I've struggled with PSA, and your post added to that struggle, in large part because I found the reasoning so persuasive. Like all serious things I sought a second opinion, and what follows is a equally persuasive retort from my pastor. I realize I'm sharing this as a intermediary of sorts between two learned men in this area, but feel it's worth sharing the response in its entirety: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1rKhyQe5fsIXON8yCUKtG70nkCevNjakecp9CUTl3WQQ/edit?usp=drivesdk
Hi Darren, thanks for passing this along, and please thank your pastor for reading the essay closely enough to argue with it. At length, no less. Some of what he says lands decently well, so I’ll start there.
He’s right that I didn’t work through Isaiah 53, 1 Peter 3, or Romans 3:24-26. The essay was intentionally a historical and logical argument about whether God had to require satisfaction, and the sacrificial texts require their own fight. I’m not dodging them. They just weren’t the focus. He’s also right that parables can’t carry a whole doctrine. I used those two for a narrow purpose, to show Jesus describing forgiveness as a loss somebody absorbs, and I wouldn’t claim more for them than that. Your pastor, being a pastor, is going to read things pastorally and devotionally. That wasn’t my aim in that piece, though I do work at that level elsewhere on Drink Wisely.
Several things he attributes to me I didn’t say. I never argued that substitution is an invention of the Reformation. Substitutionary language predates the sixteenth century by a mile. Justin and Chrysostom have Christ bearing the curse in our place, and I’m happy to grant it. My target is much narrower, the claim that God cannot forgive without punishing, which Turretin states outright and which Thomas and Scotus both denied. He also recruits Gregory of Nazianzus for PSA, which is a strange move given that the Gregory passage in my essay asks to whom the blood was offered and answers that the Father accepted it without ever demanding it. I’d love to hear how those two Gregorys get along!
He also says I’m unaware that God acts according to his nature. The essay has a section on exactly that. The real question is whether retribution belongs to God’s nature the way truthfulness does, and that ought to have an argument behind it rather than an assumption. Here’s where I’d put my cards on the table. I don’t believe retributive justice or wrath are constitutive of who God is in anything like the way scripture describes God as love. John doesn’t write that God has love, or has it in abundance, or expresses it when provoked. He writes that God is love. Nobody anywhere writes that God is wrath. Wrath in scripture is something God turns from, relents of, and is repeatedly talked out of by people who seem to understand it’s negotiable.
That’s the grammar of a response, not an attribute. So when your pastor says God’s nature includes perfect justice toward sin and therefore punishment is necessary, he’s smuggling the conclusion into the premise. And he does it while also saying God’s hands were not tied and offering to “do an Aquinas” by having God freely assume the role of impartial judge. He’ll need to pick one. If the judge’s role is freely assumed, the requirement lives in God’s will, which is the whole of what I was arguing. If it’s constitutive, then the “do an Aquinas” escape hatch is closed and he’s back to being buddies with Turretin.
On the charge that my view makes the cross unnecessary, I’d point out that Thomas held the cross was fitting and meaningful while denying it was strictly required, and he’s not usually accused of emptying Golgotha. Fittingness is a reason. A law is a constraint. I don’t cite Thomas because I’m bound to him in any way. I cite him because the tradition PSA’s defenders claim as their inheritance had this argument already and came down on the other side, and that history gets skipped more times than not.
Now the part we both danced around a little. Twice, maybe three times, your pastor hedges his argument with some version of “assuming Connelly is not a universalist.” Well. Bingo.
I hold to apokatastasis, the final restoration of all things to God. I’m in the lineage that runs from Gregory of Nyssa through George MacDonald to David Bentley Hart and Thomas Talbott, which is to say a position with better patristic credentials than people assume, held by a Cappadocian the church never condemned and whose brother-in-faith wrote the Easter sermon I quoted. I was an infernalist my entire life before this, and that older view never once sat easy with me. I like to think that I can finally articulate why and know there is a good reason for my unease.
