Michael Spangler doesn’t really fit the picture most of us have of a white supremacist. The soft-spoken Winston-Salem pastor gave Religion News Service a Zoom interview in a charcoal suit and a neatly trimmed beard, seated in front of a fish tank that reporter Bob Smietana says looked like it came off the set of Finding Nemo.1 Then the conversation turned to Jews, and a broad smile crossed Spangler’s face. His start-up church, which has a handful of families, bars Black people on the theory that mixing is harmful, and he told Smietana that since God did not make the sexes equal, God did not make the races equal.2 Take note of that second claim, in particular, because the rest of this essay is in response to that.
Spangler grew up in the pews of a historic African American congregation where his mother was the pastor.3
Joel Webbon is the better-funded version. The Texas pastor owns a media company whose YouTube channel currently counts 187,000 subscribers, up from the 125,000 he says it had when his company bought it, and he sells everything from subscriptions to T-shirts through it.4 In 2024, he posted a video saying that if his daughter brought home a Black Christian man who loved the Lord, he would thank God and give the wedding his blessing. More recently he sat in a wood-paneled studio with Thomas Rousseau, founder of the white nationalist group Patriot Front, and told him that he does not find the claim that Black people cannot be Americans racist. He understands the position.5 The Bible stayed put but the conclusion didn’t, and a man whose position derives from a book ought to be able to say what in the book changed.
Smietana’s investigation describes a small but growing network of Reformed pastors and influencers who preach and sell white supremacy, antisemitism and patriarchy to angry young men as the authentic Christianity of the Bible.6 Several of them would reject those labels, and some may not grasp what they are selling. The labels fit anyway, and the men are wrong, ignorant or both. The common response is that these men are simply misreading the book they claim as their highest authority. I want to try a more nuanced, harder response since on two counts they read the text accurately.
The Bible regulates slavery but never condemns it, and it prescribes a hierarchy of the sexes, and anyone who holds the particular doctrine of inspiration these men hold has to be able to answer for both facts. The white supremacy in all of this comes from somewhere else. The Bible gives them nothing directly on that. They brought it with them, and it has a timestamp, a legislature and a lineage of Southern Presbyterian apologists, all of which I intend to show. The antisemitism idea has its own long road, through Luther and Chrysostom and one verse in 1 Thessalonians, that will require its own essay in the future.
The floor under the doctrine
We’ll start with the doctrine these men stand on, because it explains why they cannot step off of it. Drink Wisely has previously examined how that doctrine arrives in a youth group, as a three-part package of verbal plenary inspiration, inerrancy and infallibility, and how it holds up once somebody opens the book. A person who says every word of the Bible is God’s word has to say where the claim comes from and the usual answer is 2 Timothy 3:16, as if it is crystal clear and obvious. Dan McClellan, who argues about the Bible on the internet for a living, points out in The Bible Says So that this is a textbook case of begging the question. Citing a verse to prove the Bible is inspired only works if you already accept that the verse is inspired.7 That, at least, is indeed obvious.
The Bible, as a bounded collection, did not exist when that verse was written. “Scripture,” in that context, meant an open category of Jewish writings, wider than any modern canon and without a word of the New Testament included, and the earliest references to individual volumes holding “the scriptures” come in the early fourth century.8 Most critical scholars also hold that 1 and 2 Timothy and Titus (the “Pastoral Epistles”) were written well after Paul’s death, toward the end of the first century or into the second.9 Defenders of this reading have an answer that sounds reasonable enough on its face. The early church accepted the letters, no rival account of their origin has won, and so they should remain genuinely Pauline until proven otherwise, which one scholar claimed by saying the epistles are innocent until proved guilty.10 The presumption of innocence is cute and works for defendants, not documents. Documents get weighed on evidences, and the evidence of vocabulary, theology and church structure points toward a later hand.
Another argument takes the verse apart further. The Greek word translated “God-breathed,” theopneustos, appears only once in the New Testament, so its sense has to be argued from the word family it belongs to and from the rest of ancient Greek. That family points toward animating breath. Across the New Testament the Spirit is the life-giver. In John 6:63 Jesus says the spirit is what gives life, and in Romans 8:11 the Spirit who raised Christ will give life to mortal bodies as well. Read against that background, 2 Timothy 3:16 sounds like a claim about living presence in the texts, and the evangelical reading took a word about the Spirit and turned it into a doctrine about the book. Drink Wisely has also looked at the pneumatological side of this word. John Poirier’s The Invention of the Inspired Text (2021) lands in a similar place and dates the turn to “inspired” to Origen of Alexandria in the third century.11 The verbal plenary position needs the word to mean literally breathed out by God, and the evidence will not give it that. Even if it did, the only scripture Timothy’s readers had in view was the Hebrew Bible, which leaves the New Testament out of the claim altogether.
Now the part that really interests me. The letters that supply the proof text for inspiration also supply the proof texts for the positions these men prize most. First Timothy 2:12 is the verse behind silencing women in the church, and 1 Timothy 6:1-3 tells enslaved Christians to treat their masters as worthy of all honor.12 A man who needs every line of those letters to be God’s own words has built his floor and his furniture from the very same disputed lumber. If a later author wrote them in Paul’s name, which was a rather common practice in the ancient world, the doctrine and its favorite applications share an origin and that origin was not an apostle.
