Essay Six – Perseverance of the Saints
Long before I had ever heard of the Synod of Dort, I would often lie awake doing rudimentary math on my own soul.
The scene typically went something like this. God wanted me saved and had done everything on his end to make it possible, and the remaining variable was my faith. Not whether I had any. Whether I had the right kind, and enough of it, and whether it was the sort that would stick. That is a genuinely terrible thing to put on a fourteen-year-old at two in the morning, because there is no tangible instrument for measuring it. You cannot weigh your own trust; measure your own faith. You can only ask whether it feels like enough, and at that time of the morning it rarely does.
Sin made it worse, as sin does. Every failure mounted up as evidence in a case I was always building against myself. And I had the proof text ready, because I had been taught it well and often. You will know them by their fruits.1 My fruit was far too frequently rotten or at least well past its sell-by date. I could see it plainly, and so could anybody who lived with me, I’m sure. That verse was presented to me as a means of evaluating other people’s actions and behaviors and I turned it immediately on myself, which I suspect is what most sincere, introspective people end up doing with it too.
So when I encountered Reformed theology for the first time in my mid-teens, the fifth point in the mnemonic did not wound me further. It rescued me.
That detail is important at the outset, because the previous five essays have all been arguments against things I used to embrace, and this one begins with gratitude instead. The doctrine of the perseverance of the saints took a young man who was constantly auditing his own regeneration and gave him somewhere more solid to stand upon. That is not a small feature. It is the warmest, most hopeful thing the Synod of Dort ever produced and I have no interest in tearing that down now.
So here is what the fifth head actually says, which is awfully revealing about the Christian life and considerably kinder about God. Believers in this life are never entirely free from sin, and blemishes cling to even the best of their works. Left to their own devices, they could not remain standing for even an afternoon. What preserves them instead is God’s faithfulness rather than the strength of their grip.
That last sentence, incidentally, is Jonathan Edwards and it is the actual argument of the sermon everybody thinks they know to be something else. Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God survives in the public memory as a spider dangled over a flame, and people come away picturing a God who is just itching to let it go. Read it again, carefully, and observe where the emphasis of the scene actually falls. It falls on the hand keeping the spider suspended. The entire sermon is about what is holding the sinner up, which is the only reason anyone is still standing at all.2 I spent years making that case to people who had encountered Edwards exactly once in their life, in a high school textbook, and had understandably drawn a very different conclusion.
The doctrine of perseverance makes no promise that the road is going to be smooth. Dort says flatly that true believers can fall into serious sins, that they sometimes commit what the canons call monstrous sin, that they grieve the Spirit and interrupt the exercise of faith and lose the awareness of grace for a time.3 David and Peter are the examples the synod reaches for, which makes for quite a revealing pair. One denied Christ on the record three times in a single night. The other committed adultery and then arranged a man’s death to cover it up. Peter’s is the more famous failure, perhaps, but David is the one standing in the back saying hold my beer.
The claim is both narrow and enormous at once. The elect fall, sometimes catastrophically, and are still not finally lost, because the holding is not being done by them.
Two specific things in that statement carried me for the better part of three decades.
The first was what I’ll call the logic of non-earning. I did nothing to obtain this gift, therefore I can do nothing to forfeit it. Faith itself was the gift, not the price of the gift. God bought me and God would keep me. That argument struck me as close to unassailable back then and I will say now, without equivocation, that a nuanced version of it still does.
The second was the doctrine of imputation. Whatever remained of me, and plenty remained, God was not looking at it. He was looking at the righteousness of Christ laid over me like a covering. My rotten fruit had been accounted for in advance, already forgiven, and no longer admissible as evidence against me.
Quick aside, I came very close to getting simul iustus et peccator tattooed on my arm some years ago. Righteous and a sinner at the same time. I never did it, but I thought about it seriously enough to consider placement and design.
Look at what those two ideas really indicate, though, because they do not behave the same way in a field test.
The first one holds. It holds so well, in fact, that I still hold it. An assurance grounded in something outside yourself is the only kind that can survive a bad month, or year, or decade, and the instinct behind it is the same one that made me argue for an effectual atonement rather than a merely potential one. I have not given that up. In fact, it has since widened.
The second one is where I want to pump the brakes a little, however.