This changes the force of two of his objections, so let me take them on directly. He asks why, on my logic, God doesn’t just save everyone regardless of their orientation toward sin or Christ. Nearly right. God does save everyone. Not regardless, though, and that’s where his question goes a bit sideways. Repentance isn’t a toll God collects before unlocking the door. Rather, it’s the shape the healing takes in my view. A person has to actually turn toward the physician for the surgery to do anything, and the claim I’d defend is that God can and will finally become every creature’s strongest inclination, given enough time and enough refining fire. Resistance is quite real. MacDonald was clear that it burns. Resistance is also, on my account, finite, and yet God is not. So grace gets resisted along the way yet never resisted finally. I might add that wrath is also finite. I don’t believe that it, or anything else, can be co-eternal with God.
He also says the destiny question depends on what a person must do to be saved rather than on which atonement model is correct, and that PSA and my view land in the same place for a grieving widow. That’s true only if you don’t follow the mechanics closely enough. If the cross is God absorbing a loss rather than collecting a payment, there’s no outstanding ledger left on which anyone can be held, and the entire category of the permanently uncollected debtor disappears. The atonement model and the universalism are the same argument wearing very different hats. That’s why I’d rather he engage the logic than wave at hypotheticals.
On the widow I sat with all those years ago, he and I may be closer than this exchange suggests. Her husband’s fate rests with the same God either way. My complaint is with the job description I handed God that afternoon; a deity who had to be satisfied before he was free to do what she was hoping for. That part I no longer believe, and I’d say so to her now if I could. I have even better good news these days.
If god loves you & god has known you since the womb, why would such a caring god allow you to suffer eternal pain & torment?
One might start with whether the stories about eternal damnation are true. We tend to treat the passages in the books of the Bible as direct descriptions of events witnessed by persons who weren’t diarists. Authorship is traditional not authenticated. Manuscripts are based on what has survived library fires & questionable transcription likely modified to support a particular theological position or argument.
Was there an itinerant preacher named Yoshua ben Yosef who threatened the rule of religious & secular powers? Quite likely. Did his followers spread a gospel of creating a heaven on earth by loving your neighbor? That seems to be the core message.
Was he Jewish with a notion of Gehenna & Sheol? Again, quite likely, where the former was associated with Hell & the latter was the more common reference for an afterlife as a place of of stillness and darkness.
Our description of Hell seems more Greek being modeled after Hades/Tartarus with the Devil replacing Hades brother of Zeus, mayor of Hadestown. One difference is that unlike the Devil, Hades wasn’t a chief tormentor, more an indifferent host of the place where just desserts were served.
I suspect Jesus would have leaned more into a Jewish concept of Sheol in parables & teaching rather than the Greek. The question is whether the descriptions of a tempter as the devil were part of Jesus’ message or added later when it spread into the Greco-Roman world?
When it comes to the question as to whether a particular individual is in heaven or not, there’s no definitive answer this side of the mortal coil.
I would answer that if you believe in a loving god & that the person in question was loved, then yes they are in heaven.
It’s a matter of loving & comforting your neighbor.
I would just like to take a moment to thank you for these essays. I do not come from the Reformed tradition, my background is Methodist/Anglican, and if you ask me, I'm more of a Whitehead/John Cobb kinda guy. But all this is terrifically interesting, and while I have read a bit of Barth, that felt nothing like this. To tell the truth, (giggle if you like) I had never heard of TULIP before! Thank you for being an excellent teacher.
This makes good sense, and tosses PSA into a cocked hat. I don’t want to undermine it, yet I see a problem. What shall we make of “Nevertheless, Thy will be done.”? What is that will? Christ clearly sees it with horror. It’s sublime, the very type of sublimity, but it does not fit your argument. I’d be glad to see you resolve this while keeping your argument
Good question. Three things. First, Gethsemane establishes that the cross was willed, which every atonement model requires; it doesn't establish what the cross accomplishes, which is what my essay is arguing about. Second thing, the cup referenced is not obviously the cup of wrath. In Mark 10, Jesus tells James and John they will drink the same cup and nobody thinks they drank divine retribution. Third, a petition assumes the one being petitioned can say yes. Turretin's God cannot. If vindicatory justice is essential to the divine nature, the Father has no discretion in that garden and there is nothing to ask for. The scene only works if God could have done otherwise, which is precisely what the Reformed account of things denies. The horror is real. I read it as the horror of a man who knows what Rome does to people like him. Thanks for reading!