What the text gives them
I want to be fair to Joshua Haymes, which is not a sentence I would think I’d ever type. On his Reformation Red Pill channel, he said that owning another human being is not inherently evil and told every Christian to affirm as much, and then he immediately pitched a sleep powder.13 On the narrow question of what the text says, he actually has the better of the argument against the apologists who say otherwise. Get your attention? Let me explain.
McClellan spends a chapter taking those apologists apart, and their case comes in three parts. The first holds that the Bible’s slavery was gentler than its neighbors’, in a feeble effort to somehow minimize the severity of slavery in the Bible as bad, yes, but not as bad as other slavery. McClellan lines the biblical laws up against the cuneiform collections and finds them mostly equivalent, now kinder and now crueler. The Covenant Code adapts Hammurabi, so an ox that gores a slave costs its owner thirty shekels where Hammurabi’s law, a thousand years earlier, set twenty.14 Leviticus gives an Israelite debt slave forty-nine years of service where Hammurabi gave a citizen three.15 Exodus 21 says a master who beats an enslaved person to death will face vengeance, and owes nothing if the person survives a day or two, because the person is, literally, his money.16
The second holds that the Bible bans the slave trade, usually by way of Exodus 21:16 and 1 Timothy 1:10. Both are kidnapping laws. The Greek word in Timothy, andrapodistes, appears in a lexicon of the Attic orators in a line about executing men for robbing others of their slaves, and in Chariton’s novel Callirhoe for a crook who sells a slave who is not his to sell.17 The verse condemns stealing other people’s slaves, which a slaveholder could affirm with a clear conscience, and it’s in a letter whose last chapter tells enslaved Christians to honor their masters. Oops.
The third holds that God was walking Israel, and then the church, toward eventual abolition by degrees. McClellan replies that every change in the text concerns how enslaved people are treated and none questions the system itself. The God of the Hebrew Bible overturns whole societies without hesitating, so reluctance to disturb Israel’s economy or social norms cannot explain the complete silence. And slavery becomes one of the Bible’s governing metaphors, with worship described as service, redemption as being bought back, and followers as slaves of Christ, which is an odd vehicle for a message that slavery is evil.18 In McClellan’s judgment, abolition came from enslaved people and the abolitionists who stood with them, who often renegotiated the biblical texts to do it, and from Enlightenment arguments for universal rights, and he has no patience for the claim that it was baked into Scripture.19 His chapter ends bluntly. “What is clear is that the Bible absolutely nowhere says that slavery is wrong.”20
Galatians 3:28 is the common reply, because Paul says there is no longer slave or free, and abolitionists did lean on the verse. Read the whole sentence, though. It comes out of a baptismal formula about who counts as Abraham’s heirs, and it lists three pairs, Jew and Greek, slave and free, male and female.21 Whatever the verse abolishes about the middle pair it abolishes about the third, and no complementarian is willing to read it that way. Paul also sent Onesimus back to his owner in Philemon, and scholars dispute whether he asked for the man’s release. The letters that carry his name keep telling the enslaved to obey.
None of this was discovered in the twenty-first century. The antebellum church fought on the same ground. Charles Hodge, the Princeton theologian who stayed with the Union and came around to emancipation later, held that Scripture does not prohibit slavery in all cases and that slaveholding is not sin in itself, and readers in the North and the South took his article as a biblical defense of the institution.22 Historian Mark Noll studied that debate and concluded that the defenders of slavery won the argument over Scripture, at least when the argument is narrowly defined, because the Bible really does not condemn slavery as such.23 Noll also describes a road that stayed open and went untaken. Antislavery Christians could have conceded the point and condemned the racial slavery actually practiced, since nothing in the text required the slave to be Black. That nuanced argument lost, he says, to a culture that preferred common-sense readings and to a pervasive racism, North and South, that led white readers to assume the slaves of the Bible could only mean Black ones.24 That failure belongs as much to history and language as to morals. Few people in those pews had been taught what a slave meant in the ancient world or how the Hebrew and Greek words work, and plenty of pulpits still send their people into these arguments with the exact same gap.
Patriarchy carries the same problem, and inerrantists know it. The best complementarian answer holds that headship rests on creation while slavery rested on a fallen social order, so one binds permanently and the other does not. On paper, that’s a compelling distinction. The slavery side has an answer ready, though. Paul never calls slavery a part of the fallen order, he tells the enslaved to obey and the masters to be fair, and Leviticus treats ownership of other humans as ordinary property law. A man who says the Bible defends slavery, as Haymes does, has the text on his side. Meanwhile egalitarians read the same inerrant text and conclude the opposite about the women. A doctrine that yields two answers has not decided between them, which means everyone in that room is doing their own editing, and the only dispute is over which verses get the red pen.
The theobros have noticed the editing that is happening and decided to stop, and in that narrow sense they are the most consistent inerrantists in the building.