Imputation relieves the anxiety by removing the person from view. The comfort in it is that God is looking at someone else standing where you are. That works, and I can testify that it works, but it also leaves the actual man underneath entirely untouched. Still rotten, by his own account. Just no longer under inspection.
Consider that notion alongside the image I wrote about in the last essay. George MacDonald’s consuming fire burns the dross out of the ore until what is left is pure metal.4 Imputation can be thought of almost like covering the ore and calling it pure gold. One of those actually changes what a thing is, intrinsically. The other only really changes what God is looking at.
I largely took my comfort from the second one for most of my life. I now double down on the first.
And there is a further problem in Dort’s fifth head that I didn’t notice while it was providing me comfort all those years, which is that it quietly hands the anxious person back their own charges. Here’s what I mean.
Article 9 says believers obtain assurance of their perseverance according to the measure of their faith.5 Read that with the two-in-the-morning anxiety in mind. Assurance scales with faith. So the man whose faith feels thin gets thin assurance, which is exactly the man who came looking for reinforcement. The doctrine is calibrated to reassure the people who need the reassurance the least.
Article 10 then names three grounds for that assurance. Faith in God’s promises, which is solid. The testimony of the Holy Spirit witnessing with our spirit, which is interior and unfalsifiable in both directions. And third, a serious and holy desire to preserve a good conscience and to perform good works.6
There it is, written right into the confession. The third ground of assurance is an inspection of your own desires and your own works. Which is to say the fruit test, the one I had been agonizing over before I ever got to Dort, is not something anxious people import into the doctrine by mistake. It is in the document, and it is listed as a source of comfort. I concede it certainly can be that, when directed outward. When directed inward, however, comfort is seldom the result.
To the synod’s credit, Article 11 concedes what follows. Believers contend with doubts, and under severe temptation they do not always experience the full assurance the previous articles describe.7 That is an honest admission that the comfort does not always arrive. It is also, if you are the person it failed to reach, not really much help in the moment.
When somebody came to me some years ago afraid they had perhaps never truly believed, or afraid that they had lost it, I had an answer ready and I gave it warmly, because I truly meant it. If you believe and trust in Jesus Christ as Lord and Savior, if you have put your trust wholly in him and in what he did for you, then you can be confident that God has saved you. And here is the best part. Because you did not earn any of this, you cannot lose it. God turned your heart of stone into a heart of flesh and enabled you to respond to him in faith. Even that faith you exercised was a gift. He bought you and he will keep you. There is remaining sin, of course there is, but it has no real claim on you anymore. When God looks at you, he sees Christ and his righteousness. And if the person seemed the slightest bit theologically savvy, I would add this detail, that salvation is monergistic and sanctification is synergistic, God’s work alone in the first case and cooperatively in the second.
I believed every word and most of it, I have to confess, I still find quite appealing and beautiful. If you read that first line again, though, a problem arises. It reads, If you believe and trust.
The person sitting in front of me had come in asking precisely whether or not they did. Whether what they had was the real thing or just a good imitation of it. How could they tell? And my answer, kind and orthodox and sincerely meant, handed the question straight back to them. The whole thing hung on that word ‘if,’ and the if was about the one thing they could not get a clear read on.
That detail I offered actually made the situation worse, or potentially so. If sanctification is the cooperative part, God and us working together, then the visible evidence of my own effort is the one thing in the equation I am told I must contribute. So the worried person goes looking there, at the fruit or lack thereof, at whether there is enough of it and its quality. Which is, in effect, taking them right back where they started.
I do not know what else I could have told them from inside that system. That is the real point I want to make in this story more than a confession of malpractice on the part of a church leader. The answer was the best answer available, and the best answer available just returns the person to the question they began with.
The supporting structure around it worked the same way too.
We required a credible profession of faith for church membership. In practice, that meant a credible testimony of some sort. How and when you came to faith, what you understood that faith to be, whether you could articulate the basics reasonably well. Notice what that examination quietly requires. A datable conversion, an event with a before and an after, which can be a difficult thing to require of somebody raised in the church who never had a definitive moment because they never had an interval outside it.
In fairness, I can hardly remember a time the test failed anyone seeking membership. The screen was intentionally gracious. Almost everyone got through. But the screen existed, and everyone knew it existed, and a test you are sure to pass is still a test you have to take.
