The Tour
Robert Kraft made one phone call, and by the end of the week Ed Sheeran didn’t have an opening act left on his own tour.
Quick recap for anyone who somehow missed it. Macklemore opened for Sheeran at MetLife Stadium this month, wore a keffiyeh, and told the crowd the reason he wanted this tour in the first place was so he could stand in stadiums and say two words that were very near and dear to his heart: Free Palestine.1 Kraft, who owns the Patriots and Gillette Stadium, decided Macklemore’s stage material and a pattern of what he called antisemitic rhetoric crossed a line he wasn’t willing to host, and Macklemore got dropped from the rest of the US dates. The walkouts followed right away. Finneas quit, then the Irish duo Beoga, who posted that the real enemy was “the zionist lobby” working to silence artists over a genocide happening in plain sight, then the folk artist Aaron Rowe, then the Danish band Lukas Graham, who apologized to fans on the way out.2
Sheeran, who says he had no hand in the removal, released a statement calling the war “a human tragedy” with “suffering and pain caused on both sides”, the kind of sentence written specifically to avoid saying much of anything at all.3
Macklemore had a more pointed line for it than Sheeran’s own statement did. He said Sheeran “couldn’t get past his public facing, ‘I don’t take sides.’”5 And the internet made the obvious point back to him. Refusing to pick a side during a mass killing is itself a side. Actor Liam Cunningham put it as bluntly as it can be put: “If you find yourself saying ‘I’m not taking sides’ during a genocide, you are.”4
The tour logistics are really just a sideshow here. What’s underneath is where American Christianity keeps failing the same test, at a bigger scale and for longer.
Whose Israel
Go back to this past June, for example, when Ted Cruz went on Tucker Carlson’s show to explain why the US should back Israel against Iran, up to and including regime change. Cruz didn’t reach for a national security-based argument. He reached for an interpretation of Genesis 12:3. “Those who bless Israel will be blessed, and those who curse Israel will be cursed,” he told Carlson, adding that he wanted to be on the blessing side of things. Carlson asked him a simple question: which book is that in? Cruz couldn’t produce chapter or verse.6 He’d absorbed a slogan from Sunday school and clearly never opened the passage himself, a detail that carries real weight given what he was proposing to do with it, because the actual verse never uses the word Israel at all. It’s God speaking to Abram, generations before Abram’s grandson gets renamed Israel, promising blessing to whoever blesses him.
That’s not a small distinction. The word “Israel” does triple duty in this argument: a person (Jacob, renamed after wrestling with God), an ancient covenant people descended from him, and a twentieth-century nation-state with a government, a military, and a foreign policy. Treating those three as interchangeable is exactly how a patriarch’s blessing turns into a Pentagon strike package.
Cruz isn’t a total outlier either. It’s the same verse Mike Huckabee, now the sitting US ambassador to Israel, has leaned on for years to argue the country’s boundaries were given “not by the United Nations but by almighty God7,” the same conviction behind the hat reading “Build Israel Great Again” he wore at a West Bank settlement, and the same instinct that had him declaring in 2008 that there’s “no such thing as a Palestinian.”8 When the Carlson-Fuentes mess broke this fall, Huckabee didn’t soften any of it. He went on a Christian talk show and doubled down, arguing that Christians and Jews live under two separate divine covenants, and that anyone who doubts God’s promises to the Jewish people has no basis for trusting God’s promises to Christians either.9 That’s a live foreign policy position, held by the man representing the United States government in Jerusalem. It also comes with some serious theological baggage of its own. Serious biblical scholarship, across Protestant, Catholic, and Orthodox traditions, doesn’t back a strict two-covenant split.
This isn’t a minor interpretive quibble. It’s a category error with real, tangible consequences. A blessing spoken to one man, refracted through a nation formed centuries later, does not translate cleanly into a blank check for the specific military conduct of a twenty-first-century government, and getting from one to the other takes several leaps that nobody in this crowd shows any sign of having examined much less been aware of. You can take Jewish safety and the “never again” commitment as seriously as the twentieth century demands and still refuse to treat a war cabinet as beyond criticism because a senator half remembers a Bible verse that isn’t even speaking about what he thinks it is.