Consistency is not correctness, and the place it leads is clear. If Ephesians 5 describes God’s design for the household, the household gets one vote and the husband casts it, which Dale Partridge’s church in Prescott, Arizona has embraced, as the New York Times reported this spring.25 Partridge once gave a TEDx talk about valuing people over profits and was best known for his view that yoga pants are sinful. He now says women should not be allowed to vote.26 The road from yoga pants to the Nineteenth Amendment is apparently shorter than it looks.
Spangler made the move in public. If God built hierarchy into the sexes at creation, as he thinks God did, then building it into the races looks to him like more of the same design. The analogy is bad, as I will argue, but it follows the first claim in a straight line, and the first claim was available in the text. These men did not make up the sex hierarchy. They found it in texts like 1 Timothy 2 and Ephesians 5 and believed it as written.
Where race comes in
McClellan opens his slavery chapter with a clarification that everything after it depends on. The slavery of the Bible is not race-based slavery, at least not as we understand race. The New Testament word often translated “race” had no connection to skin color, and the idea of race as skin color begins with medieval Europeans rationalizing imperial conquest.27 Most of us assume without thinking that slavery means the enslavement of people of another color, and that assumption is the reason everything below can happen.
The text people go to first is Genesis 9, the so-called curse of Ham. Read it. Noah curses Canaan, Ham’s son, Noah does the cursing and not God, and the story mentions neither skin nor Africa.28 David Goldenberg’s history of the interpretation argues that two separate stories, one explaining dark skin and one explaining slavery, got conflated, and that the link between Ham’s curse and Black Africans turns up in Near Eastern writers by the seventh century and in Western Christian writers by the fifteenth.29 The Bible doesn’t say that. Interpreters said it, bad ones and centuries later, when it was most useful.
Virginia gets us to the law. The colony had no clear body of slave law for roughly forty years after the first enslaved Africans arrived, and the first statute to call “negroes” slaves comes in 1659.30 In 1662 the General Assembly ruled that a child’s status follows the mother’s, a rule already common elsewhere in the Americas, and in the same act doubled the fine for fornication between a “Christian” and a “negro.” In 1667 it declared that baptism does not exempt anyone from bondage.31
Note that vocabulary. Christian on one side, negro on the other, as if a person could not be both. Plenty of Africans in Virginia were both, which was the legislature’s problem. Historian Katharine Gerbner argues that colonial Protestants first built an identity she calls Protestant supremacy, then watched Africans become Christians, and swapped the identity out for race, so that whiteness replaced Christianity as the mark of freedom.32 The 1667 law was solving a theological problem, whether a baptized person could still be property, and it answered it by cutting the link between baptism and liberty. A legislature wrote that answer, and it wrote the answer that the slaveholders preferred.
By the 1850s Presbyterians had the Bible argument at the ready. Robert Lewis Dabney and James Henley Thornwell, the Southern Presbyterian divines, defended slavery from Scripture, and SPLC says Dabney saw Black people as a “morally inferior race.”33 R. Ward Holder, the historian Smietana quotes, notes that Presbyterians, like Baptists, split North and South over the war, and he says Southern Presbyterians of that era were zealous proponents of the righteousness of slavery and racism.34 Spangler and his friend Samuel Ketcham named their new denomination the Southern Presbytery, and RNS refers to the name as telling, which it certainly is.35
Then the war ended and the project changed form. Reconstruction collapsed in 1877. Segregation by statute then spread across the South, with Tennessee’s railway law of 1881 an early example, and in Plessy v. Ferguson in 1896 the Supreme Court upheld separate but equal.36 C. Vann Woodward argued in 1955 that segregation was a late invention of the post-Reconstruction South. Later historians have refined the timeline and found habits of separation that came earlier, but his core claim survives, that the codified system was built politically by leaders who wanted the votes of poor whites, and it was built after a war in which both sides quoted the same Bible.37
Did you ever wonder where the name originated? Jim Crow came from a minstrel routine. “Jump Jim Crow” was performed by Thomas Dartmouth Rice beginning in 1828, and his caricature of a Black man gave white America its definitional word for the system.38 That is the true pedigree of the belief system these men call a biblical order of society. A white entertainer in blackface, a Virginia statute, and a Presbyterian chaplain with a grudge. Scripture is not on the origin list.
Jemar Tisby compares the present moment to the Redemption era, the years after Reconstruction when Black Southerners lost much of what they had gained. Redemption, he points out, is a religious word that means restoring a people to right relationship with God, and white supremacists twisted it to mean taking the country back.39 The theobros didn’t originate that either.
The best argument they have
Their strongest case rests on a short list of passages, and the theobros know exactly where to find them. God made the nations, set their boundaries, scattered them at Babel, and shows them still distinct in the final vision of Revelation. Acts 17:26 is the go-to text, with its allotted times and boundaries.40 Add Leviticus 25:44-46, which McClellan reads as heartily endorsing chattel slavery for foreigners, who become property and may be passed down to your children in perpetuity.41 Add Ezra, who learns that the holy seed has mixed itself with the peoples of the lands and has the men send away their foreign wives and the children born to them, and Nehemiah, who confronts the same marriages and recalls that the law bars Ammonites and Moabites from the assembly.42 Put those together and you have a Bible that organizes humanity by descent, assigns different statuses to the groups, and in Ezra’s Jerusalem expels entire families. If you presuppose the whole text is indeed God’s word for all time, you have a serious case for ethnic hierarchy. I will not pretend otherwise as far as that premise is concerned.