I've struggled with PSA, and your post added to that struggle, in large part because I found the reasoning so persuasive. Like all serious things I sought a second opinion, and what follows is a equally persuasive retort from my pastor. I realize I'm sharing this as a intermediary of sorts between two learned men in this area, but feel it's worth sharing the response in its entirety: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1rKhyQe5fsIXON8yCUKtG70nkCevNjakecp9CUTl3WQQ/edit?usp=drivesdk
Hi Darren, thanks for passing this along, and please thank your pastor for reading the essay closely enough to argue with it. At length, no less. Some of what he says lands decently well, so I’ll start there.
He’s right that I didn’t work through Isaiah 53, 1 Peter 3, or Romans 3:24-26. The essay was intentionally a historical and logical argument about whether God had to require satisfaction, and the sacrificial texts require their own fight. I’m not dodging them. They just weren’t the focus. He’s also right that parables can’t carry a whole doctrine. I used those two for a narrow purpose, to show Jesus describing forgiveness as a loss somebody absorbs, and I wouldn’t claim more for them than that. Your pastor, being a pastor, is going to read things pastorally and devotionally. That wasn’t my aim in that piece, though I do work at that level elsewhere on Drink Wisely.
Several things he attributes to me I didn’t say. I never argued that substitution is an invention of the Reformation. Substitutionary language predates the sixteenth century by a mile. Justin and Chrysostom have Christ bearing the curse in our place, and I’m happy to grant it. My target is much narrower, the claim that God cannot forgive without punishing, which Turretin states outright and which Thomas and Scotus both denied. He also recruits Gregory of Nazianzus for PSA, which is a strange move given that the Gregory passage in my essay asks to whom the blood was offered and answers that the Father accepted it without ever demanding it. I’d love to hear how those two Gregorys get along!
He also says I’m unaware that God acts according to his nature. The essay has a section on exactly that. The real question is whether retribution belongs to God’s nature the way truthfulness does, and that ought to have an argument behind it rather than an assumption. Here’s where I’d put my cards on the table. I don’t believe retributive justice or wrath are constitutive of who God is in anything like the way scripture describes God as love. John doesn’t write that God has love, or has it in abundance, or expresses it when provoked. He writes that God is love. Nobody anywhere writes that God is wrath. Wrath in scripture is something God turns from, relents of, and is repeatedly talked out of by people who seem to understand it’s negotiable.
That’s the grammar of a response, not an attribute. So when your pastor says God’s nature includes perfect justice toward sin and therefore punishment is necessary, he’s smuggling the conclusion into the premise. And he does it while also saying God’s hands were not tied and offering to “do an Aquinas” by having God freely assume the role of impartial judge. He’ll need to pick one. If the judge’s role is freely assumed, the requirement lives in God’s will, which is the whole of what I was arguing. If it’s constitutive, then the “do an Aquinas” escape hatch is closed and he’s back to being buddies with Turretin.
On the charge that my view makes the cross unnecessary, I’d point out that Thomas held the cross was fitting and meaningful while denying it was strictly required, and he’s not usually accused of emptying Golgotha. Fittingness is a reason. A law is a constraint. I don’t cite Thomas because I’m bound to him in any way. I cite him because the tradition PSA’s defenders claim as their inheritance had this argument already and came down on the other side, and that history gets skipped more times than not.
Now the part we both danced around a little. Twice, maybe three times, your pastor hedges his argument with some version of “assuming Connelly is not a universalist.” Well. Bingo.
I hold to apokatastasis, the final restoration of all things to God. I’m in the lineage that runs from Gregory of Nyssa through George MacDonald to David Bentley Hart and Thomas Talbott, which is to say a position with better patristic credentials than people assume, held by a Cappadocian the church never condemned and whose brother-in-faith wrote the Easter sermon I quoted. I was an infernalist my entire life before this, and that older view never once sat easy with me. I like to think that I can finally articulate why and know there is a good reason for my unease.
This changes the force of two of his objections, so let me take them on directly. He asks why, on my logic, God doesn’t just save everyone regardless of their orientation toward sin or Christ. Nearly right. God does save everyone. Not regardless, though, and that’s where his question goes a bit sideways. Repentance isn’t a toll God collects before unlocking the door. Rather, it’s the shape the healing takes in my view. A person has to actually turn toward the physician for the surgery to do anything, and the claim I’d defend is that God can and will finally become every creature’s strongest inclination, given enough time and enough refining fire. Resistance is quite real. MacDonald was clear that it burns. Resistance is also, on my account, finite, and yet God is not. So grace gets resisted along the way yet never resisted finally. I might add that wrath is also finite. I don’t believe that it, or anything else, can be co-eternal with God.
