Essay Seven – Conclusion
The Canons of Dort end with a section most people never read, titled the Rejection of False Accusations. (This is not to be confused with the section on the airing of grievances.) In it, the synod complains about being misrepresented. It denies teaching that God is the author of sin, or a tyrant, or a hypocrite, and it asks to be judged on the basis of the churches’ own official confessions rather than on accusations, or on stray remarks by individuals quoted out of context. Then it closes by urging ministers to handle all of this in a godly and reverent manner, in the schools and in the churches, with an eye to the glory of God’s name, holiness of life, and the comfort of anxious souls.1
Okay, maybe it is the airing of grievances after all.
Since I have no interest in contributing to more fake news where the synod is concerned, I have tried to give it that fair hearing for six essays. I quoted the articles themselves where I could rather than the caricature. I also attempted to grant the strongest version of each point before disassembling it. And the last essay was precisely about an anxious soul, which is what Dort said it was for, right?
Now I am going to do something unexpected that the synod would like considerably less than a mere caricature of their construct. I am going to redeem the five points or at least make an attempt to open them up to their broader, deeper implications.
This wasn’t at all my intention going into this project. Here is what I honestly didn’t anticipate when I started.
I initially endeavored to explain why I had left the Reformed formation of my youth (and most of my adulthood). I assumed the series would be a rather laborious accounting of reasons for the rejection of what I had previously embraced: five essays of ‘I used to believe this and here is why I don’t anymore.’ That is not exactly what happened.
The further into the work I got, the more I found myself conceding things back just a bit. The arguments the mnemonic kept bringing to mind turned out to be better than I remembered and the places where they failed kept turning out to be narrower than I anticipated. Somewhere around the fourth essay, I had more or less stopped dismantling much of anything and started reassembling it in a way that suggested there was always more substance there than the language allowed.
There is a phrase for this the tradition also gave me that I want to use carefully here for illustrative purposes, because it has a particular history that should, frankly, humiliate anyone who uses it too casually.
Ecclesia reformata, semper reformanda secundum verbum Dei. The church reformed, always being reformed according to the Word of God.
Ask where that Latin phrase came from and the answer is uncomfortably familiar. It traces to Jodocus van Lodenstein, a Dutch pastor trained at Utrecht under Voetius, who served in Utrecht from 1653 until his death in 1677. This places him approximately one generation downstream of Dort, inside the church the theology of the synod built. The devotional work is usually dated 1674, though it came out in parts and the dating runs on to 1678. And the phrase remained more or less unused until Karl Barth revived it in 1947, after which it became the slogan you now see on seminary letterhead and theology bro tattoos.2
A Dutch phrase from decades after the synod, mostly dormant for centuries, popularized in the twentieth century and now used constantly for purposes its author would likely not recognize. That’s the part I wanted to mention. If it sounds vaguely familiar, it should. It’s the exact same biography of the mnemonic I spent this series analyzing. I ought not complain about a mnemonic outliving its argument and then toss in another slogan that did basically the same thing.
So we should take the following criticism seriously, because it is well founded. Michael Horton and others have argued that van Lodenstein was concerned with piety and practice rather than doctrinal innovation, that the phrase presumes doctrinal stability instead of licensing revision, and that the full version ends secundum verbum Dei, according to the Word of God, which is a constraint not a permission slip. There is a further grammatical point too. Reformanda is passive. Always being reformed. The church is the object and God is the agent acting on it in this instance, which is an entirely different notion than the popular understanding of it as meaning simply ‘always reforming.’
All of that is, technically, correct and that’s okay. I didn’t revise anything here to suit my purposes. I went back to what the canons actually say, article by article, and back to the texts they cite, and I stayed there for six essays. That is secundum verbum Dei working as an actual restraint rather than as a virtue-signaling motto, which it often does. And the word’s passive voice turns out to be the most honest description of what happened to me during the course of writing. I did not intend to reform the five points. I meant to document and explain my exit from them and the material ended up reforming me in a sense.