Start with what I am willing to concede. The structure is in the text. Permanent, heritable ownership of people from other nations, sanctioned in Leviticus, is a template, and slaveholders in Virginia and Mississippi found that template. Noll’s point stands, that readers assumed the Bible’s slaves must be Black ones. What the reader cannot find is the verse that says who actually counts as the nations around you. The text offers a structure with no category, and implementing the structure requires a map from ancient peoples to modern ones. Who are the Moabites now? The map was drawn in Virginia, and Genesis had absolutely nothing to do with it. McClellan notes that biblical enslavement was organized around national, ethnic and social identities, none of which divided by skin color, and sometimes around none of them at all.43
Acts 17:26 is Paul in Athens saying that God made every nation from one ancestor, and the point of the sentence is common origin and a God near to each of them. Revelation 7:9 shows the nations worshiping together in one multitude before the throne, which is difference without hierarchy and without separate spaces.44
Ezra and Nehemiah take longer, because they are the most formidable texts the theobros have. Ezra’s concern is lineage. The phrase “holy seed” is about descent, obviously. The ban also grows in Ezra’s hands. Deuteronomy 7 lists seven Canaanite nations whose daughters Israel must not marry, and Ezra 9 adds Ammonites, Moabites and Egyptians to the list.45 The reason Deuteronomy gives is cultic in nature; that foreign spouses will turn Israel’s heart to other gods (Deuteronomy 7:3-4), and the setting in Ezra is a small community of returnees in a Persian province with the temple and the land at stake, where boundary-keeping was a primary strategy for survival. People who live under that kind of pressure write laws like that. It doesn’t follow that the rest of us automatically inherit them as the permanent design for creation.
The canon argues with Ezra, and it argues forcefully. Ruth the Moabite, whom Deuteronomy 23:3 would have kept from the assembly for ten generations, appears in David’s line, and Matthew’s genealogy includes Tamar, Rahab, Ruth and the wife of Uriah.46 Some scholars, including Tamara Cohn Eskenazi in her commentary on Ruth, read the book as a challenge to the exclusive politics of Ezra and Nehemiah, though the date and purpose of Ruth are debated.47 Isaiah 56:3-8 speaks directly to the foreigner who has joined himself to the Lord, telling him not to say that the Lord will surely separate him from his people, and calls God’s house a house of prayer for all peoples. The New Testament finishes the argument. In Acts 10 Peter learns that God has shown him he should not call anyone profane or unclean. In Galatians 2 Paul rebukes Peter to his face for pulling back from the table with Gentiles. Ephesians 2 says the dividing wall of hostility has come down, and Colossians 3:11 says there is no Greek and Jew in Christ.48
So, then, a test of consistency is warranted. If Ezra 10 binds the modern church, the remedy is to send away the foreign wives and their children. Nobody in Smietana’s reporting proposes that. A recent panel with Webbon, Partridge and the British cleric Calvin Robinson on what to do about “the Black problem” argued, in RNS’s summary, that interracial marriage, while not banned by the Bible, is ill-advised, and that minorities should know their place.49 Look at what happened there. On the one subject where the text speaks most directly about descent and marriage, they gave up the verse and kept the rule, and relabeled it wisdom. That is the most bro move available. A conclusion that survives losing its only text had another source.
A code book that was never a code book
Webbon told RNS that his content is grounded in “the historic Protestant tradition.”50 I know what that tradition says about the Old Testament’s civil laws, because I once subscribed to it as an officer in Reformed churches. The Westminster Confession states that God gave Israel judicial laws, “which expired together with the state of that people, not obliging any other now, further than the general equity thereof may require.”51 John Calvin, according to a review of McVicar’s biography of Rushdoony, called insistence on Moses’s political system for modern states “false and foolish.”52 The historic Protestant tradition, on this point, is the opposite of what these men are selling.
The scholarship on the laws themselves is worse for them. David Wright’s Inventing God’s Law (2009) argues that the Covenant Code in Exodus depends directly on Hammurabi’s laws and reworks them.53 McClellan pushes the point further. The slavery laws were scribal exercises and elite propaganda, preserved to train palace and temple scribes, and it is doubtful they ever governed the terms of service of a single Israelite or Judahite debt slave.54
The legal code that Christian Reconstructionists want to impose on modern America turns out to be recycled Mesopotamian homework, and nobody in ancient Israel was likely bound by it.
