Drink Wisely — Pouring Over Theology and Truth

Drink Wisely — Pouring Over Theology and Truth

First Church of Paul

Part I - Jesus preached the Kingdom. Paul preached Jesus. The tradition decided they were the same thing.

Shawn Patrick Connelly's avatar
Shawn Patrick Connelly
May 05, 2026
∙ Paid

The Protestant world I grew up in was, without knowing it, a decidedly Pauline enterprise. Paul in the morning service, Paul in the evening service, Paul in Sunday school. Romans explained salvation. Ephesians explained the church. Galatians explained grace. First Corinthians explained everything else. The Gospels made appearances on Christmas, Easter, and the occasional sermon illustration, but the actual theological architecture of the whole thing was Paul’s. Jesus was the reason for it all, of course, but Paul was the explanation of what the reason meant.

I didn’t notice this for a long time. Most people in most evangelical churches don’t, and there’s a structural reason for that. Evangelical theology is built on the presupposition that Scripture is a unified, harmonious whole, that the sixty-six books cohere into a single, non-contradictory revelation, and that any apparent tension between them is a problem of interpretation rather than a fact of the texts. This is not a neutral reading strategy. It’s a theological commitment, and it shapes the reading before it begins. If Paul and Jesus must agree, then every difference between them gets smoothed into agreement, and the reader never has to confront the possibility that the smoothing is the problem.

The logical structure here is important to examine on its own terms. The argument runs roughly like this: Scripture is inerrant and internally harmonious (assumed as a non-negotiable presupposition). Jesus and Paul appear to differ on significant theological points (an observable fact). Therefore, they cannot actually differ, and the appearance of difference must be resolved through interpretation. The conclusion is guaranteed in advance by the premise, which means the whole exercise is not really a reading of the texts at all. It is a performance of a reading whose outcome was fixed before it began. That is not exegesis. It is confirmation of a prior commitment, and it is the most consequential intellectual move in evangelical biblical interpretation.

It took me years of reading, some considerable discomfort, and eventually the slow admission that the discomfort was telling me something true, to see what had been in front of me the whole time. The man who preached the Sermon on the Mount and the man who wrote the letter to the Romans are working with genuinely different materials. They share a tradition, a God, and an inheritance. What they don’t share, at least not without significant interpretive labor, is a gospel. That statement will shock some readers, anger others, and for a few it will do both, which is itself a testament to how thoroughly the tradition has learned to read past the evidence.

That is not to dismiss Paul; it is a description of him. Paul was one of the most consequential thinkers in human history, a genuine theological architect who took a movement rooted in rural Galilee and made it legible to the Greek-speaking world. What he built is truly remarkable. It is also, in significant ways, his own construction.

I should say where I’m standing before I go any further. I no longer occupy the evangelical tradition I was formed in. I don’t hold many of its doctrines. These questions interest me for their own sake rather than as instruments of a predetermined verdict, and I’ve tried to follow them honestly rather than strategically. I’m not writing as a reformer trying to call the church back to a purer version of itself, and I’m not writing as a skeptic whose conclusion was fixed before the research began. I’m writing as someone who finds these questions genuinely interesting, who has done considerable reading, and who thinks the gap between what the texts actually say and what most people in the pews have been told they say calls for honest public examination.

“On this reading the Kingdom was imminent, cosmic, and, given that the world did not actually end on schedule, largely mistaken.”

User's avatar

Continue reading this post for free, courtesy of Shawn Patrick Connelly.

Or purchase a paid subscription.
© 2026 Shawn Patrick Connelly · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.