Essay Two - Unconditional Election
The Canons of Dort define election in the seventh article of the first head of doctrine. Before the foundation of the world, by sheer grace and according to the free good pleasure of his will, God chose in Christ, to salvation, “a definite number of particular people” out of a human race that had ruined itself.1 The ones chosen were no better than anyone left behind.
The math contained in that sentence is the doctrine. A number was fixed, and it was fixed before anything yet existed. Nothing about the people inside the number accounts for their being inside it.
Dort then closes the obvious out this allows just two articles later. God did not look forward through time, see who would believe, and ratify the result. That position has a name, the prescient view of election, and the synod rules it out quite explicitly. Foreseen faith is excluded, along with foreseen obedience and holiness and any other quality that might function as a qualification. Election, then, is the source of faith and never its reward. The following article puts it in the plainest terms available; that God adopts particular persons out of the common mass of humanity.2
Whatever else the synod was, it was not evasive in this respect. Dort said rather plainly what it meant.
So here is the doctrine itself in plain terms, because the word unconditional does a lot and it doesn’t really mean what most people hear it to mean. Unconditional does not mean nothing is required. Faith is certainly required. Likewise, holiness is required. Perseverance to the end is also required. What Dort claims is that every one of those requirements is supplied by God to the people God already decided to give them to. The conditions are very real, and they are met somewhere other than in the person needing them met. Election, then, is all of grace and none of us according to this construct.
Put two people in the same pew listening to the same sermon. One walks out believing and one walks out unfazed. On this account, the difference between them was settled before either of them existed and nothing about either of them contributed to that decision in the slightest.
The tradition would want one qualification added here, and it should be. Reformed theology does not teach that the believer is simply a marionette. The person who walks out believing actually believes, wants to, chooses it, and would tell you that he decided. The confessions are careful to hold that God ordains the end and the means together and that secondary causes remain intact. The claim concerns where the decisive difference is located. Both people in that pew acted freely by any definition the tradition accepts. Only one of them, however, was ever able to act otherwise.
The case for reading the New Testament this way is robust, and anyone who says it isn’t is likely not arguing completely above board. Ephesians clearly has God choosing us in Christ before the world was made and destining us for adoption according to the good pleasure of his will. The Greek gives no relief here. The verb is eklegomai, to pick out or select, and the participle is proorizō, to mark out beforehand.3 Neither word softens under examination, and anyone hoping a lexicon will alleviate the problem should stop hoping. Romans 8 runs the chain from foreknowledge through predestination, calling, justification, and glory, with no link left to human initiative. John’s Jesus says nobody comes to him unless the Father draws them, and the verb behind that word is closer to hauling than inviting. The same word gets used for dragging a full net onto the beach and for dragging men into the marketplace to face charges.4 Luke reports in Acts that as many as had been appointed to eternal life became believers, which is about as direct as a sentence gets. Paul tells the Thessalonians that God chose them from the beginning for salvation.
Five texts, and there are more, and none of them require a lot of mental gymnastics to yield the accepted Reformed reading. So what’s the issue? What is my critique? The argument in this essay is not that God fails to choose. Of course God chooses. God chooses constantly in these texts, unconditionally, and without consulting anyone on those choices. The argument is about what the choosing is for.
Start with the passage Dort itself references. Article 10 grounds unconditional election by quoting Romans 9, the lines about Jacob and Esau, before either twin had done anything good or bad. That is the synod’s own proof text for the doctrine, so it should be fair ground for further examination.
Read carefully what Paul says he is doing in that particular passage. The chapter opens with him in anguish over his own people, Israel, who have not accepted the Messiah, and his question in verse six is whether the word of God has failed. That is the crisis driving the argument and a responsible hermeneutic must recognize that fact. It’s not the eternal destiny of individuals that is in scope here, at least not primarily, but whether God keeps promises to a nation that has gone off the rails.
Then look at where his Jacob and Esau material comes from. Genesis 25:23 is an oracle to Rebekah, and the oracle says two nations are in her womb, with one people stronger than the other. The line about loving Jacob and hating Esau comes from Malachi, written something like a thousand years after both men were dead and buried, and Malachi is talking about Edom. Again, peoples, not persons; plural not singular. Paul is doing what Paul does, reaching for the national story to explain a national crisis. When viewed that way, these puzzle pieces align quite differently.
