whatever I decide about the other details. His example holds up, especially in the Sermon on the Mount, and the Jesus who delivers it has very little in common with the Jesus of “church,” particularly the modern institutional kind.
The second is that I can’t shake his centrality in relationship to God. I couldn’t tell you adequately what that relationship is, which is where the apophatic instinct comes in, but I can’t make him peripheral either.
The third is harder to admit as a Reformed Protestant academic type, or a former one, I guess. There is a feeling, a drawing toward, that I can’t describe or attribute. Maybe that’s Kierkegaard’s leap. I don’t know. Whatever it is, I feel it and know it despite my doubts about a great deal else.
The Charge
Some people call where I’ve landed a devolution of faith rather than an evolution, and I get it. I’ve gone from dogmatic certainty to unsure about a lot, and from a tradition with well-defined answers to a man with a pile of maybes and what-ifs. Here’s my reply to that suspicion.
First, I ask, devolved from what? The certainty I gave up is not directly from God. It’s not even directly from the Bible. It’s younger in origin than its adherents want to admit. Drink Wisely has examined elsewhere where some of that certainty came from, in “The First Church of Paul” and “Until Wednesday”.
Second, the ideas I lean on now aren’t recent inventions of a man with a grudge against the church. Theosis, the idea that humans are drawn into the life of God, runs through the Greek fathers, and apokatastasis, the hope that God’s restoration reaches everyone, has defenders in no less than Origen and Gregory of Nyssa. If that’s devolution, the direction of travel is backward past Calvin, past Anselm, and past Augustine into the Greek East, which is a long way to walk for an obvious mistake. From where I sit now, I’d put the broader, older tradition up against the post-Reformation Reformed dogmatics any day to see which has the more credible, consistent history.
Third, look back at the five failures I pointed out. Each operates on certainty, whether about who is saved, whose face Jesus wears, or what the church must protect, and I’ve concluded that it is the certainty that was the problem more than any particular content or doctrine. The doctrines themselves are a mixed bag. Some hold up and some do not, which is why I wrote a full seven-essay series (see note) revisiting the Reformed T.U.L.I.P. acronym from where I stand now, instead of from presupposed agreement.15 Both of my current ideas mentioned here describe processes, and processes take as long as they take. I no longer need answers on a certain schedule (pun intended).
I could be wrong about all of it, of course. So could you. So could any of us. I now hold the concept of apokatastasis with the same attachment I once held the opposite, and the difference is that I now say forthrightly that it is possible I could be mistaken, which the old system never let me do.
The longer answer to the charge of arrogance or innovation, or to the fair worry that I’m building a private mythology to suit myself, is in “Where the Teeth Are”.
Where That Leaves Me
I’ve been out of the institutional church for about a year now, maybe longer. I have no particular return date and no farewell address to give. It might last months, or years, or forever, and I’ve made peace with not knowing the answer to that, which is another skill the system never taught. I’m able to do this because I understand now what used to be easily confused in my mind. The church, at least as an institution, isn’t the real point. It’s a means. Similarly, and this one will get me in trouble if I’m not already, the same can be said for the Bible. It’s a means, not an end in itself.
Some have said we are “a people of the book.” I disagree. Well, maybe we are, but I don’t believe we ought to be. I have come to see more and more that we are to be a people of the Word instead. To which you might reply, “didn’t you just say we shouldn’t be that?” And I’d reply, “you know, the Logos; the man Jesus Christ. He’s the “Word,” the book just points to him.” Many things would be different if we realized more often that the Word became flesh, not vellum-thin paper.
None of this is an argument against needing other people, of course. Connection, belonging, and a seat at a shared table are human needs, and the institutional church did not invent any of them, though it did a remarkable job of billing for them. Leaving the building did not cancel the need, and I’d be misleading you if I said the year has been easy on that front. I’m still working out what it looks like, and I expect to be at it for a while.
Whoever first said it, the line about Christ and Christians I cited at the beginning is at least half right. The other part is that so much of what I know about him came through the people I left, and I haven’t worked out what to do with that just yet. Maybe I never will. I remain glad, through it all, that in some inexplicable way Jesus remains at the fore of my thoughts and at the head of his church, which is people.