The Other Failure
The opposite failure is growing right alongside it, and it gets far less scrutiny. In November, Tucker Carlson spent two cordial hours with Nick Fuentes, a young white nationalist who has praised Hitler, denied the Holocaust, and claimed Jewish loyalty to Israel and other Jews stands in the way of a unified American society.10 The interview split the conservative movement in half. Heritage Foundation president Kevin Roberts defended Carlson before backing off under staff revolt. Ben Shapiro tore into Carlson on air, saying he’d “decided to normalize and fluff Nick Fuentes” and calling him a coward for it.11 Trump, asked about the whole thing, shrugged and said people could decide for themselves.12
So one wing of the American Christian right treats a modern government as a literal extension of Abrahamic covenant, exempt from criticism because someone can recite half a verse. Another wing is sliding, with real audience numbers, toward the oldest conspiracy theory in the Western world, the one that blames a shadowy Jewish influence for whatever a movement doesn’t like about itself. Both of these are the same fundamental failure in opposite expressions. Neither side has read the material closely enough to have the foggiest idea it’s wrong.
What’s Actually Happening
None of that theological confusion changes what’s actually happening to the people on the ground in Gaza, which is the thing everyone keeps managing to avoid discussing while they argue over a rapper’s setlist. Gaza’s Health Ministry has reported more than 73,000 dead since October 202313, and several hundred more killed since the ceasefire that was supposed to have ended the killing. The International Court of Justice found back in January 2024 that South Africa’s genocide case against Israel was plausible enough to order Israel to take measures preventing genocidal acts; a case that’s still open.14 You don’t have to wait for the court’s final word to notice the scale of what’s already happened. If a theology requires defending that scale of death as righteous because the nation doing the killing shares a name with a Bible story, the theology is the real problem, not the rapper who got fired for objecting to it.
Macklemore’s crime, in Gillette Stadium’s accounting, was two words and a scarf. Whatever anyone thinks of his music, politics or his delivery, he ended up closer to the true moral center of this than the ambassador reciting real estate promises from Genesis, or the senator who can’t find his own proof text, or the pop star trying to keep both fan bases happy by saying nothing meaningful.
Inherited, Not Studied
Most American Christians never picked any of these positions, and that should trouble us more than it does. Almost nobody approaches Genesis 12, Romans 9 through 11, and two thousand years of Jewish and Christian argument about what those texts mean and arrives independently at “we should strike Iran” or “there’s no such thing as a Palestinian.” They inherited a slogan from a pastor who inherited it from a curriculum built a little over a century ago, on a specific and very much contested interpretive system called dispensationalism, spread less by careful exegesis than by a particular study Bible and a shelf of paperback novels about the so-called rapture. Ask most people holding this position to open the text and walk you through it, the way Carlson made Cruz attempt to do, and watch how fast it deteriorates into “I was taught” or “my Bible clearly says” territory. That’s inheritance; that’s programming, standing in for study and it currently governs how a nuclear-armed superpower spends its foreign policy capital.
The Side He Already Took
Which brings the whole thing back to Sheeran, standing in his own stadium with no opening acts left, insisting he doesn’t take sides as if it’s a virtue. In truth, he already did. He took it the moment he let the venues and the power brokers make the call for him. Declining to choose, when one side is literally dying and the other side is deciding whether the man who mentioned it still gets to open your show, is a pretty concrete decision. Silence isn’t neutral; it’s just quiet.
Update, September 18
The story kept moving after the rest of this piece was drafted. Kraft says Sheeran called him and asked him to commit two million dollars to humanitarian aid in the region, and that the call came before Macklemore’s public donation challenge went out.15 Macklemore pledged the entirety of his million-dollar net earnings from the tour to six organizations working directly with Palestinians. Kraft matched Sheeran’s two million, and framed the exchange as building bridges.
None of that changes what happened at Gillette Stadium, or the theology underneath it. It changes the shape of Sheeran’s non-answer. A check written quietly, with no public word for or against Gaza, still isn’t the same thing as taking a side. It may be the most honest version yet of the argument above: money moves easily when a name doesn’t have to move with it. The Gillette shows are still scheduled for September 25 and 26. This isn’t finished.
Endnotes
1. “Fellow opening acts quit after Ed Sheeran tour drops Macklemore,” CNN, September 15, 2026, https://www.cnn.com/2026/09/15/entertainment/ed-sheeran-macklemore-palestine-openers-quit-cec.
