Always have recognized Evangelicals as having personal salvation as their reason for being… and that this has caused them to interpret pretty much everything from the wrong position, as you so beautifully call out with regard to reading the Matthew verse. But I have never ever thought of Evangelical “Christianity” as in anyway related to the Gnostic heresy. Didn’t think the Gnostic heresy would be quite as far off base as is Evangelicalism! (Partial joke) The Orphic cult helped. The Presbyterian church’s vote to name Evangelical nationalism a heresy shows we are moving in the right direction in stamping back the flames of this not very Christian Christianity. Maybe their rise will cause their fall, eventually. I’m sending this article to many many people. Thank you so much!
Just finished reading. Thank you for a well-written piece! Your analysis is clear and well reasoned. I especially appreciated your statement:
"The resurrection is not primarily an exit event; it is the first evidence of a new creation coming. The goal is not the extraction of souls from a doomed world but the transformation of the world itself, the whole cosmos drawn into the life of God.”
I’ve spent over 3 decades educating myself on the roots of Christian church and specifically the fundamentalist American church I was raised it. This is hands down the best explanation I’ve ever read. Thank you!!
Thanks for the work on this. You invite readers to consider that our ideas and beliefs come from a tradition or history of thought, which they do. It's so easy to be certain about our ideas when we don't look at where they come from nor look at other traditions of thought that are not our own. It seems that to not examine our ideas, we risk living out of line with who we profess to be. The church has a wonderful tradition of self-examination, confession, and repentance. This mechanism gives it permission to admit doctrinal drift and re-align with Jesus. Sadly, the pride of certainty seems to keep the church from accessing this mechanism.
I refuse to muse on this length of reading and feeding on history. I have had a personal encounter with Jesus being sent back from heaven after a brain-dead coma. This theological bent prevents people from understanding what God can do for each one in His divine way. Each Christian community can provide worship, fellowship, and support in growing in faith after people are hurting. Drawn to help others come back to faith, I believe in His miraculous grace.
“What American evangelicalism largely produced instead was a theology of transaction.”
That may be true for some, but faith in the word of God in scripture leads to transformation. God’s word promises this inner transformation into the likeness of Jesus if we follow him with the guidance of the indwelling Holy Spirit which is given us when we give up our own authority and submit our lives to Him. It is not fair to blame others (or teachers) for our own failure to follow and trust in God’s word, ie in Jesus’ words and life.
American Evangelicalism is the thing everyone loves to hate, especially these days, and most of all, by former members. Evangelicals are a neopagan cult? The grass is always greener on the other side, like among the Eastern Orthodox, or in Rome, it seems. Really? Evangelicals are hated because they have been quite successful and done a lot of things right, while others have not. American ex-evangelicals generally lack any experience of the horrors of European state churches or imperial religion. But now all the her enemies from Qatar, to Russia and Rome are out the crush her, remove that hated obstacle, or pillage what she has built. Thank God, He is in charge and that the Global South will take over the calling while American Evangelicalism seems to be descending into internal chaos under a constant barrage of attacks.
I wonder if the category "American Evangelical" is too broad brush to be entirely useful. There are many who personally encounter Christ through the Word, then accept that "if you love Me, you will keep My commandments", and pursue the Sermon on the Mount and Matthew 25 as part of those commands. There is a corrupted "evangelical" sub-economy, all celebrity and prosperity. But there's also a lot of serious evangelicals who want to follow Jesus. So the category has become less and less precise.
I’m going to have to chew on this for a bit. I think I need to reread it too. I thought it was going a little over my head, but towards the end I was thinking, this could be a case for socialism. And then you cited “Three cheers for socialism,” so I guess I was picking up on more than I thought. (I know you weren’t being prescriptive though, as you said.) It’s hard for me because I grew up in very evangelical circles and had to massively disentangle the truth about God’s character from the experiences I had. I’m glad God got a hold of me so I didn’t throw in the towel all together. My encounter with Him was a very personal experience but I have had to learn to (with fear and trepidation) be part of a community of believers again. I grew up in strict Calvinist, Evangelical, Republican circles. Now I consider myself much more on the mystical side than the systematic theology side. And politically I’m more just fatalistic than anything - for two reasons. 1. I feel like it’s easy for people to attach themselves to a party and feel like they are “living out their faith” through their political involvement. Just pick your stance. People make a case for voting republican, democrat, libertarian, socialist, Green Party all from the bible, and as long as they’re willing to highlight certain passages and ignore others, they feel like they’re fulfilling the biblical mandate to… fill the earth and subdue it, or submit, or turn the other cheek, love your enemies, be faithful, obedient, give generously, look out for false prophets, be shrewd and innocent, look after orphans and widows… It’s easy to think that if I vote in line with my conviction on one or several of these, I have done my part. And then we can get into debates whether socialism or capitalism is the better avenue for biblical obedience. But Jesus didn’t seem to spend much time on political solutions. He gave a job to his church, not to the church to pawn off on the government. He came to write the law not on tablets of stone but on human hearts right? But that brings me to my number 2. We want a way to pick the weeds. We want to go out in the field and pick the weeds among the wheat and what better way than these self-made labels? We can pluck away till our hearts content at any label we’ve decided is problematic. The thing is, Jesus told us not to do that. Because we suck at it. “You will accidentally pull up the wheat too.”