So here is the accounting of what survived and what I had to retool in order to keep it serviceable. Perhaps the biggest surprise in this is the fact that there is actually very little that I adulterated in order to make peace with the points.
Total depravity is right about the diagnosis and right about the inability parts. Human beings are indeed in structural trouble and cannot climb out of that trouble under their own power. What had to go was the idea of a will that has stopped existing rather than one pulling hard in the wrong direction. I’ll add that Dort itself grants more than its heirs admit here, and the better name for the doctrine was always total inability, for that reason. This is closer to what the tradition really means and what the canons actually argue. So, total inability. So far, so good.
Unconditional election is right that God chooses, right that the choosing is unconditional, and right that nothing in the chosen (us) accounts for it. What had to go this time was the assumption that God’s choosing is a selection for one’s final destination. The concept of election in the texts is a call to a task and that task is other people. Abraham is chosen so all the nations get blessed through him. Israel is chosen to be a light to the whole world. The choosing is real enough and it is about a commission rather than the issuance of a personal boarding pass.
That points at a much older habit, and it is one of the weightier things evangelicalism ever taught me. We tend to make everything about ourselves. Not out of arrogance, exactly, but because the entire apparatus is fashioned around the individual and his eternal outcome. Election turns into a question about whether my name is on a list or it’s not. The gospel turns into a description of a transaction by which I secure my own future. Discipleship devolves into maintenance on that transaction. And the functional purpose of the Christian life shrinks down to making sure I end up in the right place when I die.
Read Paul’s election and predestination language through that lens and of course it looks like a discussion of individual destinies. That is the only thing that lens can see. N. T. Wright and others have spent decades arguing that the emphasis actually lies elsewhere; that Paul is talking about a people called to a purpose in the world and about God keeping promises he made to Israel.3 Personal salvation is entailed in all that, yes. It simply is not the primary point being made, and I find myself standing firmly with Wright on this one.
Limited atonement is right that the cross actually accomplishes something rather than simply offers something, which is the argument I used to preach and still find pretty close to airtight. The word in the acronym that has to go, though, is ‘limited.’ Dort’s own second head says the sacrifice is sufficient for the sins of the whole world. So, I propose we say limitless atonement instead, and I am not even the first person with a Reformed pedigree to say so.
Two things before I move on from that one, because I compressed it and the compression isn’t fair to the other side.
First, why insist on a limitation at all? Not because anybody thinks the cross came up short on power. Dort is emphatic that the sacrifice carries infinite worth. Not because God lacked the knowledge or the capacity to apply it more widely. The limitation sits entirely in the divine will. God intended that death to redeem the elect, doing otherwise was fully available to him, and he chose not to. Why he intended it that way is not disclosed to us anywhere, and the tradition does not pretend otherwise. It is God’s good pleasure, sealed, and that is the entire answer. I want to be fair about how serious a move that is. The tradition is declining to speculate about something Scripture never explains, which is more disciplined than a great deal of what gets said about the atonement from every direction.
Second, when I say two of the men who signed the canons believed Christ died in some real sense for everyone, a Reformed reader will want to correct me immediately, and I want to get ahead of it. Of course the cross benefits everyone in some sense. Common grace, the restraint of evil, the sincere offer of the gospel to all who hear it. None of that amounts to redemptive efficacy for the non-elect, and nobody claims it does. But that is not what Davenant and Ward held. Their position was stronger and stranger. They held that God appointed the death of his Son as a remedy genuinely applicable to every human being, and grounded a real conditional covenant on that appointment, so that the offer made from every pulpit has something actual standing behind it. That is a claim about what the atonement was intended for, not a claim about its side effects.4
Irresistible grace is kept intact, word included. Grace achieves precisely and completely what it intends and cannot finally fail. Right on. The only thing that had to go was the boundary drawn around whom that grace is intended for. The tradition has spent more than four centuries apologizing for the word irresistible while defending the doctrinal concept. I would keep the word and widen the number of people it references to include everybody. Everyone can agree, I think, that resistance occurs. That the resistance we offer is not final and full is where the disagreement lies.