2. “Finneas, Aaron Rowe exit Ed Sheeran tour to protest Macklemore dropped over pro-Palestinian remarks,” NBC News, September 15, 2026, https://www.nbcnews.com/pop-culture/pop-culture-news/finneas-aaron-rowe-exit-ed-sheeran-tour-protest-macklemore-dropped-pal-rcna597948.
3. “Ed Sheeran Responds To The Macklemore Mess: ‘I Am Not Complicit,’” Daily Wire, September 2026, https://www.dailywire.com/news/ed-sheeran-responds-to-the-macklemore-mess-i-am-not-complicit.
4. “’Game of Thrones’ Star Has Blunt Message for Ed Sheeran Amid Macklemore Fallout,” Reality Tea, September 17, 2026, https://www.realitytea.com/2026/09/17/game-of-thrones-star-ed-sheeran-macklemore-fallout/.
5. “’Not Taking Sides Is Also Taking Sides’: Ed Sheeran Faces Fury for Staying Apolitical After Macklemore’s Tour Exit,” Fashion Times, September 2026, https://www.fashiontimes.co.uk/ed-sheeran-macklemore-us-tour-gaza-backlash-1764012.
6. “Ted Cruz cites Genesis 12:3 as ‘personal motivation’ for supporting Israel in heated Tucker Carlson interview,” The Christian Post, June 2025, https://assets.christianpost.com/news/ted-cruz-cites-genesis-123-for-support-of-israel.html.
7. “Fierce Israel Supporter Mike Huckabee Confirmed As Ambassador To Israel,” Daily Wire, https://www.dailywire.com/news/fierce-israel-supporter-mike-huckabee-confirmed-as-ambassador-to-israel.
8. “Trump nominates Mike Huckabee, evangelical hardliner, as U.S. ambassador to Israel,” Forward, November 2024, https://forward.com/fast-forward/674284/mike-huckabee-israel-ambassador-trump/.
9. “Mike Huckabee responds to Tucker Carlson fallout; suggests separate covenants with Christians, Jews,” The Christian Post, https://assets.christianpost.com/news/huckabee-suggests-separate-covenants-with-jews-christians.html.
10. “Nick Fuentes’ comments on the Tucker Carlson show sparks backlash from conservatives,” NPR, November 9, 2025, https://www.wuky.org/2025-11-09/nick-fuentes-comments-on-the-tucker-carlson-show-sparks-backlash-from-conservatives.
11. “Tucker Carlson interview with Nick Fuentes stirs controversy, conversation on antisemitism in GOP,” Spectrum News, November 3, 2025, https://spectrumlocalnews.com/us/snplus/news/2025/11/03/tucker-carlson-interview-with-nick-fuentes-stirs-controversy--conversation-on-antisemitism-in-gop.
12. “Trump defends Tucker Carlson after interview with Nick Fuentes, far-right activist known for his antisemitic views,” Associated Press via PBS NewsHour, November 17, 2025, https://www.pbs.org/newshour/politics/trump-defends-tucker-carlson-after-interview-with-nick-fuentes-far-right-activist-known-for-his-antisemitic-views.
13. “Robert Kraft Responds to Macklemore’s Challenge to Match $1 Million Donation to Palestinian Groups,” Billboard Canada, September 17, 2026, https://ca.billboard.com/music/music-news/robert-kraft-responds-macklemore-ed-sheeran-asked-donate.
14. International Court of Justice, Order on the Request for the Indication of Provisional Measures, South Africa v. Israel, January 26, 2024; coverage via Al Jazeera, https://www.aljazeera.com/amp/news/liveblog/2024/1/26/israels-war-on-gaza-live-icj-to-rule-on-south-africas-genocide-case.
15. “Billionaire Kraft says Ed Sheeran sought $2 million aid donation from him amid fracas over Macklemore’s Palestine comments,” CNBC, September 17, 2026, https://www.cnbc.com/2026/09/17/kraft-ed-sheeran-macklemore-palestine.html.




The OT prophets criticized Israel. A very patient God eventually divorced the evil Israelites, who were removed from the land they had been promised. It's still theirs? Give me a break. Truth-tellers are still the good guys.