A month before the 2016 election, a self-described prophet named Lance Wallnau told his audience he had seen a “Cyrus anointing” on Donald Trump.1 He was careful about what he meant by that. He was not saying Trump was a good man, or a godly one. He was saying God had chosen him anyway; the way God once used a pagan Persian king to do a job for Israel. That distinction, slight as it sounds on the surface, is the entire issue. This essay is about Donald Trump only tangentially, then. Its real subject is the church that heard he’s not a good man, but God chose him and that settles the matter.
The Cyrus turn
For most of Christian history, people argued about whether a ruler was honest, temperate, and just; the sort of person you would want your children to grow up to emulate. They often got the answer wrong, and routinely excused their own side’s sins while magnifying their opponents’. But character still set the terms of the fight. You praised a leader by praising his virtues and attacked him by exposing his vices. That was then.
Wallnau’s Cyrus talk changed the question altogether. The test he proposed was usefulness to God’s purpose, and by that test a leader’s private character became a peripheral issue. The appeal of this approach is very real. Scripture is full of God working through people who behaved badly, from Jacob the deceiver, to David, who had a man killed to cover an affair, to Cyrus himself, a Marduk-worshipping Persian who had never heard of Israel’s God when Isaiah called him the Lord’s anointed; the only foreign king in the Hebrew Bible given that distinction.2
Nobody who reads the Bible honestly can pretend God only ever uses saints.
So on the face of it, the Cyrus talk said nothing particularly new. The troubling innovation comes in when the sentence is directed at a sitting politician.
The trapdoor
The broad “God can use flawed people” statement is true, which is exactly where the problem happens. Applied to a living politician who has been declared anointed, that sentence does more than just excuse his flaws and infidelities. It fuses God’s very purpose to his political career. A man who has been made God’s chosen instrument cannot be held to account in the same way an ordinary officeholder would be, because criticizing the anointed instrument starts to feel like resisting God rather than the man.
Once you have anointed a politician in your imagination, honesty about him basically turns into disloyalty to God. His lies become God’s inscrutable methods, his cruelty a wrecking ball God himself is swinging at your enemies, his appetites the rough edges of a chosen vessel.1 Each new embarrassment costs more to admit than the last and builds until the believer who still notices the lies becomes the one who is the problem.
Accountability has quietly become apostasy.
I grew up around this kind of talk. As an early teen, I left a Catholic parish for a non-denominational charismatic-adjacent church, mostly for the youth group, and I learned the vocabulary of the laying on of hands, the anointing oil, the prophetic word spoken over a person’s life. So I am not writing here as a complete outsider who finds all of this exotic. The mechanism of anointing can be meaningful and real in a small room with a hurting person at the center of it. What happened after 2016 took that same mechanism and pointed it at an entire presidency.
The ballot and the altar
Many of the critiques of Trump-supporting Christians I’ve read go wrong at the same spot, and it is the spot where they lose the exact people they most hope to reach. They treat the vote itself as the scandal, as though no honest believer could ever mark a ballot for a man like that. That argument proves too much, in my opinion. A two-party ballot is a blunt instrument by nature. You get two names and a bundle of consequences attached to each one, and choosing the lesser risk to the things you love is a defensible act that a thoughtful person can make with a clear conscience. This happens every election cycle.
A Christian can vote for a man he would never leave alone with the church’s bank account or secretary, then, and still be thinking clearly. The trouble begins somewhere beyond the ballot box. It begins at the altar, when a held-nose vote turns into an anointing, when relief that your side won hardens into the certainty that God Himself has won, when a candidate stops being a flawed instrument you must tolerate and becomes a sacred figure you fervently defend.
This is the key line. You can hand a man your vote without handing him your witness. The first thing is politics. The second thing is idolatry.
What the useful man revealed
It would be convenient to treat all of this as somebody else’s disease; a pathology of the charismatic fringe or the hardcore MAGA faithful. But that lets the rest of us off too cheaply. Trump revealed what was already in the room. He showed how much power a great many American Christians had already come to prize, and how little persuasion it took to get them to say so.
The people who believed the Cyrus story were not all stupid, and calling them brainwashed explains nothing substantive. They were afraid, and their fear had real content. They watched a culture that once treated their faith as the default stop treating it as such, felt mocked in places that used to defer to them, and saw their children absorb a world that filed their deepest beliefs under bigotry. Into that real fear, the Cyrus story arrived as good news indeed. It offered a champion in place of the slow, mostly invisible work of becoming more like Christ, complete with a strongman God had supposedly raised up and anointed to fight on their behalf, and it promised that their fading standing in the culture and world could be restored by the right man winning.
A frightened people will forgive a champion almost anything. This is, in a nutshell, the entire phenomenon of the perceived Christian culture war.
