Pete Hegseth wants Americans to watch a man die. The Pentagon has confirmed that the firing squad execution of Nidal Hasan, set for December 3 at Fort Hood, will be livestreamed.1 According to Al Jazeera, no state or federal execution in the United States has ever been televised, and this would be the military’s first execution of any kind since 1961.2 Hegseth told Jack Posobiec on a Real America’s Voice program that people need to understand there are serious consequences for this sort of thing. Robert Jeffress, the Dallas megachurch pastor, has said he supports a public execution and plans to watch, according to Christian Post, and the president reposted the article saying so.3
Hasan murdered thirteen people and wounded thirty-two at Fort Hood in 2009, and a court-martial sentenced him to death. Nothing below disputes any of that, and I am not opposed to his execution for what he did. I am opposed to the spectacle of it, and to a country that calls itself better than its enemies while borrowing their methods. Jesus was innocent and Hasan is guilty, and I’m not building a comparison between the two men at all. That is missing the entire point. The comparison is to the crowd, and specifically to the Christians who are eager to join it.
Trump has two thoughts
By Friday the president’s relationship to the plan had gotten complicated. States Newsroom reports that Trump first told reporters he would make a determination about the livestream, and then, asked whether he had approved it, answered “Did I approve? Absolutely.”4 By Saturday he had settled on “two thoughts,” show it or don’t, and the case for showing it was that other people might think twice before doing what Hasan did. He said he would make a decision. Reuters reports that a senior White House official, speaking anonymously, said he does not oppose a livestream but could change his mind.5
That leaves a rather peculiar arrangement. The man who approved the sentence is undecided about the broadcast, the vice president says he won’t be watching, and the Defense Secretary is out selling tickets and making popcorn.6 Meanwhile, on the same Saturday Trump said he was still deciding, he reposted a pastor’s endorsement of it. As of Sunday the president hasn’t decided, and he wants you to know a pastor is in favor.
Some Republicans have objected to this as well, including several who support the sentence itself. Whether the broadcast goes forward is a question for the White House, and the answer may change again by Tuesday if we know anything about this Administration. The appetite is already on the record, however, and the appetite is what I’m writing about here.
The lion everyone ordered
Revelation 5 contains a scene that Christians who love the book tend to skim over. John is weeping because nobody can open the scroll. An elder tells him to stop, because the Lion of the tribe of Judah has conquered and can open it. John turns to look and sees a Lamb standing there as though it had been slaughtered. The elder announced a lion and the text delivers a lamb instead. The chorus then spends the rest of the chapter singing about the Lamb, and nobody stops the proceedings to say they were promised a lion.7
That scene compresses the Christian claim about power into one image, and it was a very hard sell from the start. Some first-century Jews hoped for a messiah who would break the occupation, and a king executed by the occupier looks an awful lot like a failed audition. Preachers like to say the Palm Sunday crowd waving branches became the Good Friday crowd howling for blood, because the arc is satisfying. The Gospels never say that, exactly. Mark puts a crowd at Pilate’s headquarters and says the chief priests stirred it up (15:11).8 That is a different scene with different people, and making it into “the Jews turned on Jesus” has fueled centuries of violence against Jewish communities rather than the real instigators.
The instigators were religious leaders, chiefly the chief priests in Mark and the chief priests together with the Pharisees in John’s account of the plot (11:47), and the reason had nothing to do with their being Jewish. They were certain what the messiah would look like, and the man in front of them did not fit. That certainty is the parallel to the religious establishment and evangelical leaders of our own day, who claim authority and claim to represent real Christianity, yet far too often call for blood and temporal vengeance upon their enemies.
What the texts do preserve is a set of people deeply invested in the existing arrangement of power. In John, the chief priests worry that Jesus’s following will provoke a Roman crackdown (11:48), and by the end they are telling Pilate they have no king but Caesar (19:15).9 Whatever one makes of the historical value of that exchange, the story it tells is clear. The people who wanted a king to beat Rome hand the Lamb to Rome and pledge their loyalty to the emperor on the way out. The Gospel writers have their own reasons for how they tell it, and I’m not claiming a transcript, but the pattern seems to hold.