The habit of reading the Old Testament as a code book for modern society comes from R. J. Rushdoony, whose Institutes of Biblical Law (1973) founded theonomy, the view that Mosaic civil law binds modern governments. The Southern Poverty Law Center describes him as favoring a society of classes with differing rights and opposing interracial marriage, and Library Journal reports that Michael McVicar’s history of the movement finds many of its racist and patriarchal tenets flourishing in newer movements.55 In the 1960s, according to SPLC, the theologian Gregg Singer rediscovered Dabney’s work, Rushdoony followed, and both admired his picture of a godly South victimized by godless Yankees.56
Gary North, Rushdoony’s son-in-law and one of the movement’s most prolific writers, took the method furthest. His Tools of Dominion (1990) is a vast commentary on Exodus, with special attention to its case laws.57 By the accounts I found, he wanted stoning for a list of offenses that includes blasphemy, adultery and homosexuality, and wanted whipping, restitution, indentured servitude or slavery in place of prisons for lesser crimes. That is where the code-book habit ends, with stones for adulterers and servitude for lesser offenders, justified by laws that, on McClellan’s account, scribes preserved to train other scribes.
Steven Wilkins, a pastor who helped found the League of the South, hosted Confederate heritage conferences and collaborated with Doug Wilson on a 1996 booklet defending Southern slavery, which Drink Wisely has examined elsewhere [LINK]. Wilson co-signed the 2024 Antioch Declaration against racial categories in the church, which Baptist News Global ties to a dispute with Webbon, a onetime Wilson disciple who went further right.58 Crawford Gribben’s Survival and Resistance in Evangelical America (2021) is the academic account of how this strand of theonomy took root in the Pacific Northwest.59
That is the lineage of the inclination, while the newer thing is the delivery system. Podcaster Will Spencer, who has warned about neo-Nazi ideas entering churches, describes the economics. Tap a segment of young, angry, disaffected men with disposable income, he says, and they become hyper-tribal and hyper-loyal and engage consistently, but you have to keep feeding them increasingly red meat, and it is a one-way trip.60 Sociologist George Yancey of Baylor says Trump’s election and the way he talks about race created a permission structure for people who held racist ideas but had been afraid to voice them.61 Partridge’s own arc fits the economics well. In 2015 he was a social-justice evangelical entrepreneur with a TEDx talk (literally). Now he preaches a sermon series on the curse of Ham, argues for returning America to 90 percent white, and calls for deporting 100 million immigrants.62
Selling it
Smietana’s line is that along the way these men are turning outrage into cash.63 Webbon’s company sells subscriptions at $9.99 a month for premium content and $19.99 for VIP access, a $99.99 “Christian Nationalist Starter Pack” of books with titles like White Genocide, and T-shirts, including one with a slogan about taking the Christian and holding the Judeo. It also offers subscribers an audiobook of Luther’s On the Jews and Their Lies.64 He once jumped from praising Patriot Front to a pitch for grass-fed beef, then back to praising Patriot Front. Haymes went from defending slavery to an energetic pitch for sleep powder and a discount code. I am not claiming to know whether these men are sincere bigots or merchandisers of bigotry, and neither does anyone else. The beliefs are inexcusable either way, and the sales funnel is very real.
Webbon told RNS after publication that the channel does not promote white supremacy and never has.65
The denial rests on a definition. As far as I can find, RNS never uses the word, but the label for this outlook in Reformed circles is often kinism, the idea that God ordained distinct races and peoples who should stay apart, which its defenders call a natural and biblical duty to love your own kind.66 It lets a man say he is only acknowledging created reality, that he is no white supremacist, and that interracial marriage is merely unwise, all in one breath. That describes the panel above. Partridge managed it alone in January, writing on X that “Interracial marriage is not the ‘ideal,’” that he does not think it sinful, and that he is happily married to a “Mexican/Spanish/American woman.”67 Presumably she has read the post and is okay with not being ideal.
Reformed bodies have noticed. The Reformed Presbyterian Church of North America excommunicated Samuel Ketcham, who started the Southern Presbytery with Spangler, in January 2026 for advocating kinism, and a committee of the Associate Reformed Presbyterian Church has drafted a report calling it incompatible with Scripture, which that denomination’s synod sent back for revision in June.68 Whether Webbon or anyone else here accepts the label is theirs to say. Define white supremacy as hatred, and anything short of hatred walks free. Convenient.
The exit
Hunter Baker, a senior fellow at the First Liberty Institute, told Smietana that “Jesus is not front and center with these guys,” and that some of the influencers seem to have rejected the Sermon on the Mount.69 He is right, and the observation points somewhere uncomfortable for the Reformed world that produced these men and their critics alike. A flat doctrine of inspiration cannot rank the Sermon on the Mount above Leviticus 25 when the two collide, because ranking is editing and editing is what the doctrine forbids. Nobody reads the Bible unedited, of course, and readers differ mostly in whether they admit it. Those who rank anyway, quietly, are doing what the abolitionists did, which was to overrule a text on the strength of a moral judgment the text itself does not supply or support.
That is the out, and it comes with a price. Nobody in the history I have laid out got out by winning the exegetical argument. Noll says the defenders of slavery won that one. The people who ended slavery overruled the text, and the church eventually followed them, and the church is better for it. If you cannot say the Bible is wrong about slavery, you cannot say Haymes is wrong about it either, only that he is rude.