But the argument does not stop where the proof-texting stops. It runs through chapter eleven, where Paul says God has imprisoned all in disobedience in order to be merciful to all. That is an awfully strange conclusion for a passage supposedly establishing that mercy was allotted in fixed quantities before the world began.
That dilemma brings up the older pattern revealed underneath all of this. Election in the Hebrew Bible is a job. For example, Abraham is chosen so that all the families of the earth get blessed through him. Israel is called a light to the nations and a kingdom of priests, which happen to both be descriptions of work performed on behalf of somebody else.
Notice what being chosen does to the people who are chosen. It exposes them. Amos tells Israel that out of all the families of the earth God knew them only, and then draws the conclusion nobody wants, which is that God will therefore hold them accountable for their sins. Being selected does not put Israel outside the reach of judgment. It actually puts Israel first in line for it. The prophets treat chosenness as a standard the nation is measured against, and the measuring goes badly more often than it goes well. Whatever that is, it functions nothing like a list of names guaranteed a good personal outcome.
There is one thing the Greek does settle, and it cuts in a particular direction. Ephesians says what the predestining is toward, and the answer is adoption. Romans 8 says the same thing a little differently; that those foreknown were marked out to be conformed to the image of the Son. Neither passage says anyone was individually predestined to be saved instead of damned. Both name a collective status and a shape of life as the destination. A Calvinist will answer that the ones adopted are precisely the elect, and that answer is fair enough. It still leaves the texts much more interested in the purpose of the choosing than in the tally itself, however.
Krister Stendahl, a Swedish New Testament scholar who taught at Harvard for decades, served as dean of its divinity school, and later became the Lutheran bishop of Stockholm, argued in 1963 that Western Christians inherited a habit of reading Paul through a question Paul wasn’t even asking. He first made the case in a lecture to the American Psychological Association, which is a fitting audience for the claim, since the claim is that the West had been projecting its own guilty conscience backward onto a first-century Jew. Augustine and Luther both came to the letters carrying an intensely personal anxiety about how a guilty individual finds a merciful God, and they found their question answered on every page. This was the lens through which they were looking at these texts.
Stendahl’s contention is that Paul’s actual problem was corporate, having to do with how Gentiles could belong to Israel’s God without first becoming Jews.5 This idea might sound familiar to some who have followed theological developments over the last fifty years or so. N. T. Wright has spent decades developing a closely-related case, that election in Paul retains its vocational shape and that the church inherits Israel’s assignment.6
That particular reading remains contested, of course, and conservative Reformed scholars have resisted the larger movement it belongs to for forty years. E. P. Sanders and James Dunn built out the fuller case for what Wright articulates, and I am borrowing a specific observation from Stendahl rather than signing on to a full program or label that can prove too restrictive. Drink Wisely has examined the New Perspective on Paul elsewhere and will return to it again in due course.
The argument in this essay stands or falls on Genesis 25, Malachi, and Paul’s own stated question, none of which need Stendahl (or Dunn, Sanders or Wright) to work.
Note that Dort does not stop at election alone. Article 15 spells out the other decree, that some are passed by, left in the misery they brought on themselves, denied saving faith and the grace of conversion, and finally condemned. The synod is very careful to insist this does not make God the author of sin. It also does not actually soften what is being described which is a decision made in eternity about people who did not yet exist.7
This half of the doctrine rarely makes it onto the whiteboard in discussion groups. Election gets presented as unmerited rescue, which is warm and fuzzy, and reprobation gets handled quickly or described as mere “passing over” in some inert sense.
The tradition has two versions of this, and the difference between them is substantive. The harder version treats election and reprobation as mirror images of one another. God works faith into the elect and works unbelief into the reprobate with equal directness, intervening on both sides. R. C. Sproul called this equal ultimacy and rejected it, describing it as a caricature of the Reformed position, identifying it with hyper-Calvinism, and noting that Reformed thinkers have rejected it almost without exception.8
The softer version is the confessional one. It denies any symmetry of operation while keeping the symmetry of the decree, or at least it attempts to do so. God intervenes in the elect to create faith. God simply passes over the rest, leaves them in the condition they were already in, and condemns them for sins that are entirely their own. Westminster uses the language of passing by. Dort does the same thing in Article 15, which specifies that the reprobate are left in the misery they brought on themselves and condemned for their unbelief along with all their other sins. By this account, nobody gets pushed one way or the other. Some simply do not get pulled out.