That reflex owes its existence to no single movement. It is a human one at its foundation, with a long pedigree, and anyone who wants an outcome badly enough is susceptible to a version of it. A progressive who looks the other way regarding a favored politician’s corruption because he delivers the right policies is running the exact same game with a different set of players. The American Christians who ran it in 2016 become easier to understand than to mock, once you notice that the same temptation is standing at everyone’s door.
I have been guilty of making this very mistake numerous times over the last decade or so.
The apostles and their mountains
The prophets in this story have a name for themselves. Lance Wallnau, Dutch Sheets, Cindy Jacobs, Paula White, and the rest belong to a loose but potent network called the New Apostolic Reformation, a term coined in the 1990s by a Fuller Seminary church-growth professor named C. Peter Wagner.3 Wagner taught that the church had entered a second apostolic age, one in which God was restoring two offices most Protestants had left behind in the first century, the apostle who governs networks of churches with real authority and the prophet who claims to hear from God directly. He called it the most radical change in how Christians do church since the Reformation, and he meant it as praise.
The borrowed word flatters the movement. Whatever the New Apostolic Reformation is, it has little to do with the Protestant Reformation or its theology. Luther fought to pull authority back toward Scripture and to break a hierarchy that claimed to speak for God, and the apostles and prophets Wagner has in mind claim precisely that God-speaking authority and call it a recovered gift. Wagner reached for the word only to signal the scale of the rupture, a break as large as the sixteenth century’s and aimed the other way.
The program attached to that authority is the Seven Mountain Mandate, the idea that Christians are called to take the commanding heights of seven spheres of society, among them government, media, education, business, and the family, and rule from the top. It began in 1975 as a modest evangelistic vision shared among Loren Cunningham, Bill Bright, and Francis Schaeffer, a plan for shaping the culture.4 In Wallnau’s hands, decades later, it hardened into something closer to conquest, a charge to occupy every institution, with the most extreme versions teaching that Christ will not return until the church has taken control of all seven mountains. Put that belief next to an election and the math changes considerably.
If God’s kingdom advances when Christians seize worldly power, then the right president becomes a mountain to climb, and his character is only the changing of the weather on the way up. And you cannot control the weather.
This is the movement that turned up in Washington on January 6, 2021. The scholar Matthew Taylor, who has traced these networks closely, counted more than fifty charismatic leaders with NAR ties in the capital that day.5 For weeks they had run Jericho Marches, circling government buildings the way Joshua’s army circled Jericho, praying for the walls of a stolen election to fall. Dutch Sheets had revived an obscure Revolutionary-era banner, the Appeal to Heaven flag, and by January 6 it flew by the dozens in the crowd, carried beside the people tearing down barricades and breaking windows. As the building was breached, a cluster of apostles and prophets stood outside it while Sheets prayed over the scene by phone. The spiritual-warfare story they had told for months made a riot; an insurrection, feel like obedience instead.
The prayer warriors were not alone in those streets that day. A few weeks earlier, on the night of the December Jericho March, members of the Proud Boys, a far-right group long described as a hate group, tore Black Lives Matter banners from two historic Black churches in Washington and set one on fire and four people were stabbed before the night ended.6 The prayer march and the hate group shared a cause, a calendar, a flag, and a belief that the country was being stolen from its rightful owners. And the movement did not remain in the streets. Paula White, the pastor who first brought this world of apostles and prophets into Trump’s orbit, now runs the White House Faith Office on a federal appointment and salary.7
The useful man had carried his prophets all the way inside the Oval Office.
Where it goes
Give this logic a few years and watch where it goes. By the time Trump returned to office, one in four American voters, and three in five white evangelical Protestants, told pollsters they believed God had ordained him, specifically, to win.8 That is a remarkable sentence to write about a modern democracy. The useful man had become, for literally millions of people, a divinely appointed one. That’s a game changer.
The theology built outward from that point. In 2017, a group of self-described apostles and prophets organized POTUS Shield, a prayer network devoted to surrounding the president with spiritual protection and advancing a program that included ending abortion, ending same-sex marriage, and removing federal judges who ruled the wrong way.9 By 2024, a secretive club of wealthy Christian donors called Ziklag was moving millions to mobilize voters for the cause, including a reported seven hundred thousand dollars for a swing-state revival tour led by Wallnau himself.10
The man who had seen a Cyrus anointing in 2016 had become an adviser to a dominion-minded political operation.
The endpoint of anointing is apotheosis. At a White House Easter event in the spring of 2026, Trump’s faith adviser Paula White stood by the president, compared his legal ordeals directly to the passion of Christ, told him he had been betrayed and falsely accused in a pattern already familiar from the Gospels, and assured him that “because of his resurrection, you rose up.”11 That same Easter weekend Trump posted an AI image of himself in a white robe and red sash, laying a healing hand on a sick man, then deleted it after the backlash and told reporters he had thought it showed him as a doctor.12
The useful man had traveled the entire distance, from a pagan king God could use, to a chosen instrument, to a figure rendered in the language, and now the very image, of the risen Christ.
