Drink Wisely — Pouring Over Theology and Truth

Drink Wisely — Pouring Over Theology and Truth

What Cheap Grace Actually Costs

On the theology that protects abusers and why it keeps working

Shawn Patrick Connelly's avatar
Shawn Patrick Connelly
May 20, 2026
∙ Paid

THE SEDUCTIVE DIAGNOSIS

Legalism is real. Before we talk about what happens when the idea of grace swings too far in the other direction, that needs to be established, because the people who built platforms and ministries on radical grace were responding to something that is actually happening in American evangelical and fundamentalist churches.

I spent over fourteen years as a ruling elder in the Evangelical Presbyterian Church. The EPC is a broadly evangelical and broadly ecumenical Reformed body, and our particular congregation sat decidedly on its theologically conservative end, though not uniformly so, and not in ways that produced the kind of suffocating moral policing you often find elsewhere in the evangelical Protestant world. But you don’t always have to experience the worst versions of a thing to recognize it. I knew many people from nondenominational churches, charismatic churches, Pentecostal congregations, Baptist churches that had swallowed a particularly rigid and narrow reading of Scripture whole. In those contexts, legalism wasn’t an intellectual problem or a doctrinal position. It was the water people were swimming in.

Legalism, in the sense I’m using the term, is the belief that right standing with God depends on behavioral performance, that grace must be earned or maintained through correct compliance with an expanding set of requirements.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Shawn Patrick Connelly.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Shawn Patrick Connelly · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.