And then there is the discipline aspect, which is where I noticed something I had participated in for years without ever looking at completely squarely.
If someone left, or was deemed to have fallen away or succumbed to willful sin, we would try to understand the situation, determine whether there was indeed grievous and willful sin in it, and if there was, bar them from the Lord’s Table for a time. If there was no eventual repentance, the end of that road was formal excommunication from the church, still with the hope of restoration.
That is the confessional process exactly as written. Westminster lists six purposes for church censure, and the first one on the list is the reclaiming and gaining of offending brethren. Admonition first, then suspension from the Supper for a season, then excommunication, graduated to the nature of the offense.8 The whole apparatus is built to eventually get the person back into the fold. Suspension is temporary by design. Restoration is the expected outcome and the door stands open throughout.
Even the final step doesn’t close it. Matthew 18 says that the person who will not listen even to the church should be to you as a Gentile and a tax collector, and that line gets read as the door slamming.9 Look at who said it, though. Consider how that man conducted himself around Gentiles and tax collectors. He ate with them constantly and got in trouble for it. The instruction is to treat the unrepentant as an outsider, and outsiders are the people the entire ministry was aimed at. At that point, the aim is evangelism, not shunning.
Reformed church discipline, in other words, is inherently remedial at its core, all the way down to its last resort maneuver.
And the proof text underneath this procedure is 1 Corinthians 5:5, where Paul hands a man over to Satan for the destruction of the flesh so that his spirit may be saved on the day of the Lord.10 Destruction with a specific purpose attached. Suffering as a means to an outcome. The passage authorizing the harshest thing a session can do to a person describes it as a pathway to that person’s final restoration, not their rejection.
That is basically MacDonald’s furnace, in Paul’s own words, sitting there in the footnotes of the Westminster Confession.
So the church session practiced corrective punishment on the theory that the offender could and should still be recovered, while teaching that God’s punishment of the unrepentant is retributive and eternal and recovers no one it falls on. The church was more hopeful about the wayward sinner’s temporal destiny than its own doctrine of hell permitted God to be about the sinner’s eternal destiny. I sat in those meetings. I never once noticed this before. I’m still blown away by this realization.
Which brings me to the objection this whole series has been building toward, and which somebody is going to put in the comments before the day is out. If everyone gets home eventually, why bother with any of it. Why faith, why devotion, why good works, why be moral at all.
Three things about that.
First, the objection is not aimed at me or my argument alone, thankfully. Paul fields it himself and does not have much patience for it at all. Should we continue in sin so that grace may abound? He raises the question in Romans 6 specifically because somebody had already asked it, and his answer is not an argument about incentives.11 Every soteriological account that locates salvation entirely in God’s action on our behalf is subject to this very objection. Luther got it. Calvin got it constantly.
Second, Dort answers it on its own behalf, at length, and the answer belongs to me as much as to them. Here’s why. Articles 12 and 13 insist that certainty of perseverance does not make believers proud or careless or licentious, and that it is instead the root of humility, reverence, patience, prayer, and gratitude.12 The elect, according to Dort, also cannot lose what they have been given. Four centuries of Reformed argumentation that this doctrine does not produce wanton libertines is readily available to anyone willing to look, free of charge, in their words.
Third, and more bluntly, the question is really a confession of sorts. A person who asks what would motivate good behavior without the threat of retribution is telling you what had really been doing the motivating. That is not the account of moral life the New Testament is built on. Its motivation language is about gratitude, love, union, conformity to Christ. Nobody in those letters argues from the selfish avoidance of consequences.
Edwards makes the question nearly incoherent, which I find most satisfying given where the last essay went. If regeneration is a new sense of the heart, a new capacity to perceive holiness as beautiful, then the motive is aesthetic rather than coercive. You do not pursue the good because of what happens if you don’t. You pursue it because you can finally see it and you see its sweetness, to sound Edwardsian yet again.
Compare this to how a great deal of American evangelism actually operates. We had a name for the transaction where a person is convinced to ‘accept Jesus into their heart’ mainly to avoid God’s wrath. We called it fire insurance, and we said it with contempt, and then we went right on sanctioning the policy. Ask a thorough-going Edwardsean why he would bother being good in the absence of hell and he would likely not understand the question.
