Essay One - Introduction
John Calvin never heard of TULIP. Neither did anyone at the Synod of Dort. The well-known acronym that has organized Reformed teaching for a hundred years actually came out of a lecture given in Newark, New Jersey, by a Brooklyn pastor in 1905.
It’s appropriate to begin with Dort, since this series will keep returning to it. Jacobus Arminius, a Dutch Reformed pastor and professor at Leiden, had spent years raising objections to standard Reformed teaching on predestination, and after he died in 1609, his followers put his case in writing. That document, the Remonstrance of 1610, laid out five articles of disagreement, which is why we ended up with five points and not four or nine or twelve.1 The Dutch church answered by calling a national synod at Dordrecht, joined by delegates from Reformed churches across Europe, which met from November 1618 into the spring of 1619 and rejected the Remonstrance article by article.
Remonstrant ministers lost their pulpits over the debate. Some went into exile. Calvin himself had been dead since 1564, fifty-four years by that time, and had nothing directly to do with any of it.
The mnemonic arrived on the scene much later still. Cleland Boyd McAfee, at the time pastor of Lafayette Avenue Church in Brooklyn and later professor of systematic theology at McCormick Theological Seminary, used the word TULIP in a talk before the Presbyterian Union of Newark.2 William Henry Vail, a retired New Jersey physician and Presbyterian ruling elder who had been in the room, wrote it down eight years afterward for The Outlook, a general-interest weekly with Theodore Roosevelt on the masthead.3 Loraine Boettner borrowed the device for The Reformed Doctrine of Predestination in 1932, and Steele and Thomas printed it in a cheap paperback in 1963.4 That paperback is where most American evangelicals likely first encountered it, whatever they might think they inherited directly from the sixteenth century or even earlier.
McAfee’s original version was also not the one we use today. His U stood for universal sovereignty, for example. Unconditional election was substituted somewhere between the lecture and Boettner, and I have not been able to ascertain precisely who swapped them out. Though this substitution did indeed happen, the actual import of that fact isn’t as subversive as it first sounds. Unconditional election is closer to what Dort determined than universal sovereignty is, so the substitution actually improved the acronym’s accuracy. Accuracy to the findings of the synod, I should say, which is a different question from whether the doctrine is true. The interesting part about that, to me, is that the letters in the acronym were negotiable at all. Nobody treats an actual creed that way, right?
Vail did more than report the clever mnemonic; he went and asked around. He consulted several theological authorities on how they stated the five points and in what sequence, including Francis L. Patton, then retiring from the presidency of Princeton Seminary, and he found that the wording and the order varied in nearly every case he investigated. Jonathan Dickinson, first president of the College of New Jersey, had listed original sin as the second point with Romans 5:12 associated with it, a verse that will get its own stand-alone essay eventually. The one thing Vail’s authorities agreed on was that perseverance of the saints came last. Everything before that last letter did a lot of shuffling around.7
The sequence is really the smaller problem here. My argument in the essays ahead is with what the five points actually claim, and the order only becomes relevant because of how it hides the way those claims lean on each other. Put depravity first and each point looks like an independent finding, arrived at separately and confirmed by its own set of proof texts. Put election first and the underbelly of the structure shows, because most of what follows exists to defend that opening move.
Vail flagged that problem himself, in fact. He noted, in the same article that first put TULIP in print, that adopting the word constrains the order of the points and may throw them out of their proper logical sequence.3 The first person to publish the acronym said in the same breath that the spelling was at least potentially distorting the argument.
He was right, of course, and the Canons of Dort make it quite obvious. Dort’s heads of doctrine run in this order.5
1. Divine election and reprobation
2. The death of Christ and the redemption of human beings through it
3 & 4. The corruption of humanity and conversion to God, treated together as a single head (not two separate points)
5. The perseverance of the saints
Dort answered five Remonstrant articles in four heads, joining the third and fourth because the synod did not think human corruption and God’s work in conversion could be discussed apart from each other. A Reformed reader will point out, astutely, that the synod’s own title still refers to five main points of doctrine, so I am not claiming Dort had four of anything. What I am pointing at is the seam that is exposed here. Dort declined to split that head. The acronym splits it anyway, because a five-letter word needs five slots, and then it demotes election from first position to second to make the letters spell T.U.L.I.P. Whatever else you want to say about McAfee, he solved a memorization problem easily enough, and he solved it so well that his solution outlived the actual argument it was summarizing.