By 2024, the useful man had a new biblical role. The Cyrus of 2016, the pagan deliverer, gave way to Jehu, the king in 2 Kings who has Queen Jezebel thrown from a palace window, her body trampled under horses and left for the dogs.13 Lance Wallnau and other prophets recast Kamala Harris as that Jezebel. Her rise, Wallnau warned, was more ominous than Hillary Clinton’s because “she’ll bring a racial component and she’s younger.”14 Harris is incidentally a Baptist, a fact the label conveniently ignores, since in this world a Democrat cannot really be a Christian anyway, and calling her a demon finishes the job of reading her right out of the faith. An anointed candidate needs more than an opponent, you see. He needs a demon, because you do not wage a spiritual war on a rival who is merely wrong.
The choice of Jezebel is deliberate. Evangelical men have long reached for the word to discipline any woman who declines to stay quiet and submissive, and in America the word has a second history. The Jezebel stereotype took shape in slavery, casting Black women as sexually dangerous to excuse what was done to them.15 Aimed at a Black woman running for president, it works on both frequencies simultaneously. And the story it invokes ends with a body in the street, trampled and torn by dogs, which is the part of the comparison nobody wants to admit.
The same stretch of years ran in an even darker direction too. The movement’s rhetoric runs on the fuel of spiritual warfare, on the belief that political opponents are literal demons and the faithful are soldiers in a very real war.16 In June 2025, a man named Vance Boelter, dressed as a police officer, murdered Minnesota House Speaker Emerita Melissa Hortman and her husband Mark, and shot a state senator and his wife. He carried a list of roughly seventy targets, most of them Democrats and abortion providers, and afterward texted his family that “Dad went to war last night.”17 Boelter had trained at a Dallas Bible school where the prominent apostle Dutch Sheets taught and later served as director, and his talk of holy war did not come from nowhere. The school disavowed him, and no one has drawn a straight line from any particular sermon to his crimes. The scholars who track this movement, among them Matthew Taylor and Frederick Clarkson, have been saying for years that when you teach people their neighbors are demons and their politics is a battlefield, you should not act terribly surprised when one of them takes you at your word.18
The question that’s left
None of this is intended to suggest that God never works through flawed people. He does. The Bible is emphatic that He does, and any honest reading of history agrees. The question was never whether God can use a man like Cyrus, or even a man like Trump. The question is whether our certainty that God uses such men has become the permission we needed to stop telling the truth about them.
It has.
That is the real cost, and it is heavier than any single election. When a believer can no longer tell the difference between God’s purposes and his own political preferences, every victory starts to look like divine providence and every defeat starts to look like persecution. The win is God’s vindication. The loss is the devil’s work. No outcome is left that could count as evidence against you, which is one way of saying you have stopped being accountable to reality at all.
A church that arrives there has changed more than its voting pattern. It has changed what it worships. The useful man was supposed to serve the kingdom. Somewhere along the way, for a great many believers, he became the kingdom. We did not merely change our politics, it seems, we changed our theology.
Notes
1. Lance Wallnau, “Why I Believe Trump Is the Prophesied President,” Charisma (October 2016); and God’s Chaos Candidate: Donald J. Trump and the American Unraveling (Keller, TX: Killer Sheep Media, 2016). Wallnau described “a Cyrus anointing” on Trump and called him a “wrecking ball to the spirit of political correctness,” arguing the question was which candidate was anointed for the moment rather than whose values aligned with Christians’.
2. Isaiah 45:1 (NRSVue). God names the Persian king Cyrus “his anointed” (Hebrew mashiach), the only foreign ruler given that title in the Hebrew Bible.
3. On the New Apostolic Reformation’s origins: C. Peter Wagner, a Fuller Seminary church-growth professor, coined the term in the 1990s and spoke of a “second apostolic age” restoring the offices of apostle and prophet; he called it the most radical change in Christian practice since the Reformation. See Matthew D. Taylor, The Violent Take It by Force (2024), and Taylor’s audio series Charismatic Revival Fury: The New Apostolic Reformation.
4. On the Seven Mountain Mandate: traced by its proponents to a 1975 vision shared by Loren Cunningham (Youth With A Mission), Bill Bright (Campus Crusade for Christ), and Francis Schaeffer, originally framed for evangelism; it turned dominionist after Cunningham’s 2000 meeting with Lance Wallnau and the 2013 Wallnau-Bill Johnson book Invading Babylon: The 7 Mountain Mandate.
5. On NAR involvement in January 6: Matthew D. Taylor, The Violent Take It by Force, documents more than fifty charismatic leaders with NAR ties in Washington that day; Dutch Sheets revived the “Appeal to Heaven” flag, which flew by the dozens in the crowd, and on January 6 Cindy Jacobs, Lance Wallnau, and other apostles and prophets stood outside the Capitol while Sheets prayed over the scene by phone. See NPR’s interview with Taylor (September 22, 2024).
