Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Georgina Kovacs's avatar

I would like to offer a few thoughts—not to settle these questions, but to invite further reflection.

It is worth asking whether religious teaching loses its way when the desire to convey “ultimate truth” overshadows the task of helping people deepen their own inner experience. The issue is not the theoretical framework itself, but whether it brings us closer to what it describes—or becomes a substitute for it.

This connects with the distinction drawn by Ken Wilber (an American philosopher and the originator of integral theory) between spiritual experience and its interpretation. In Wilber’s model, people at different stages of psychological and spiritual development can have profound spiritual experiences, but their developmental stage and worldview shape how they interpret those experiences. What matters, then, is not only what we experience, but also the framework through which we make sense of it.

For me, this raises a question: when someone presents their own religious interpretation as the ultimate and exclusive truth, do they distinguish between the experience itself and the meaning they assign to it? This is not to suggest that all interpretations are equally valid, or that personal experience is infallible. Rather, it is a reminder that religious teaching can foster inner understanding, but cannot replace personal experience.

There is also a related linguistic question: how do we refer to God? In some languages, personal pronouns do not distinguish between male and female; Hungarian is one such language.

In Hungarian, we do not have to identify God as male or female, even when using a personal pronoun: we simply say “ő”—a pronoun that makes no gender distinction.

John Bing's avatar

One of your best essays, applies to more than the Bible.

7 more comments...

Ready for more?