On March 25, 2026, the Secretary of Defense stood in the Pentagon auditorium at the first monthly worship service since the Iran war began and prayed for every round to find its mark against the enemies of righteousness.1 He read the prayer from a text he said a military chaplain had given the troops who captured Nicolás Maduro. It leaned on the imprecatory psalms and included a plea that God break the teeth of the ungodly.2 The Associated Press headline summarized the rest as a prayer for violence against those the prayer judged to be beyond mercy.3
Move the scene to Tehran or Kabul. A defense minister opens a wartime worship service by asking God to make the bullets land, and every American commentator recognizes the pattern in about two seconds, most of them reflexively reaching for the word extremist. The chyron writes itself.
That recognition would be correct, and it’s the standard I now apply to the Pentagon.
The rule we wrote ourselves
In March 2015, Graeme Wood published “What ISIS Really Wants” in The Atlantic, arguing that the Islamic State was a religious movement with considered beliefs, one committed to returning civilization to a seventh-century legal environment and to bringing about the apocalypse, and that treating its members as psychopaths misread them.4 The practical lesson that spread from that article was to take them at their word. American conservatives, including evangelical leaders like Franklin Graham, turned a version of this lesson into a litmus test through the Obama years, insisting that officials say “radical Islamic terrorism” out loud because the religion was precisely the point.5
I think the principle holds. When a movement announces that its violence carries divine sanction, believe that it believes it, then ask what follows.
What the comparison covers
ISIS held territory, enslaved women, and carried out mass executions.6 American Christian nationalism has no direct counterpart to any of that, of course, and Hegseth works from inside courts, a press corps, and an electoral system that ISIS dismantled wherever it governed. The claim here is more at the level of grammar and direction. Both movements sacralize violence against designated enemies, fuse a form of faith to a national identity, and tell a story about a purer, idyllic past that licenses force in the present. Whether the American version could ever do what ISIS did is an entirely separate question, and I will get to the part of it that I think can actually be tested.
My own view runs somewhat stronger than the careful version, so I’ll state it up front. A set of self-avowed Christians in far-right and theocratic circles are moving, method by method, toward the habits we typically associate with Islamist extremism. They share the attitude, which is the sense of being besieged, the certainty that God has picked a side (theirs), and an easy comfort with praying directly for the enemy’s destruction. They share the approach, which treats Scripture as a field manual and a faith test as a condition of belonging. The American versions have far less organization and a fraction of the infrastructure, and that gap is real. I’m tracking the direction, and I believe it’s clear enough to say so.
The comparison classes need caution. On the Islamic side, the class is Islamist extremist movements, which is a sliver of the world’s Muslims. On the Christian side, there are two layers. PRRI’s 2024 survey counted two-thirds of white evangelical Protestants as adherents or sympathizers of Christian nationalism, a measure built on agreement with statements about America’s Christian identity and the place of Christian values in law.7 The ideological wing is far smaller and organized around figures like Doug Wilson, and that wing is where the comparison with Islamist movements has to prove itself as legitimate. Hegseth belongs to the smaller layer through his church affiliation, and he holds an office that can carry its ideas into the American military.
Religion and nation, welded together
At the National Prayer Breakfast on February 5, 2026, Hegseth said America was founded as a Christian nation and remains one in our DNA, and he described the Pentagon’s monthly worship services as spiritual readiness.8 Every movement that wants a religious state starts there, with the legitimacy of the government and the survival of one faith treated as a single, unified project. He then read from Mark 8 and added that the warrior willing to lay down his life for his unit, his country, and his Creator finds eternal life, according to Brian Kaylor’s account for Word&Way.9 A promise of eternal reward to people who die for a sacred cause is familiar recruiting language across many religious wars, but it sounds different when the speaker heads up the American military.