Whose side the crowd is on
Crucifixion was public on purpose. Rome did not do it in back rooms, because the audience was the point. A Roman declamation traditionally attributed to Quintilian says that when the guilty are crucified, the busiest roads are chosen so that the most people can see it and be frightened, and it adds that punishment is aimed less at the offense than at the example.10 Trump said on Friday that the military wanted this execution to serve as an example too.11 Hegseth’s line to Posobiec makes the same argument, and so does Trump’s Saturday suggestion that showing it might keep others from copying Hasan. Nobody at the Pentagon is quoting Roman rhetoric, but the case for a public killing has been on offer for better than two thousand years, and Jesus was on the receiving end of it.
In the passion narratives, everyone who helps stage the public execution is working for Rome. Pilate has the soldiers, the cross, and the sign over the head. The chief priests supply the pressure and the crowd supplies the fervor. The seat open to a Christian who welcomes or cheers a livestreamed firing squad is sitting squarely in Pilate’s courtyard.
The aesthetic will be familiar to anyone who has watched which leaders this president admires. He told a rally in 2018 that he and Kim Jong Un “fell in love.”12 According to a recording CNN obtained, he told donors that same year, after Xi Jinping abolished term limits, “Maybe we’ll give that a shot some day.”13 In 2022 he called Putin’s move on Ukraine “genius.”14 Those are dated quotes, which are harder to dismiss than a diagnosis, and they repeatedly show a man who finds power performed for an audience impressive. He has also said that Article II gives him “the right to do whatever I want as president” (2019)15 and posted that “He who saves his Country does not violate any Law” (2025).16 Power, and being seen as strong and in charge, seems to be what excites him most. A livestreamed firing squad hands him both.
We are supposed to be better than this
Some of the sharpest objections come from the very people who want Hasan dead. Representative Austin Scott of Georgia, who says he absolutely supports the sentence, said that “live-streaming executions is what jihadists do.” Senator Thom Tillis compared it to the public executions of oppressive dictatorships like Iran and Afghanistan. Senator John Curtis of Utah wrote that a civilization erodes when it cultivates “an appetite for executions as a form of entertainment.” Jeff Leach, a Republican state legislator in Texas who backs a firing squad for Hasan, said it in three words, “Bloodlust isn’t Biblical.” Democrats have objected too. Senator Jack Reed warned that the footage would be a gift to anti-American recruiters, and Joe Kent, a former Trump counterterrorism official, made a similar argument about propaganda.17
These are not squeamish people. They want the sentence carried out, and they still see that the broadcast is the part that makes us look like the people who do this kind of thing. If this country really is better than its enemies, the proof is carrying out the harshest lawful punishment without staging a show. Public executions are how regimes remind everyone who holds the power, and we should not adopt the habit.
There is a commercial edge to this as well. Hegseth announced the plan on a Real America’s Voice program, and as of Friday the Pentagon had not said who would run the stream or on what platform, according to CNN. I have not seen reporting that anyone plans to sell ads or subscriptions around it. We do have precedent for who shows up when the state offers an execution as content. In 2001 a company that runs adults-only subscription websites asked a federal court for permission to webcast Timothy McVeigh’s execution, and Judge John Tinder in Terre Haute said no. The government sent a closed-circuit feed to survivors and victims’ families instead. That case involved a federal prison, not an Army post, so it does not settle this one, but it shows the pitch has been made before. If this stream goes ahead, expect clips, commentary, and somebody finding a way to make money from both.18
Romans 13 and the sword
The strongest Christian case for the execution is Romans 13, where Paul says the governing authority does not carry the sword for nothing.19 Paul gives the state authority to punish wrongdoers, Hasan is a wrongdoer by any standard, and a Christian is able to support capital punishment without being a complete ghoul. Plenty of serious Christians do, and they are not the ones making the loudest case this week. Jeffress has leaned on this passage before. In a 2019 Fox & Friends appearance he argued that Jesus was an innocent man executed by the state, that the New Testament never calls for ending the death penalty, and that Paul says in Romans 13 that God gave government the power of the sword.20 Franklin Graham made a related argument this week, calling it ironic that people who embrace what he describes as Hollywood’s culture of death are suddenly outraged over this execution.21
The problem, though, is what the passage really covers. Paul authorizes a magistrate with a sword. He says nothing about a congregation with popcorn. Romans 13 describes what the state may do, gives the church no mandate or even offer to enjoy it, and gives nobody a mandate to turn the killing into programming or propaganda. Paul also wrote it under the same empire that crucified Jesus and, according to tradition, later executed Paul himself, so he had seen the spectacle version and still described the job in terms of the magistrate’s duty. His circumstances were also very different from ours.
