Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Rob Bright's avatar

Excellent, very interesting post. Thanks for sharing.

Your discussion of election in the Old Testament (and Romans) reminds me very much of the work of Old Testament scholar Dr. Michael S. Heiser on that subject. Link to blog series below. Excerpts:

---

"God’s choice of Israel over all other nations to be his own “portion” as Deut 32:9 says so well. Israel is clearly chosen or “elected” by God...

The idea seems simple enough, but here are some questions we must ask.

1. If you were an Israelite, and your nation was elected by God, chosen out from all other nations, were you elect?

2. Is it true that other nations were not elect, does it stand to reason that to be elect one had to be an Israelite? Does it further stand to reason that Gentiles were not elect?

3. Were all Israelites “saved” (i.e., believers in Yahweh who would share the afterlife with Yahweh)?

4. If all Israelites were not saved, were they elect? If they were elect, how could they not be saved?

5. Should the concept of election in the Old Testament be viewed as salvation? In other words, are “elect” and “saved” synonyms? (cf. my definition of “saved” above: believers in Yahweh who would share the afterlife with Yahweh)

6. If “elect” and “saved” are not synonyms, what is the point of election?

My answers to the above are:

1. Yes

2. Yes and Yes

3. No

4. Yes and “Because election and salvation are not the same thing — though nearly all evangelical theologies will assume they are.”

5. No and No

6. Stay tuned...

Why don’t I think that elect = saved? Because equating the elect and the saved leads to biblical incoherent statements. For example:

1. The nation of Israel was elected (chosen) by God (Deut. 4:37; 7:6-7) … and this election refers to the people born in the line of Abraham to create Yahweh's people … but not all (most?) Israelites were "saved"; i.e., they were not followers of Yahweh (cf. the exile). This leads to logical questions:

If these apostate Israelites were elect, how could they not be saved?

How could God's election fail?

2. Consider (Romans 9-11) that the reversal of Israel's election to non-election status. This reversal was designed to enable Gentile salvation. It was settled "before foundation of the world" (Eph 1:4). Therefore, Israel's national election cannot have meant salvation, since for God’s plan for the Gentiles to be coherent and work, many Israelites had to not be saved (though they were elect).

3. Non-elect people (Gentiles) could convert (and so their non-elect status did not mean they were beyond salvation). That leads to thoughts and realizations like:

The salvation of the non-elect Gentile was predestined "before the foundation of the world" (Eph 1:4)

So if the terms elect and saved are synonyms, God predestined that the destiny of each, made in real time in the day of Abraham, would be reversed, at least in part, later on.

I hope you get the picture. Now for my solution. It’s actually pretty simple, and not novel. I’m just going where the evidence pushes me. Election and salvation must be distinct, but related, things:

Everyone saved was elect …

-but not all the elect are saved.

-There is a remnant WITHIN the elect.

-The remnant is not synonymous with the elect

Now for some ramifications — especially factoring in the non-elect. This proposal means:

-There are elect who will be saved.

-There are elect and non-elect who will not be saved (because "elect" is not a synonym for "saved").

-There are also non-elect who will be saved.

This last thought should not sound strange since the non-elect = Gentiles and many of them were and are being saved.

So what was the meaning of election, then? What I say here will logically be akin to what I said about the real meaning of baptism (for those who remember that far back):

Election meant simply that Israel alone had direct access to the true God and his true worship. Israel was privileged by the following:

-Revelation

-Worship

-Given the most direct path to redemption

-Made the conduit of that redemption for all

-Had to choose the "obedience of faith" to benefit from that access

I would further suggest that when Paul uses “election” terminology he has this view of election in mind — and that does not interfere with what he says in Romans 8...".

https://drmsh.com/election-posts/

Duke Taylor's avatar

This is an interesting conceptualization of god.

If you go back to Genesis, god created people in god’s image but “justly” condemns “the whole race” for the act of the beta version. This god let the beta version procreate under a righteous, to god, sentence of condemnation.

However, there is a lottery for god has set the parameters unknown to the justly condemned wherein some lucky (?) few will be pardoned. Unfortunately, no one knows whether they’re among the elect or not. Reminds me a bit of the Vietnam War draft lottery where we, I was a participant, didn’t immediately know our fate only a certain degree of dread. Some did know because really low numbers were definitely going, really high numbers not. The vast majority could only sweat the calipers moving the thresholds as the war progressed.

In any case, what one does according to this doctrine of election is immaterial because god has preordained one’s place.

It seems to describe the same god of Yossarian’s in “Catch-22” who acted in a mean capricious & whimsical manner the reasoning of which no mortal could fathom. That description formed the basis of Yossarian’s atheism.

All of it rests on a single premise, stated in the very first article, that the whole race stands justly condemned and God would wrong no one by leaving it right there. That premise is what makes unconditional election read as mercy instead of preference. Pull it out of that framework and the doctrine describes a sorting with nothing underpinning it. Leave it in and every hard question gets deflected right back onto the condition of the person asking. Which means the argument was never really settled in the first head of doctrine at all. It was settled only in the assumption the first head takes for granted, and that assumption is called the doctrine of total depravity. Next essay to come soon.

Ready for more?