A test for belonging
Doug Wilson, a self-described Christian nationalist, preached at the Pentagon on February 17, one of many pastors from several Protestant denominations Hegseth has hosted since the services began in May 2025.10 Hegseth belongs to a church in the Communion of Reformed Evangelical Churches, the network Wilson co-founded.11 Wilson told NPR in July that in the Christian republic he wants, officeholders would swear to uphold a Christian Constitution, so non-Christians technically would not hold office, and that public space would belong to Christ.12 Brad Onishi, a former minister who studies religious extremism, told PBS NewsHour in December 2024 that Hegseth has claimed Wilson as a spiritual mentor, summarized Wilson’s politics as the view that anyone who doesn’t share his hymnal can’t be mayor, and asked whether a Muslim, a Hindu, or an atheist could rise to captain under that leadership.13 Asked about church and state, Wilson told CNN the services disrupt that separation only if the tradition is dated to recent decades.14 A 2019 congressional report put the Christian share of service members at nearly 70 percent, the AP reported in June, which leaves a large minority who hold other faiths, none, or did not say.15
Scripture with a target
In the March service Hegseth read from Psalm 18, the passage in which David pursues his enemies until they are consumed.16 New York Times reporting described the monthly services and his calls to prayer as a stark departure from how military chaplains are taught to minister to a diverse flock.17 After Charlie Kirk was killed in September, he posted a video that set his recitation of the Lord’s Prayer over footage of missiles firing, warships steaming, and paratroopers falling.18
The verses are real Scripture, which is the point. Wood described ISIS as a movement of fundamentalists with considered beliefs, and choosing which verses to pray at the start of a war is a theology too.
Crusade as identity
Much has been made of Hegseth having Deus vult tattooed on his bicep. The Latin means God wills it, it served as a rallying cry in the First Crusade, and the same two words close his 2020 book, American Crusade. He also wears a Jerusalem Cross on his chest and a sword tattoo that he has said represents a New Testament verse, which The Bulwark identifies as Matthew 10:34.19 Read in context, that verse belongs to a passage about conflict inside households, which makes it an odd mandate for a fighting force.20 Hegseth and his crowd don’t often seem to be too concerned about correct hermeneutics or Biblical context.
In the same book he warns about an Islamist principle he calls hegira, which he describes as the nonviolent capture of a non-Muslim country, and the Guardian reported in 2024 that an expert regards his account of the history as false.21 A man who diagnoses another religion’s appetite for conquest while wearing the battle cry of the First Crusade has, at minimum, an interesting relationship with mirrors.
The man at the controls
Hegseth acknowledged at his confirmation hearing, in Defense One’s account, that he lacks the traditional experience for the job, and he pointed to his Army National Guard service, including deployments to Iraq and Afghanistan as an infantry officer, as his main qualification.22 Before the Pentagon he had run two veterans’ advocacy nonprofits. Senator Richard Blumenthal, a Democrat, said the most people Hegseth managed at either was maybe fifty, while Senator Roger Wicker, a Republican supporter, countered that Hegseth had supervised more people than the average senator. The Pentagon employs about 3.4 million service members and civilians.23 Susan Collins and Lisa Murkowski said he lacked the experience, Mitch McConnell joined them in voting no, and the Senate confirmed him 51 to 50 on Vice President Vance’s tiebreaking vote.24
Hegseth strikes me as a man cosplaying war, with the difference that the costume budget runs to hundreds of billions of dollars. He seems giddy (word chosen carefully) with the power of the office, and his first year reads like someone discovering how many levers the chair connects to. On September 30, 2025, he gathered nearly every senior officer in the joint force at Quantico and told them beards were no longer authorized and that combat troops would be held to a single fitness standard set at the male level.25 The department now uses the name Department of War under a presidential order, though the legal name still takes an act of Congress.26 In April he fired the Army’s chief of staff without giving a reason, after a string of removals that included the Joint Chiefs chairman and the chief of naval operations.27 In June the AP reported that the department had cut its recognized religious designations from more than 200 to 31, dropping categories that included atheist, Unitarian Universalist, pagan, and Wiccan.28
None of that proves the comparison, but it explains why I find it worrying. Hegseth told senators he knew what he didn’t know, and he has since remade large parts of a department of 3.4 million people with remarkable certainty. That level of certainty paired with a theology of righteous enemies is the combination I would watch closely.