. . .
Endnotes
1. Snopes, “Did Gandhi Say This About Christians?” (Dec. 26, 2022), https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/did-gandhi-say-this-about-christians/. Snopes found no authoritative source linking the line to Gandhi.
2. “7 Gandhi Quotes That Are Totally Fake,” Gizmodo (July 9, 2015), https://gizmodo.com/7-gandhi-quotes-that-are-totally-fake-1716503435. The Bara Dada remark is traced there and elsewhere to E. Stanley Jones, The Christ of the Indian Road (Abingdon Press, 1925). The essay treats it as reported secondhand.
3. “Mahatma Gandhi Says He Believes in Christ but Not Christianity,” Harvard Crimson, Jan. 11, 1927, https://www.thecrimson.com/article/1927/1/11/mahatma-gandhi-says-he-believes-in/, as described by Snopes (note 1). Per Snopes, the item presents the line as Gandhi’s view but credits the summing-up to Dr. J.H. Holmes, a Swarthmore philosophy professor who had spoken with Gandhi, so it may be Holmes’s paraphrase.
4. On the altar call and the “new measures,” see Charles Grandison Finney, Lectures on Revivals of Religion (1835). On the evangelical emphasis on personal conversion, see David W. Bebbington, Evangelicalism in Modern Britain (Unwin Hyman, 1989), which names conversionism as one of four defining marks of evangelicalism. The essay speaks of the idea because the phrase “personal Lord and Savior” itself has no clearly documented origin.
5. Revelation 3:20 (NRSVue): “Listen! I am standing at the door, knocking; if you hear my voice and open the door, I will come in and eat with you, and you with me.” On Sallman’s Christ at Heart’s Door (1942), inspired by William Holman Hunt’s The Light of the World, which illustrates this verse, see “A Head of His Time,” Evangelical Covenant Church (Feb. 8, 2016), https://covchurch.org/2016/02/08/a-head-of-his-time.
6. Edward J. Blum and Paul Harvey, The Color of Christ: The Son of God and the Saga of Race in America (University of North Carolina Press, 2012). On Sallman, see the Evangelical Covenant Church articles cited in note 5 and “Grappling with the Image of Jesus” (Jan. 16, 2024), https://covchurch.org/2024/01/16/grappling-with-the-image-of-jesus/, which dates the charcoal Son of Man to the February 1924 Covenant Companion, the commissioned oil Head of Christ to 1940, and notes the comparison some scholars make to shampoo ads of the era. Some sources date the oil to 1941. The Lhermitte attribution (The Friend of the Humble, 1892) appears in Wikipedia’s “Head of Christ,” and the print figure of more than 500 million by the 1990s is credited there to Blum and Harvey.
7. John Howard Yoder, The Politics of Jesus, 2nd ed. (Eerdmans, 1994), as cited in “The Myth of a Christian Founding.” For Yoder’s fuller treatment of the Constantinian shift, see “The Constantinian Sources of Western Social Ethics,” in The Priestly Kingdom: Social Ethics as Gospel (University of Notre Dame Press, 1984), 135-48. The final sentence of the excerpt is the author’s own gloss on Yoder, not a quotation.
8. Houston Chronicle and San Antonio Express-News, “Abuse of Faith” (Feb. 10, 2019). Religion News Service, “Southern Baptist leaders vow to improve addressing sex abuse after papers’ report” (Feb. 11, 2019), https://religionnews.com/2019/02/11/southern-baptist-leaders-vow-to-improve-addressing-sex-abuse-after-papers-report/, which confirms the figures and that SBC leaders had earlier declined a database proposal, citing local church autonomy.
9. Guidepost Solutions, report to the Southern Baptist Convention Executive Committee (May 22, 2022). NPR and the Associated Press, “Top Southern Baptists stonewalled and denigrated sex abuse victims, report says” (May 22, 2022), summarize the seven-month independent investigation, the finding that leaders stonewalled and denigrated survivors, and the list of accused ministers kept by a staffer.