Don’t misunderstand me here; the fire is real. But I need to explain what I mean by it, since I have now used the word a half dozen times and I have no interest in anybody picturing a scene from Dante.
I do not believe hell is a physical location. There is no boiler room beneath the floor of the universe where God keeps people until they improve. The older Eastern tradition has a far better account of it, I think, and Isaac of Nineveh stated it about as well as anyone has in the seventh century or since. There is one fire and that fire is the love of God. It is experienced as delight by those who have opened themselves to it and as torment by those who have not, and the difference lies in the one being met rather than in the thing doing the meeting. Isaac says outright that it would be improper to imagine that sinners in Gehenna have been deprived of the love of God. They are not deprived of it at all. They are scourged by it. What he calls the torment of Gehenna is bitter regret.13
Hell, then, is a condition rather than an address, and it is in operation right now. Anyone who has watched a person wall himself in with his own resentment, or who has done it himself for a season, has seen the machinery running in real time. What is suffered is God, experienced by a self not yet able to bear him.
Which raises the obvious follow-up question, and it is one I would have fired off myself not too many years ago. What about wrath? Scripture is not remotely shy about it. Wrath gets stored up, revealed, poured out. It appears far too often and far too vividly to wave off as just a figure of speech. So, I won’t wave it away. I would rather ask what the word actually does in the passages where it appears.
Start with Paul, who gives wrath his most sustained treatment at the opening of Romans. The wrath of God is revealed, he says, and then he spends the next several paragraphs describing what that revelation looks like in real life. Three times he reaches for the same verb. God gave them up. God gave them over. Handed them across to precisely what they had already chosen for themselves.14 That is not a lightning bolt from an otherwise clear sky. It is the withdrawal of an interference. The wrath in that passage is God taking his hand off a thing and letting it run its own course, which is a considerably more frightening picture than a thunderclap and also a very different one.
Then watch what the prophets do with the word. Isaiah has God saying that in overflowing wrath he hid his face for a moment, and that with everlasting love he will have compassion. Put those two adjectives next to one another. The wrath gets a moment. The love gets eternity. Lamentations says the Lord will not reject forever, and that he does not willingly afflict anyone. The psalmist says anger lasts a moment and favor lasts a lifetime.15 That asymmetry is not something I am importing into the text to bolster my argument. It is sitting right there in the sentences, and it is there every single time the biblical writers put a duration on either one.
So wrath is real, and it is terrible, and it is temporary, and what it burns against is the thing that is destroying the person. A love with no reaction whatsoever to what ruins the beloved would be a weak and useless sort of affection. But a wrath that never ended would have stopped being corrective somewhere along the way, and that would make it the only thing in God’s economy with no real purpose, no telos, attached to it.
Whatever a person carries into that encounter gets burned out of them, and MacDonald never pretended the burning was in any way comfortable. Nobody is waved through unbothered. Coming home now and coming home through the furnace are not the same experience. What the idea of universal restoration removes is the permanence of it, not the pain.
So where does assurance land in light of all of this? The fifth point exists to answer a question. The question. Am I in or not? And every route it offers for answering that question is directed either inward, at a faith I cannot measure and fruit I can clearly see is bad, or outward at a righteousness that works by covering me up rather than actually changing me.
What I believe now dissolves the question entirely instead of answering it. Not because the fire is gentle, and not because nothing is at stake, but because there is no ‘in’ group to be outside of. Assurance stops being a detection problem, since there is nothing to detect. And it stops being a concealment problem, too, since the fire works on the actual ore rather than on a covering laid over it.
The fourteen-year-old doing the math had the wrong problem in mind. He thought he was trying to determine which group he belonged to. The math never worked quite right because I have since learned there was only ever one group, not two.
Isaiah says the servant comes out of his anguish, sees light, and is satisfied, and that by his knowledge he will make the many righteous.16 That last word is the one I took apart a few essays ago. The rabbim. Not a portion and not a remnant. The multitude, the whole crowd, counted as a crowd.
He is satisfied. Whatever that means, it does not sound like a man who settled for a percentage. And it certainly doesn’t sound like a God who cannot or will not redeem his entire creation, losing none.