How an institution gets built
The services began in May 2025, when Hegseth’s pastor in Tennessee, Brooks Potteiger, preached the first one. Pastors from Wilson’s denomination have appeared at least three times since, and the Labor Department’s secretary now hosts monthly prayer gatherings inspired by the Pentagon’s.29 Hegseth has also announced that chaplains will drop rank insignia in favor of symbols of their faith, saying a chaplain is a chaplain first and an officer second.30 Each step is defensible alone. A recurring ritual, a recognizable clergy, and a template that other agencies copy are also the early materials of an institution, and that is the sense in which I think the American version is heading somewhere specific.
The best case for Hegseth
His defenders have some real material. According to the Catholic News Agency, the Jerusalem Cross appeared in the years before the First Crusade, and pilgrims to Jerusalem have gotten it tattooed for more than seven centuries.31 Pentagon aides cite precedents like Franklin Roosevelt’s support for giving Bibles to troops, and Hegseth often points to George Washington’s role in establishing the chaplain corps. The services are formally voluntary, and Hegseth told Christian broadcasters he holds them mostly because he needs them more than anyone else does.32 The imprecatory psalms are canonical, and anyone who has survived a Reformed adult Sunday school class knows them, usually handled with tongs and an asterisk. Wilson, for his part, says his route to a Christian republic runs through preaching, church planting, and mass conversion, and that he has met Hegseth only a few times and has not been asked for policy advice, to his knowledge.33
All of that is fair as far as it goes. The picture changes with the combination and the office, however. A cabinet secretary is using state occasions, during a war against a majority-Muslim country, to ask God for violence against the ungodly, and the pastor he has reportedly claimed as a mentor advocates for a Christian republic whose officeholders would have to be Christian, a position a CNN headline called Christian theocracy.34 Critics, including Rachel Laser of Americans United for Separation of Church and State, which has sued for records about the services, argue that attendance pressure comes built in even when attendance is technically optional.35
Does it get worse
The easy version of the desensitization argument would point to PRRI’s polling on political violence, so I looked at it. In 2024, PRRI reported that 38 percent of Christian nationalism adherents and 33 percent of sympathizers agreed that true American patriots may have to resort to violence to save the country, compared with 17 percent of skeptics and 7 percent of rejecters, and the sympathizer figure had risen eleven points since 2022.36 In PRRI’s 2025 survey the numbers were lower, at 28 percent of adherents, 22 percent of sympathizers, 12 percent of skeptics, and 8 percent of rejecters, with 14 percent of all Americans agreeing, down from an overall peak of 23 percent in September 2023.37 Those are different surveys with different timing, so I would not draw a single line through them. They show adherents running at several times the rate of rejecters both years, and they show no steady climb.
Whatever desensitization exists shows up better in what officials now say aloud, on a livestream, than in the poll lines. I would treat the movement as heading toward the Islamist pattern if it produced a religious qualification for rank or office, discipline for service members who decline to participate, Scripture invoked as the legal basis for statute, or violence against internal dissenters described as defense of the faith. Evidence against would be courts and Congress holding their ground, the services ending when Hegseth does, and the survey numbers falling. I would like the second list to win, obviously. The first list is where I intend to keep looking.
. . .
Nobody has to decode Hegseth. He put the battle cry on his arm, ended his book with it, and read the prayer into a livestream. The remaining question belongs to the people who spent a decade insisting that religious violence be taken at the believer’s word, and it is whether they will extend the same courtesy to a man who shares their Bible.
. . .
Notes
1. Tiffany Stanley, Associated Press (Konstantin Toropin contributing), “At Pentagon Christian service, Hegseth prays for violence ‘against those who deserve no mercy,’” March 25, 2026 (updated March 26), https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/at-pentagon-christian-service-hegseth-prays-for-violence-against-those-who-deserve-no-mercy. The AP identifies the service as the first monthly Pentagon worship service since the Iran war began, quotes the line about every round finding its mark, and reports that Hegseth said a military chaplain first gave the prayer to the troops who captured Maduro.
2. Cristina Stassis, Military Times, “Hegseth prays for ‘overwhelming violence’ during Pentagon Christian service,” March 26, 2026, https://www.militarytimes.com/news/pentagon-congress/2026/03/26/hegseth-prays-for-overwhelming-violence-during-pentagon-christian-service/, for the plea to break the teeth of the ungodly and the “premission reading” provenance. Jon Brown, Christian Post, “Pete Hegseth quotes imprecatory psalms during Pentagon prayer service,” https://assets.christianpost.com/news/hegseth-quotes-imprecatory-psalm-during-pentagon-prayer-service.html, for the imprecatory-psalm character of the prayer.