I took the doctrine of inerrancy seriously for most of my adult life, and I know what it costs to keep it and what it costs to leave it. These men show what it costs to keep it without flinching and the price is a Bible that cannot object to anything it contains. Samuel Sey, a Black conservative Christian who once shared a panel with Webbon, told Smietana he fears where the rhetoric ends. You cannot keep saying these things, he said, without a violent consequence at some point.70 I see no reason to disagree with him.
Spangler, by his own account, found patriarchy in a sermon on Ephesians and reached race by analogy from the sexes.71 The Bible supplied the first claim. The color line in the second came from a Virginia legislature, a Confederate chaplain and a century of Jim Crow, and he now enforces it in a church that bars the kind of congregation that raised him. I looked for the verse. I couldn’t find it.
Endnotes
1. Bob Smietana, “The rise of the Jim Crow theobros,” Religion News Service (RNS), September 24, 2026 (updated October 1, 2026). The Zoom interview, charcoal suit, trimmed beard, fish tank and Spangler’s smile are from the opening of the article.
2. Smietana, RNS. Spangler is pastor of Piedmont Presbyterian Church in Winston-Salem, North Carolina. RNS describes the church as a start-up with “a handful of families” that bars Black people out of fear of “harmful race-mixing,” and it reports Spangler’s statement about the sexes and the races.
3. Smietana, RNS. Spangler grew up attending Lloyd Presbyterian Church, a historic African American congregation in the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.) where his mother was pastor.
4. Smietana, RNS. On the Nose Media LLC does business as NXR Studios and, as RNS tells it, took over the YouTube channel that Webbon’s nonprofit Right Response Ministries had run. RNS reports 187,000 subscribers. In a post-publication email, Webbon said the channel had 125,000 subscribers at the time of sale and has added more than 50,000 this year.
5. Smietana, RNS: Webbon’s 2024 video, and his interview with Thomas Rousseau, whom RNS identifies as founder of Patriot Front and describes the group as a white nationalist organization. RNS reports that Webbon told Rousseau he does not find the claim that Black people cannot be Americans racist, and quotes him saying he understands the position.
6. Smietana, RNS, standfirst and opening paragraphs.
7. Dan McClellan, The Bible Says So: What We Get Right and Wrong About Scripture’s Most Controversial Issues (New York: St. Martin’s Essentials, 2025), ch. 2. McClellan illustrates the fallacy with a TikTok creator’s answer to the question of why anyone believes in a book written by people.
8. McClellan, ch. 2, on “scripture” as an unbounded category in the first century and on the earliest references to volumes containing “the scriptures” in the early fourth century CE.
9. McClellan, ch. 2, on the case against Pauline authorship of the Pastoral Epistles from vocabulary, theology, church structure and their fit with Acts. He quotes Raymond Collins, who notes that of roughly 850 non-name words in the Pastorals, almost a third are absent from the undisputed Pauline letters. See McClellan’s notes for the full citations.
10. McClellan, ch. 2, quoting a defender of Pauline authorship who wrote that the epistles are “innocent until proved guilty.” See McClellan’s note 9 for the citation.
11. John Poirier, The Invention of the Inspired Text: Philological Windows on the Theopneustia of Scripture (London: T&T Clark, 2021), Library of New Testament Studies 640. Poirier argues that in every pre-Origen use, theopneustos means “life-giving.” I follow McClellan’s summary in ch. 2, where he calls the case convincing while noting that it is new and has not yet had extended scholarly scrutiny. See also John 6:63 and Romans 8:11.
12. 1 Timothy 2:12; 1 Timothy 6:1-3. Titus 2:9-10 also instructs enslaved people to submit to their masters.
13. Smietana, RNS: Haymes’s late-December episode of Reformation Red Pill, in which he says it is not inherently evil to own another human being and that every Christian should affirm this, followed immediately by his pitch for Beam Dream Sleep Powder with the code RRP.
14. McClellan, ch. 5: Exodus 21:32 sets a fine of thirty shekels, and Hammurabi’s law 252, more than a thousand years earlier, sets twenty.
15. McClellan, ch. 5: Leviticus 25:39-43 against Hammurabi’s law 117, which frees a debt slave in the fourth year.
16. McClellan, ch. 5, on Exodus 21:20-21 and its comparison with Hammurabi’s law 116.
17. McClellan, ch. 5, on Exodus 21:16 and 1 Timothy 1:10, citing Harpocration, Lexicon of the Ten Orators (quoting Lycurgus, Against Lycophron), and Chariton, Callirhoe.
18. McClellan, ch. 5, on slavery as a governing metaphor, including Isaiah 48:20, Romans 6:22 and 1 Corinthians 7:22-23.
19. McClellan, ch. 5. He presents this as his own opinion.
20. McClellan, ch. 5, final paragraph.
21. Galatians 3:26-29; Philemon 10-16. Scholars debate whether Paul is asking Philemon to release Onesimus.
22. Richard Reifsnyder, “Charles Hodge: A Conservative Theologian Finds His Way to Emancipation,” Presbyterian Historical Society blog, April 17, 2018, discussing Hodge’s 1836 article “Slavery” in the Biblical Repertory and Princeton Review. I have not read Hodge’s article directly.