Perseverance of the saints is right that assurance has to rest on something outside the self, which is the only kind that survives a bad patch of life. What had to go was the mechanism, which offered comfort via concealment rather than by actual change. And the subject needs correcting, which Dort would half agree with, I think, since its own argument is that the holding is not being done by us. Perseverance of God, then. Or, alternatively, I can also get behind the preservation of the saints.
That’s five for five and look at the shape of it after my makeover.
Every single point is correct about God’s initiative and incorrect only about the boundary drawn around it. It’s all about the scope and scale of God’s work. The error is never in the doctrine itself; it’s the fencing we put up. Which means what I have been doing for six essays now isn’t demolition at all. It is removing a perimeter we erected to cordon off God’s mercy to some and discovering that most of it functions even better without it.
This revelation raises an obvious question. Why is there a fence around each of these points in the first place?
It took me until the sixth essay to really see it, but in every case the fence requires that God operate from the outside. Here’s why that is significant.
Election as a selection requires God to stand at a vantage point outside the people he is selecting, apart from them, reaching in. Limited atonement requires a transaction, which requires two separate parties on either side of it. Irresistible grace requires force applied to a will from somewhere other than where that will already is, which is why the word immediately sounds coercive and why the tradition keeps trying to equivocate it. Imputation requires a magistrate on the bench and a defendant on the stand. Penal substitution requires a judge who must be satisfied before he is free to act.
Not one of those pictures works unless God is an extrinsic agent over against his creation, operating on it from a position external to it. Take that presupposition away and the fences we erect have nothing left to stand on.
Somebody will object here that I am trampling all over God’s transcendence. That God is wholly other, not one more item in the furniture of the universe, and that what I am describing risks collapsing the distinction between Creator and creature. That worry is legitimate, and sloppy versions of what I am about to describe do exactly that, so I am not going to wave it off.
But look at which picture actually protects transcendence.
A God who operates on creation from outside it is a God with a location, standing in some relation to a place, positioned over against other things. That is a being among beings. A very large and very powerful one, certainly, but still one item in the inventory. The classical tradition has insisted for a very long time that God is not in a genus, not a member of any category, not one of the things that happen to exist, but rather the ground of there being anything at all. Which is exactly why the word outside cannot apply to him. Outside is a spatial relation between two objects that share a frame, and God does not share a frame with anything.5
That makes the external God the smaller of the two, shrunk down into an agent with coordinates. Saying that all things exist in God takes divine transcendence more seriously than saying God stands off at a distance working the controls.
Hell is the interesting exception to everything I’ve just laid out, and I want to deal with it separately, because the popular version and the serious version are nowhere near the same. The popular version needs an address. Hell is a place God sends people to and then stays away from, which is how most of us were taught it and which is what people picture when the word comes up. That version needs God to be outside in the most literal sense available. But any Reformed reader with a decent grasp of the material will tell you that is not the actual doctrine. Hell is not the absence of God. Hell is the presence of God in his wrath. Revelation has the condemned tormented in the presence of the Lamb, and the one text that seems to say otherwise turns on a Greek preposition that scholars have argued about for a very, very long time.6
I am not going to argue with the latter definition, surprisingly. I think it is largely correct, and I think it is the single most important thing the tradition says about hell.
Notice what it concedes, though. If hell is God present in wrath, then nobody is ever anywhere God is not. The whole spatial picture has already been given up by the best version of the doctrine, and what remains is one fire, one presence, experienced very differently depending on the condition of the one experiencing it. Which is word for word what Isaac of Nineveh said in the seventh century and what I landed on in the last essay.7
So we agree about where God is, right? We agree about what is being suffered. What we do not agree about is whether the encounter ever ends and whether it has a purpose. The fence around hell is not a wall in physical space. It is a wall in time, and it is the claim that this particular work of God is the only work of God that never finishes for some reason.
Which brings me to a word that always requires careful definition, because it will inevitably be misread no matter how carefully I define it. That word is panentheism.