This distinction is real, and it clears the tradition of the charge that God manufactures the unbelief he then punishes. It also just relocates the problem without solving it. Passing by remains a decision, made in eternity, concerning a particular person, on grounds having nothing to do with that person. The reprobate cannot repent, because repentance requires a grace that was decided against before he drew a breath. He is condemned for sins he was never able to avoid and left unrescued by a determination he had no part in. Whether the decree pushed him under or declined to reach for him, the result was fixed and he was never a variable in it.
High Calvinists notice this and accuse Sproul of softening Calvin to make him more presentable. They have a point. Calvin called bare permission an absurdity and said the people who reach for it have God sitting in a watchtower waiting to see what humans will do.9
The logic will not permit that easy separation, then. If nothing whatsoever in the elect accounts for their election, then nothing in the reprobate accounts for their reprobation either, and the symmetry both ways is the whole point of the doctrine. This logic lands the burden where the tradition has always known it to exist. If the deciding factor lives entirely in God, and nothing about the person bears on it in any way, the doctrine must be able to account for why it is not simply arbitrary or capricious.
Arbitrary is not the exact right charge, of course. Dort says the choice follows God’s good pleasure, which means there is a reason behind it though we don’t know that reason beyond “the pleasure of God’s will.” The reason is sealed. Nobody gets to see into it, including the very people it sorted.
The standard defense has three parts and all three are weighty. Nobody is wronged, since Dort’s opening article establishes that the entire race already stands under a just sentence and God owes rescue to no one, so mercy shown to some is not injustice done to the rest. Calling the decision unfair assumes a standard of fairness sitting somehow above God against which the decision could be objectively measured, and the tradition denies any such standard exists. And every alternative offered relocates the deciding factor back into the person somehow, which is the exact notion Paul spends much of his letters debunking.
The first of the aforementioned defenses is the strongest one, and it absolves the charge of injustice, but it doesn’t effectively touch the question people are actually asking. Nobody in disagreement with this doctrine is complaining that the reprobate received in any way less than they deserved. The complaint is about what it means to sort equally undeserving people into two permanent categories for reasons that will never be disclosed, and then to hold the second group eternally accountable for a condition they were never given the ability or means to escape. Justice is not the sore spot for detractors in this; moral character is.
Calvin at least had the nerve to flinch a bit on this one. In the Institutes, he concedes the decree is horribile, which Reformed scholars have argued for a century (with a straight face, I’m sure) means awe-inspiring rather than repellent and they are probably right about the Latin.10 He was also a careful writer who chose that word at that spot, in the middle of explaining that God ordained the fall, and the concession still stands whichever way the word is rendered. Something in the argument required an admission.
The Reformed response to this comes in Article 18, which quotes Paul asking who are you, O man, to talk back to God. That line has ended a great many conversations on the spot. It is also not an argument, and Dort surely knew it was not an argument, which is why the synod placed it at the end rather than the beginning. The verse is used to shut down objection, not answer it.
All of it rests on a single premise, stated in the very first article, that the whole race stands justly condemned and God would wrong no one by leaving it right there. That premise is what makes unconditional election read as mercy instead of preference. Pull it out of that framework and the doctrine describes a sorting with nothing underpinning it. Leave it in and every hard question gets deflected right back onto the condition of the person asking. Which means the argument was never really settled in the first head of doctrine at all. It was settled only in the assumption the first head takes for granted, and that assumption is called the doctrine of total depravity. Next essay to come soon.11
Endnotes
1 Canons of Dort, First Main Point of Doctrine, Article 7. Quotations follow the English translation approved in 2011 by the Christian Reformed Church in North America and the Reformed Church in America. Translation © 2011, Faith Alive Christian Resources, Christian Reformed Church in North America.
2 Canons of Dort, First Main Point, Articles 9 and 10. Article 9 excludes foreseen faith, foreseen obedience, and foreseen holiness as grounds of election, and states that faith and holiness flow from election as its fruits. Article 10 quotes Romans 9:11-13 and Acts 13:48. The prescient view, which grounds election in God’s foreknowledge of who would believe, was the position of the Remonstrants and is rejected at length in the first head’s rejection of errors.