I used to favor capital punishment in most cases, and I no longer know for certain where I land on it, since many things I once favored I’ve since backed off of. I do see a huge difference between the magistrate’s sword used where it is truly warranted and the enthusiastic support of execution as judgment against any and all who oppose the empire. Hasan’s crime was murder, not dissent, and I am not putting him in that second category. The precedent is what concerns me, because that second thing is so often where Trump seems to be heading, and his followers are willfully and excitedly following.
The man who was shot seven times
Alonzo Lunsford was shot seven times by Hasan in 2009, and he has no sympathy for him. He backs the firing squad, says his Christian faith helped him forgive Hasan, and plans to be in the room. Asked about the livestream on BBC Radio 4, he said he doesn’t agree with putting the whole thing out uncensored for the general public, and he wondered what message that sends young people, while also saying survivors and families should be able to watch.22 Nobody with a pastor’s microphone or a Truth Social account has more standing on this question, and he draws the line where I think I would. The sentence is rightly justice for the victims, the witnesses belong in the room, and the broadcast is a show.
Wanting Hasan executed has a long pedigree and real moral weight, especially for the families who lost people. Wanting an audience for it is a different appetite altogether, and the country has seen it before. The last public execution in the United States was the hanging of Rainey Bethea in Owensboro, Kentucky, in 1936. An estimated 20,000 people came, vendors sold snacks and soft drinks, and reporters called it a picnic hanging. Bethea was a Black man in his twenties, the case against him was thin by the account of author Sonya Lea, and an all-white jury deliberated for about four and a half minutes. The carnival-like atmosphere embarrassed Kentucky lawmakers enough that they rewrote the state’s execution law in 1938.23
We already ran this experiment and did not like what we saw in the crowd. Lynchings drew crowds the same way, and photographers sold souvenir postcards of them, a comparison Krisanne Vaillancourt Murphy of Catholic Mobilizing Network made herself this week.24 The president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, Archbishop Paul Coakley, has condemned the livestream plan as well, I might add, calling it “a barbaric promotion of a culture of death,” which is Franklin Graham’s phrase turned back on the broadcast.25 Bishop Sean Rowe of the Episcopal Church has called a live broadcast of a firing squad reprehensible.24
One o’clock Central
If the broadcast goes ahead, Christians have an easy option that takes no courage at all. They can leave it turned off. If the president decides against it, they can skip the part where they wish he hadn’t. Lunsford plans to be there because he legitimately earned the seat, and the rest of us can spend one o’clock Central on December 3 doing literally anything else.
Hasan’s guilt is not in question, and neither is the sentence. What worries me is the appetite for public vengeance and spectacle, and for making sure everyone sees what happens to those the empire deems the enemy. Hasan really is the enemy for what he did. What happens when someone else gets made the enemy for disagreeing with the Administration or speaking out against its leader? A crowd that has learned to cheer on cue does not check the veracity of the charges first. Trump told a Tennessee rally on Saturday, “I could say the stupidest things and you’d clap.” He added that he doesn’t, but the observation about the crowd was his own.26
The Lamb already headlined one public execution. Christians of all people should know how the audience looks in that story.