3. AP headline, as in note 1.
4. Graeme Wood, “What ISIS Really Wants,” The Atlantic, March 2015, https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2015/03/what-isis-really-wants/384980/. The characterization of the argument rests on YaleGlobal’s summary and excerpt, https://archive-yaleglobal.yale.edu/content/what-isis-really-wants, which quotes Wood on a commitment to returning civilization to a seventh-century legal environment and to bringing about the apocalypse, and describes the group as religious fundamentalists with considered beliefs rather than simply psychopaths.
5. Franklin Graham’s complaints about the Obama administration’s refusal to say “radical Islamic terrorism” are in Gospel Herald, “Franklin Graham Disappointed in Obama Administration for Refusing to Use Term ‘Radical Islamic Terrorism,’” https://www.gospelherald.com/news/franklin-graham-disappointed-obama-adminisration-refusing-use-term-radical-islamic (undated page, 2016). Obama’s response to the criticism, which came from Donald Trump and Republican lawmakers, is in Bryant Jordan, Military.com, “Obama Criticizes Trump’s Rhetoric on Radical Islamic Terrorism,” June 2016, https://mst.military.com/daily-news/2016/06/14/obama-criticizes-trumps-rhetoric-on-radical-islamic-terrorism.html.
6. On enslavement, UN Human Rights Council Commission of Inquiry on the Syrian Arab Republic, “They Came to Destroy: ISIS Crimes Against the Yazidis,” June 16, 2016, summarized at https://www.ecoi.net/en/document/1345919.html, which found genocide and reported thousands of Yazidi women and girls sold in slave markets and held in sexual slavery. On mass executions, Human Rights Watch put the toll at Camp Speicher in June 2014 at between 560 and 770 captured men, reported by the Associated Press, September 4, 2014, https://newsinfo.inquirer.net/635211/group-islamic-militants-executed-770-iraqi-troops.
7. PRRI, “First of Its Kind Survey Maps Support for Christian Nationalism Across All 50 States,” February 28, 2024, https://www.prri.org/?p=39886. The survey interviewed 22,465 adults between March 9 and December 7, 2023, and found 66 percent of white evangelical Protestants to be adherents or sympathizers. Religion News Service, “New survey finds pockets of support for Christian nationalism across the country,” February 28, 2024, https://religionnews.com/2024/02/28/new-survey-finds-pockets-of-support-for-christian-nationalism-across-the-country/, reports the survey’s statement about laws being based on Christian values.
8. Brian Kaylor, Word&Way, “At National Prayer Breakfast, Hegseth Says US Soldiers Gain Salvation by Dying for ‘Christian Nation,’” February 5, 2026, https://wordandway.org/2026/02/05/at-national-prayer-breakfast-hegseth-says-us-soldiers-gain-salvation-by-dying-for-christian-nation/. Kaylor quotes Hegseth saying America remains a Christian nation in our DNA and describing the Pentagon services as spiritual readiness.
9. Kaylor, as in note 8, reports that Hegseth read Mark 8 and glossed it with the line about the warrior who lays down his life for his unit, his country, and his Creator finding eternal life.
10. Kaanita Iyer and Haley Britzky, CNN, “Hegseth invited pastor who calls for Christian theocracy to lead Pentagon prayer service,” February 19, 2026, https://kvia.com/?p=1447069, describes Wilson as a self-described Christian nationalist and reports that a source called him one of many preachers from several Protestant denominations over the past year. The services began in May 2025 with Brooks Potteiger preaching, per the AP story in note 1.
11. AP, as in note 1, identifies Hegseth as a member of the Communion of Reformed Evangelical Churches, a network co-founded by Wilson, and reports that CREC pastors have appeared at his Pentagon services at least three times.