23. Mark A. Noll, The Civil War as a Theological Crisis (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2006), as quoted in Lewis Perry, “Scripture and Slaughter: The Civil War as a Theological and Moral Crisis,” Modern Intellectual History 6, no. 1 (2009): 207-221. Perry quotes Noll’s judgment that the defenders of slavery won the argument over Scripture “at least when the argument was narrowly defined,” and his point that the Bible does not condemn slavery per se. I have not read Noll’s book directly.
24. Robert Tracy McKenzie, “Both Read the Same Bible,” review of Noll, The Civil War as a Theological Crisis, Books & Culture (Christianity Today), March 2008. McKenzie credits a culture that favored common-sense readings and a pervasive racism, North and South, that led white readers to assume the slavery of the Bible meant Black slavery.
25. Smietana, RNS, which reports that Partridge and King’s Way Reformed Church in Prescott, Arizona were featured in the New York Times for biblical patriarchy and household voting. See Vivian Yee, “The Women Who Believe That Women Should Lose the Right to Vote,” New York Times, April 2, 2026, which I have not read directly.
26. Smietana, RNS: Partridge’s 2015 TEDx talk “How to Value People over Profits,” his view that yoga pants are sinful, and his current claim that women should not be allowed to vote.
27. McClellan, ch. 5, opening, including his note 3 on the medieval European origins of skin-color race.
28. Genesis 9:18-27.
29. David M. Goldenberg, The Curse of Ham: Race and Slavery in Early Judaism, Christianity, and Islam (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2003), and Black and Slave: The Origins and History of the Curse of Ham (Berlin: De Gruyter, 2017). The two-stories argument is from the publisher’s description of Black and Slave, and the dating from Molly Levine’s review of The Curse of Ham, Bryn Mawr Classical Review 2004.02.53.
30. Alejandro de la Fuente and Ariela Gross, “How Christians of color in Colonial Virginia became ‘black,’” Religion News Service, December 12, 2019, adapted from their Becoming Free, Becoming Black: Race, Freedom, and Law in Cuba, Virginia, and Louisiana (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2020).
31. De la Fuente and Gross. The article also discusses baptized Africans who sued for freedom, including Elizabeth Key in 1654.
32. Katharine Gerbner, Christian Slavery: Conversion and Race in the Protestant Atlantic World (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 2018), as described in the Gospel Coalition’s review. I have not read the book directly.
33. Mark Potok, “Doug Wilson’s Religious Empire Expanding in the Northwest,” Intelligence Report 113 (Southern Poverty Law Center, Spring 2004). The phrase “morally inferior race” is SPLC’s description of Dabney’s view, and SPLC is an advocacy organization. Dabney’s own writings should be checked, for example his A Defence of Virginia (1867).
34. Smietana, RNS. Holder is director of the Center for the Study of Religion and Public Life at Saint Anselm College.
35. Smietana, RNS: Spangler was expelled from the Orthodox Presbyterian Church in 2024, and Ketcham was defrocked by the Reformed Presbyterian Church earlier this year. The sentence “That name is telling” is Smietana’s. Holder’s comment on Southern Presbyterians of the Civil War era is in the same article.
36. Virginia Center for Digital History, University of Virginia, “Post Reconstruction through 1920” (timeline of Jim Crow, including Tennessee’s 1881 railway law and Plessy v. Ferguson); Encyclopaedia Britannica, “Jim Crow law.”
37. C. Vann Woodward, The Strange Career of Jim Crow (1955), as summarized, with later work by Joel Williamson and Edward Ayers, in the Virginia Center for Digital History essay cited above.
38. Encyclopaedia Britannica, “Jim Crow law”: Thomas Dartmouth Rice began performing “Jump Jim Crow” in 1828.
39. Smietana, RNS: Jemar Tisby, author of The Color of Compromise, on the Redemption era.
40. Genesis 11:1-9; Deuteronomy 32:8-9; Acts 17:26; Revelation 7:9.
41. McClellan, ch. 5, on Leviticus 25:44-46, which he describes as heartily endorsing chattel slavery.
42. Ezra 9:1-2 and 10:1-44; Nehemiah 13:1-3 and 13:23-27.
43. McClellan, ch. 5, opening.
44. Acts 17:26-27; Revelation 7:9.
45. Deuteronomy 7:1-4; Ezra 9:1-2. Deuteronomy 7:1 lists seven nations. Ezra 9:1 names the Canaanites, Hittites, Perizzites, Jebusites and Amorites and adds Ammonites, Moabites and Egyptians.
46. Deuteronomy 23:3; Ruth 4:17-22; Matthew 1:3-6.
47. Tamara Cohn Eskenazi and Tikva Frymer-Kensky, Ruth, JPS Bible Commentary (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 2011), as described in Timothy J. Stone’s review in the Journal of Hebrew Scriptures 12 (2012). Eskenazi reads Ruth as a counterpoint to Ezra-Nehemiah and favors a postexilic date without settling the question.
48. Isaiah 56:3-8; Acts 10:28; Galatians 2:11-14; Ephesians 2:14-16; Colossians 3:11.
49. Smietana, RNS: the YouTube discussion among Partridge, Webbon and Calvin Robinson about “the Black problem.” The summary of their argument, including “ill-advised,” is RNS’s.