Not pantheism. Pantheism says God is identical with the universe, that the sum of everything is what the word God names, and that there is no remainder. I do not believe that and neither does anyone I am drawing on for historical or scholarly support.
Panentheism, on the other hand, says all things exist in God. Creation is not God. God is not the sum of creation and is not exhausted by it. But nothing that exists, exists outside of God, because there is no outside of God.
Paul told the Athenians that in God we live and move and have our being. Colossians says all things hold together in Christ. Ephesians has one God and Father of all, above all and through all and in all. And Paul’s own destination for the whole story, at the end of the great resurrection chapter, is that God may be all in all.8
If that is where this is all going, then the fences we made never actually had any utility.
Election is not God standing apart from humanity and reaching in to pick out particular people, because there is nowhere to stand that is apart from humanity. Grace is not force applied from elsewhere, because there is no elsewhere for it to be applied from. And the fire is not a furnace God built and then abandoned. The fire is God, met by a self not yet able to bear him.
A well-catechized reader will point out that classical theism already affirms every bit of this. God is omnipresent. God sustains all things at every instant. Acts 17 is in their confessions too, and no orthodox theologian has ever claimed God is some large man actually located somewhere up in the sky. So what exactly am I really arguing against here?
Fair, and I concede it entirely at the level of propositions. Nobody denies divine omnipresence with a straight face. My claim is narrower and it is about something other than propositions. It is about the picture running underneath the doctrines when they do their actual work. You can affirm omnipresence in chapter two of your systematic theology and then spend chapter eleven describing a courtroom, chapter twelve describing a transaction, and chapter fourteen describing a condition the condemned never leave. The confession says one thing and the operative image says another, and the operative image is what shapes how a fourteen-year-old lies awake in the middle of the night doing soul math.
Again, I am not asking anyone to deny omnipresence. Rather, I am asking what happens to the five points if you allow God’s omnipresence all the way in instead of just up to the fence. This is also where the notion of relational trinitarianism stops being a fancy phrase and starts doing something important. If the persons of the Trinity are constituted by their relations rather than being three isolated substances that happen to get along, then relation is not something that is added to being. It is what being is. Which makes total inability a claim about isolation rather than a claim about broken equipment. A self cut off from relation genuinely cannot move itself, because a self cut off from relation isn’t a whole self. That is a truer account of the human condition than the one I was taught, and it is the same doctrine put a different way.
So here is where I land, stated as plainly as I can.
Total inability. Unconditional election, understood as a call to a task. Limitless atonement. Irresistible grace, with no boundary drawn around it. The Perseverance of God.
I am not trying to destroy the mnemonic. I am trying to salvage it. What I have described across these seven essays is not an alternative to the five points and it is not a novel replacement for them. It is the five points with the fences taken down, and I think it lands closer to what the texts actually say than the version I knew, and closer to what the older church believed than anything that came out of Dordrecht in 1619.
We’ll end this series on a verse I have circled three times now without landing on it. Paul says the Son hands the kingdom over to the Father, and that the last enemy destroyed is death, and that the end of the whole business is that God may be all in all. Gregory of Nyssa, a Cappadocian bishop and one of the men who gave us the creed, wrote an entire treatise on that sentence and concluded from it that nothing is finally lost.9
All in all. Not most in most. Not some in some.
There is no outside of God. There never was.
Endnotes
1 Canons of Dort, Conclusion, titled “Rejection of False Accusations.” The synod denies, in its own words, that its teaching “makes God the author of sin, unjust, a tyrant, and a hypocrite,” and asks readers to form their judgment about the faith of the Reformed churches “not on the basis of false accusations” or of personal statements “often either quoted out of context or misquoted and twisted to convey a different meaning,” but “on the basis of the churches’ own official confessions.” The closing exhortation to ministers is that the doctrine be handled “with a view to the glory of God’s name, holiness of life, and the comfort of anxious souls.” Quotations throughout this series follow the English translation of the Canons approved in 2011 by the Christian Reformed Church in North America and the Reformed Church in America. Translation © 2011, Faith Alive Christian Resources, Christian Reformed Church in North America. Two phrases used earlier in the series, “neither able nor willing” in the Third and Fourth Main Points and “sufficient to expiate the sins of the whole world” in the Second, are given in the older public-domain English rendering because those are the forms in which they circulate and the forms the essay titles depend on.