10. Mark 9:42 (NRSVue): “If any of you cause one of these little ones who believe in me to sin, it would be better for you if a great millstone were hung around your neck and you were thrown into the sea.” The essay paraphrases “cause . . . to sin” as “stumble,” following the Greek verb skandalizō.
11. Adapted from Shawn Patrick Connelly, “The Hell We Think We Know (Expanded),” Drink Wisely, Feb. 26, 2026, section “Hell as Weapon and Boundary Maintenance.” The excerpt is revised for this essay and adds two sentences to the third paragraph. The historical sources for the revivalist background appear in that essay’s endnotes.
12. Cyprian of Carthage, Letter 73 to Jubaianus (numbered 72 in the Ante-Nicene Fathers edition), sec. 21: “there is no salvation out of the Church,” https://ccel.org/ccel/schaff/anf05.iv.iv.lxxii.html. The Ante-Nicene Fathers edition dates the letter to 256 CE; other compilations give 253 to 256. It addresses the validity of baptism by heretics and schismatics. The earlier disputes over those who lapsed in the Decian persecution (250 to 251) belong to Cyprian’s earlier ministry. Origen, Homilies on Joshua 3.5, has an earlier version of the saying; for an English translation, see Barbara J. Bruce, trans., Homilies on Joshua (Catholic University of America Press, 2002).
13. Andreas J. Köstenberger and David A. Croteau, “‘Will a Man Rob God?’ (Malachi 3:8): A Study of Tithing in the Old and New Testaments,” Bulletin for Biblical Research 16.1 (2006): 53-77, concluding that none of the Old or New Testament passages can legitimately be used to argue for the continuation of tithing in the new covenant period. See also David A. Croteau, You Mean I Don’t Have to Tithe? (Pickwick Publications, 2010).
14. Søren Kierkegaard, Concluding Unscientific Postscript, “The Historical View,” trans. Alastair Hannay (Cambridge University Press, 2009), https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/abs/kierkegaard-concluding-unscientific-postscript/historical-view/3A05CF28B814C8D5D70B1A145855A7B9: “with regard to history the greatest certainty is after all only an approximation, and an approximation is too little to base his happiness on.” Kierkegaard’s public attack on the Danish church began in December 1854.
15. The Drink Wisely T.U.L.I.P. series, seven stand-alone essays. (1) “Out of Order” (introduction). (2) “A Definite Number of Particular People”. (3) “Neither Able Nor Willing”. (4) “Sufficient for the Sins of the Whole World”. (5) “Pour Forth Light All Around”. (6) “According to the Measure of Their Faith”. (7) “All in All” (coda).




As I’ve said before, you can be a Christian without the book. Behaviour and practice are what matter. Any branch of Christianity is defined by its nitpicking pomposity, structure and abuses of power. Mostly (with some exceptions) hollowed out structures far away from Christ’s central discourse with us. We’re both in the same place, thinking about our humanity and how best to make a connection that’s not filtered through endless discussion and rule making. In the end, try your best to be the man he was. Nothing else matters
You name dubious characteristics of a popular view of Christianity: personal savior, white American Jesus, sexual abuse & coverup, threat of fire & brimstone hell, & the church as the only path to a comfortable afterlife. The addition of these peculiar theological features come years, decades, even centuries after the beginning of the common era & with questionable author, translator, editorial pedigree. You can also add Jesus’ divinity, trinitarianism, Filioque, & a host of other deemed heretical by one Christian faith expression or another.
Jesus was a Jew at a time & place where announcing even to your most intimate circle of followers would likely get you stoned by others if they heard tell. Even in the story where Jesus asks the disciples for their opinions on who he might be he tells them to keep the SoG idea to themselves. Is it because “his time hasn’t come,” he knows he risks death by an angry mob, or it isn’t true is left to the reader. Just because you pick an option doesn’t make the others less plausible.
My opinion is that it probably matters most whether you do justice, love mercy, & help your neighbor especially the foreigner. That seems core Jewish & Muslim teachings, given that they’re the children of Abraham. It’s the core of Jesus’ message & found in other religious expressions.
That’s basic Christianity, the rest is adiaphora, to use a bit of Greek.