All that to say, I have a hard time knowing where I fit in the Christian and political landscape these days. I know He met me personally and also He made me part of His church. These are not mutually exclusive. I don’t believe the commands of God were something He wanted me to campaign or vote for, but to actually just go and do. And I think money and power corrupt indiscriminately. I think we as people have the ability to screw things up no matter the economic or political system. And I whole heartedly agree with Douglas Adams, “Anyone who is capable of getting themselves made President should on no account be allowed to do the job.”
Anyway, thank you for writing this. It gave me a lot to think about.
I have written and spoken critically regarding Transactional Salvation, and substantially agree with your comments regarding it. I agree that much of Evangelical teaching and practice is too focused on the individual and the conversion experience, and has (over time) lost sight of "the widows and orphans" (in other words, social concerns, beyond seeing people as merely potential converts). Put another way, it has focused on saving people from hell rather than saving them to a new life. It should be helping them become more Christ-like, serving God and others. In these things we argue.
I have a problem with using the worst bad boys of the evangelical fringe as representative of the whole. I am alarmed by the rise of the "super-church" (we often call them Six Flags Over Jesus), the cult of personality surrounding many of the high-profile leaders of those churches, and especially the "prosperity gospel" heresy taught by some. I just don't believe they represent the majority of Evangelical Christians and their churches.
While the Gnostic similarities might extend to theological language as well as eschatological musings (the end times and Rapture) so perennially popular in some Evangelical circles - "sacred knowledge / hidden wisdom" - I think you have carried that analogy too far. The Orphic and Gnostic cults were secretive, unlike mainstream Evangelicalism. They were entirely based on the Great Secret, and only entered into through the initiation ceremony. Evangelical Christianity is more open and carries a gospel of cheap grace to point of "catch and release" evangelism. Also, the gatekeeper function is alive and well in virtually all Christian churches, including the Catholic and Orthodox (who have priests who are often as authoritarian as an Evangelical minister, and have impressive processes and ceremonies to initiate converts).
Thank you for this!!!
This is what n.t.wright has been saying for decades. You should check him out
Always have recognized Evangelicals as having personal salvation as their reason for being… and that this has caused them to interpret pretty much everything from the wrong position, as you so beautifully call out with regard to reading the Matthew verse. But I have never ever thought of Evangelical “Christianity” as in anyway related to the Gnostic heresy. Didn’t think the Gnostic heresy would be quite as far off base as is Evangelicalism! (Partial joke) The Orphic cult helped. The Presbyterian church’s vote to name Evangelical nationalism a heresy shows we are moving in the right direction in stamping back the flames of this not very Christian Christianity. Maybe their rise will cause their fall, eventually. I’m sending this article to many many people. Thank you so much!
Thanks for reading!
This is a good read!
Just finished reading. Thank you for a well-written piece! Your analysis is clear and well reasoned. I especially appreciated your statement:
"The resurrection is not primarily an exit event; it is the first evidence of a new creation coming. The goal is not the extraction of souls from a doomed world but the transformation of the world itself, the whole cosmos drawn into the life of God.”
Regarding Hart’s teaser comment: Ouch!
I’ve spent over 3 decades educating myself on the roots of Christian church and specifically the fundamentalist American church I was raised it. This is hands down the best explanation I’ve ever read. Thank you!!
Thanks for the work on this. You invite readers to consider that our ideas and beliefs come from a tradition or history of thought, which they do. It's so easy to be certain about our ideas when we don't look at where they come from nor look at other traditions of thought that are not our own. It seems that to not examine our ideas, we risk living out of line with who we profess to be. The church has a wonderful tradition of self-examination, confession, and repentance. This mechanism gives it permission to admit doctrinal drift and re-align with Jesus. Sadly, the pride of certainty seems to keep the church from accessing this mechanism.
I refuse to muse on this length of reading and feeding on history. I have had a personal encounter with Jesus being sent back from heaven after a brain-dead coma. This theological bent prevents people from understanding what God can do for each one in His divine way. Each Christian community can provide worship, fellowship, and support in growing in faith after people are hurting. Drawn to help others come back to faith, I believe in His miraculous grace.
“What American evangelicalism largely produced instead was a theology of transaction.”
That may be true for some, but faith in the word of God in scripture leads to transformation. God’s word promises this inner transformation into the likeness of Jesus if we follow him with the guidance of the indwelling Holy Spirit which is given us when we give up our own authority and submit our lives to Him. It is not fair to blame others (or teachers) for our own failure to follow and trust in God’s word, ie in Jesus’ words and life.
