Gregory of Nyssa may not have made your argument in exactly the same form, but he seems to me to come close. He makes a curious, almost statistical argument in Chapter 21 of On the Making of Man. Essentially, he says that evil is finite, while good is infinite. Infinite progress toward the good is possible, because of the unbounded nature of the good. But infinite progress in evil is not possible, because evil is contained within limits. Fascinatingly, he uses the analogy of space travel within the cone-shaped shadow cast by the earth. Eventually, you reach the point where the Shadow is no more, and Light once more fills the universe uninterrupted.
This didn't feel convincing to me at first, but he also uses the idea of the "low point," or "rock bottom." Eventually, the cost of self-destructive behavior becomes too high, and there is nowhere to go but up. At some point, given unlimited time, we DO learn from our mistakes. This was more convincing to me.
Of course, Hart gets this idea that the will is fundamentally oriented toward the Good from Gregory, and from Gregory's own philosophical sources. For Gregory, the only way that a rational being can choose evil is by being misguided by an appearance of good.
But Gregory is strongly opposed to any appearance of determinism. He manages to hold exceptionally strong universalist convictions in harmony with an extraordinarily high esteem for the human power of free choice. He doesn't connect all his dots, but I think his theology is still rationally coherent. And I think it is coherent through something similar to what you have described--God's perfect wisdom knows precisely how to draw his every creature without overriding their power of choice.
This gets us back to the almost "statistical" argument in On the Making of Man. Gregory notes that it is impossible for the misguided will to be as steady in its choices as God's will is in his choice of the Good. This implies that, statistically, over time, there is a 100% chance of us gradually coming around to the steadiness of God's genial drawing influence. And that "coming around" will be our own free choice. Gregory doesn't say it in precisely this way, but that is how I read his logic. And I think it makes sense of his "limited shadow" analogy.
George MacDonald (with his Calvinist background) is the one who brought me over to universalism, so I am perhaps more OK with limitations on our free will than Gregory is. But, in the end, I think they are essentially saying the same thing.
This is…challenging. My formal background is Lutheran, and I've always chafed against the Calvinist Elect. So I've generally gone with a type of nihilism, e.g. "Hell is eternal separation from God," (my version of Sheol) and happily left the rest to mystery. But this series has forced me to think again. (How dare you! 😉) Your conclusion resonates with my understanding of the grace and love of God. Thank you for putting in the work and sharing it here.
Gregory of Nyssa may not have made your argument in exactly the same form, but he seems to me to come close. He makes a curious, almost statistical argument in Chapter 21 of On the Making of Man. Essentially, he says that evil is finite, while good is infinite. Infinite progress toward the good is possible, because of the unbounded nature of the good. But infinite progress in evil is not possible, because evil is contained within limits. Fascinatingly, he uses the analogy of space travel within the cone-shaped shadow cast by the earth. Eventually, you reach the point where the Shadow is no more, and Light once more fills the universe uninterrupted.
This didn't feel convincing to me at first, but he also uses the idea of the "low point," or "rock bottom." Eventually, the cost of self-destructive behavior becomes too high, and there is nowhere to go but up. At some point, given unlimited time, we DO learn from our mistakes. This was more convincing to me.
Of course, Hart gets this idea that the will is fundamentally oriented toward the Good from Gregory, and from Gregory's own philosophical sources. For Gregory, the only way that a rational being can choose evil is by being misguided by an appearance of good.
But Gregory is strongly opposed to any appearance of determinism. He manages to hold exceptionally strong universalist convictions in harmony with an extraordinarily high esteem for the human power of free choice. He doesn't connect all his dots, but I think his theology is still rationally coherent. And I think it is coherent through something similar to what you have described--God's perfect wisdom knows precisely how to draw his every creature without overriding their power of choice.
This gets us back to the almost "statistical" argument in On the Making of Man. Gregory notes that it is impossible for the misguided will to be as steady in its choices as God's will is in his choice of the Good. This implies that, statistically, over time, there is a 100% chance of us gradually coming around to the steadiness of God's genial drawing influence. And that "coming around" will be our own free choice. Gregory doesn't say it in precisely this way, but that is how I read his logic. And I think it makes sense of his "limited shadow" analogy.
George MacDonald (with his Calvinist background) is the one who brought me over to universalism, so I am perhaps more OK with limitations on our free will than Gregory is. But, in the end, I think they are essentially saying the same thing.
Where does universalism leave the Great Commission, in your view?
This is…challenging. My formal background is Lutheran, and I've always chafed against the Calvinist Elect. So I've generally gone with a type of nihilism, e.g. "Hell is eternal separation from God," (my version of Sheol) and happily left the rest to mystery. But this series has forced me to think again. (How dare you! 😉) Your conclusion resonates with my understanding of the grace and love of God. Thank you for putting in the work and sharing it here.
Have you read Bradley Jersak‘s book, Her Gates Will Never Be Shut? If you have, i would be interested in your thoughts.
I have not!
A comedian asks his Christian audience, "What will you do when Satan gets saved?"