3 Ephesians 1:4-5. The verb exelexato is an aorist middle form of eklegomai, used throughout the Septuagint for God’s choice of Israel. Proorisas is an aorist participle of proorizō, to determine or mark out in advance. No serious translator disputes either rendering.
4 The verb in John 6:44 is helkyō, used elsewhere in the same gospel for hauling a loaded net ashore and for drawing a sword, and in Acts for dragging men before magistrates. The Reformed reading of this verse is philologically strong.
5 Krister Stendahl, “The Apostle Paul and the Introspective Conscience of the West,” Harvard Theological Review 56, no. 3 (1963), 199-215. The essay is a revised version of a lecture delivered to the annual meeting of the American Psychological Association on 3 September 1961, itself developed from an article published in Swedish in 1960. Stendahl (1921-2008) taught New Testament at Harvard from 1954, served as dean of the divinity school from 1968 to 1979, and was elected Lutheran bishop of Stockholm in 1984.
6 The vocational reading of election runs throughout N. T. Wright’s Pauline work.
7 Canons of Dort, First Main Point, Articles 1, 15, and 18. Article 1 establishes that God would do no injustice in condemning the entire race. Article 15 sets out the decree of reprobation. Article 18 answers objectors with Romans 9:20 and Matthew 20:15.
8 R. C. Sproul, “Double Predestination,” first published in Soli Deo Gloria: Essays in Reformed Theology, a festschrift for John H. Gerstner (Presbyterian and Reformed, 1976), and developed further in What Is Reformed Theology? Sproul distinguishes a positive-positive scheme, in which God works both faith and unbelief directly, from the positive-negative scheme he identifies as the classical Reformed position. The Westminster Confession, 3.7, uses the language of God passing by the rest of humanity. The distinction between infralapsarian and supralapsarian orderings of the divine decrees belongs to the same family of disputes and has never been settled within the tradition.
9 John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion 1.18.1, where Calvin rejects nuda permissio, bare permission, as an account of God’s relation to events he has decreed. The passage concerns providence and evil rather than reprobation specifically, though Calvin returns to the same objection in his treatment of predestination in Book 3. Kenneth Stewart argues in Ten Myths About Calvinism that Calvin’s formulation on this point differs from the language later adopted at Dort and Westminster, which is the distinction under discussion here.
10 John Calvin, Institutes of the Christian Religion 3.23.7. The Latin is decretum quidem horribile fateor. W. G. T. Shedd argued that Calvin, a trained Latinist, used the term in its classical sense of awe or reverential dread, and recent Reformed scholarship generally follows him; the Selderhuis Calvin Handbook renders the phrase as “awesome decree.” The context is Calvin’s argument that God ordained the fall rather than merely permitting it.
11 Scripture references in this essay: Genesis 12:3; Genesis 25:23; Exodus 19:6; Isaiah 42:6; Amos 3:2; Malachi 1:2-3; John 6:44; Acts 13:48; Romans 8:29-30; Romans 9:1-13; Romans 11:32; Ephesians 1:4-5; 2 Thessalonians 2:13. The Third and Fourth Main Points of Doctrine ground original sin in Romans 5:12, the verse at the center of the forthcoming essay on Augustine and the Latin transmission problem.




Excellent, very interesting post. Thanks for sharing.
Your discussion of election in the Old Testament (and Romans) reminds me very much of the work of Old Testament scholar Dr. Michael S. Heiser on that subject. Link to blog series below. Excerpts:
---
"God’s choice of Israel over all other nations to be his own “portion” as Deut 32:9 says so well. Israel is clearly chosen or “elected” by God...
The idea seems simple enough, but here are some questions we must ask.
1. If you were an Israelite, and your nation was elected by God, chosen out from all other nations, were you elect?
2. Is it true that other nations were not elect, does it stand to reason that to be elect one had to be an Israelite? Does it further stand to reason that Gentiles were not elect?