He also says the destiny question depends on what a person must do to be saved rather than on which atonement model is correct, and that PSA and my view land in the same place for a grieving widow. That’s true only if you don’t follow the mechanics closely enough. If the cross is God absorbing a loss rather than collecting a payment, there’s no outstanding ledger left on which anyone can be held, and the entire category of the permanently uncollected debtor disappears. The atonement model and the universalism are the same argument wearing very different hats. That’s why I’d rather he engage the logic than wave at hypotheticals.
On the widow I sat with all those years ago, he and I may be closer than this exchange suggests. Her husband’s fate rests with the same God either way. My complaint is with the job description I handed God that afternoon; a deity who had to be satisfied before he was free to do what she was hoping for. That part I no longer believe, and I’d say so to her now if I could. I have even better good news these days.
If god loves you & god has known you since the womb, why would such a caring god allow you to suffer eternal pain & torment?
One might start with whether the stories about eternal damnation are true. We tend to treat the passages in the books of the Bible as direct descriptions of events witnessed by persons who weren’t diarists. Authorship is traditional not authenticated. Manuscripts are based on what has survived library fires & questionable transcription likely modified to support a particular theological position or argument.
Was there an itinerant preacher named Yoshua ben Yosef who threatened the rule of religious & secular powers? Quite likely. Did his followers spread a gospel of creating a heaven on earth by loving your neighbor? That seems to be the core message.
Was he Jewish with a notion of Gehenna & Sheol? Again, quite likely, where the former was associated with Hell & the latter was the more common reference for an afterlife as a place of of stillness and darkness.
Our description of Hell seems more Greek being modeled after Hades/Tartarus with the Devil replacing Hades brother of Zeus, mayor of Hadestown. One difference is that unlike the Devil, Hades wasn’t a chief tormentor, more an indifferent host of the place where just desserts were served.
I suspect Jesus would have leaned more into a Jewish concept of Sheol in parables & teaching rather than the Greek. The question is whether the descriptions of a tempter as the devil were part of Jesus’ message or added later when it spread into the Greco-Roman world?
When it comes to the question as to whether a particular individual is in heaven or not, there’s no definitive answer this side of the mortal coil.
I would answer that if you believe in a loving god & that the person in question was loved, then yes they are in heaven.
It’s a matter of loving & comforting your neighbor.
I would just like to take a moment to thank you for these essays. I do not come from the Reformed tradition, my background is Methodist/Anglican, and if you ask me, I'm more of a Whitehead/John Cobb kinda guy. But all this is terrifically interesting, and while I have read a bit of Barth, that felt nothing like this. To tell the truth, (giggle if you like) I had never heard of TULIP before! Thank you for being an excellent teacher.
What if it wasn’t about punishment at all?
What if God has one Word about sin and one Word about grace?
What if God is justified in the response to sin and also justified by forgiveness but in totally different ways?
This makes good sense, and tosses PSA into a cocked hat. I don’t want to undermine it, yet I see a problem. What shall we make of “Nevertheless, Thy will be done.”? What is that will? Christ clearly sees it with horror. It’s sublime, the very type of sublimity, but it does not fit your argument. I’d be glad to see you resolve this while keeping your argument
Good question. Three things. First, Gethsemane establishes that the cross was willed, which every atonement model requires; it doesn't establish what the cross accomplishes, which is what my essay is arguing about. Second thing, the cup referenced is not obviously the cup of wrath. In Mark 10, Jesus tells James and John they will drink the same cup and nobody thinks they drank divine retribution. Third, a petition assumes the one being petitioned can say yes. Turretin's God cannot. If vindicatory justice is essential to the divine nature, the Father has no discretion in that garden and there is nothing to ask for. The scene only works if God could have done otherwise, which is precisely what the Reformed account of things denies. The horror is real. I read it as the horror of a man who knows what Rome does to people like him. Thanks for reading!