American Evangelicalism is the thing everyone loves to hate, especially these days, and most of all, by former members. Evangelicals are a neopagan cult? The grass is always greener on the other side, like among the Eastern Orthodox, or in Rome, it seems. Really? Evangelicals are hated because they have been quite successful and done a lot of things right, while others have not. American ex-evangelicals generally lack any experience of the horrors of European state churches or imperial religion. But now all the her enemies from Qatar, to Russia and Rome are out the crush her, remove that hated obstacle, or pillage what she has built. Thank God, He is in charge and that the Global South will take over the calling while American Evangelicalism seems to be descending into internal chaos under a constant barrage of attacks.
I wonder if the category "American Evangelical" is too broad brush to be entirely useful. There are many who personally encounter Christ through the Word, then accept that "if you love Me, you will keep My commandments", and pursue the Sermon on the Mount and Matthew 25 as part of those commands. There is a corrupted "evangelical" sub-economy, all celebrity and prosperity. But there's also a lot of serious evangelicals who want to follow Jesus. So the category has become less and less precise.
I’m going to have to chew on this for a bit. I think I need to reread it too. I thought it was going a little over my head, but towards the end I was thinking, this could be a case for socialism. And then you cited “Three cheers for socialism,” so I guess I was picking up on more than I thought. (I know you weren’t being prescriptive though, as you said.) It’s hard for me because I grew up in very evangelical circles and had to massively disentangle the truth about God’s character from the experiences I had. I’m glad God got a hold of me so I didn’t throw in the towel all together. My encounter with Him was a very personal experience but I have had to learn to (with fear and trepidation) be part of a community of believers again. I grew up in strict Calvinist, Evangelical, Republican circles. Now I consider myself much more on the mystical side than the systematic theology side. And politically I’m more just fatalistic than anything - for two reasons. 1. I feel like it’s easy for people to attach themselves to a party and feel like they are “living out their faith” through their political involvement. Just pick your stance. People make a case for voting republican, democrat, libertarian, socialist, Green Party all from the bible, and as long as they’re willing to highlight certain passages and ignore others, they feel like they’re fulfilling the biblical mandate to… fill the earth and subdue it, or submit, or turn the other cheek, love your enemies, be faithful, obedient, give generously, look out for false prophets, be shrewd and innocent, look after orphans and widows… It’s easy to think that if I vote in line with my conviction on one or several of these, I have done my part. And then we can get into debates whether socialism or capitalism is the better avenue for biblical obedience. But Jesus didn’t seem to spend much time on political solutions. He gave a job to his church, not to the church to pawn off on the government. He came to write the law not on tablets of stone but on human hearts right? But that brings me to my number 2. We want a way to pick the weeds. We want to go out in the field and pick the weeds among the wheat and what better way than these self-made labels? We can pluck away till our hearts content at any label we’ve decided is problematic. The thing is, Jesus told us not to do that. Because we suck at it. “You will accidentally pull up the wheat too.”
All that to say, I have a hard time knowing where I fit in the Christian and political landscape these days. I know He met me personally and also He made me part of His church. These are not mutually exclusive. I don’t believe the commands of God were something He wanted me to campaign or vote for, but to actually just go and do. And I think money and power corrupt indiscriminately. I think we as people have the ability to screw things up no matter the economic or political system. And I whole heartedly agree with Douglas Adams, “Anyone who is capable of getting themselves made President should on no account be allowed to do the job.”
Anyway, thank you for writing this. It gave me a lot to think about.
I have written and spoken critically regarding Transactional Salvation, and substantially agree with your comments regarding it. I agree that much of Evangelical teaching and practice is too focused on the individual and the conversion experience, and has (over time) lost sight of "the widows and orphans" (in other words, social concerns, beyond seeing people as merely potential converts). Put another way, it has focused on saving people from hell rather than saving them to a new life. It should be helping them become more Christ-like, serving God and others. In these things we argue.
I have a problem with using the worst bad boys of the evangelical fringe as representative of the whole. I am alarmed by the rise of the "super-church" (we often call them Six Flags Over Jesus), the cult of personality surrounding many of the high-profile leaders of those churches, and especially the "prosperity gospel" heresy taught by some. I just don't believe they represent the majority of Evangelical Christians and their churches.
While the Gnostic similarities might extend to theological language as well as eschatological musings (the end times and Rapture) so perennially popular in some Evangelical circles - "sacred knowledge / hidden wisdom" - I think you have carried that analogy too far. The Orphic and Gnostic cults were secretive, unlike mainstream Evangelicalism. They were entirely based on the Great Secret, and only entered into through the initiation ceremony. Evangelical Christianity is more open and carries a gospel of cheap grace to point of "catch and release" evangelism. Also, the gatekeeper function is alive and well in virtually all Christian churches, including the Catholic and Orthodox (who have priests who are often as authoritarian as an Evangelical minister, and have impressive processes and ceremonies to initiate converts).
Of course Hart is Eastern Orthodox...
From the very start, THE VERY START, the disciples never got it.