I openly concede the point a Calvinist reader (like I was for 30+ years) is likely already formulating. None of this historical detail means the doctrine itself is late. The content of the five points is old; it is Dort’s own, and TULIP is a fair enough summary of it. Anyone who thinks the acronym’s twentieth-century origin refutes anything it was constructed to convey has confused a simple mnemonic with a much more thorough-going theology. I don’t have interest in arguing against a caricature, and I am not going to pretend that catching Reformed teaching in a mere labeling error amounts to catching it in a theological mistake. Total depravity, unconditional election, limited atonement, irresistible grace, and perseverance of the saints are the doctrines I intend to take on in the strongest form their defenders can muster. Why? I remain indebted to my Reformed upbringing for many reasons and still hold onto some of the basic principles of Reformational thought although I don’t articulate them the same way anymore. Nonetheless, I want to be accurate and I want to be fair in my critique to respect and honor the good parts of the tradition without glamorizing the not-so-good parts.
I should also say that none of the history above is my own discovery, and it isn’t a case made by opponents of Calvinism. Kenneth Stewart, who teaches at Covenant College and is himself a convinced Calvinist, devoted a full chapter of Ten Myths About Calvinism to the argument that the acronym is late, imprecise, and treated with far more reverence than it has truly earned. He took real incoming fire from inside the tradition for saying so, unsurprisingly.6
A series like this can read as an attempt to embarrass people, and embarrassing anyone is not the project. TULIP is a memory aid, and a decent one. McAfee built it to help a room full of Presbyterians hold five arguments in their heads at once, and it worked so well that it’s still working a hundred and twenty years later. Memory aids are fallible by design, since they compress ideas, and compression always loses something of the substance in the process.
The trouble starts when the memory tool gets promoted up past its pay grade. I have heard the five points called nothing short of the very gospel itself. I have heard them used as a test of whether a person can be trusted to teach children. I have heard them described as the recovered original truth that the church misplaced for fifteen centuries and Geneva finally resurfaced.
The acronym is a hundred and twenty years old, folks. The canons behind it are four hundred years old. Whether the argument inside them runs in a straight line back through Augustine to Paul is a real claim one is certainly entitled to make, and it is the claim this series intends to test rather than simply assume.
Augustine belongs in the aforementioned lineage, and I won’t ignore him, since predestination and inherited guilt and the perseverance of the elect are all present in his late works and Dort knew exactly whose language it was using. Whether Augustine read Paul correctly is a separate question and a really good one. See, there is a Latin translation problem underneath it that is problematic and needs to be addressed on its own. As I’ve said before, an essay on this subject is forthcoming.
What the history shows us gives us permission to stop treating the acronym as somehow sacrosanct. The order is a memory aid, chosen by a working pastor, and questioned in print by the layman who first published it. So this series will run in the order the doctrine actually runs, for accuracy’s sake. I venture to guess that this may come as news for some Reformed devotees despite their extensive reading within that particular tribe.
Unconditional election first. After all, this is the engine that runs the entire construct. Everything downstream exists to explain how this doctrine works and to make it bearable.
Total depravity second. Depravity is the argument that makes election look necessary instead of simply arbitrary, which is why it functions better as a defense of election than as an independent starting point in terms of logical order.
Limited atonement third. This is the most sensitive point, and the place where Calvinists have never fully agreed with each other, and the place where a lot of people first noticed that something in the machinery of the construct was off and making a weird noise.
Irresistible grace fourth. Here the question stops being about God’s decisions and becomes a question about whether a human being is a participant in anything with regard to our desires, motivations, and actions.
Perseverance last, because assurance is where the whole apparatus finally makes contact with an actual person trying to sleep at night.
That order puts me closer to Dort than the beloved floral acronym does, which I find funny, and will probably keep pointing out. I do agree, though, that U.T.L.I.P. doesn’t quite have the same ring to it.
I want to note two things that this series will not do, by design. It will not relitigate the Remonstrant side of the argument, meaning the Arminian case that Dort was convened to reject, because I do not hold that position either, and a fight between two seventeenth-century Dutch factions is not the fight I am picking here. And it will not be exceedingly long, despite my tendency, since I’d actually like folks to read it through. These are brief pieces, written for people who want to know what the doctrines claim, stated accurately, before deciding whether the claims hold up against the texts they are said to originate from.
