Drink Wisely — Pouring Over Theology and Truth

Drink Wisely — Pouring Over Theology and Truth

The Hard Word

A word the church borrowed and emptied

Shawn Patrick Connelly's avatar
Shawn Patrick Connelly
May 26, 2026
∙ Paid

The word “prophetic” circulates through contemporary Christian discourse with an authority it has largely stopped earning. On the progressive end of the Christian spectrum, it gets attached to almost any statement challenging the political right, whether a sermon on immigration, a post about poverty, or a declaration against nationalist violence. On the conservative or charismatic end, it gets attached to claims of direct divine revelation, from pastors declaring God’s choice for president to conference speakers announcing the end-times significance of current events to networks of self-appointed apostles claiming biblical-level authority.

Both usages have borrowed the vocabulary without doing the requisite reading.

The tradition that generated the word is specific, demanding, and largely incompatible with how it gets used today. Tracing it back to its source is the precondition for using it honestly. That turns out to be considerably harder than either end of the contemporary Christian spectrum has found it convenient to acknowledge.


What the prophets were actually doing

Prediction appears in the prophetic literature, but it is peripheral to the central task. The prophets of the Hebrew Bible were covenant critics, people who held Israel accountable to its own stated commitments before God, in specific historical and social conditions, at serious personal cost.

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Shawn Patrick Connelly.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Shawn Patrick Connelly · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.