3. Were all Israelites “saved” (i.e., believers in Yahweh who would share the afterlife with Yahweh)?
4. If all Israelites were not saved, were they elect? If they were elect, how could they not be saved?
5. Should the concept of election in the Old Testament be viewed as salvation? In other words, are “elect” and “saved” synonyms? (cf. my definition of “saved” above: believers in Yahweh who would share the afterlife with Yahweh)
6. If “elect” and “saved” are not synonyms, what is the point of election?
My answers to the above are:
1. Yes
2. Yes and Yes
3. No
4. Yes and “Because election and salvation are not the same thing — though nearly all evangelical theologies will assume they are.”
5. No and No
6. Stay tuned...
Why don’t I think that elect = saved? Because equating the elect and the saved leads to biblical incoherent statements. For example:
1. The nation of Israel was elected (chosen) by God (Deut. 4:37; 7:6-7) … and this election refers to the people born in the line of Abraham to create Yahweh's people … but not all (most?) Israelites were "saved"; i.e., they were not followers of Yahweh (cf. the exile). This leads to logical questions:
If these apostate Israelites were elect, how could they not be saved?
How could God's election fail?
2. Consider (Romans 9-11) that the reversal of Israel's election to non-election status. This reversal was designed to enable Gentile salvation. It was settled "before foundation of the world" (Eph 1:4). Therefore, Israel's national election cannot have meant salvation, since for God’s plan for the Gentiles to be coherent and work, many Israelites had to not be saved (though they were elect).
3. Non-elect people (Gentiles) could convert (and so their non-elect status did not mean they were beyond salvation). That leads to thoughts and realizations like:
The salvation of the non-elect Gentile was predestined "before the foundation of the world" (Eph 1:4)
So if the terms elect and saved are synonyms, God predestined that the destiny of each, made in real time in the day of Abraham, would be reversed, at least in part, later on.
I hope you get the picture. Now for my solution. It’s actually pretty simple, and not novel. I’m just going where the evidence pushes me. Election and salvation must be distinct, but related, things:
Everyone saved was elect …
-but not all the elect are saved.
-There is a remnant WITHIN the elect.
-The remnant is not synonymous with the elect
Now for some ramifications — especially factoring in the non-elect. This proposal means:
-There are elect who will be saved.
-There are elect and non-elect who will not be saved (because "elect" is not a synonym for "saved").
-There are also non-elect who will be saved.
This last thought should not sound strange since the non-elect = Gentiles and many of them were and are being saved.
So what was the meaning of election, then? What I say here will logically be akin to what I said about the real meaning of baptism (for those who remember that far back):
Election meant simply that Israel alone had direct access to the true God and his true worship. Israel was privileged by the following:
-Revelation
-Worship
-Given the most direct path to redemption
-Made the conduit of that redemption for all
-Had to choose the "obedience of faith" to benefit from that access
I would further suggest that when Paul uses “election” terminology he has this view of election in mind — and that does not interfere with what he says in Romans 8...".
https://drmsh.com/election-posts/
This is an interesting conceptualization of god.
If you go back to Genesis, god created people in god’s image but “justly” condemns “the whole race” for the act of the beta version. This god let the beta version procreate under a righteous, to god, sentence of condemnation.
However, there is a lottery for god has set the parameters unknown to the justly condemned wherein some lucky (?) few will be pardoned. Unfortunately, no one knows whether they’re among the elect or not. Reminds me a bit of the Vietnam War draft lottery where we, I was a participant, didn’t immediately know our fate only a certain degree of dread. Some did know because really low numbers were definitely going, really high numbers not. The vast majority could only sweat the calipers moving the thresholds as the war progressed.
In any case, what one does according to this doctrine of election is immaterial because god has preordained one’s place.
It seems to describe the same god of Yossarian’s in “Catch-22” who acted in a mean capricious & whimsical manner the reasoning of which no mortal could fathom. That description formed the basis of Yossarian’s atheism.
All of it rests on a single premise, stated in the very first article, that the whole race stands justly condemned and God would wrong no one by leaving it right there. That premise is what makes unconditional election read as mercy instead of preference. Pull it out of that framework and the doctrine describes a sorting with nothing underpinning it. Leave it in and every hard question gets deflected right back onto the condition of the person asking. Which means the argument was never really settled in the first head of doctrine at all. It was settled only in the assumption the first head takes for granted, and that assumption is called the doctrine of total depravity. Next essay to come soon.