Each of the five points makes an argument about God and a corresponding argument about the reader, and each one claims Scripture as its basis and warrant. So the question in every essay is going to be the same one. Does the text really say this, or does the system just need it to?
In the next installment, we’ll start with election, because Dort started there.
Endnotes
1 The Five Articles of Remonstrance were drawn up at a gathering of Dutch Reformed pastors at The Hague in January 1610, following the death of Jacobus Arminius (1560-1609), and were signed by roughly forty pastors. Johannes Wtenbogaert, also rendered Uytenbogaert, took the lead in drafting them. The five articles addressed the basis of election, the extent of the atonement, the necessity of grace for any good, the resistibility of grace, and the question of whether believers can fall away. A Counter-Remonstrance followed in 1611 on behalf of the strict Calvinist party. The Synod of Dordrecht held its first session on 13 November 1618 and its one hundred fifty-fourth and last on 9 May 1619, with voting delegates present from Reformed churches in eight foreign countries.
2 Cleland Boyd McAfee (1866-1944) delivered the lecture before the Presbyterian Union of Newark, New Jersey, in 1905, while serving as pastor of Lafayette Avenue Church in Brooklyn. He taught systematic theology at McCormick Theological Seminary from 1912 to 1930, served as Moderator of the 141st General Assembly of the Presbyterian Church in the United States of America in 1929, and directed the Presbyterian Board of Foreign Missions from 1930 to 1936. He is more widely remembered as the author of the hymn “Near to the Heart of God.”
3 William H. Vail, “The Five Points of Calvinism Historically Considered,” The Outlook 104 (June 21, 1913), 394. Vail (1845-1943) graduated from the College of New Jersey in 1865, took an M.D. at the College of Physicians and Surgeons, Columbia, in 1868, and practiced medicine until 1886. He later served as secretary and treasurer of Blair Academy, sat on bank and railroad boards, and served as a trustee of Lincoln University in Pennsylvania, funding the construction of its Vail Memorial Library in 1898. He was a Presbyterian ruling elder and a Sunday school superintendent.
4 Loraine Boettner (1901-1990), The Reformed Doctrine of Predestination (Philadelphia: Presbyterian and Reformed, 1932), which grew out of the master’s thesis he wrote at Princeton Seminary; David N. Steele and Curtis C. Thomas, The Five Points of Calvinism: Defined, Defended, Documented (Philadelphia: Presbyterian and Reformed, 1963), ninety-five pages, with a preface by Roger Nicole. Boettner himself cautioned readers against identifying the five points too closely with the Calvinist system as a whole, since the system includes a great deal more. Steele and Thomas were Baptist pastors in Arkansas.
5 Canons of Dort, heads of doctrine. The third and fourth heads are treated as one under the title “The Corruption of Man and His Conversion to God.” The document’s full title refers to five main points of doctrine in dispute, so the synod counted five while organizing its answer into four.
6 Kenneth J. Stewart, Ten Myths About Calvinism: Recovering the Breadth of the Reformed Tradition (Downers Grove: InterVarsity, 2011). The relevant chapter is titled “TULIP Is the Yardstick of the Truly Reformed,” and an appendix extends the argument. For the response from within the tradition, see the multi-part review in The Standard Bearer, published by the Reformed Free Publishing Association. Stewart dates the acronym to roughly 1913, working from the Vail article as its earliest appearance in print, which is consistent with placing the coinage at the 1905 lecture Vail was describing.
7 The five points circulated as five points well before the acronym existed. R. L. Dabney’s The Five Points of Calvinism (Richmond: Presbyterian Committee of Publication, 1895) gave them as total depravity and inability, effectual calling, God’s election, particular redemption, and perseverance of the saints. Same content, different order, no flower. Dabney opens by conceding that the title itself has little historical accuracy or worth and that he uses it only because custom made it familiar.




Nicely written. I appreciate the wit, and I can't wait to read them!
Looking forward to the follow up pieces as well.
I think I suffered a Tulipian form of PTSD from the hardcore Calvinists I came across in the early 2000’s, pre social media where these convos were taking place in various blogs of “discernment ministries”. For those that had embraced after many years in “theological wilderness” it was as if they had just discovered penicillin.