Endnotes
1 Matthew 7:16-20.
2 Jonathan Edwards, “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God,” preached at Enfield, Connecticut, 8 July 1741. The reading of the sermon’s emphasis offered here is interpretive rather than settled, though it is shared by a good many Edwards scholars, and the sermon’s closing appeal to the open door of mercy supports it.
3 Canons of Dort, Fifth Main Point of Doctrine, Articles 1 through 5. Article 1 states that believers are not entirely freed from the flesh and the body of sin in this life; Article 2 that blemishes cling to even the best works of God’s people; Article 3 that believers could not remain standing in grace if left to their own resources; Article 4 that true believers can fall into serious and even monstrous sins, with David and Peter given as examples; Article 5 that by such sins they grieve the Holy Spirit, interrupt the exercise of faith, and sometimes lose the awareness of grace for a time.
4 George MacDonald, “The Consuming Fire,” Unspoken Sermons, First Series (1867). Discussed at greater length in “Pour Forth Light All Around,” the previous essay in this series.
5 Canons of Dort, Fifth Main Point, Article 9.
6 Canons of Dort, Fifth Main Point, Article 10. The three grounds given are faith in God’s promises, the testimony of the Holy Spirit witnessing with our spirit, and a serious and holy desire to preserve a good conscience and to perform good works.
7 Canons of Dort, Fifth Main Point, Article 11.
8 Westminster Confession of Faith, 30.3 and 30.4. The six stated purposes of church censure begin with the reclaiming and gaining of offending brethren. Section 4 prescribes admonition, suspension from the sacrament of the Lord’s Supper for a season, and excommunication, according to the nature of the offense.
9 Matthew 18:15-17.
10 1 Corinthians 5:5, among the texts cited by the Westminster divines in support of 30.3.
11 Romans 6:1-2.
12 Canons of Dort, Fifth Main Point, Articles 12 and 13.
13 Isaac of Nineveh, The Ascetical Homilies of Saint Isaac the Syrian, First Part. The passage states that those punished in Gehenna are scourged by the scourge of love, that it would be improper to think sinners in Gehenna are deprived of the love of God, that the power of love works in two ways by tormenting some and delighting others, and that the torment of Gehenna is bitter regret. The number and order of homilies in the First Part vary considerably between manuscripts, editions, and translations, and this passage is cited variously as Homily 25, Homily 28, and Homily 72. The standard English translation is that of the Holy Transfiguration Monastery (Boston, 1984; revised second edition 2011).
14 Romans 1:18-32. The verb is paradidōmi, to hand over or deliver up, and it appears at verses 24, 26, and 28. That Paul defines the revelation of wrath by this threefold handing over is an observation widely made in the commentary literature. It does not by itself establish that wrath means nothing else anywhere in Scripture, and no such claim is made here.
15 Isaiah 54:7-8; Lamentations 3:31-33; Psalm 30:5. Isaiah 54:8 is the sharpest of the three, since the contrast between overflowing wrath for a moment and everlasting love sits inside a single verse.
16 Isaiah 53:11. The Masoretic Text, followed by the King James, reads that he shall see of the travail of his soul and shall be satisfied. The Isaiah scrolls from Qumran and the Septuagint include the word “light,” giving “he shall see light and be satisfied,” and the NRSVue follows them. Both readings keep “satisfied.” The word rendered “many” here is the rabbim, discussed in “Sufficient for the Sins of the Whole World.”
17 Scripture references in this essay: Matthew 7:16-20; Matthew 18:15-17; Isaiah 53:11; Isaiah 54:7-8; Lamentations 3:31-33; Psalm 30:5; Romans 1:18-32; Romans 6:1-2; 1 Corinthians 5:5. Scripture is paraphrased throughout rather than quoted.




Some 45 years ago, a friend used the analogy of vice grips (locking pliers) versus pliers. We try to hold on to God with our pliers and get tired. But God holds on to us with his vise grips and they never let go. Our small ministry group was traveling down the freeway one day when we were passed by a VW Beetle (1960s vintage) with the engine being held to the frame on one side by a pair of vise grips. We all laughed ourselves to tears. And use the analogy frequently. (Thanks to Teri Bender Ehrs.)
You warm my heart when you cite MacDonald!