2 The phrase ecclesia reformata, semper reformanda secundum verbum Dei is generally traced to Jodocus van Lodenstein (1620-1677), a pastor of the Dutch Nadere Reformatie who studied under Gisbertus Voetius at Utrecht and ministered there from 1653 until his death. The devotional work is Beschouwinge van Zion, usually dated 1674 and issued in parts at Amsterdam through 1678. Theodor Mahlmann’s study of the slogan’s history, Ecclesia semper reformanda: Eine historische Aufklärung (2010), establishes that the familiar Latin formula is considerably later than the popular attribution suggests. Karl Barth gave the phrase its modern currency in 1947. For the argument that its present usage inverts van Lodenstein’s intent, see Michael Horton, “Reformed and Always Reforming,” in Always Reformed: Essays in Honor of W. Robert Godfrey, 116-134.
3 The vocational reading of election runs through much of N. T. Wright’s Pauline work. The Climax of the Covenant (Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1991) is where the Israel-vocation argument is worked out in detail, and Paul and the Faithfulness of God (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2013) is the fullest statement of the whole case. Cited by general attribution here, as in “A Definite Number of Particular People.”
4 Canons of Dort, Second Main Point, Articles 3 and 8. On the distinction between the common-grace benefits of the cross and Davenant’s stronger claim about ordained sufficiency, see Michael J. Lynch, John Davenant’s Hypothetical Universalism: A Defense of Catholic and Reformed Orthodoxy (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2021), discussed at length in “Sufficient for the Sins of the Whole World.”
5 That God is not a member of any genus is a standard claim of classical theism, stated by Thomas Aquinas at Summa Theologiae I.3.5 and resting on the prior argument that God’s essence and existence are not distinct. David Bentley Hart makes the same point against modern theistic personalism in The Experience of God: Being, Consciousness, Bliss (Yale University Press, 2013).
6 Revelation 14:10, where the condemned are tormented in the presence of the holy angels and in the presence of the Lamb. The text usually cited on the other side is 2 Thessalonians 1:9, and whether the Greek apo prosōpou means separation from the Lord’s presence or destruction proceeding from it has been disputed for a very long time. The essay states the dispute without resolving it.
7 Isaac of Nineveh on the fire of divine love is discussed at length in “According to the Measure of Their Faith.”
8 Acts 17:28; Colossians 1:17; Ephesians 4:6; 1 Corinthians 15:28.
9 1 Corinthians 15:24-28. Gregory of Nyssa, In Illud: Tunc et Ipse Filius, his treatise on 1 Corinthians 15:28, cited previously in “Sufficient for the Sins of the Whole World.”
10 The essays referenced in the accounting are, in order, “Neither Able Nor Willing,” “A Definite Number of Particular People,” “Sufficient for the Sins of the Whole World,” “Pour Forth Light All Around,” and “According to the Measure of Their Faith.” The series opened with “Out of Order.”
11 Scripture references in this essay: Acts 17:28; Romans 5:12; 1 Corinthians 15:24-28; Ephesians 4:6; Colossians 1:17; Revelation 14:10; 2 Thessalonians 1:9. Paraphrased throughout; NRSVue per house style for any direct quotation.




This has been an interesting journey with much to chew on. Thank you.
Very nice. You mentioned Panentheism in an earlier piece, and I thought you might be headed there. It solves a number of problems for you, and nicely "takes down some fences". Panentheism also usually infers at least some part of God that exists beyond Creation, and I sense that could open some other interesting doors for you. I once spent a good 75 pages trying to get around Theodicy questions, but I never got it to work. Really enjoy your work, and hope to read more.