Notes
1. Al Jazeera, Oct. 8, 2026, report on the announcement; Dallas Express (date, time, and the Posobiec appearance).
2. Al Jazeera, Oct. 9, 2026, report on lawmakers’ reaction; Fox News (first military execution since 1961); CNN via KION.
3. Christian Post, roundup of Christian leaders’ reactions; Newsweek (the repost). The Dallas Morning News original was blocked and not read.
4. States Newsroom, report on Trump’s comments; UPI, Oct. 10, 2026. States Newsroom says the “absolutely” answer came when he was asked about the livestream; Al Jazeera describes it as approval of the execution.
5. Reuters wrap-up via Devdiscourse.
6. Vice President Vance’s comment and the reactions from both parties: Philadelphia Inquirer; CNN via KION.
7. Revelation 5:1–6, NRSVue. Bible Gateway.
8. Mark 15:6–15, NRSVue. Bible Gateway.
9. John 11:47–48 and 19:15. The essay paraphrases these verses, and the wording has not yet been checked against the NRSVue text. Verify the verse numbers before publishing.
10. Pseudo-Quintilian, Declamationes Maiores 274. Not verified against the Latin or an English translation. For the broader point that crucifixion was a public deterrent, see Martin Hengel, Crucifixion in the Ancient World and the Folly of the Message of the Cross.
11. Trump’s Friday remarks as reported by Fox News and UPI.
12. Associated Press via the Washington Times, report on the 2018 rally (West Virginia rally, September 2018).
13. Mediaite, report on the Xi remark (March 3, 2018, from audio CNN obtained).
14. NPR via WAMC, report on the Putin remarks (Feb. 22, 2022).
15. Raw Story, July 23, 2019.
16. Mediaite, report on the post (February 2025).
17. Al Jazeera, Oct. 9, 2026 (see note 2); Philadelphia Inquirer; roundup of Christian leaders’ reactions (Leach).
18. CNN via KION (see note 2); Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, report on the ruling (Judge Tinder, April 18, 2001). I found no reporting of ads, subscriptions, or paid access tied to the Hasan stream, and the essay says so.
19. Romans 13:4. The essay paraphrases this verse, and the wording has not yet been checked against the NRSVue text. Verify before publishing.
20. Mediaite, report on the interview (2019).
21. Christian Post (see note 3).
22. Daily Beast, report on Lunsford; The Mary Sue (BBC Radio 4 interview, Oct. 9). The BBC page was blocked. The forgiveness detail is the Mary Sue’s paraphrase, so confirm it and the “shot seven times” figure against the interview.
23. WPLN, report on the interview with Lea (interview with author Sonya Lea); Wikipedia, Rainey Bethea (1938 law).
24. Christian Post (see note 3), for Krisanne Vaillancourt Murphy of Catholic Mobilizing Network and Bishop Sean Rowe. The claim that lynching photographers sold souvenir postcards rests on search results only. For the history, see Amy Louise Wood, Lynching and Spectacle (UNC Press, 2009).
25. USCCB, statement (Oct. 9, 2026).
26. Mediaite, report on the remark (Tennessee rally, Oct. 10, 2026).




I no longer recognize this country. Indeed, I cannot understand how people who claim to be Christians can gladly want a ringside seat to watch the death of another human, albeit a murderer. It is pandering to our worst qualities and has nothing to do with Jesus.
Yup. And;
I'm just not quite 'there' anymore with execution. Indeed, had I been on scene during his mad rampage (and where'd THAT come from?) and had a weapon, there'd been little hesitation on my part to endeavor to stop him with deadly force. And yes, I'm capable, technically.
I'd heard, though, that Hasan is now in a wheelchair, and I'm reminded of the setting when His Majesty's Government executed one of the IRA leaders of the Easter Rising, and because of his severe wounds had to lash him to a chair in front of the post before they shot him. It all feels off to me.
Thanks for your thoughts and insight here.
Tim Long, Just Up the Hill from Lock 15