12. Leila Fadel, NPR, interview with Doug Wilson in Moscow, Idaho, July 7, 2026, as carried at https://www.hppr.org/2026-07-07/pastor-doug-wilson-on-why-he-believes-the-u-s-should-be-a-christian-theocracy. Wilson said officeholders in a Christian republic would have to vow to uphold the Christian Constitution, so non-Christians technically would not hold office, and said church bells would be acceptable in public space but minarets would not, because the public space would belong to Christ.
13. Brad Onishi, interview with Laura Barrón-López, PBS NewsHour, December 12, 2024, https://www.pbs.org/newshour/show/how-hegseths-controversial-religious-views-could-affect-military-leadership. Onishi is introduced as someone who studies religious extremism and calls himself a former minister. The characterization of Wilson’s position and of Hegseth’s relationship to him is Onishi’s own.
14. CNN, as in note 10. Wilson’s remark about “longstanding” separation of church and state is paraphrased.
15. Tiffany Stanley, Associated Press, “Defense Department slashes its religious designations list from more than 200 choices to 31,” June 5, 2026, https://www.wavy.com/news/politics/ap-defense-department-slashes-its-religious-designations-list-from-more-than-200-choices-to-31/amp/, which cites a 2019 congressional report finding nearly 70 percent of troops identifying as Christian and almost a quarter listed as other, unclassified, or unknown.
16. Jon Brown, Christian Post, as in note 2, which quotes the Psalm 18 verses Hegseth read.
17. New York Times, March 20, 2026, as republished by the Boston Globe, https://www.bostonglobe.com/2026/03/20/nation/hegseth-invokes-divine-purpose-justify-military-might/.
18. New York Times, as in note 17, which quotes Hegseth’s caption for the video.
19. The Bulwark, “What’s the Deal With Pete Hegseth’s Crusader Tattoos?” https://thebulwark.com/p/whats-the-deal-with-pete-hegseth-crusader-tattoos, which reports the Deus vult, Jerusalem Cross, and sword tattoos, ties the sword to Matthew 10:34, and quotes the book’s closing lines about seeing readers on the battlefield and saving America with God’s help, ending in Deus vult. Religion Unplugged, https://religionunplugged.com/news/pete-hegseth-trumps-defense-secretary-nominee-has-multiple-christian-and-crusades-inspired-tattoos, reports that Hegseth says the sword tattoo represents a New Testament verse. Both are secondary sources for the book.
20. Matthew 10:34–36 (NRSVue), and Luke 12:51. For a Reformed reading of the sword as division, see Joel Kim, “No Peace, but a Sword,” Tabletalk, September 25, 2015, https://learn.ligonier.org/articles/no-peace-sword. Kim reads the sword as the division and conflict Jesus’s message produces and cites Micah 7:6 for family strain.
21. Hegseth’s description of hegira as the nonviolent capture of a non-Muslim country, and the Guardian’s note that an expert calls his connection to the capture of Europe false, are quoted in Georgetown Bridge Initiative, “Factsheet: Pete Hegseth,” January 28, 2025, https://bridge.georgetown.edu/?p=6321, citing Jason Wilson, “Trump Pentagon pick Pete Hegseth’s books foreground anti-Muslim rhetoric,” The Guardian, November 28, 2024, https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/nov/28/pete-hegseth-trump-anti-muslim-book.
22. Meghann Myers, “‘I know what I don’t know,’ SecDef pick says at confirmation hearing,” Defense One, January 14, 2025, https://defenseone.com/policy/2025/01/i-know-what-i-dont-know-secdef-pick-says-confirmation-hearing/402184.
23. Jeff Schogol, “Pentagon Hegseth experience,” Task & Purpose, January 14, 2025, https://taskandpurpose.com/news/pentagon-hegseth-experience/. Hegseth was executive director of Vets For Freedom (2007 to 2010) and CEO of Concerned Veterans for America (2012 to 2015). The “maybe 50” figure is Blumenthal’s characterization, and Wicker’s rebuttal is reported in the same story, which also gives the Pentagon workforce as about 3.4 million service members and civilians.