50. Smietana, RNS: Webbon’s post-publication email, in which he says the channel’s content is grounded in the Scriptures and “the historic Protestant tradition.”
51. Westminster Confession of Faith 19.4. Wording and punctuation vary slightly among editions.
52. Mark J. Larson, review of Michael J. McVicar, Christian Reconstruction: R. J. Rushdoony and American Religious Conservatism (Chapel Hill: University of North Carolina Press, 2015), Themelios 41, no. 2, reporting Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion 4.20.14. I have not checked the passage in a translation of the Institutes.
53. David P. Wright, Inventing God’s Law: How the Covenant Code of the Bible Used and Revised the Laws of Hammurabi (New York: Oxford University Press, 2009).
54. McClellan, ch. 5, which refers forward to his ch. 8.
55. Potok, SPLC, Intelligence Report 113 (on Rushdoony’s views and his Institutes of Biblical Law, 1973); Carolyn Craft, review of McVicar, Christian Reconstruction, Library Journal, March 15, 2015.
56. Potok, SPLC, on Singer, Rushdoony and Dabney.
57. Gary North, Tools of Dominion: The Case Laws of Exodus (Tyler, TX: Institute for Christian Economics, 1990). North’s positions on stoning and on servitude in place of prison are reported secondhand in Rob Boston, Americans United for Separation of Church and State, March 22, 2022, and in Frederick Clarkson, “Christian Reconstruction: Theocratic Dominionism Gains Influence,” in Eyes Right! Challenging the Right Wing Backlash (Boston: South End Press, 1995), 62, and his March 1994 report for Political Research Associates, the latter two as cited in the Wikipedia entry on North.
58. Potok, SPLC (Wilkins as a founding director of the League of the South and host of Confederate heritage conferences); “Plagiarizing Slavery,” History News Network, May 2, 2005 (the 1996 booklet Southern Slavery, As It Was, pulled in 2003 over unattributed passages from Time on the Cross); Mark Wingfield, “Antioch Declaration exposes a rift among neo-Calvinists,” Baptist News Global, November 26, 2024.
59. Crawford Gribben, Survival and Resistance in Evangelical America: Christian Reconstruction in the Pacific Northwest (New York: Oxford University Press, 2021).
60. Smietana, RNS: podcaster Will Spencer.
61. Smietana, RNS: George Yancey, professor of sociology at Baylor University.
62. Smietana, RNS: Partridge’s sermon series on the curse of Ham, his call for America to be 90 percent white again, and his call to deport 100 million immigrants.
63. Smietana, RNS.
64. Smietana, RNS: NXR’s subscription tiers, the “Christian Nationalist Starter Pack,” the T-shirts, the Luther audiobook, and Webbon’s pitch for Wild Pastures beef.
65. Smietana, RNS, in an editor’s note: Webbon’s post-publication statement.
66. “ARP Report Condemns Kinism,” Heidelblog, May 18, 2026, quoting the Kinist Institute’s own definition; Jeffrey Stivason, “A Word to Kinists,” Reformation21, May 16, 2026.
67. Partridge’s post on X, January 10, 2026, as quoted in Dale Chamberlain, “Pastor Sparks Backlash for Saying Interracial Marriages, Including His Own, Are Not ‘Ideal,’” ChurchLeaders, January 12, 2026, https://churchleaders.com/news/2211880-pastor-dale-partridge-interracial-marriage.html. Premier Christian News reported the same remarks the same day. I have not viewed the post itself, and the wording is as ChurchLeaders quotes it.
68. “RPCNA Denomination Excludes Pastor for Racist Statements,” The Aquila Report, January 28, 2026 (Ketcham); “When the ARP Debates: A Report on the Proceedings of the 222nd ARP Synod,” Heidelblog, June 2026, on the synod returning the committee’s report for revision; Smietana, RNS, on the Southern Presbytery.
69. Smietana, RNS: Hunter Baker, senior fellow at the First Liberty Institute.
70. Smietana, RNS: Samuel Sey, a conservative Black Christian blogger who appeared on a panel with Webbon at a 2022 church conference.
71. Smietana, RNS, on Spangler’s conversion experience while reading a sermon on Ephesians and his statement linking the sexes and the races.




This was an enlightening read. We humans are so good at self-justification. Adds another twist to the separating of the sheep and the goats, i.e. "When you did it to the least of these, you did it to me," and explains wholesale discounting the Sermon on the Mount without batting an eye.
All of the law is fulfilled when we treat others only as we want to be treated. So if you have no problem with the idea that you and your family could be made slaves, then I guess that it's okay to have slaves (but only if you only treat them in ways that you would want to be treated). But if you think that it would be wrong for you to be made into a slave, then for you to own a slave, or even support others owning slaves, would be lawlessness, violating the law, on your part. Same thing for if you're okay with having your rights taken away simply because of the color of your skin. And Jesus will tell those who practice lawlessness that He never knew them, as they are excluded from His kingdom. In the end it all comes down to "Is this how I would want to be treated?" God's blessings on you today, Shawn!