6. On the December 12, 2020 Jericho March and the Proud Boys: Religion News Service and NCR (December 2020). Members of the Proud Boys, widely designated a hate group, tore down and burned Black Lives Matter banners from Asbury United Methodist Church and Metropolitan AME, both historic Black churches, the night of the march; four people were stabbed. Proud Boys leader Enrique Tarrio was later sentenced for burning Asbury’s banner, and a court awarded Metropolitan AME more than $1 million.
7. Paula White-Cain was appointed Senior Advisor to the White House Faith Office in February 2025; she earlier led the Faith and Opportunity Initiative during Trump’s first term (appointed November 2019).
8. PRRI, “Analyzing the 2024 Presidential Vote: PRRI’s Post-Election Survey” (December 13, 2024). One in four voters (25%) agreed that “God ordained Donald Trump to be the winner of the 2024 presidential election”; among white evangelical Protestants the figure was 60%. A differently worded Pew question yields far lower numbers, so cite PRRI’s exact wording.
9. On POTUS Shield, founded in 2017 by Frank Amedia: coverage in Religion Dispatches and Right Wing Watch (2017). Its stated aims included ending legal abortion, prohibiting same-sex marriage, and removing federal judges whose rulings it opposed. The underlying report was Peter Montgomery’s, for People for the American Way’s Right Wing Watch (2017), with a companion interview in Religion Dispatches on August 7, 2017.
10. “Inside Ziklag, the Secret Organization of Wealthy Christians Trying to Sway the Election,” ProPublica (co-published with Documented, July 2024); on the $700,000 Ziklag gift underwriting Wallnau’s Courage Tour, Baptist News Global (2024). The investigation was reported by Andy Kroll (ProPublica) and Nick Surgey (Documented), published July 13, 2024.
11. Paula White-Cain, remarks at a White House Easter event, April 1, 2026, reported by The New Republic and others; the White House later removed the video.
12. Trump posted an AI-generated image of himself as a Christ-like figure, in a white robe and red sash healing a sick man, to Truth Social over Easter weekend 2026, then deleted it after backlash and told reporters he thought it showed him as a doctor. Variety, Snopes, and The Globe and Mail (April 2026).
13. 2 Kings 9:30-37 (NRSVue), the death of Jezebel: Jehu has her thrown from a window; horses trample her, and dogs consume her body.
14. On the 2024 recasting of Trump as Jehu and Harris as a “Jezebel spirit”: Lance Wallnau’s remarks, reported by Religion News Service (September 13 and October 21, 2024) and the Associated Press (October 2024); and Religion Dispatches, “The ‘Jezebel Spirit’ Isn’t (Just) Bible-Based Misogyny” (November 1, 2024), which traces the Jehu/Trump and Jezebel/Harris pairing. Scholars Anthea Butler and Tamura Lomax note the term’s racist and misogynistic roots and that it falsely implies Harris, a Baptist, is not Christian.
15. On the Jezebel stereotype as a slavery-era construct casting Black women as hypersexual and rationalizing sexual violence against them: the Jim Crow Museum (Ferris State University); Deborah Gray White, Ar’n’t I a Woman? Female Slaves in the Plantation South; and Tamura Lomax, Jezebel Unhinged: Loosing the Black Female Body in Religion and Culture (Duke University Press, 2018).
16. On the New Apostolic Reformation and its spiritual-warfare theology, see Matthew D. Taylor, The Violent Take It by Force (Minneapolis: Broadleaf Books, 2024).
17. On the June 14, 2025 killings, Boelter’s roughly seventy-name target list, and the “Dad went to war” text: Associated Press reporting and federal charging documents (June 2025). The Hortmans were killed in their Brooklyn Park home; Senator John Hoffman and his wife Yvette were wounded in Champlin, about nine miles away.
18. On Boelter’s attendance at Christ for the Nations Institute, where Dutch Sheets taught and later served as executive director, and on the contested question of his ties to the movement: SPLC Hatewatch; Religion News Service, “Christ for the Nations denounces alum’s ‘hateful actions’”; and analyses by Matthew D. Taylor and Frederick Clarkson (2025). The school disavowed Boelter, and no causal link between NAR teaching and the murders has been established.




Brilliant article! Anyone who has questioned the evangelical pass Trump gets from the right, will find this essay enlightening. Any evangelical who still adores Trump, will have a hard time finding this essay.
Just a question that nagged at me through this article. Do these “apostles” truly believe that Trump has been chosen by God (and if so how do they know this is so) or are they cynical opportunists who see a useful fellow traveller who can be brought to power and in return deliver their agenda?