24. Denver Gazette, “Hegseth confirmed: Vance comes to rescue after McConnell rebellion forces tiebreaker,” January 25, 2025, https://www.denvergazette.com/2025/01/25/hegseth-confirmed-vance-comes-to-rescue-after-mcconnell-rebellion-forces-tiebreaker-6f99009f-e4dc-5d41-bb0b-23d68598e1ea, which reports the 51-50 vote on January 24, 2025, and that Collins and Murkowski said he lacked the experience to lead the Pentagon.
25. U.S. Army, “Hegseth announces series of War Department reforms in sweeping speech to top military brass,” https://www.army.mil/article/288832, on the September 30, 2025, address at Marine Corps Base Quantico, which lists the end of beard authorizations and a gender-neutral male standard for combat occupations.
26. Jason Breslow, NPR, “President Trump signs order to rename the Defense Department as the Department of War,” September 4, 2025, https://www.ijpr.org/npr-news/2025-09-04/president-trump-signs-order-to-rename-the-defense-department-as-the-department-of-war, which reports that the order creates a secondary title and that changing the legal name requires Congress.
27. Breaking Defense, “Hegseth fires Army’s top officer Gen. Randy George,” April 2, 2026, https://breakingdefense.com/2026/04/hegseth-fires-armys-top-officer-gen-randy-george/, which reports that Hegseth gave no reason and lists earlier removals including Gen. CQ Brown and Adm. Lisa Franchetti.
28. AP, as in note 15, reports that the Defense Department cut the list to 31, that Hegseth announced the changes in December, and that the new list drops atheists, Unitarian Universalists, pagans, and Wiccans. Spokesman Sean Parnell said the change is designed to let chaplains see the religious composition of their units quickly.
29. AP, as in note 1, for the May 2025 launch with Potteiger preaching, the CREC appearances, and the Labor Department gatherings hosted by Secretary Lori Chavez-DeRemer.
30. Cristina Stassis, Military Times, as in note 2, reports Hegseth’s Tuesday video announcement that chaplains will no longer wear rank insignia and will wear symbols of their faith, and his remark that a chaplain is first and foremost a chaplain and an officer second.
31. Catholic News Agency, “What Is the Jerusalem Cross?” November 19, 2024, https://www.catholicworldreport.com/2024/11/19/what-is-the-jerusalem-cross/, adapted from the National Catholic Register.
32. AP, as in note 1, for the defenders’ examples, Hegseth’s citation of Washington, and his February 2026 remark to Christian broadcasters.
33. NPR, as in note 12, for Wilson’s account of a nonviolent route through evangelism and mass conversion, his description of the Constitution as a work of theological genius, and his statement that he has met Hegseth a few times and texted some and that Hegseth has not sought his policy advice, to his knowledge.
34. CNN, as in note 10, which says Wilson has advocated that the United States adopt a Christian theocracy. NPR’s interview, as in note 12, is headlined as Wilson explaining why he believes the United States should be a Christian theocracy.
35. AP, as in note 1, which reports that Rachel Laser, president and CEO of Americans United, said that even if the services are voluntary there is pressure on federal employees to attend, and that the group filed suit to enforce a records request about the services.
36. PRRI, as in note 7: adherents 38 percent, sympathizers 33, skeptics 17, rejecters 7, with sympathizers up from 22 percent in 2022.
37. PRRI, “Prophecy, Trump, and the Justification of Political Violence,” June 18, 2025, https://prri.org/spotlight/prophecy-trump-and-the-justification-of-political-violence/, drawing on the PRRI Trump’s First 100 Days Survey. The page reports 14 percent of Americans agreeing overall, a September 2023 peak of 23 percent, and 28, 22, 12, and 8 percent among adherents, sympathizers, skeptics, and rejecters. It does not state field dates or sample size, and it is a different instrument from the 2024 report.




Thanks for writing on such a serious topic. It's hard to write about politics right now without being swallowed up by all things political. But at certain points, it's necessary.
I'm not sure if you've subscribed to Elizabeth Neumann, but she works in the field of identifying extremism. I appreciate her wisdom and experience. I'm thankful for her book, Kingdom of Rage.
During the Iraq / Afghanistan wars when they found that American kid fighting for the Taliban, the scapegoating heaped on him was so obviously unexamined transference that I started saying to anyone who would listen that this was the trajectory we were on as a country…to become the American Taliban.
And here we are.